Lawyer: Clerk may have interfered with order on gay marriage
Rowan County Deputy Clerk Brian Mason, left, asks Shannon Wampler-Collins, right and her partner...
Sep. 18, 2015
OWENSBORO, Ky. (AP) A Kentucky county clerk may have again defied a federal judge's order regarding gay-marriage licenses by altering license forms to remove her name, an attorney who represents one of the clerk's employees told the judge Friday in a court filing.
In a separate filing Friday, attorneys for the gay couples who sued Davis appear to agree.
Rowan County Clerk Kim Davis spent five days in jail for refusing to obey a federal judge's ruling that she issue marriage licenses to same-sex couples to comply with a U.S. Supreme Court decision that effectively legalized gay marriage nationwide. Davis, an Apostolic Christian, believes same-sex marriage is a sin and cited "God's authority" in refusing to obey the ruling.
U.S. District Judge David Bunning released Davis from jail on the condition that she not interfere with her employees as they issue marriage licenses. When she returned to work, Davis altered the marriage forms by removing her name, making deputy clerk Brian Mason initial the form instead of sign it, and then requiring the form to be notarized.
"A notary has nothing to do with it," Mason's attorney, Richard Hughes, told The Associated Press on Friday after filing a status report with the judge. Hughes said it was "really bizarre" that Davis would alter the forms.
"Unless she's got a really good reason, and I'll certainly be patient and wait to hear it, the only inference I personally can draw from it is she is trying to circumvent the court's order," he said.
Bunning appointed attorneys for each of Davis' deputy clerks and asked them to file status reports every two weeks. The reports are not due until Tuesday, but Hughes filed his on Friday saying Davis' "changes were made in some attempt to circumvent the court's orders and may have raised to the level of interference against the court's orders."
"We'll see what Judge Bunning is going to do with it," Hughes said.
Also Friday, the attorneys for the American Civil Liberties Union said in a court filing that the changes on the form require Mason to issue the licenses "in his capacity as a 'notary public' rather than a deputy clerk of the Rowan County Clerk's Office," changes that "do not comply" with the court's order to not interfere with her employees who issue the licenses.
"These alterations call into question the validity of the marriage licenses issued," the attorneys wrote in a footnote to a motion asking the judge to certify the case as a class-action lawsuit. "Plaintiffs are exploring legal options to address these material alterations."
State law requires marriage licenses to be issued under the authority of the county clerk. Someone else, a minister or other officiant, then performs the ceremony and signs the license. The clerk then files the license with county records.
Davis has said that any license issued with or without her name is not valid unless she authorizes it. However, when she was released from jail she changed the marriage license forms to say they were being issued under the authority of the federal court. Davis' attorney said this new form, if OK with the judge, would solve the problem because gay couples would have a marriage license and Davis would have a clear conscience.
Kentucky's Democratic governor and attorney general have both said the licenses are valid and will be recognized by the state. Bunning, the federal judge, has said he does not know if the licenses are valid and it was up to the gay couples to take that chance.
Mason is the only employee in Davis' office who has said he does not object to issuing marriage licenses to same-sex couples. Hughes said he agreed with his fellow deputy clerks to issue the licenses to "ease the stress of the situation." But Hughes noted the other clerks would issue the licenses if Mason were absent.
Mason has calmly and cheerfully issued marriage licenses in Rowan County, often amid a scrum of TV cameras and recorders documenting his every move. He has declined interview requests, and it is not clear what relationship he has with Davis. During her federal testimony, Davis described Mason as a "very loyal, very dedicated, very good employee."
"(Mason) says he has a good relationship with her," Hughes said. "It's been hard on all of them."
__
This story has been edited to clarify that attorney is saying Davis may have interfered with the judge's order.
Tags
Who is online
102 visitors

She need to quit fucking around! She's been ordered not to interfere and then she changes the licenses to the point where even she says she doesn't think they're legal. I hope to hell the judge throws her ass in jail and doesn't let her out until her term expires and then if she is reelected, keeps her there until that term expires too! Sooner or later the people where she lives are going to want their town back peaceful and they can't because of her showboating.
Her 15 minutes are up and now she's trying to grab more. She's stopped being a woman basing her actions on religion and has just became another reality show type media hog. She has a rubber tube around her upper arm and she is mainlining her own ego!
I wonder how Davis would have taken it if she had been refused one of her several divorces, by a clerk acting against the law but under "God's authority". Maybe when she goes to heaven she will be surprised to learn that divorce is not a term God recognizes, and she will be forced to spend eternity getting banged by all of her husbands.
She seems to want to play hardball. The judge can and should throw her stupid ass in jail.
No need for such foolishness 1ofmanny.
Once the Supremes ruled any Kentucky State law that differs from their decision is of no concern.
Here in Arkansas the State Constitution still states that I can't hold a public office or be a witness in a court of law, (something I did for my company for more than 20 years, 5 years here in AR).
No judge or opposing counsel ever challenged my right to be a witness because of their own personal religious beliefs or because the State Constitution still specifically singled " My Type " out for less than equal treatment under the law.
This clerk is just being a fool that has already been shown more than enough deference. Time for her to STFU, sit down and either do her job or get out of the way.
Good point. There are still a lot of sects that do not recognize divorce...
How do you know what "God's law" is on the subject of gay marriage? I know that the Bible condones polygamy and concubinage, which are therefore "God's law but against the state's law"... but I know of no reference to gay marriage anywhere in the Bible.
Some people interpret the "Centurion's companion", whom Jesus healed, to be the officer's (male) lover, but there are several other possibilities. ( There's an excellent article on the subject here .)
Other than that, I know of nothing in Jesus's teachings that comes even close to gay marriage.
Oh wait!!
"Love one another "!
Leviticus 20:13 -- If a man has sexual relations with a man as one does with a woman, both have done what isdetestable.
This prohibition was unchanged by Jesus. Matthew 5:17 -- Do not think that I have come to change the law or writings of theProphets.
Since sexualrelationsbetween men is an abomination, marrying them and blessing a sexual relationship is an abomination as well. And Jesus's statement telling people to "love one another" is obviously not an invitation to engage in sex since you love your parents, friends and fellow humans without having sex with them (I hope).
And Jesus's statement telling people to "love one another" is obviously not an invitation to engage in sex since you love your parents, friends and fellow humans without having sex with them (I hope).
Even in the hills of Kentucky?
Besides, it her interpretation of God's law and the SCOTUS doesn't see it that way. She lost and rightfully so. She was elected to be a public servant and she is instead trying to force her religious beliefs on the people applying for a LEGAL marriage license.
1ofmany,
First "detestable" is not "illegal". Second, we have accepted several changes in sexuality in the thousands of years since Leviticus was written... unless you argue in favor of polygamy and concubinage, and forced marriage of little girls... and such.
Second, of course Jesus's injunction to love one another does not refer to sensual love. If means to care for one another... and it allows no exceptions. If you hate, you are not a follower of Jesus. If you exclude anyone from your love, you are not a Christian:
1 John 4:20
But I don't like clobbertexting. Our texts are too doubtful to draw detailed conclusions from them.
But even if we cannot be sure of any one of Jesus's sermons... the overall thrust of His message is clear: "Love one another... and there are no exceptions to this commandment!"
Anyone who hates... anyone who excludes... betrays Christ.
Yes. With a clear understanding that if she deviated in the slightest, she would return to jail...
So, since in her version of religion, Jews are not Christians, she then gets to decide if they have the "right" to get married? She is the Supreme Law of the Land and only what she says should be the law according to what her church teaches counts?
She may not like that the SCOTUS ruled Gay marriage is Constitutional, but she doesn't have the right, as a public servant, to force her religious beliefs on others based on what she thinks the law should be. She only has the right to enforce the law as it is and not what it was when she took her oath. The last I checked she is not serving on the Supreme Court.
Off to jail with this media whore. Or she hoping to get rich off her own reality show?
I have never suggested that she can block the law. All I said was that she can note that she signs at the direction of the court.
The way it has been traditionally viewed is that one can love the sinner not the sin. Your twist is that loving the sinner requires embracing the sin. Embracing the sin in order to love the sinner, arguably undoes the bible, advances the work of the devil, and betrays Christ through sophistry. But we can agree to disagree.
Also Friday, the attorneys for the American Civil Liberties Union said in a court filing that the changes on the form require Mason to issue the licenses "in his capacity as a 'notary public' rather than a deputy clerk of the Rowan County Clerk's Office," changes that "do not comply" with the court's order to not interfere with her employees who issue the licenses.
If she changes the forms so they are no longer legal then this is interference and I hope the judge throws her ass back into jail.
I thought that's the only basis the judge used for releasing her.
She is not only disobeying the Constitution that she swore to uphold, but is also disobeying her release order. Federal Judges do NOT like getting jerked around and this one has said as much to her by sending her to jail in the first place.
If the court can go so far as to redefine the institution of marriage for every state in the country, then authorizing the form should be a snap. Let's see what the judge says.
It did not redefine marriage for anyone. My son is married to his husband. It was performed in a court by a judge, just like many other marriages are performed. He and my son-in-law are just as married as any heterosexual couple. If they split up they'll have to go through a normal divorce, just like they went through a normal marriage. The SCOTUS ruled that it was unConstitutional to discriminate against gays from getting married. It did not change what a marriage entails. It did not change what a marriage IS. It did not change any of the laws concerning the rights and responsibilities of marriage. Marriage is the exact same thing to gay couples that it is to straight couples. No more, no less. The SCOTUS said that it is discriminatory not to allow gay couples to be considered as equals to heterosexual couples. That's all. Marriage itself is still exactly the same.
It absolutely and categorically redefined marriage. From the dawn of recorded history and in every society both civilized and savage, marriage has been understood to be a union between a man and a woman. The USConstitution is obviously premised on this belief since homosexuality was illegal and the Constitution makes no mention whatsoever of same sex marriage. Damn, even animals have figured out how to mate.
We are all animals. Just some more then others. The Supreme Court did not change what a marriage is. They simply said that gays have a Constitutionally protected equal right to it also. That's all. They did not change marriage itself. The institution of what a marriage is was not changed.
Hey, bitch to them! I didn't make the ruling. I just think it makes perfect sense.
Oh and homosexuality exists throughout the animal kingdom. There are many, many recorded cases of gay (non-human) animals.
Again, marriage hasalwaysbeen between a man and a woman. That is no longer the case and, therefore, marriage has beenredefined.
I disagree. It was strictly an equal rights issue, not a marriage one. Not a redefinition of the institution of marriage itself.
1ofmany,
Say WHAT? You cite the Bible when it serves your purpose, but you "forget" that polygamy was the rule in OT times...
Again, marriage hasalwaysbeen between a man and a woman.
Says you.
Homosexual behavior exists intheanimal kingdom but there is no evidence that any animal was born to be gay if that's what you mean any more than a dog was born to hump your leg or a person was born with a foot fetish.
Your point escapes me but even polygamy was marriage between men and women.
Your Leviticus was a complete nut case :
It's kinda hard to take any of it seriously.
My son was born gay. So was his husband. My step-son was born gay and so was his older brother, though he died of aids in 1992. In fact I don't have a single gay or lesbian friend who wasn't born gay or lesbian. As soon as they became aware of any sexual feelings, they knew they were attracted to members of their own gender. Just like when I first became aware of sexual feelings, I knew I was attracted to girls. They are both the same thing.
I have owned (or actually been owned by
) several dogs (probably more then a dozen in my life) and none of them, male or female, has ever humped my leg. Not once. Maybe there is a reason dogs hump your's?
Also a fetish (such as a foot fetish) is a learned behavior. Being born gay is not a fetish. Being gay is not a fetish anymore then being heterosexual is. It is simply something a person is. Exactly the same as a straight person.
And no one, including you, has ever seen a gay baby.
Lucky you.
That's your opinion. To me, it's just like foot fetish. Maybe one day parents can marry their children, people can marry their pets, and a narcissist can marry himself . . anything goes when it's all about love.
That's because babies are not sexually aware yet. At least I wasn't. I didn't much like girls until I started noticing some changes in them! Man did I ever realize what gender I was attracted to then! When teens become sexually aware, they realize what gender they are attracted to, but it's not a decision they make. It simply is who they are. No one decides if they are straight or gay. They either are or are not. No one sits down in their room one day at the beginning of puberty and says "Well, I'm starting to feel like a sexual person, so what gender should I choose to be attracted to? Am I going to pick to be attracted to men or women? Hmmm....I'm not sure. Well, since I am a guy people tell me a should be attracted to girls, but I'm not?" You or I didn't choose to be gay or straight anymore then any other gay or straight person did. We just were straight or gay. It was not a choice. We just were.
To me, it's just like foot fetish.
Well. That would make you wrong now, wouldn't it? Ask a gay friend or co-worker or family member (everyone knows several (you almost certainly have several in your family), even if they may not be aware of it or have closed their eyes to it) if they think that them being gay is a fetish. They will (hopefully politely) gently say that no, it is not. It is just how and who they are. It is not my opinion that it is not. It is what every gay person I have ever known has said.
It's hard to understand why the fundies are so upset about the gay, while not worrying at all about blasphemers.
Oh wait... no... it's not hard to understand at all:
Fundies neither know nor care what is actually in the Bible, but they do know that they hate people who are different.
*shaking head, "Uh, uh, uh!"
She needs to go back to jail.