╌>

Liberal VS Conservative VS Libertarian VS Authoritarian Table / Chart (because you love charts)

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  96ws6  •  11 years ago  •  13 comments

Liberal VS Conservative VS Libertarian VS Authoritarian Table / Chart (because you love charts)

Many people get confused on what's what when it comes to political ideology. Many people think that conservatives dislike big government and that liberals love big government, but in reality, they both like big government in different ways.

Government can be split in to two main dichotomies: economic and social. Of these two dichotomies you have two levels: complete government control or no government control. The following chart will better illustrate my point:

Or to put it more simply:

Ideology Economic Freedom Social Freedom
Authoritarian watchdog-error.png watchdog-error.png
Liberal watchdog-error.png watchdog-ok.png
Conservative watchdog-ok.png watchdog-error.png
Libertarian watchdog-ok.png watchdog-ok.png

Liberals and conservatives are only opposites on social and economic things. They both favor government control, they just want that control in different areas. Liberals want freedom when it comes to anything having to do with social and personal items. Conservatives want freedom when it comes to anything having to do with economic and business items.

Let's take a look at some popular political issues:

In favor of Liberals Conservatives
Abortion watchdog-ok.png watchdog-error.png
Gay Marriage watchdog-ok.png watchdog-error.png
Government Health Care watchdog-ok.png watchdog-error.png
Immigration watchdog-ok.png watchdog-error.png
Welfare watchdog-ok.png watchdog-error.png
Social Security watchdog-ok.png watchdog-error.png
Drugs watchdog-ok.png watchdog-error.png
Less Business Regulation watchdog-error.png watchdog-ok.png
Less Labor Laws watchdog-error.png watchdog-ok.png
Less Bailouts watchdog-error.png watchdog-ok.png
Lower Taxes watchdog-error.png watchdog-ok.png
Military watchdog-error.png watchdog-ok.png
Note: Keep in mind these are the general trends. There are still logical inconsistencies with some issues, moreso on the liberal side. For example liberals support personal freedom but are less likely to support the freedom for people to own personal firearms.

There is another important distinction to be made here. Conservatives want less government involvement in economic issues and want government involvement in social issues. Liberals, however, want government involvement in economic issues and social issues.

In other words:

Ideology Government In Economic Issues Government In Social Issues
Conservative watchdog-error.png watchdog-ok.png
Liberal watchdog-ok.png watchdog-ok.png

And then to bring in people who favor no government and people who favor pure government you can bring libertarians and authoritarians into the mix:

Ideology Government In Economic Issues Government In Social Issues
Libertarian watchdog-error.png watchdog-error.png
Conservative watchdog-error.png watchdog-ok.png
Liberal watchdog-ok.png watchdog-ok.png
Authoritarian watchdog-ok.png watchdog-ok.png

Again, this is oversimplified to show the general trend. Not all libertarians believe in no government. Not all conservatives believe in no government on economic issues. And not all liberals believe in complete government control on both social and economic issues. But these are the trends and in most cases bear true.

Example Issues

To gain a better understanding let's look at a few examples of issues between three ideologies.

Ideology Gay Marriage
Conservative Oppose gay marriage and want the state to prevent it.
Liberal In favor of gay marriage and want the state to allow it.
Libertarian Don't care one way or the other and want no state involvement in the issue.

So right away we can see an interesting distinction. Conservatives and liberals both want the government to do something about an issue. They both want the government to control it on one side or the other. Libertarians, on the other hand, want the government out of the issue. They don't want the government to pick sides for people. They want people to pick sides individually on their own, without the government mandating for them.

Let's look at another one.

Ideology Lower Taxes
Conservative Generally favor lower taxes on most social things but are okay with taxes on military spending.
Liberal Generally want more taxes or at the very least taxes spent on less military spending and more on social spending.
Libertarian Generally believe taxation is theft and a misallocation of resources. Would rather have no taxes and pay for services taxes pay for directly.

Taxes is an interesting issue with these ideologies. Both liberals and conservatives are in favor of taxes, but for different things. Liberals want taxes on social things and conservatives want taxes on military things. Libertarians, on the other hand, want no taxes for the most part. They believe that forcing a group of people to pay for something that another group of people want is immoral and a violation of the non-aggression principle. Rather than raising a bunch of money through taxes to pay for, say, the government post office, libertarians would rather get rid of the government post office completely and allow private businesses such as UPS and FedEx to carry out post office needs. People can pay directly when they need to use a post office service rather than paying through taxes even if they're not using it.

Let's look at one more:

Ideology Government Health Care
Conservative Do not want the government involved with health care directly. Are okay with indirect government involvement through insurance companies and drug companies which dictate prices and quality, but are not okay with a completely government run health care system. Conservatives prefer a semi-government run health care system.
Liberal Want a government run health care system and want most services to be free which are payed for through taxation.
Libertarian Want no government involvement with health care at all. In favor of multiple competing health care industries working to provide the best level of service with the lowest cost. Not in favor of government involvement in insurance or drug companies either.

Conclusion

So this should give you a better understanding of how liberals, conservatives, libertarians and authoritarians work. It is all based around government control and where that government control is focused.

At one end of the spectrum you have people who want full government control, authoritarians (Communism, Fascism, etc) and then at the other end you have people who essentially want no government control, libertarians. In between these two polarities you have the various colors of political parties such as democrats, republicans, independents, green party, constitution party and so forth. All off these parties represent different colors of liberal and conservative leanings. All of these parties favor some form of government involvement in various aspects of life commensurate to the level of freedom they are comfortable exercising individually.

More freedom means less government and less freedom means more government. Consequently, as people grow in maturity, discernment and philosophy they become more comfortable with less government and more freedom. These are the libertarians of the bunch. They are okay with less government because they understand what less government represents: freedom, the end goal.

On the other hand you have people who are less mature and who are less discerning of philosophic issues who are much less comfortable with freedom and prefer some type of control over their lives. This is where government enters the picture. The less comfortable people are taking care of themselves the more comfortable they are letting somebody else do it for them. And the government is always there to satisfy that need. So we have government step in for the less mature which is where we start to descend into the realms of conservative, liberal and then ultimately the lowest of low, authoritarian.

http://www.slayerment.com/liberal-vs-conservative-vs-libertarian-vs-authoritarian


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   seeder  96WS6    11 years ago

It seems there are a lot of people confused on political ideology here at NT. Hope this helps.

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   FLYNAVY1    11 years ago

Here is the sticking point.....

It is impossible to balance social and economic freedom without law and regulation due to the basic human motivator of greed. The only real value government has is to protect both the individual and society against the negative aspects of capitalism while harnessing the good parts.

This is where the concept of libertarianism falls on its face. It expects that everyone will play nice all of the time. The history of human nature is exactly the opposite. It might be workable plan on a village scale, but on a country sized scale that has to interact with the rest of the world.... not a snowballs chance in hell!

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   FLYNAVY1    11 years ago

Not sure greed is actually a basic human motivator.

Watched any three year olds on a play date? They have a great deal in common with corporate executives...... or vise-verse.

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man    11 years ago

That is the big conundrum Fly.

Socialism also falls flat on it's face for the same reason. the founders knew this and tried to create a system to counterbalance one against the other.

Man, is both social and independent.

The only way socialism works on a large scale is through force. People have to be made to comply with it's tenents. This was proven with the French communes in the 1890's and early 1900's. It is what prompted Marx to radicalize socialism then steal the name commune for his brand of socialism calling it communism.

Socialism cannot survive without killing the patient so to speak. There is ample evidence of that throughout history.

A balance is what is needed, and neither the Republicans nor Democrats today are for any sort of balance.

Libertarianism, at least the American form of it, is all about balance.

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man    11 years ago

You know as much about our country as we do about Indonesia.

So why play so arrogant?

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika     11 years ago

Actually Nonya makes some good points. I may not agree with them, but they are worth discussing.

I don't think it's arrogant at all, simply voicing his opinion.

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika     11 years ago

Hello Nonya,

It's quite true regarding the Christian ''doctrine of discovery'' our land was taken by force and what they called laws.

The simple fact is, IMO that manyAmericans have little knowledge of their own history, and when confronted with it, deny it.

They also have little knowledge of the history/culture/language of other countries. That is sad, since there is much around the world worth knowing and experiencing.

What country are you from Nonya?

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man    11 years ago

Maybe in the large cities, but not many other places.

It is much different than you describe in most of the country.

It is true that you don't get much truth from the media here, I suspect that where ever you are at you get even less.

You will find that as a people Americans are some of the most giving people as you would find anywhere. Maybe not so much as a government that props up regimes around the world both governmental and financial.

Don't take the view the media or government puts out as what America actually is, meet the people talk and discuss I think you wil find out that this nation is a lot different than most think it is.

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   seeder  96WS6    11 years ago

This articles comes off like it was written for junior high schoolers. Anyone who actually needs to read this probably doesn't belong on a discussion forum.

My point exactly. Why are you still here.

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   seeder  96WS6    11 years ago

Fly,your problem is that for some reason you choose to view libertarianism in it's absolute extreme. To abolish every law and all government. Again I say Anarchy is to Libertarianism as Marxism is to Liberalism. No thoughtful discussion can take place until you get in touch with reality.

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   seeder  96WS6    11 years ago

What some libertarians want is a government that favors "their" interests as opposed to a general interest.

Proof that you are one of the ones that needs this chart the most. Libertarians don't want government to favor anyone. A concept Liberals are incapable of understanding. To you, if the government is not favoring your interests they are favoring some groups interest. It is impossible for you to fathom you don't always speak for the majority.

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man    11 years ago

I understand the metaphor you are trying to make.

The best you can put it is but a mischaracterization that comes from not really knowing the American people as a people.

And no the big cities are NOT where most Americans live, maybe 45-49 % of Americans live in the big cities.

See, to me what your statements say is that you really have a stilted view of America and Americans, probably from watching too much of your own stilted media.

I would say that most Americans have a stilted view of the rest of the world also.

Ignorance is common around the world and the people that rule us like it that way. It is incumbent on everyone to learn about the world around us.

Unfortunately, most only learn about the world around themselves.

I can see why they end never believing you, cause your metaphor is wrong.

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man    11 years ago

So, You say your living in the US, where are you from, what are these experiences from the "Other" side?

I mean I believe in people, no one will know America till they know her people. And to do that one needs to stay a while. I mean it is nice to speak in metaphor, but it is better to state clearly the whats and whys.

It is easier to understand the points being made. You talk about being on the receiving end of US foreign policy, we have been on the receiving ends of others foreign policy also, what makes your experience any more valid than ours?

 
 

Who is online




108 visitors