Massive settlement aims to repay tribes for contract costs
http://www.eenews.net/eenewspm/stories/1060024906/print
The Department of the Interior has proposed a $940 million settlement to make up for discrepancies between what the U.S. government promised to pay tribes to provide federal services on their own lands and what they actually were paid -- a gap at the center of a more than two-decade-old class-action lawsuit.
The attorneys representing the 645 tribal plaintiffs agreed to the deal filed yesterday in U.S. District Court in Albuquerque, N.M. If a judge signs off, and barring a legal appeal, payments could start rolling out in the next year.
Interior Secretary Sally Jewell hailed the agreement as another landmark victory for the Obama administration in Indian Country.
With the proposed settlement, Interior is resolving claims from contracts between 1994 and 2013, but the problem dates back to the Indian Self-Determination and Education Assistance Act of 1975. The law, which turned over services like forest management, road maintenance and law enforcement to tribal governments, was a monumental step in tribes' fight to self-govern.
But Congress capped the amount of funding available for administrative costs like worker compensation. Quickly, the Bureau of Indian Affairs began shortchanging tribal contractors, creating lapses, according to the plaintiffs, that helped fuel crime, poverty and unemployment, major issues that Indian Country has been combating for generations and that the U.S. government has a trust responsibility to address.
In 2012, the Supreme Court sided with tribal plaintiffs, namely the Ramah Navajo Chapter, Zuni Pueblo and Oglala Sioux Tribe, that the U.S. government had to pay contract support costs regardless of congressional appropriations.
The decision resulted in negotiations between the tribes and the Justice Department.
"This agreement was long in the making -- reached only after years of complex negotiations -- and both sides can be proud of the result," said Principal Deputy Assistant Attorney General Benjamin Mizer, head of the Justice Department's Civil Division.
This settlement follows more than 80 settlements totaling more than $2.2 billion, including the landmark Cobell trust land settlement, that the Obama administration has reached with tribal leaders. While the land buyback program established by the Cobell settlement has struggled, Jewell said the Obama administration is slowly taking action on issues allowed to fester for too long in Indian Country ( Greenwire , Nov. 21, 2014).
"Today's news is a really good reminder that settling past grievances -- the hard work that sometimes takes many years, in this case decades -- is absolutely necessary if we're going to set the stage for moving forward on repairing years of broken promises," she said.
Jewell reiterated President Obama's recent call for Congress to pass mandatory contract support costs moving forward, removing it from the appropriations process, with tribal self-determination and self-governance being the "North Star" to guide the government's unique relationship with tribes.
"Congress can and should make this happen," she said.
Assistant Secretary for Indian Affairs Kevin Washburn said letting tribes provide their own services is simply a superior solution to others attempted by the U.S. government -- tribal assimilation and termination. In Arizona, forests managed by the San Carlos Apache Nation escaped most of the damage inflicted by the 2011 Wallow Fire, the largest fire in Arizona history, a "dramatic example of the effectiveness of Indian forest thinning," according to a 2013 report by the federally commissioned Indian Forest Management Assessment Team ( ClimateWire , May 19, 2014).
"Time and again, we have seen that when a tribal government runs a federal program, the program is more successful and more responsive to the tribal community," Washburn said.
"I commend tribal leaders and lawyers and American citizens that have stood up to force their government to do the right thing," he said. "We urge Congress to provide mandatory funding for contract support costs in the future so that tribes will never again have to fight their own government to live up to its contracting promises."
Tags
Who is online
102 visitors

645 claims against the government by tribes for non-payment of contracts - sounds vaguely familiar with the 436 treaties with non-payment.
80 tribes, in a two year period, filed claims for $2.2B - presently being settled.
SCOTUS - Justice Sonia Sotomayor delivered the opinion of the court. Sotomayor first noted that this was not a case of first impression , and that the court had ruled on a similar issue only seven years previously. Sotomayor stated that Cherokee Nation of Okla. v. Leavitt held that when the government makes a contractual promise to pay in return for services, the government is bound to pay for those services. This was a long-standing principle of contract law, dating back to Ferris, and the "principle safeguards both the expectations of Government contractors and the long-term fiscal interests of the United States." If the appropriation exceeds the amount of the individual contract, then the government is bound to honor the contract. Sotomayor stated that although the situation that Congress placed the BIA in is frustrating, but it is an issue for Congress to resolve. The court affirmed the decision of the Tenth Circuit Court. Justices Scalia, Kennedy, Thomas, and Kagan joined Sotomayor's opinion. "
As usual, the actual amount of the claims was over $48B - very similar to the Cobell case, whose figure was $41B. This case amount has been whittled down to less than $992M, just as the Cobell case was whittled down to $3.3B -
"because the government doesn't have the money topay the debt."
Funny - how many wars are we fighting that we don't need to be/shouldn't beinvolved in at how many billions of dollars a year - and we can't pay the debts that we owe the Native American people - at home?????
Good, about time.
I've been trying to find the actual amount owed on this case. No luck as yet.
There's a "new" contracting mechanisms that was put into place with the tribes back in the early '90's, that is managed by the SBA called an 8(a) contract for work over $500K.
This is only a settlement on BIA portion. There is still an outstanding suit on IHS.
What I like to see is that DOJ is fully investigating this one - .
How many Indians do you think have died from illness because their tribe didn't have funds to care for them while they were waiting for payment from the government? How many sanitation or education or housing projects are left undone or even started because payment has been withheld?
Payments to Indians are always cut drastically below the contracted amount. What hell are we paying Iran billions for anyway? Why do we pay countries like Iraq and Pakistan billions for "reconstruction" when we blatantly short change the tribes here that are struggling to survive, when Indians die from the bitter cold during winter because of a lack of proper heating?
True.
There is no amount of money that would ever cover the debt. That healing must be spiritual,real; it has to be heart felt. Not just sorry because one got caught and now is penalized, but sorry to the point of "it will never happen again".
And the courts slamming them against the wall hasn't/won't help. Congress has to learn how to take responsibility for their stupidity - and this is just the beginning of the learning phase.
The amounts of money involved are mind boggling. I stumbled across the IHC suit, seems that it's over a billion dollars, not confirmed though.
Oh hell no, we can't pay those damn Indians, just because we stole it from them doesn't mean we should pay more than a penney on a dollar./s
Didn't we just spend $500 million to train 5 Syrian troops..Hell of a deal.
"We" paid to train them? Why did "we" pay for the training?
Never mind that question, why is the title of this article "Massive" settlement? It should read, " Once Again, Shamefully Reduced" settlement....
''Never mind that question, why is the title of this article "Massive" settlement? It should read, " Once Again, Shamefully Reduced" settlement....''
Yes it should Mimi.
Butt...butt...butt - "we" just paid $500M to train 5 people - "we" don't have that kind of money for the Indians.
Yes, it is Raven.
Israel comes to mind.
Good point, RW. Seems like America is good at pointing the finger at others, while allowing bigotry and injustice within our own borders. May take a few generations, a lot of education, and more tolerance all around, but maybe just maybe, our children and grandchildren will be able to live in peace and harmonywith each other.
Don - our children and grandchildren have no problem getting along now - the whites, reds, browns, yellows and blacks are doing just fine.
However, when the adults show up, all hell breaks loose and the kids run and hide - seriously.
We, in the U. S., need to get all of the adults to act like the children and grandchildren and start living in peace and harmony with each other and start accepting responsibility for our actions - no matter when those actions took place if we gave our word to honor those actions.
1st.... I could not agree with you more. You just said it better and with more emphasis and clarity than I did. Thank you. When adults try to act like adults, not much gets accomplished. Hope is all well with you, my friend. Funny, when I was in AK this summer I wondered if you were out and about on "War Pony" much. Undoubtedly, the best paint job I have ever seen on ' 'bike'.
Thank you Sir.
We need to "try" to get acting adults into the U. S. political stream. There are some, but not enough.
Time and again, we have seen that when a tribal government runs a federal program, the program is more successful and more responsive to the tribal community,
Truer words were never spoken.