(Bloomberg) -- The best-laid estate plans just got muddled.
President Barack Obama is proposing a fundamental change in tax policy that would limit what many Americans can leave to their heirs. The change would affect billionaires -- as well as people who arent wealthy enough to pay estate taxes, if their assets have gained sharply enough in value.
A family home or a stock portfolio that quadrupled in value to $1 million over the years and goes to a child could be subject to taxes on that gain, whether or not its sold.
Though its likely to go nowhere in the Republican-led Congress, the plan lays down a marker for future Democratic tax policy. That prospect is prompting people to seek advice from estate planners and lawyers as they consider the proposed new tax at death that could expose a family home, business or securities to more than 60 percent in combined federal and state levies.
We have a lot of families that own a specific stock, and theyve owned that forever, and they do not want to get rid of it, said Katherine Dean, a managing director of wealth planning at Wells Fargo Private Bank in San Francisco. This will have a huge impact on them. Huge.
Obamas proposal, which will be detailed in his budget plan on Feb. 2, would impose a capital gains tax at death on the growth in the value of assets since they were purchased, except for those donated to charity. The plan also raises the top capital gains rate to 28 percent from 23.8 percent.
Home Exemption
There would be a $200,000 exemption plus a $500,000 exemption for homes. For the $1 million home initially purchased by a married couple for $250,000, that would mean $500,000 of the gain would be exempt and a federal tax of up to $70,000 would be owed on the remaining $250,000 in appreciation.
Its one of the plans Obama is pushing in his final two years in office that resonate with those concerned about income inequality and policies that promote inherited wealth.
The simplest strategy to blunt the proposed tax increase would involve making gifts to children -- even taxable gifts -- well before reaching old age. That gives the assets more time to grow in value for younger heirs before they would be hit by the estate tax or by Obamas proposed levy on appreciated assets at death.
Full Gain
The only catch is that recipients of the gifts would have to pay taxes on the full gain if and when they sell.
Gift-giving is a particularly advantageous strategy for assets -- like a growing business -- that have a relatively low value now but are expected to increase.
If you believe that company, that asset, whatever it is, is going to blow up in value, yeah, get it out of your estate while it has an extremely low value, Dean said.
Currently, upon ones death, the estate is assessed the federal estate tax with a top rate of 40 percent on property. Yet it applies only to the handful of Americans with more than $5.43 million in assets and for married couples with more than $10.86 million.
If and when heirs sell, they owe capital gains taxes only on the difference between the sale price and the value when they inherited the asset.
In some cases, all appreciation during ones lifetime can go untouched by the capital gains tax. That gives people an incentive to hold onto assets for tax reasons, especially if they have a low-cost basis, or the value when purchased.
The tax break will cost the government an estimated $33.2 billion in revenue this year, according to the congressional Joint Committee on Taxation.
Curbing Break
Obamas plan to curb the break would end what the White House has labeled -- inaccurately -- the trust fund loophole and what others have called the angel of death loophole. The rule has nothing to do with trust funds.
Hes really creating a whole other set of taxes that will hit people who die with an estate, said David Scott Sloan, a partner at Holland & Knight LLP in Boston who specializes in estate planning.
A disproportionate share of Obamas proposed capital gains tax increases would fall on the wealthiest Americans: The top 0.1 percent of households -- those with incomes exceeding $3.4 million -- would pay 35 percent of the higher levy, according to the Tax Policy Center in Washington. It would affect fewer than 1 percent of households with incomes below $500,000.
Using different methodology, the Treasury Department says an even greater share of the costs are borne by the wealthiest households, with more than 80 percent of the burden on the top 0.1 percent.
Entirely Optional
For wealthy people, whether they pay taxes on capital gains is entirely optional, said Ray Madoff, a professor at Boston College Law School. So to close that loophole would be enormous from a tax policy point of view.
There would be some winners. Owners of small businesses would be able to defer the tax until the business is sold, and owners of closely held businesses would be able to spread the taxes over 15 years.
Even with those protections, the proposals would require estate planners to rethink their strategies. Much of the planning is premised on the existence of the tax break on capital gains.
Because state income taxes -- including Californias 13.3 percent top rate -- typically apply to capital gains, the combined rates for some taxpayers may exceed 60 percent if they were paying federal estate and capital gains levies, and local ones.
Gift Tax
Facing that liability would make it attractive for people to gift more assets during their lives and have any future appreciation occur inside a younger heirs estate, Madoff said.
Because of how its structured, the gift tax is also cheaper. At the 40 percent gift-tax rate and ignoring the exemption, making a $100 million gift requires $140 million to transfer the asset and cover the levy. By comparison, leaving the asset through an estate at death requires $166.7 million because the estate-tax rate is applied to the whole amount including taxes paid.
Obamas plan would also make work for people charged with tracking down the original cost of assets, minus depreciation.
Under current law, the step up in basis at death -- where assets are calculated at full market value in the owners estate -- means executors dont have to figure out what someone paid for stock, land or a business when purchased years ago, let alone take into account what improvements were made along the way.
The last time estate lawyers had to confront this issue, as part of the temporary 2010 repeal of the estate tax, they had trouble doing all the research.
There could be a whole new industry of people tracking ancient basis, said Bobbi Bierhals, a partner at McDermott Will & Emery in Chicago who specializes in estate planning.
http://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2015-01-30/inheriting-grandma-s-house-comes-with-tax-bill-under-obama-plan
In the New York City Area, meaning the 5 Boroughs of Manhattan, Bronx, Queens, Brooklyn and Staten Island, homes are typically, a Minimum of $500K - $1miilion and upwards, even more in the suburbs, depending on the neighborhood, Now, there are some properties that has been in families for generations, passing from one to another, they were not purchased at a huge sum, but over time the value has increased, those people inheriting those properties are not necessarily rich, they are mostly working folks but they keep up with the property taxes and maintenance, now, according to the above article, those folks would be required to pay the inheritance taxes even though the property has not been sold, lets say its that way, what happens to those families who may not have the money to pay? will their property be seized by the govt. and sold at auction, or, they would be forced to take a loan, this is a set up for disaster by the Obama administration, the same kind of set-up that had been proposed on the 529 college savings plan...Does Obama know what the hell he is doing to people, or, are the Repubs..onto something...
This could have an adverse effect on family farms and small privately owned businesses and those that might have to sell rather than continue after the death of a parent if they cannot pay the taxes.
A possible adverse effect
I see it just the same RIO...Should I start listening to Sixpick, is he knowing what I failed to see???
Yes, you should have been listening to Sixpick all along. Just be glad he's a lame duck blowing hot air at this point of the game.
Well, I don't just listen to folks, I have to see evidence to be convinced and the evidence I seek should be coming from the Horse's mouth...
Not necessarily sure that yes or no is the right answer in this situation
That changes are needed to the tax code is inarguable, that some subsidies, credits, deductions and loopholes need to be closed or eliminate is also pretty much a given.
Inheritance taxes are tricky, what should be exempt from the tax, should exemptions be by estate value or income level or should there be no exceptions? All questions to be answered if a meaningful bipartisan attempt at tax code reform is undertaken. Otherwise it is simply political theater from both sides of the aisle on the matter.
I personally think that inheritance/estate/death tax (whatever you wish to call it) should be in place and that it needs to be a graduated liability so that estates valued at $500K or $1M are taxed at the same rate as much larger estates. I also think that the tax should be on the value of estate at the time of passing from one individual to the other.
Why should "ANYONE" pay inheritance tax when the person passing on that property has paid over the years, If I have paid all the taxes on my property, paid all the taxes on my income and now passing on to my children, WHY??? should my children pay on top of what I have earned and paid on...I paid taxes BECAUSE I DO Not want my children and grandchildren to be BURDENED...Look, I know the property has increased in value, but that's the purpose of leaving an inheritance, you want that person to benefit from your labor, I don't want the GOVT. dipping their nasty little fingers in what I have left for my kids...I don't think their should be inheritance taxes..
CM
Then you should take steps to gradually pass ownership to your heirs over time, to minimize tax burdens on all concerned.
When a bank account or a property passes to a "new" owner it is income to them, that is how the law reads.
Don't like the law, then elect people who will change the tax code more to your liking.
Elimination of the estate tax is highly unlikely, but changes to it to make it more fair are possible and even likely as bargaining points as the two sides work out a compromise on tax code reform in the coming years.
I know and agree RIO, I was not speaking from a personal matter, just what I didn't like...
I get that and there are steps that can be taken as well.
For instance, a retired couple living comfortably in a home that is paid for and owns additional property could have a living trust set up consisting of their three sons, sell the house and property to the trust, pay the trust enough monthly to cover the property taxes and upon their death the property is already in the hands of their children and no estate tax is paid.
You should call a lawyer and get that property into a trust CM.
The Internal Revenue Service announced the 2015 estate and gift tax limits today, and the federal estate tax exemption rises to $5.43 million per person,
That's right RIO...
Thanks DM..I was only giving my opinion about inheritance taxes...thanks anyway, someone could benefit from the information..
No one should. It is akin to the used car tax IMO. Somebody already paid the sales tax when it was new. Why should the 2nd, 3rd ect...owners have to pay it again, and again, and again...
Nothing more than a new governmental scheme to steal your money. They don't give a crap who it hurts.
Nobody likes the inheritance tax, but stand back and take a look at the big picture. The whole idea is to keep money in circulation rather than pooling. It is the same with capital gains taxes. Our economy only works when money is in circulation. In short, money has to work.
So with that in mind, how do we keep money in circulation?
Under the mattress, Just kidding, couldn't help it...
The estate tax currently protects a little more than the first $5 million. That protects almost everyone.
There are laws on the books that will insulate those with more than that. There are trusts that can be executed that can effectively remove most of the tax liability from larger estates. Life insurance policies are exempt from the estate tax, which can go to paying any estate taxes.
If you're worth less than $5 million, it doesn't matter much. If you're worth more than that, chances are your accountant told you to see a lawyer about writing a trust and an insurance broker to write you a policy to pay the taxes.
I have no idea how to "imbed" youtube stuff - but, here's George, Paul, Ringo and John.
Yes that is the BS reason they tout for the tax. Supply and demand for vehicles is what it is. Before the tax came to being, used cars sold for more.... and the money went in your pockets if you were the seller. The only real difference in the scheme today is that the government takes a piece. Cars break and new ones must be bought regardless. If the supply of used is low, prices rise and it makes sense to buy new. This is still as true today as it was before the taxes.
Now you know from the message I sent you.
Money in circulation is what makes our economy go. What other engine is there to help keep money in circulation?
Not being facetious, but jobs would help.
Got it - gonna practice - thanks.