╌>

Europe cannot agree to write off Greece’s debt

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  bob-nelson  •  11 years ago  •  9 comments

Europe cannot agree to write off Greece’s debt

The prospect of defaults would frighten the markets and increase the risk of another crisis

56fe9a50-0100-4f25-aa42-38ca87c9484f.img?width=500

Syriza have won the Greek election . But, perhaps just as startling, the far left party is making considerable headway in the struggle to win over elite opinion in the west.

Many mainstream economists and policy makers are so alarmed by the state of the Greek economy that they have come to agree with Syrizas argument that the only solution is to make a radical cut in Greeces national debt, which stands at 175 per cent of gross domestic product.

Greeces debt needs to be right-sized, one senior anglophone policy maker told me in Davos . And the Germans should remember they benefited from official debt relief in the 1950s. Letters from Nobel Prize winners and several opinion pieces in this newspaper have made similar arguments.

Unfortunately, an explicit Greek debt write-off would cause more problems in Europe than it solved. Three main negative effects could be expected. First, it would cause a political backlash in northern Europe, which would strengthen far-right and nationalist parties. Second, far-left and anti-capitalist parties would gain credibility in southern Europe and would press for similar debt writedowns, as well as much expanded social spending something that would lead to a collapse in market confidence. Third, the breakdown in trust between members of the EU that would follow a Greek default even a negotiated default would make it much harder to keep the EU together.

The focus on the unforgiving stance of Germany raises emotional issues about the second world war but obscures the fact that almost all Greeces European creditors take a similar view. It was very hard for politicians in countries such as Finland and the Netherlands to make the case for a bailout of Greece. Their sceptical citizens appeared to suspect that they might never be paid back. (Silly them!) If those fears are now vindicated, the nationalist parties that opposed the bailouts will benefit.

Alexander Stubb, the prime minister of Finland, points out that his country has lent Greece about 1bn equivalent to just under 2 per cent of the governments annual budget. To write off half that money in Finland a country that has also suffered a deep recession would be politically poisonous. The likely beneficiaries would be the nationalist True Finns party.

That pattern would be replicated elsewhere with the National Front in France and the Freedom party in the Netherlands likely beneficiaries. Carl Bildt, a former prime minister of Sweden, gave a sense of the reaction in northern Europe, when he tweeted: Syriza in Greece has won the election by promising that taxpayers in other euro countries will pay even more to them. Rather daring.

The effects on the politics of Germany the cornerstone of the EU would also be noxious. The Alternative for Germany party (AfD), which has now added resentment of immigration to its opposition to the euro, would certainly make gains. One of Chancellor Angela Merkels biggest achievements has been to prevent the rise of a far-right party in Germany, similar to those in France, Austria and the Netherlands. That achievement is now in jeopardy.

Europes far-left is also cheering on Syriza. The idea that there is an easy way to repudiate debt and end austerity must be incredibly seductive for hard-pressed countries such as Spain, Portugal, Ireland and Italy. Parties including Podemos in Spain, Sinn Fin in Ireland and the Five-Star movement in Italy will gather support if Syriza succeeds in slashing Greek debt. But the prospect of debt-defaults across the eurozone particularly in Italy or Spain would then frighten the markets and increase the risk of yet another financial crisis. Everybody would suffer.

Even without a drift to the political extremes or a financial panic, a Greek default would do serious damage. The EU can really only operate if all its members believe that the other countries will respect their financial commitments to each other and obey European law. Once that idea is conclusively undermined, it will become almost impossible to negotiate future agreements. How would you persuade a German or Finnish parliament ever to vote through another European bailout? And how are cherished ideas such as a banking union expected to make progress if mutual trust evaporates?

All that does not mean that Greece must simply continue to suffer. Although the overall size of Greek debt is intimidatingly large, there are things that can be done short of an outright default. The amount of interest that Greece pays on its debt has already been cut and deferred. This policy of extend and pretend could be elaborated to lighten the debt burden further. Debt repayments could be deferred until some sustained growth returns to the Greek economy. Combined with the European Central Banks radical monetary policies and lower oil prices that would help to restore growth in the Greek economy.

Of course, yet another messy EU compromise would be much less exciting than the debt write-off that Syriza has spoken of. But, given all the other dangers, dull compromise looks strangely appealing.

Europe cannot agree to write off Greeces debt , Gideon Rachman, Financial Times


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Bob Nelson    11 years ago

Confidence fairies and bond trolls. IMHO, they are about as real as unicorns.

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   Robert in Ohio    11 years ago

More likely than debt write off is that the repayment schedule and/or terms will be changed to be more favorable to the Greeks in the short and medium term

EU OPEN TO LATER GREEK DEBT REPAYMENT, BOT NOT WRITE-OFF

Meanwhile, the Eurozone this morning showed a willingness to give Athens more time to pay its debts, but little sign that it would yield to a new Greek government's demands for debt forgiveness.

European Union leaders and policymakers warned that a debt reduction for Greece would be against euro zone rules and would send the wrong message to other members of the single currency.

Before any talks on more time for Greece to repay its debts can start, Athens must get an extension of its existing bailout to give itself time for negotiations on future economic policy and on longer loan maturity with international lenders.

"My forecast is that an extension of the (Greek bailout) programme will have to happen," Thomas Wieser, who heads the Euro Working Group that prepares decisions of euro zone finance ministers, told Austrian broadcaster ORF.

The euro fell to an 11-year low as Syriza's victory set Athens on collision course with international lenders and potentially threatened its place in the single currency.

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   Robert in Ohio    11 years ago

Greek debt

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Bob Nelson    11 years ago

This pie chart is very important. It shows that most of Greece's debt is intergovernmental. Only a fraction is of immediate impact on real people. It is very open to... shuffling...

If TPTB are willing, of course. They would be fools not to deal... but they have constantly been fools, ever since 2008, so I am not optimistic.

109.gif 109.gif

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   Robert in Ohio    11 years ago

To say that the intergovernmental debt has no immediate effect on people is short sighted in my view.

The people of the countries making the loans or guaranteeing loans to Greece are largely opposed to writing it off and the politicians/leaders in those countries are well aware of that. There was opposition in many EU countries to the nail out initially and that is why I do not think there will be much (if any) level of support from the key EU nations (Germany, France)in particular, but all the other EU countries to a write off, but an extension of payment time or modification of terms is possible, even likely.

Some of the countries with skin in the game (the Greek loans) are having economic issues of their own at this point.

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Bob Nelson    11 years ago

Politics is often a matter of taking the least bad solution.

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   Robert in Ohio    11 years ago

Exactly correct and for the other EU countries that is lowering terms and or extending the payment period on the debt rather than writing it off completely or in part.

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Bob Nelson    11 years ago

OK. I won't fight that. If the term is lengthened sufficiently, the can is kicked way, way down the road. The crisis is solved for a long time... and that is what is needed.

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Bob Nelson    11 years ago

It is a dishonest industry that expects all their bets to profit.

True... but there are an awful lot like that!

 
 

Who is online




108 visitors