╌>

What is wrong with Liberalism?

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  96ws6  •  11 years ago  •  82 comments

What is wrong with Liberalism?

by Patrick Alan Pittman

What is Liberalism?
Modern American Liberalism is not the same as classical (Jeffersonian) liberalism. In fact it is almost the exact opposite. Modern American liberalism is:

  • The (mistaken) belief that the restriction of Individual Liberty and private property rights can improve society through government efforts to design and manage economic and social structures.
  • The (mistaken) belief that a mob of men can better manage society than core values that protect the individual and his property and enforcement of laws that ensure equal protection of citizens while limiting government and allowing individuals to protect themselves.
  • The (mistaken) belief that social safety nets imposed on the populace are more compassionate than allowing the individual freedom to fail (or succeed) from ones life decisions.
  • The (mistaken) belief that involuntary re-distribution of wealth is moral.

Classical (Jeffersonian) Liberalism (Which is modern conservatism) is a belief in the superiority of the American core values:

  • Individual Liberty
  • The right to self protection
  • The protection of private property rights
  • Equal protection under the law
  • Limited government (Self reliance)

With these working definitions we begin to describe why liberalism fails so often:

Political correctness achieves the opposite of its intent-
What is the intent of political correctness? Possibly to achieve less animosity and promote greater harmony among different cultural and racial groups by limiting the publicly acceptable speech in diverse company through collective shaming and disparagement of undesirable thoughts and verbiage in public. The intent being to remove thought and speech offensive to certain groups.

The results of political correctness are that it interrupts positive as well as negative cultural structures. Political correctness creates an atmosphere of fear that pits cultural groups against each other in polarity rather than in cooperation. People are afraid to say the wrong thing because political correctness dictates an air of cultural entitlement to historically submissive cultures and a sense of guilt to historically dominant cultures thus dividing further the intended blend of cultures in a dynamic of fueling the offensiveness of words that could fade with apathy without the politically correct labeling of the speech; giving power and longevity to the negative impact of words that would otherwise remain a remnant of the cultural lexicon.

Political correctness creates an atmosphere of intolerance of other cultures by leaving no flexibility for cross-cultural transition through natural healing and natural interaction, preventing offensive speech that could grow into tolerable speech over time and cultural abstraction and transition of typical cultural vagary.

Redistribution of wealth fails to achieve economic equality and prosperity-
The concept of wealth redistribution by central government planners has been attempted many times and always results in the reverse of its intention. The dynamics of economic interaction cause people to respond positively to income enhancement, but the productivity of those in society with a propensity to succeed economically is proportional to their ability to keep what they earn.

When the productive are punished for their audacity to generate income (through its forced removal by nebulous entities who claim that their earnings are better spent by supporting the unproductive), not only does this cause discontent, but it decreases the desire to produce by reducing the reward. The recipients of those redistributed dollars become complacent and assume its repetition to the point of eventual dependency. Just as removal of earned dollars causes the productive to reduce output when the futility of added production becomes evident; so does the distribution of the un-earned dollars cause the recipient to trend complacent and apathetic toward the need to exert productive behavior while the assurance of new dollars continues.

Multiculturalism inflames cultural jealousies and bias instead of erasing them
Multiculturalism is the liberal concept of unnaturally forcing the amalgamation of differing cultures through institutional structures designed to promote the blending of disparate peoples in public settings. Removal of any established set of values or cultures as central is essential to the idea of Multiculturalism .Multiculturalism attempts to equalize values ,religions and ethnic groups in a (well intended ) attempt to remove the natural barriers among differing groups found in proximity to one another.

The problems arise when cultural differences get prominence under a director of multicultural thought ; when one (supposed minority) group gets favor in a public setting to achieve some reparation for a perceived past wrong it has suffered under another group. Multiculturalism attempts to achieve equality through unequal treatment or favor to selected groups to mend their differences. This concept ignores or disregards the cultural assertions and desires of each group by trivializing their dominant traits and removing their natural social power. Multiculturalism neuters the cultures it attempts to equalize by establishing the power for cultural foundation in the institution and not leaving the establishment of cultural power to the cultures themselves.

In order to preserve harmony, multiculturalism removes natural cultural hegemony and establishment of authority. If central planning of cultural integration is better, then which culture gets to establish the plan; and with which favor or aversion do the selected other group(s) comply? Multiculturalism creates an established power for the elite and relegates the common cultures to subservience to the Liberal in charge of determining how the cultures may or may not interact.

Centrally planned economies fail more people than they help
Bureaucracies, by their very nature, are inefficient and cumbersome in actual (as opposed to theoretical) operation. It takes far more resources to produce any government generated output than a free market output merely because of the added bureaucracy involved in every step of its inception. The development of an entire economy controlled by a centrally planned bureaucracy is, in practice, untenable because there are always too many interdependent factors involved in the interaction of market forces and human cultural and economic transaction to predict key policy measures accurately enough to maintain balance.

Without balance, an economy spins uncontrollably in tangential directions and must be compensated by policies that can exacerbate already perilous trends. The inefficiency and clumsiness of bureaucratic decision making is only catalyst to the corruptible influences of power so easily abused and leveraged through the lives of people subjugated by the unique dispensation of the use of force given to the government that no other entity in society can legitimately claim. With the combination of economic complexity and bureaucratic inefficiency, central planning has proven to be disastrous in nations who have attempted this system in the past. The history of communism and socialism is replete with the inherent failure of central planning to both predict and correct anomalies in the interactive cultural and economic markets in time to have the desired positive effects.

On the contrary, central planning has, historically, been the broken lynchpin in the essential connection between producer and consumer in society. It has also proven to be a culturally disrupting factor in its inability to address regional and local intricacies that require surgical solutions rather than sledge hammer rectification. The environmental destruction and economic failure of past socialist attempts pale in comparison to the deaths that have been caused as the tyranny of the bureaucracy combines with the corruption of the planners.

When liberalism restricts Individual liberty it causes more discontent than the absence of promised benefits
There is a reason that the founders of America singled out individual liberty as a crucial element in the inception of the new constitution. Individual liberty is the primary element of success in a free society and cannot be substituted for perceived security. Liberalism is in opposition to individual liberty because the individual is to be subjugated to the collective will under the modern liberal ideal. With Liberal collective management of society, the individual is to surrender to the will of the mob. The group is supreme and the individual is subordinate.

When the desire for perceived security causes liberals to force the sacrifice of freedoms and property rights through government regulation and micro-management of the lives of citizens, the overall satisfaction of society is diminished when the benefits of the attempted security measures dwindle in time under the crushing cost of the bureaucracy that must be instituted to manage the details and juggle the infinite complexities of the equitable disbursement of seized assets to deserving parties. The benefits of individual liberty outweigh the burdens of social management.

The repeated failure of the elites in management of the treasury to accurately predict and balance the accounts of distribution, or even read the behavior of the populace to design the next course of action is well documented in history. The promised benefits of safety net bureaucracy always end with the bankruptcy of the original plan and the raiding of the coffers to placate the ever hungry power structure, which inevitably takes precedence over the intended beneficiary of the safety net.

Private property rights protect the environment better than big government
With the increasing growth in population and its inevitable consumption of resources and waste production, conscious protection of the environment becomes increasingly more important to society.

Big government liberalism seeks to impose upon society the theories of elite professors on the government payroll (whose livelihoods depend upon continued need for their pontifications) that can tell the ignorant masses the most effective route for environmental stability. Yet, with all of their study and (unique) interpretation of data that they alone are qualified to assemble, the understanding of human nature still eludes them such that the proposed solutions to our environmental problems continue to be untenable and completely impracticable. With solutions impossible to adequately implement, they become useless as real applicable answers.

Individual actors with property to protect and preserve, however, have proven through the years to be more adept at maintaining a more viable balance of: production and waste, problem identification and solution, and self preservation of an environment that supports continuance of the productive activities that create the profits that individual actors work to create. With continued productivity as an incentive, individuals with property to protect will usually maintain an environment which supports that goal.

When property is seized by bureaucrats and applied to programs that build more infrastructure that is by nature not self-supporting, the users of that property have no personal vested interest to protect that which they do not own and can never control.(see any public areas and compare to privately maintained property of similar monetary value , people will not voluntarily maintain public property that of which someone else is probably assigned to take care).

People will trash public highways and beaches; they will deface and destroy public places with no regard to continuity. But someone who owns a building or a farm or a piece of property will be much more likely to protect and maintain his own place. (If for no other reason than the possible loss of value). When property rights are destroyed, what is the incentive to maintain that which is kept out of the reach of individuals?

Capitalism causes more wealth than big government
Government does not create wealth. It seizes wealth. Government can print money, but that has no value unless some individual is willing to sacrifice some portion of his time (life) in exchange for that currency. It is in this regard that printed money is only worth what value the productive members of society are willing to attach to it. If the government prints too much, wealth does not increase; it decreases when inflation devalues those things which are artificially in abundance.

Property is only as valuable as it is difficult (or rare) to obtain. If the government seizes earned wealth from the productive to redistribute to those whom liberal bureaucrats think need or deserve it more than the person who earned it, then the value diminishes, not only with the free distribution of property in an inflationary sense, but it diminishes in the respect that anything that requires little or no effort to obtain loses its rarity. As a trophy which all players in the soccer league receive (for mere participation) is not as desirable as the championship (or Most Valuable Player) trophy would be.

If Government gives away property (that it must seize to obtain in the first place) , it ceases to be wealth (the accumulation of items of value)because it diminishes in value through the act of unearned receipt. Capitalism (in a free market) is the embodiment of what wealth accumulation represents. People are free to act in ways that increase (or decrease) their own ability to gain items of value. That, in turn, allows more people to participate in the attempt as more wealth circulates in society.

Liberalism, in fact, decreases the value of valuable things through the process of elites rewarding favor to other like-thinking elites to display the greatness of liberalism. Giving away a Nobel Prize to Barack Obama (and before that, Yasser Arafat, and Al Gore respectively) before he had accomplished anything to earn it is the perfect example. The prize, used to be a universally valued award for great accomplishments, yet liberals, in rewarding mere liberalism (and appeasing terrorists in the case of Arafat) have forever tarnished the value of the once great symbol of achievement. It is blatantly evident, not so much in who received the prize when these liberals were honored by their fellows, but in who was passed by (and the ignored achievements of those people).

Equal protection under the law is impossible under liberalism
The constitutional principle of equal protection of all citizens under the law cannot be implemented by liberal elites whose core philosophy comes from the ten planks of Karl Marxs Communist Manifesto; the primary concept of which resides in the forced heavy progressive income tax. Taxing citizens on income, rather than consumption, requires a large Liberal government to investigate the personal financial activity of citizens and to punish productive behavior by taxing the earnings of the most productive at a greater rate than the least productive (who become rewarded for their lack of productivity by this system).Equal treatment of citizens would require the government to view (and tax) all citizens the same regardless of productive capacity. A consumption tax on retail sales would accomplish this objective. (And Alexander Hamilton stated as much in Federalist 12 when the design of the constitution was being forged).

Liberalism cannot tolerate equal protection under the law because that would undermine its primary directive of wealth redistribution among citizens. It is impossible to use the government to redistribute wealth and still maintain private property rights for individual citizens. In order to take the productive capacity (earned or inherited property) from one citizen to give to another, the property rights must be suspended for the productive while protecting the property rights of the recipient. Equal protection under the law would require the government to treat all citizens and their property with identical reverence. Liberalism insists on cultural and racial discrimination by the government as well as financial discrimination. Federally funded institutions require diversity in everything but philosophical thought conservative (and especially Christian) ideas are removed from governmental discourse at all levels in the name of political correctness.

Racial discrimination is forced through school systems insisting on cultural reparations for perceived (and real) past wrongs by discriminatory systems such as affirmative action (and cultural student centers which divide people into all isolated racial groups except whites , who are not allowed to exclude the other groups in reciprocal fashion.)Government contracts also seek to amend these past wrongs through the elite treatment of (liberally) favored groups of citizens over others who cannot be eligible for these set-asides.(your great grandfathers past wrongs must be punished and you are the recipient of these lashes, and whomever he wronged must have a great grandson in need of some government favor to amend for these evils).In totality the entire concept is riddled with the very unevenness it intends to cure.

Liberalism cannot protect citizens while appeasing the enemies of the culture
American culture, long established with the standards of Judeo-Christian ethic and traditions, is replete with examples of the success of liberty and the superiority of the laws of property and limited governance. When an entity displays its belligerence to American tradition and culture, and even openly demands its destruction (as in the case of the world wide spread of Islam) Liberals are the first to defend these entities and even oppose the defenders of traditional American values.

The examples are voluminous; all public vestiges of Christian heritage and tradition have been attacked by liberals using the invented constitutional principle of separation of church and state, the defense of Islam as its incremental encroachment in America begins to mimic the malignant spread of violent culture in Europe and other past centers of liberty worldwide, The kneejerk support of Hamas and the Palestinian culture which feeds violent Islam against our ally Israel, Appeasement of La Rasa and illegal alien invasion of America by cultures that want, not to assimilate and blend with American culture( as the Irish,Italians,Jews,Polish,Germans ,Scots and others did at the end of the 19th century)but to invade our territory (to which they claim title)and establish new conquest (they call themselves reconquistadores )with no immigrant process to establish their acceptance of our laws and acknowledgement of American culture.

Liberal appeasement of all enemies of American culture describes their inability to understand the lessons of history and illustrates their animosity toward the rule of law and the maintenance of the culture of property rights and equal protection that America represents. How can Liberals both protect Americans while appeasing their enemies?

How can Liberals both respect the immigration laws of America while simultaneously suing states that enact laws (even laws that mimic [unenforced] federal laws) that are geared to protect those Border States from the violent and intrusive invasion by people who refuse to abide by the law voluntarily? How can Liberals defend the Islamic terrorists captured fighting our soldiers overseas and claim to protect American culture which is in the crosshairs of these same groups?

They cannot. Liberal appeasement is yet another blatant failure of the philosophy that is rife with failures.

The safety net has no protection from wasteful politicians and will go bankrupt financially while simultaneously promoting a culture of dependence
Social security, no longer isolated away from the sticky fingers of ravenous politicians, has become (and provably so) a Ponzi -scheme destined to run out of funds. Originally designed as a safety net for the destitute retiree, Social Security has become a catch all crutch for the dependency culture. Born of liberal golden intentions, Social security has also become the unmentionable third rail of political discourse and the well worn political shame bat for beating the fiscal conservative back into place whenever the reform of this broken entity is suggested. Welfare and Social Security have also transformed an American culture founded on self reliance to one of acceptance (appeasement) of a dependency class who refuses to acknowledge the immorality of a life lived at the expense of others.

Once dependent, the moocher class is not only dependent on the fruits of their neighbors labor, but also on the provider (in the form of a liberal looter class which trades seized money from the productive for votes from the dependent moocher). This immoral cycle is the heart of liberalism and promotes fear and animosity on the part of the dependent class, who is ever afraid of losing the free lunch while simultaneously building severe (goaded) animosity and resentment of the producers from whom their livelihood is taken. This wealth envy fire is stoked by liberalism and is the primary weapon through which the producer is demonized and looted by the bureaucratic tyranny of the big government machine.

The producers in society have little in the way of recourse when the leverage of votes comes from the dependent class bent on preserving their unearned stipend, and while the looters are eager to promise a new round of payments from the wealthy to even the playing field in a contrived class war in which the unproductive become victims of an imaginary task master.(who, in reality wants the poor to become wealthy through self reliance, if, for no other reason than to remove another burden from the overtaxed producers).

The liberal war on poverty has failed miserably
When President Lyndon Johnson declared a war on poverty in 1964, a new era of bureaucratic overkill and incompetence was launched with glorious fanfare. The evidence that liberalism has lost this war in miserable sniveling fashion is all around us today. Everywhere there are big government programs to eliminate poverty and redistribute the wealth in society, there are slums, empty factories, and dependent citizens standing in line for the latest round of government subsidized giveaways ranging from reduced (or free)lunches for those citizens whose parents are not responsible enough to limit their breeding habits to those children that they can afford, to hoards of people standing in line to receive free vouchers for power bill assistance (all the while complaining about the inefficiency and inconvenience of the process for free stuff taken from the neighbor who is at work earning the money to support them as they bark out their objections).

When refugees from Hurricane Katrina werent raping and robbing each other in the Superdome in New Orleans, they were luxuriating in donated quarters on cruise ships and trashing the place in wanton fashion. If poverty were just an unfortunate circumstance as liberals claim, then its escape would be swift in a free society where jobs are plentiful and opportunities to create income are as abundant as ideas and free hours of the Idle. But as the mass influx of illegal immigrants have taught us (through the millions of earned dollars wired back to their home countries after arriving in America with, literally only the clothes on their backs) poverty in America is largely voluntary.

In fact, poverty in America is a function of cultural failure. Namely the liberal culture who designs a war on poverty based on giving a man a metaphorical fish (taken involuntarily from his productive neighbor) rather than leaving him to his own motivation after teaching him to fish. This is the starkest and obvious failure of liberal philosophy, and its repercussions resonate throughout the cultures it infects in the form of unintended consequences that effect society in concentric waves around each liberal attempt to repair a problem with something other than high expectations, self reliance, individual responsibility and the freedom to fail.

Everywhere in America that poverty exists today is an example of dependence on government programs designed to foster that continued failure rather than to repair the initial cultural problem. No one wants poor people to burden their neighbors, but it is far more compassionate to teach self reliance (and there is only one way to teach self reliance) than to perpetuate dependence.
Liberalism always perpetuates dependence.

In debt is no way to raise a responsible population
Huge financial debts, whether personal, institutional or generational, always limit productive capacity and self actualization of people. Liberalism and government control over larger and larger portions of American life seed the expansion of bureaucracy with the debt of the productive institutionally, and when those programs double and triple in size and scope , the debt becomes generational as todays politicians pay for their expansions with tomorrows expected revenues and thus children who are not even born are in debt to pay for the excesses that liberals design to manage society in opulent (and unnecessary) fashion. Personal debts can be controlled by the individual, but as America has experienced recently, when liberals attempt to appease parasitic voters with debt bailouts based on tomorrows production, the financial irresponsibility (enabled by a ravenous liberal bureaucracy) becomes geometric in progression.

Liberalism itself excuses irresponsible behavior by appeasing the mooching voters with redistributed wealth. And thus, perpetuates poor fiscal habits by denying free citizens the important freedom to fail from their poor decisions and to learn (and possibly to improve) from necessary mistakes. This denial of human nature and needed education in reality is a function of liberal inability to accept the proven self corrective characteristics of individual liberty and capitalism. Individually, sheltered children have an obvious and distinct disadvantage from children whose parents allowed their exploration of lifes trials and tribulations. Sheltered children grow into spoiled and dependent adults.

Children who were allowed to fall and struggle through their own selectively assisted exploration of the world around them are always better equipped adults when it comes to troubleshooting the problems and puzzles that life presents everyone .If you were never allowed to fail as a child, the difficulties in adulthood would be new to you when the decision making process is more critical and dangerous. When you have encountered the challenge of solving a problem before, the immediate reaction would be more focused on solution the second time around, rather than wonder at the enormity of the challenge. Liberalism and its accompanying bureaucratic overspending causes debt and reduces productive capacity for the individual, the institution and the generation that has to shoulder the debt and struggle to compensate for its burden.

When liberal big government programs capture a generation of dependents and lead them down the path of entitlement , the individuals become not just financially indebted to their neighbors for the receipt of their looted earnings, but the psychological dependency that evolves from this dysfunctional relationship becomes resentment and envy which is then used to advantage by the political class in the next round of the cycle as the instigation of jealousy and resentment fuel another raid on the productive in society.

I know a some are going to call this a misguided opinion piece (especially the ones who post opinions about other ideologies)

So I would like to ask some questions to help me understand Liberalism better.

What exactly is the "fair share" of someone's income that hes earned that he should be able to keep?

If people in the middle class aren't willing to pay enough in taxes to cover the government services that they use because they don't think it's worth the money, shouldn't we prune back government to a level people do feel comfortable paying for in taxes?

We live in a world where people have more choices than ever before in music, entertainment, careers, news sources and what to do with their time. Shouldn't government mirror that trend by moving towards federalism and states rights instead of centralizing more and more power in Washington, DC?

Since we "all agree" with the idea that our level of deficit spending is "unsustainable," what would be wrong with permanently freezing federal spending at the current level until we balance the budget by increasing revenue, cutting spending or some combination thereof?

Give me a ballpark estimate: If something doesn't change dramatically, how long do you think it will be until we have an economic crash in this country similar to the one we're seeing in Greece or Cyprus?

How can liberal economists like Paul Krugman be right when they claim that our economy isn't doing well because we aren't spending enough money when we're already running massive, unsustainable deficits and spending is going up every year?

If corporations are so awful, greedy and bad for the country, then shouldn't we be celebrating when they decide to close their plants here and move overseas?

Are you really pro-choice or just pro-abortion? If it's pro-choice, do you feel people should be able to choose to have an assault weapon, what kind of light bulb they use in their house or whether they'd like to put their Social Security funds into a private retirement account?

If you believe we have a "right" to things like health care, food, shelter and a good education, then doesn't that also mean you believe we also have a right to force other people to unwillingly provide those things under threat of imprisonment?


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   seeder  96WS6    11 years ago

I was going to read it, then saw it was a book, so I'll pass,

Why am I not surprised? Reading a book once in a blue moon would probably do you some good. Care to answer any of the questions at the bottom?

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   seeder  96WS6    11 years ago

Yes, I do.

I figured you would answer this question that way. Care to take a stab at the others?

Should people be allowed to enjoy the benefits of those things that are good for the country because they think they shouldn't have to pay for them too?

Let me rephrase the question. Do you think we also have a right to force some people to unwillingly provide more than others for those things under threat of imprisonment?

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   seeder  96WS6    11 years ago

What does capitalism have to do with social safety nets?

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   seeder  96WS6    11 years ago

Don't blame you. They are tough questions. That require thought.

 
 
 
Chucky Stuart
Freshman Silent
link   Chucky Stuart    11 years ago

What exactly is the "fair share" of someone's income that hes earned that he should be able to keep?

Tough question, but I don't think it's too much to ask that millionaires pay at least as much a percentage of their income in federal income tax as I do. As it stands, many pay a far lower percentage.

Since we "all agree" with the idea that our level of deficit spending is "unsustainable," what would be wrong with permanently freezing federal spending at the current level until we balance the budget by increasing revenue, cutting spending or some combination thereof?

I doubt you'll get either side to agree with that.

Are you really pro-choice or just pro-abortion? If it's pro-choice, do you feel people should be able to choose to have an assault weapon, what kind of light bulb they use in their house or whether they'd like to put their Social Security funds into a private retirement account?

Pro-choice all the way, whether it's the right of a woman to have sovereignty over her own body or someone choosing an Ar-15 over an AK (a choice I'll never understand but whatcha gonna do) or any other lifestyle choice that is no one elses business. I'll support anyone's right to light up, guzzle a Big Gulp, and listen to bad music.

If you believe we have a "right" to things like health care, food, shelter and a good education, then doesn't that also mean you believe we also have a right to force other people to unwillingly provide those things under threat of imprisonment?

I've long held the belief that health care should not be market driven. It's far more expensive and leads to health care decisions be based on a bottom line.

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   seeder  96WS6    11 years ago

What happens to the people that don't do well , in this libertarian ideology, or whatever it is?

Don't get me wrong. I am not saying people down on their luck shouldn't get help. What I am saying is the system gives them too much reason to stay on it. Recently in MI, they started enforcing the max 4 year limit on welfare. (up until a year or two ago NO time limit was enforced) Guess what happened. 85% of the "lifers" on welfare got jobs! They did it pretty fast too, and in a depressed economy. Imagine that!

 
 
 
Dean Moriarty
Professor Silent
link   Dean Moriarty    11 years ago

Good find this is a well thought out and informative article. I'm not very good at putting these thoughts into writing and this guy did a good job of it. Not much to disagree with on this one.

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   seeder  96WS6    11 years ago

Thanks for your thoughtful responses Chucky.

Tough question, but I don't think it's too much to ask that millionaires pay at least as much a percentage of their income in federal income tax as I do. As it stands, many pay a far lower percentage.

Close the loopholes and this problem goes away. It's not the rate that is the problem, so much as the damn loopholes. How about a consumption tax instead of income tax, that way the more you buy the more taxes you pay, the rich who buy more will pay more.

I doubt you'll get either side to agree with that.

Not the D&R's for sure

 
 
 
Dean Moriarty
Professor Silent
link   Dean Moriarty    11 years ago

"The article you seeded seems to be arguing that people should not contribute to the social safety net unless they want to. How many people do you think will "want to"?"

Not very many including Democrats. They would realize their party has been robbing them blind for far to long with no positive return. They will realize their party is not representing what they really want.

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   seeder  96WS6    11 years ago

You posted an extremely long article.

Yes, well there is much wrong with Liberalism isn't there?

 
 
 
Dean Moriarty
Professor Silent
link   Dean Moriarty    11 years ago

Capitalism will grow and they will create opportunities for themselves the way it should be. You will be surprised how many will pull themselves off the couch when we stop paying them to watch Oprah.

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   Bob Nelson    11 years ago

Capitalism will grow and they will create opportunities for themselves the way it should be.

Almost all added value in the American economy is going to the 1%.

 
 
 
Dean Moriarty
Professor Silent
link   Dean Moriarty    11 years ago

I was thinking more along the lines of the individual taking responsibility for his well being. The work camps were before my time and I really don't know enough about the pros and cons of them to comment. If they are going to be run by the government I think they would probably be a failure.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    11 years ago

Almost all added value in the American economy is going to the 1%.

It wasn't that way historically ...

 
 
 
Dean Moriarty
Professor Silent
link   Dean Moriarty    11 years ago

"Almost all added value in the American economy is going to the 1%"

Sure take Detroit for example those peoplehaven't doneanything to grow their economy in fifty years. They gave up they don't even mow the lawn or paint the houses anymore. People that do things right build andgrow and continue to reinvest and grow. There are a lot of 1%ers that do things right.

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   Bob Nelson    11 years ago

It's a long article... but it doesn't contain anything but poncifs. One after another, the bumper-sticker slogans are dutifully repeated... but nothing is demonstrated . Nothing at all.

Or downright delusional:

When refugees from Hurricane Katrina werent raping and robbing each other in the Superdome in New Orleans, they were luxuriating in donated quarters on cruise ships and trashing the place in wanton fashion.

Sadly, I think this is Libertarianism. Bumper-sticker slogans and delirium.

For example:

The concept of wealth redistribution by central government planners has been attempted many times and always results in the reverse of its intention.

If this is true there should be data. But just the other day, I posted this:

2545_discussions.jpg?width=500

Redistribution clearly works quite well... except in America.

I don't mind an opinion piece, but to be credible, it has to have at least a little bit of supporting data. Otherwise (as with redistribution) a single piece of adverse data carries the day.

This seed has no supporting data at all. It is not credible.

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   Bob Nelson    11 years ago

It's a long article... but it doesn't contain anything but poncifs. One after another, the bumper-sticker slogans are dutifully repeated... but nothing is demonstrated . Nothing at all.

Or downright delusional:

When refugees from Hurricane Katrina werent raping and robbing each other in the Superdome in New Orleans, they were luxuriating in donated quarters on cruise ships and trashing the place in wanton fashion.

Sadly, I think this is Libertarianism. Bumper-sticker slogans and delirium.

For example:

The concept of wealth redistribution by central government planners has been attempted many times and always results in the reverse of its intention.

If this is true there should be data. But just the other day, I posted this:

2546_discussions.jpg?width=500

Redistribution clearly works quite well... except in America.

I don't mind an opinion piece, but to be credible, it has to have at least a little bit of supporting data. Otherwise (as with redistribution) a single piece of adverse data carries the day.

This seed has no supporting data at all. It is not credible.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    11 years ago

Although somewhat interesting your stats are not the in the venue of the govt . Govt supposedly only concerns itself with income , not net worth . That's in the constitution . And there is you demonstrating you're not credible ...

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   Bob Nelson    11 years ago

Petey... If revenue is redistributed over a long period, the result will be what you see in the table.

And I don't think you'll find anything like you said in the Constitution. It says government cannot take property without due process. Eminent domain is an example. Or taxes, on another level.

 
 
 
Cerenkov
Professor Silent
link   Cerenkov    11 years ago
Silly. Capitalism does not create poverty. It lifts people out of poverty.
 
 
 
Cerenkov
Professor Silent
link   Cerenkov    11 years ago
Millionaires pay a higher percentage of their income as taxes. This is a typical liberal propaganda taljing point. It's quite simply a lie.
 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    11 years ago

If revenue is redistributed over a long period, the result will be what you see in the table.

The makeup of the top %tiles of US incomes keep changing ... to different members . Based on that fact US capitalism is about as fair as a capitalist system can be . It rewards the successful , not the wealthy "group" currently at the top .

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   Bob Nelson    11 years ago

Millionaires pay a higher percentage of their income as taxes.

No. False.

Here are some basics .

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   seeder  96WS6    11 years ago

I noticed you completely sidestepped the issues of Liberalism and instead offered why a different ideology is flawed. You also ignored the questions all you liberals have such a hard time answering. No surprise here. You just can't admit anything wrong with your own ideology, thanks for pointing out another problem with liberals.

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   Bob Nelson    11 years ago

Petey,

It wasn't that way historically ...

That depends on what moment(s) of history we look at. The lower classes (that is to say, the 99%) got a decent slice of the growth pie, in the form of rising wages, from WWII through the 70s. From then on, the share of the 1% has grown until today it is all of America's growth. Wages have been stagnant for a decade.

Picketty's contribution to our understanding was to go much further back, to show that concentration of wealth is the norm. We who lived during those post-WWII times of significant wage growth have a hard time accepting the fact that they were an exception, not the rule.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    11 years ago

Bob from here :

That depends on what moment(s) of history we look at.

Good point . Now if we can only get some of our NT whiners about the 1% to make that realization it might change their perspective ...

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   Bob Nelson    11 years ago

Petey,

if we can only get some of our NT whiners about the 1% to make that realization it might change their perspective ...

Do you think it a good thing that the already-rich get all newly created wealth?

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   seeder  96WS6    11 years ago

Pro-choice all the way, whether it's the right of a woman to have sovereignty over her own body or someone choosing an Ar-15 over an AK (a choice I'll never understand but whatcha gonna do) or any other lifestyle choice that is no one elses business. I'll support anyone's right to light up, guzzle a Big Gulp, and listen to bad music.

Spoken like a true JEFFERSON liberal. Sadly, you are the only liberal I know that is close. Most today that claim the title are nothing near a Jefferson liberal and would even argue against his beliefs.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    11 years ago
John would prefer Everyone starving, then no one would be poor.Capitalism is undoubtedly the greatest anti poverty program in the history of mankind. As the American poor of 2015 can attest, it's the best thing to happen to humanity.
 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   seeder  96WS6    11 years ago

John would prefer Everyone starving, then no one would be poor.

Everyone would be equal. Liberal mission accomplished!

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi    11 years ago

The work camps were before my time and I really don't know enough about the pros and cons of them to comment. If they are going to be run by the government I think they would probably be a failure.

The only work camps I know of were before my time as well, and were called the Conservation Corps, or CC Camps. My father volunteered for the CCC when he wasn't allowed to follow his brothers and join the Army because of his heart. He was stationed in the Great Smokey Mountains National Park.

Some of us have mentioned the CC Camps before and how they helped the economy and the nation. Kavika posted a terrific piece about the Native Americans involved with the Conservation Corps. There are certainly enough workers and skilled professionals out of jobs right now who could be put to work on the country's infrastructure were the Corps to be revived.

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man    11 years ago

If everyone was poor, then there are no poor. they would become the new middle class.

It is where socialism and liberalism (based upon socialism) has always failed. (except for the few chosen to lead)

Statism is always like that, doesn't matter if it is a monarchy, or a socialist/communist state. It is the epitome of "From the many, for the One"

As distinguished from "Out of Many, One" (E Pluribus Unum)

Greed and envy, is all a socialist/liberal supports. The "I got mine" philosophy of living.

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   seeder  96WS6    11 years ago

If everyone was poor, then there are no poor. they would become the new middle class.

Sad thing is that Liberals would say, everyone is equal and actually claim mission accomplished. I think they would be quite happy with this result. They would take responsibility for equality but never EVER would they claim the responsibility for the level of said equality.

As Bob pointed out, they are incapable of being in any way critical of their own ideology. This is why they all skipped the questions (as expected) With the exception of the only Liberal I know on NT that I would consider close to a Jefferson Liberal (Chucky) Obviously the rest decided they couldn't answer the questions without at least some level of admittance of a flawed ideology.

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   FLYNAVY1    11 years ago

The "I got mine" philosophy of living.

I'm not so sure that you have things quite right with this statement. This clearly aligns itself with the idea of self first, which again is at the heart of conservatism and libertarianism. Most definitely not the liberal mind.

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man    11 years ago

You have it backwards Fly.

"I Got Mine" is decidedly NOT at the heart of Libertarianism.

The example I most remember of this was at the Democrat convention where there was video if the lady with the Obama phone very loudly saying "I Got Mine" and "You Should Get Yours Too!"

You never hear such things coming from a libertarian.

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man    11 years ago

That is why I don't bother trying to explain or educate anymore. any time you try, it just winds up with you being abused and their espousing their failed ideology.

They really do NOT want to know anything but what they have been spoon fed.

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   Bob Nelson    11 years ago

As Bob pointed out, they are incapable of being in any way critical of their own ideology.

I hope you are not talking about me! IMHO, liberals spend entirely too much time soul-searching. Conservatives, with their ideas based on faith rather than fact, are never bothered by doubt.

Liberals present projects based on data.

Conservatives, meanwhile, spend most of their time attacking straw men built from their own fantasies, as in this thread. Why spend your time on highly dubious interpretations of John's ideas, instead of presenting your own?

Do you have any ideas to present? For example, you abhor Obamacare and are convinced that it is a disaster. What do you propose? Boehner and McConnell had nothing to propose last Sunday on TV. What do you suggest?

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   seeder  96WS6    11 years ago

You have just unwittingly proven my point Bob. How about you answer the questions at the bottom of the article, (if you are capable) Then I will answer yours.

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man    11 years ago

liberals spend entirely too much time soul-searching.

Yep, soul searching everyone else, when they should be soul searching themselves.

Liberals wouldn't be liberal without the ability to self assuredly point the finger at someone else.

Cause that is all they do is point fingers.

Just like you just did to 96, you deftly turned his question around and pointed the finger at someone else.

What question you ask?

Obviously the rest decided they couldn't answer the questions without at least some level of admittance of a flawed ideology.

that one.

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   Bob Nelson    11 years ago

Good afternoon, Gunny,

I never see any propositions from conservatives. I only see criticism of liberals. (Like here.)

So I am going to begin overtly asking for conservative ideas.

Do you like Obamacare? If not, what would you like to see instead?

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man    11 years ago

This is a perfect example of deflection, a method of controlling the discussion.

Pointing the finger at something else.

The discussion here is not about anything the republicans are or aren't doing. It is about the Liberal philosophy itself.

Which, unfortunately, liberals avoid discussing like avoiding the plague.

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   Bob Nelson    11 years ago

The discussion here is not about anything the republicans are or aren't doing. It is about the Liberal philosophy itself.

OK.

I recently read a simple distinction:

Liberals want to spread power among all people. Conservatives want to concentrate power in a limited number of people.

Wealth is of course a form of power, so liberals want to spread it around; conservatives want to concentrate it.

Rights are a limitation on power, so liberals promote rights while conservatives limit them.

... and so on.

I do regret, though, that conservatives spend so much time fantasizing about liberals, and so little proposing policy.

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   seeder  96WS6    11 years ago

Hypocritical statement of the day:

I never see any propositions from conservatives. I only see criticism of liberals.

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   Bob Nelson    11 years ago

Fly,

The simplest formulation:

  • Liberal = us
  • Conservative = me
 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man    11 years ago

Spread power amongst the people, locking people into welfare really does that doesn't it?

What about those few liberals at the top? power concentrated in those who set policy? those who ALWAYS set policies for the rest. Isn't that a concentration of power?

Spread the wealth, ok, I'll give you that one when I see Mr Gates spread his billions around to everyone. Since money is wealth, it is nice to see that many of the richest men in the world, capitalists all are amongst the most fervent liberals.

Rights are a limitation of power? so lets give up the bill of rights and gain POWER! So by your own thinking your promoting rights which is a limitation of power. Thank you for the admission that you want to take power away from the people.

Limiting rights? how about maintaining the ones we have?

And so on and so forth....

Back to proposing policy? you really want to change the subject don't you!

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   Bob Nelson    11 years ago

I said, "I never see..."

Are you presuming to know what I see?

Wow.

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   Bob Nelson    11 years ago

I do not understand your gibberish. Could you please use straightforward declarative sentences in a logical order?

Thank you.

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man    11 years ago

I did, responded exactly the way you laid them out. Unless your points were gibberish in the first place.

Since your devolving to insults, which clearly shows that you are not happy with your failure to dictate the conversation off topic.

I'm glad that you admit your attempt at a rational discussion of YOUR political philosophy is gibberish.

PS: I don't expect any liberal to understand that they point the finger at themselves when they devolve to insults.

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   Bob Nelson    11 years ago

Please reread your previous post. Seven of its fourteen sentences are questions. No one can understand your thinking, if you are asking questions about someone else's thinking.

Therefore I asked you to "please use straightforward declarative sentences". Can you do that?

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man    11 years ago

Trying to discuss Liberal philosophy with a Liberal is like trying to eat Spaghetti with a spoon, you just get it all together to take a bite and it slips and slides all over.

Never getting to it's destination, hence no satisfaction, no nutritional value.

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   Bob Nelson    11 years ago

Gunny,

I'm pretty sure you are a decent guy. (You have good references from someone whose opinion I value.) But you say some remarkable things:

But to be told what you can and cannot have in a supposed free society is just socialism.

When parents tell their children what to do, is it "socialism"? Or when a MGSGT tells a Private what to do, is that "socialism"? Of course not... so it kinda depends on who is doing the telling and who is being told, and the circumstances. Hmmm....?

And then... "is socialism". I think you have an erroneous notion of what "socialism" is :

  1. Socialism is a social and economic system characterised by social ownership of the means of production and co-operative management of the economy, as well as a political theory and movement that aims at the establishment of such a system.

Note that there is no "political" aspect. Socialism is an economic system. Just as capitalism can be linked with either democracy or dictatorship, the same is true of socialism.

As for "what you can and cannot have"... this kind of restriction has been true in every society in human history. You can't have drugs, you can't have... lots of stuff...

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   Bob Nelson    11 years ago

Socialism is a state of control, mind control physical control, idealogical control

Not in English.

When a person misuses a word, they are committing anerror. When they do so knowingly, they are intentionally committing an error. That's either childish or delusional, no?

There are words that are accurate: "authoritarian" for example. Why do you insist on using the wrong one?

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   Bob Nelson    11 years ago

I am a liberal, Gunny. When you attack liberals, you attack me.

Do you ignore people who attack you?

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   seeder  96WS6    11 years ago

"Yesterday, 96 posted a thread that suggested that the social safety net should be removed because people should not have to support people who don't work."

Why don't you use the exact quote from the article John?

"96's libertarian says they are shit out of luck during the period of their unemployment, even though the economic system that we all support requires that level of unemployment to function.

quit peddling your bullshit and use the exact wording or the exact article or the exact quote or STFU.

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   1stwarrior    11 years ago

96 - a lot of information and a lot of room for interpretation in answering the questions posed.

The "government" started with minimal intrusion and, within the Constitution, strong states rights. However, over the years, Congress has curtailed those rights by establishing "Agencies" to perform the functions of the states. In 1789, there were three agencies - today, there are over 2,000 different agencies, and the federal bureaucracy is almost certain to run into problems with organization, overlapping responsibilities, and efficiency. - . Congress also only met twice a year.

However, there are a few members of SCOTUS who believe strongly in state's rights - Scalia, Roberts, Thomas, Kennedy and Ginsburg (I believe).

Give the power back to the states, cut back on federalbureaucracy, reduce greatly "freebie" programs, and reduce federal employment - all plans from the Federalist Papers and the founding members of the Republic.

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   seeder  96WS6    11 years ago

Give the power back to the states, cut back on federalbureaucracy, reduce greatly "freebie" programs, and reduce federal employment - all plans from the Federalist Papers and the founding members of the Republic.

Nothing I disagree with here 1st.

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   seeder  96WS6    11 years ago

Just like you just did to 96, you deftly turned his question around and pointed the finger at someone else.

Deflection is all he's got. Pitiful isn't it?

 
 
 
Chucky Stuart
Freshman Silent
link   Chucky Stuart    11 years ago

My ideology is a weird mash-up of liberalism, libertarianism and anarcho-syndicalism; often contradictory and I have many interesting arguments with myself.

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   seeder  96WS6    11 years ago

I am starting to find the fact that I usually agree with you disturbing. LOL

Seriously though, Jefferson was a "Liberal" that resembles nothing of "today's Liberals". I wholeheartedly agree with the Jefferson principals listed in this article in addition to many others.

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   Bob Nelson    11 years ago

I'm always happy to answer questions if I understand them. The problem with your series is that they concern your fantasm of liberalism, and are meaningless in my actual political philosophy.

For example, "What exactly is the "fair share" of someone's income that hes earned that he should be able to keep?" I have no idea because there is no such notion in my thinking. I know that there was a "just price" way back in the Middle Ages, but I have no idea what your "fair share" is.

Let's try the second one: "If people in the middle class aren't willing to pay enough in taxes to cover the government services that they use because they don't think it's worth the money, shouldn't we prune back government to a level people do feel comfortable paying for in taxes?" I am a democrat, so I would not confide decisions of any sort to any single class. I am very open to any number of schemas for taxes, to be defined by the democratic process. Once the schema is law, "violaters will be prosecuted", as they say.

Third one? "We live in a world where people have more choices than ever before in music, entertainment, careers, news sources and what to do with their time. Shouldn't government mirror that trend by moving towards federalism and states rights instead of centralizing more and more power in Washington, DC?" I see no relation whatsoever between the two.

Fourth: "Since we "all agree" with the idea that our level of deficit spending is "unsustainable," what would be wrong with permanently freezing federal spending at the current level until we balance the budget by increasing revenue, cutting spending or some combination thereof?" We do not agree, at all. The deficit has been dropping for several years, and is now at the lowest level since the Clinton surpluses. If there is a concensus that it must be reduced further or faster (I know of no competent economist who holds that position), I would prefer an increase in taxes to a reduction in services.

Fifth: "Give me a ballpark estimate: If something doesn't change dramatically, how long do you think it will be until we have an economic crash in this country similar to the one we're seeing in Greece or Cyprus?" Not a ball-park figure: what happened to Greece CANNOT happen to America. America has its own currency. There isn't room to explain the details.

Sixth: "How can liberal economists like Paul Krugman be right when they claim that our economy isn't doing well because we aren't spending enough money when we're already running massive, unsustainable deficits and spending is going up every year?" This is nonsense on several levels. First, Krugman is a liberal commentator on social and political issues. He is a middle-of-the-road economist, and does not mix the two. Second, a deficit is not just spending; it is also revenues. America's corporations are making record profits, while wages stagnate. Ideally, wage increases would be a better way to prime the demand pump, but if wages do not rise, we should tax those record profits for the same purpose. The deficit is not involved. Finally, government spending (and employment) are not going up. Both have gone down regularly during the current administration.

Seventh: "If corporations are so awful, greedy and bad for the country, then shouldn't we be celebrating when they decide to close their plants here and move overseas?" Silliness.

Eighth: "Are you really pro-choice or just pro-abortion? If it's pro-choice, do you feel people should be able to choose to have an assault weapon, what kind of light bulb they use in their house or whether they'd like to put their Social Security funds into a private retirement account?" Silliness.

Ninth: "If you believe we have a "right" to things like health care, food, shelter and a good education, then doesn't that also mean you believe we also have a right to force other people to unwillingly provide those things under threat of imprisonment?" Yes, just as they are required to pay for all government or para-government services, whether they agree or not. Taxes are not opt-out.

Now... Can we avoid gotchas?

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   seeder  96WS6    11 years ago

Hey! You are actually capable of a response other than deflection!

I have no idea because there is no such notion in my thinking.

Anyone who believes everyone should pay taxes has this notion. Is the amount left after taxes not the same as what potion of earned income one is allowed to keep?

I am a democrat,

That is strange. I thought you were a Liberal. and that

equating liberalism and the Democratic Party

showed a

remarkable level of naivety

Liberals are a confused lot aren't they?

so I would not confide decisions of any sort to any single class. I am very open to any number of schemas for taxes, to be defined by the democratic process. Once the schema is law, "violaters will be prosecuted", as they say.

So you believe the democratic process should be used to determine what the "fair share" of someone's income that hes earned that he should be able to keep and what should be taken/paid/used for government programs. Fair enough, you answered the question.

I see no relation whatsoever between the two.

Not so much of a relation as a question. Why doesn't the government offer choice by letting the states govern instead of centralizing power at the Federal level?

a deficit is not just spending; it is also revenues. America's corporations are making record profits, while wages stagnate. Ideally, wage increases would be a better way to prime the demand pump, but if wages do not rise, we should tax those record profits for the same purpose. The deficit is not involved.

I don't agree, but you answered the question. Fair enough.

Finally, government spending (and employment) are not going up. Both have gone down regularly during the current administration.

This is not completely true but I don't have time to get into it right now, bring it up again if you really want to discuss it.

"If corporations are so awful, greedy and bad for the country, then shouldn't we be celebrating when they decide to close their plants here and move overseas?" Silliness.

Silly indeed, but to prove a point. Corporations aren't so awful we want them moving overseas. Point taken.

Yes, just as they are required to pay for all government or para-government services, whether they agree or not. Taxes are not opt-out.

Yes everyone is forced to pay regardless of if they agree what it is being used for or not and regardless of how many. Considering the ridiculous waste and corruption of our government I think this is robbery for the most part. This is also why I want small government, but again, if you want to discuss it more, bring it up.

Now to answer your question..

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    11 years ago

Bob ,

Do you think it a good thing that the already-rich get all newly created wealth?

"good" is a moralistic term , neither an economic one nor a legal one . The govt can affect the amount of income by changes to the tax law but they can't do a lot with already existing wealth . And as I said before the top %tile for income keeps changing from 1 year to the next .

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   seeder  96WS6    11 years ago

Now to answer your question

Do you have any ideas to present? For example, you abhor Obamacare and are convinced that it is a disaster. What do you propose? Boehner and McConnell had nothing to propose last Sunday on TV. What do you suggest?

Well the problem with our healthcare system is not the number of people insured it is the cost of care itself, which is several times the cost in most other countries. ACA does little to nothing to address this (the real)problem.

The absurd complexity of U.S. health care creates its own costs. There is a separate health care system for seniors, veterans, military personnel, Native Americans, end-stage renal failure, under 16 in a poor family, over 16 in a poor family, and working for the federal government the list goes on and on. All these systems require another inefficiency -- the existence of compilers, middlemen who compile the bills doctors submit and shuttle them thru the payment system. The obvious solution to this is consolidation and shrinking of these agencies and plans.

Other problems include the cost of insurance for providers because of law suits, this is passed along to you and me. Solution? Take the approach of some of the EU countries. If you sue and lose you pay for your and the defendants court costs. This virtually eliminates frivolous law suits.

Our red tape and bureaucracies also cause medicine to be much more expensive here. Get rid of the government bureaucracies inflating these costs.

If we could get costs of our medical system down to the Canadian level, or the level of practically any other country, the money saved would be enough to pay for health care for all the Americans who are uninsured. Better yet, healthcare would actually be affordable for most people without government help. Currently 85%+ of people with ACA get government assistance in paying for it. How the hell can anyone call that "affordable"?

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   Bob Nelson    11 years ago

"good" is a moralistic term

Yes. It is economically possible to have a nation with 1% wealthy and 99% poor. But in your opinion, would that be "good"? Would that be a society that you would admire?

And as I said before the top %tile for income keeps changing from 1 year to the next .

I was under the impression that turnover is modest. Do you have a link?

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    11 years ago
This is an excellent summary of a topic worthy of a dissertation.
 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   seeder  96WS6    11 years ago

I'm glad you agree.Grin.gif

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   Bob Nelson    11 years ago

Hey! You are actually capable of a response other than deflection!

I very nearly stopped here. Let's avoid the gratuitous insults, OK?

Is the amount left after taxes not the same as what potion of earned income one is allowed to keep?

OK, but I dont see anything "fair" about it. A tax scale should be designed to maximize revenue, not to be "fair", which is a purely subjective notion. The most efficient top bracket is about 70%. By efficient, I mean most revenue without inciting people to quit earning. (There were a couple of bullet-proof studies a few years ago.)

I am a democrat. I am not a Democrat. I gave you credit for knowing the difference. Should I not have?

Why doesn't the government offer choice by letting the states govern instead of centralizing power at the Federal level?

As a general rule, I think decisions should be made as low as possible. Also, I think more could be done with national standards applied at lower levels. (I avoid the "Federal / state" vocabulary, which is specifically American. The same notion exists everywhere.)

Corporations aren't so awful we want them moving overseas.

If corporations were employee-owned (i. e., socialist) the problem would not exist. They would not off-shore their own jobs.

Considering the ridiculous waste and corruption of our government I think this is robbery

You are linking two very different notions, and I think you weaken your own arguments by doing so. Taxes are one thing; waste and corruption are another.

The insanity of defense procurement should unify everyone... but pork politics ber alles...

It seems to me that we should look at programs -- what they accomplish and how much they cost -- and decide, one by one, what to do. Then run the total, and the tax schedule it implies. Then, iteratively, add, adjust, and subtract programs until there is a satisfactory concensus.

Starting with the tax burden sounds miserly.

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   Bob Nelson    11 years ago

I agree with your observations about the current situation. I don't agree with your analysis of the reasons for the absurdly high costs. There are indeed lots of programs, but I have seen no evidence of costly overlap or interference. Malpractice insurance costs are a couple points, no more.

The big difference between the American and French systems is administration. And the key to bringing those costs down is simple: take the insurer out of the medical decision process. The patient and the doctors decide; the insurer pays. There is no need to obtain "prior accord"... and no need to administer it... and no litigation around it. The first the insurer knows of a medical act is the order to pay. Since the only way for the insurer to improve their margin is to reduce their administrative costs... they work very diligently on the subject! The French system is 95% paper-free.

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man    11 years ago

When this government was designed, the federal level was supposed to be the least intrusive, least powerful arm of government in the individual citizens lives. the States were to have a minimal effect on the citizens life, but it was the responsibility of the state to handle issues within their jurisdiction for their citizens.

This ideal that the Federal Government is all powerful over all entities in this country, is what is killing us.

Those that believe this, are the domestic enemies the founders bespoke of.

Any one who actually studies what this country was founded upon will eventually understand this, and work to stop it before all is lost.

Both Republican and Democrat believe that the federal government is all powerful. It is why Washington rejected political parties.

We would be wise to do the same.

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   1stwarrior    11 years ago

But, NM, there are many on NT alone who say third parties are the killers because they are the divisors. Granted, you're not "saying" a third party is necessary, but, the Libertarian Party believes/stumps on those principles - and, yet, no one "supposedly" listens.

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   seeder  96WS6    11 years ago

But, NM, there are many on NT alone who say third parties are the killers because they are the divisors.

If only that were true, the Democrat and Republican parties would have ceased to exist long ago.

I think we would have a third at least. The facts are both the D&R have made damn sure that will never happen by restricting the process. They have removed the freedom for anyone to start a third party by their unconstitutional regulations. Both are guilty of this.

Third party candidates are at a disadvantage because of federal campaign finance laws, rules that dictate who can enter presidential debates, and a lack of media attention.

In addition, a significant amount of paperwork is required to become a viable candidate. When Ralph Nader announced in February 2004 that he would seek the presidential nomination, he was required to collect 1.5 million signatures in all states to appear on the ballot. Deadlines for those signatures begin as early as May 2004.

Campaign finance rules say that a political party can only get government funding to run a race if it received a certain percentage of votes from the previous election. Often this leaves third party candidates to fund their own campaigns. With less media coverage, the candidates are left to find other means of exposure to raise the millions of dollars it takes to run a successful campaign.

This is only a few examples of many

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man    11 years ago

1st, I don't belong to the Libertarian party. The libertarian party does not stand for what I believe in. They come closer than anyone else, but not enough to get me to join. To be honest they are too absolutist.

Third parties are prevented from happening in this country. No more progressive party no more "Bull Moose" parties.

The two dominant parties are that way cause they wrote the laws to make it that way.

I look at things here in Washington, where both parties joined together to sue the electorate to only allow their "Chosen" candidates on the ballot.

That is when I lost all faith in either party or the party system in general. Political parties do not have the peoples interests at heart, they only have their own interests.

And, will fuck over the citizen when it is in their interests to do so as we plainly observed in the last presidential cycle.

They are a cancer on the election process.

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   1stwarrior    11 years ago

Understand NM. Went to vote in an primary election in Alabama and they wouldn't let me because I wasn't a D or R. Kinda violated the Constitutional process,eh?

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   seeder  96WS6    11 years ago

Went to vote in an primary election in Alabama and they wouldn't let me because I wasn't a D or R.

This is yet another scheme that helps keep the system to 2 parties.

Kinda violated the Constitutional process,eh?

IMO it does.

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   1stwarrior    11 years ago

That 2.5 million signature "rule" - you don't get the signatures, you don't get on the ballot.

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   seeder  96WS6    11 years ago

As 1st pointed out the 2.5 mil signature rule is another way to stop a third party from emerging. Just another road block on a very long list.

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   1stwarrior    11 years ago

Guns - THAT would be a disaster.

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   seeder  96WS6    11 years ago

Sure take Detroit for example those peoplehaven't doneanything to grow their economy in fifty years. They gave up they don't even mow the lawn or paint the houses anymore.

A predominately liberal city run by liberals exclusively for 30 years and primarily for fifty. The very poster child of liberalism.

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   seeder  96WS6    11 years ago

How many people WANT TO? NONE. Especially since the government continues to expand in size and wastefulness. What's wrong with reducing waste and bureaucracy before screwing us out of more taxes??

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   seeder  96WS6    11 years ago

We already know Liberals think everyone else should take up their slack John.

 
 

Who is online




108 visitors