Big Cases, But Little Room at Court (?Camera Coverage of the SCOTUS?)
The dignified calm of the U.S. Supreme Court was broken recently when seven protesters, one after another, rose to shout epithets about the growing power of money in American politics a trend the court has hastened through its rulings.
It was a rare moment of chaos in the court. When the episode ended, Chief Justice John Roberts told spectators , "We will now continue with our tradition of having open court in the Supreme Court."
Roberts' off-the-cuff remark was significant, reminding the public that the nation's highest court is indeed open and openness can sometimes be messy in a democracy. But as the court continues to add blockbuster cases to its docket, the unfortunate narrow scope of the court's openness deserves scrutiny.
In the next three months, the Supreme Court will hear arguments on three extraordinary landmark issues: same-sex marriage , the future of Obamacare and the constitutionality of lethal injections for capital punishment.
Roberts is correct that the court will be open when those cases are argued but only to 200 or so members of the public lucky enough to obtain seats. Many will wait in line for days in advance. If past experience is repeated, wealthy individuals who want seats will pay thousands of dollars for others to wait in line for them an unseemly business that tarnishes the court's image of openness.
Why will only a relative handful of people be able to witness history at the court? Because, as open as it is, the court has long refused to let cameras record or broadcast its proceedings. We have written about this before, but the court's policy continues to amaze people especially young people, who take transparency and access for granted.
Recent polls have shown strong approval for cameras in the Supreme Court (71%) and record-high agreement that the court should be more open and transparent generally (95%).
The group Fix the Court, which advocates for greater transparency at the Supreme Court, posted an amusing video recently in which random Americans were told that the Super Bowl will not be televised. The interviewees refused to believe it and, no worries, it will be. But when those interviewed were told that a slightly more important institution namely, the Supreme Court is never televised, they were incredulous, and upset.
The court is unlikely to suddenly see the light and open its doors to cameras in time for the same-sex marriage argument. It might allow the expedited release of the audio of the argument, as it did when a related challenge of the Defense of Marriage Act took place in 2013. It may also take other small steps toward openness.
But don't expect much. As Roberts said in his annual report Dec. 31, "courts will often choose to be late to the harvest of American ingenuity ." He also noted that sculptures of tortoises can be found in several architectural features of the court building, representing the court's "constant but deliberate" progress.
But on the cause of openness at the court, it is long past due for the tortoise to cross the finish line.
T ony Mauro is Supreme Court correspondent for The National Law Journal and the Supreme Court Brief. He is a member of the USA TODAY Board of Contributors.
http://www.usatoday.com/story/opinion/2015/01/29/supreme-court-openness-tony-mauro-column/22404151/
Tags
Who is online
106 visitors

Has the time come for CSpan live coverage of SCOTUS arguments?
Should those that disrupt the court proceedings be expelled? charged with contempt? banned?
Always appreciate a comment that gets to the crux of the issue, thanks.
Perhaps the audience should be seated on the right and left depending on whether they support the plaintiff od the defendant.
And that is important to you I can see
I assume you are being disingenuous, but in case you really want to know
Think about the adage "nothing disinfects like sunshine and fresh air" -- it is a metaphor advocating openness and transparency
Gunny
I agree that the open sessions of the court (arguments) should be televised and I see no reason to change the ability of people to attend the court sessions either.
So would being arrested for contempt of court.
Protests are not acceptable in lower courts and are certainly not appropriate inside the SCOTUS
We are talking about open and transparent as regards the SCOTUS not the entire government.
Apparently you are in a minority that do not want more openness (cameras) in the SCOTUS
The metaphor is what it is, openness provides information to "we the people" whether we use that knowledge to hold someone accountable is another issue entirely.
You are conflating a simply issue.
The issue and the topic is whether SCOTUS proceedings should be televised, the rest is ancillary.
So what say you to cameras in the SCOTUS - YES or NO.
Simple question
And when they do, those causing the disruptions in the court rooms *wherever the court room) should be charged with contempt of the court and dealt with appropriately.
You are reaching again - no mentioned voting for justices.
And the justices are not voted for
Once again, the topic is whether or not to have cameras in the SCOTUS. if you have an answer to that please share it.
If you want to wander farther into the weeds, then enjoy your walk.
No yes or no to cameras in the SCOTUS, which is the topic and the question is as simple as you can get.
If you care to?
No but you have!
Just as television cameras are not allowed in he jury room, neither would they or should they be behind the scenes in the SCOTUS for deliberations by the justices.
So again, are you in favor of televised SCOTUS arguments or not?
Yes or no?