Supreme Court Rules Against Retirees in Union Health Benefits Case
WASHINGTON The Supreme Court on Monday ruled that a chemical company may be able to cut the health benefits of its retired workers, unanimously reversing an appeals court ruling that said the benefits had vested for life.
Courts should not construe ambiguous writings to create lifetime promises, Justice Clarence Thomas wrote for the court, adding that retiree health care benefits are not a form of deferred compensation.
The Supreme Court returned the case to the appeals court, telling it to use ordinary principles of contract interpretation to determine whether the collective bargaining agreement at issue had granted free lifetime health care.
The appeals court erred, Justice Thomas wrote, by placing a thumb on the scale in favor of vested retiree benefits in all collective bargaining agreements.
The case concerned a union contract at the Point Pleasant Polyester Plant in Apple Grove, W.Va. Like many other collective bargaining agreements, it did not directly say whether health benefits for retirees would vest for life.
M&G Polymers USA bought the plant in 2000. A few years later, it announced that it would require retirees to contribute to the cost of their health care benefits. Several retirees sued, saying they had been promised free health care for life.
When the case, M&G Polymers USA v. Tackett, No. 13-1010, was argued at the Supreme Court in November, several justices seemed puzzled that the contract had not nailed down such an important point.
Both sides knew it was left unaddressed, so, you know, whoever loses deserves to lose for casting this upon us when it could have been said very clearly in the contract, Justice Antonin Scalia said. Such an important feature. So I hope well get it right, but, you know, I cant feel bad about it.
The appeals court, the United States Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit, in Cincinnati, ruled for the retirees in 2013, relying on its own 1983 decision , which put a thumb on the scale in favor of vesting.
Justice Thomass opinion was an extended critique of that decision, which he said had been applied indiscriminately across industries, mentioning automobiles, electronics and steel.
He seemed to suggest that the retirees from the chemical plant were now likely to lose when the case got back to the appeals court. When a contract is silent as to the duration of retiree benefits, he wrote, a court may not infer that the parties intended those benefits to vest for life.
In a concurrence, Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg made the case that the retirees could prevail under the new, stricter standard.
No rule requires clear and express language in order to show that parties intended health care benefits to vest, she wrote.
She urged the appeals court to consider other factors. One signal that the health benefits had vested, she said, was that the retirees had vested pensions. The contract tied health benefits to those receiving a monthly pension, she said.
Justices Stephen G. Breyer, Sonia Sotomayor and Elena Kagan joined Justice Ginsburgs concurrence.
http://www.nytimes.com/2015/01/27/business/supreme-court-rules-against-retirees-in-health-benefits-case.html?_r=0
Tags
Who is online
108 visitors

A unanimous ruling on this particular approach of litigation, but this case will likely be heard by the none wise ones again with a new spin on the retiree health insurance entitlement.
"Red Box Rules Robert in Ohio"
All are welcome to post comments or pictures on my articles.
I ask only that they be at least tangentially relevant to the article topic or comment to which they are in response. Comments about members, personal attacks, gross, off-topic comments and graphics will be referred to the moderators for a decision of whether to delete or not delete the comments.
Again all are welcome, to debate, refute or argue but if you are on board only to derail and deride, you are politely requested to not participate.
"Red Box Rules Robert in Ohio"
I'm not competent on Supreme Court law... but it sounds like the scope of this case is quite narrow.
Is that right?
It seems narrow to me, which is why there was a unanimous ruling in my opinion
They are saying that unless a union agreement specifically says that health insurance benefits (for free) are a lifelong benefit to retirees that they are not and that the "contract" needs to be reviewed with that in mind.
I expect to see this back in Washington regardless of how the lower court rules within the new parameters.
I think the SCOTUS is saying that a contract is a contract and that in most cases explicit language is the norm and the requirement for an enforceable agreement to exist in a contract.
Let us see how the case is adjudicated within the narrower scope established by the SCOTUS
Right RIO - contract language has to state specifically that such and such will happen. If there are any "clouds" in the language, in most cases SCOTUS will rule against the aggrieving party.
Waiting on A. Mac's take.
slarti
Unless the contract defines that "retirees" will never have to contribute to their health insurance then there is a capability for the company to change the terms under which the retiree receives health insurance.
Before I retired, we redid our retiree benefits pack age and there is specific language in the plans that defines that the cost to retirees is subject to change if costs change and that a notice period will be given before all changes are made.I think we are going to see a ruling that the retirees are entitled to health insurance, but that the company is entitled to charge the retiree a cost share for the insurance
No, Laws work prospectively, not retroactively, this judgment interacts with the case at hand only. and was decided solely on the issue of contract law which generally holds that to be considered a settled issue in a contract it must be in writing.
Simple decision, one that was never decided on this level before. It's effect will effect any other cases coming before a court in the future and should change how the contracts are written in the future.
Effectively they have separated health benefits from pension benefits where in the past they were assumed to be inclusive.
I understand, that is how most recurring contractual agreements are done.
This will force those contracts to be re-written though, or at least an addendum issued covering the health benefits issue.
jwc
Play nice, you can disagree without calling some one ignorant
The company is not terminating the health insurance, rather it is requiring that the retirees pay a share of the cost, which it seems may be perfectly legal
slarti
But if it says that they will have health insurance and is silent on the question of cost sharing then ......
I also do not think that the question of whether insurance benefits compensation in its purest sense is a settled question either
slarti
I understand your point and I agree that retiree health insurance benefits are benefits and not deferred benefits just as health insurance to active employees is not compensation, but a benefit.
We both see it differently - no problems with that
Pity - the last contract I negotiated was only 48 pages and the language regarding retirement was very specific. We had no language for health benefits as the Union (USW and USFW) and the company wanted the option of trading companies as cost protections.