╌>

This airplane is hammering ISIS. So why is the Air Force trying to kill it?

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  bob-nelson  •  11 years ago  •  38 comments

This airplane is hammering ISIS. So why is the Air Force trying to kill it?

483987163.0.0.jpg

The A-10 Thunderbolt II, commonly called the Warthog, is a powerhouse of a plane. Boasting a massive ordinance load and one of the most powerful guns ever mounted on an aircraft, it's playing a major role in the US Air Force's bombing campaign against ISIS .

Despite its successes in combat, the Air Force wants to put the plane out of commission. The USAF is fighting with Congress to get approval for a plan to retire the aircraft from service for good.

Why does the Air Force want to get rid of a plane that seems so useful? The answer gets to the heart of a pretty important debate about the future of the Air Force, as well as the screwed up way the US military decides what weapons to purchase.

The A-10 is designed to support the Army and that's the problem

a-10 2

An A-10 in Afghanistan. (Paul J. Richards/AFP/Getty Images)

The A-10 is not like the high-flying fighter jets you usually think of when you think "Air Force." It's armored, slow, totally unstealthy, and very low-flying.

All of this makes it perfect for something called " Close Air Support " (CAS). In CAS, planes and helicopters target enemy positions that are nearby American or other friendly ground forces. The A-10's slow speed and heavy armament are ideal for this: it can hang around the battlefield targeting enemy positions for a relatively long time.

The Air Force originally created the A-10 in the early 1970s. Part of the motivation was to prevent the Army from taking over CAS duties entirely with its own helicopters, according to Robert Farley, a University of Kentucky professor and author of a book on the Air Force. So from the very beginning, the A-10 was a product of infighting between service branches a conflict which continues to define the plane.

Around the end of the Cold War, the Air Force began arguing for retiring the A-10, even though it's their own plane. According to Farley, the Air Force never really liked taking on the CAS mission.

"Air Force people, generally speaking, don't like the idea of some sergeant, lieutenant, or captain in the Army essentially directing their million dollar planes around, and that's what close air support requires," Farley said.

When the Cold War wound down, the Air Force argued that there was no need for a specialized plane to hunt Soviet tanks anymore.

But the A-10 has proven valuable in some conflicts since the Cold War, such as the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan.

That's also been true in the mission against ISIS. One of the A-10's main liabilities is that it's easy to shoot down using surface-to-air missiles, but militant groups like ISIS often don't have the hardware or the training necessary to do that. So the A-10 has been able to perform its core mission pounding enemy troops with close-altitude bombardments and gunfire very effectively. It's built up a pretty passionate fan base , made up in large part of soldiers and former A-10 pilots.

The A-10 debate is really about the future of the Air Force

F-35 night

An F-35 flying at night. ( US military )

Despite the A-10's recent use, the Air Force still wants to retire the plane. The debate over the Air Force position isn't just an argument about the A-10 it's a debate about the Air Force's entire approach to the future of air war.

The Air Force wants to replace the A-10, and other platforms designed with basically one mission in mind, with multi-purpose aircraft. Maintaining lots of single-mission planes is really expensive, and in theory unifying them into multi-purpose planes would be cheaper.

"[The A-10] is highly specialized, and in tough times we can't afford to have highly specialized," New America Foundation defense technology expert Peter W. Singer says, summarizing the Air Force case. According to one Defense Department estimate, retiring all 283 A-10s could save a cool $4.2 billion in operation and maintenance costs over five years.

The Air Force instead wants to use multi-purpose fighters, like the F-15E, F-16, and one day the F-35 (not yet in the field), to perform CAS missions. This isn't just about cost: the A-10's low speed and flying altitude makes it more vulnerable to shoulder-fired missiles and some other common forms of aerial defense than some alternatives.

"There was a story the other day about ISIS firing four missiles at A-10s. None of them hit, but if one of them had, we'd have yanked the entire A-10 fleet from the fight against ISIS," Farley says.

Though both Farley and Singer admit that the Air Force has a strong case, they believe that retiring the A-10 is a bad idea, at least in the short term. "This is not that expensive of a capability [and] we can keep it around for a long time," Farley says. "There is no one who disagrees with the idea that the close air support mission is going to become harder without the A-10."

Singer also points out that the Air Force's preferred new replacement, the F-35, is notorious for ridiculous cost overruns and delays, and it's not even ready yet. The F-35 "isn't going to be on time and in the capability that we need" to replace the A-10 in the near term, he says. "That's not just a supposition. I would literally bet my house on it."

And ultimately, the F-35 is a major reason why the A-10 fight is so controversial. "The Air Force is all-in on the F-35: not because it actually really loves the F-35, because it's so terrified of what happens if the F-35 is cancelled," Farley says.

The F-35 is, according to Singer, "the most expensive weapons project in all of human history." The Air Force needs to defend the theory behind it that a particularly versatile plane can fill a number of combat roles if wants to justify the hundreds of billions of dollars thrown at a fighter that's yet to fly a single combat mission.

"One of the ways it's going to make the case for the F-35 is by making the case that it can replace the A-10," Farley says. "The Air Force also argues the F-35 can replace all of its other planes."

So the A-10 fight is about a specific plane that many soldiers love. But it's also about whether or not the Air Force can justify a core part of its budget and its approach to 21st century air war: the multi-purpose F-35.

The politics of the A-10 are tangled, but Congress will probably keep it around

mccain ayotte

Sens. John McCain and Kelly Ayotte, two key A-10 supporters in the Senate. (Mark Wilson/Getty Images)

In terms of lobbying, the Air Force is powerful, but it's not the only interested party. Even some within the service branch itself are dissenting. Former A-10 pilots, for example, are willing to go to the mat for the plane. It's gotten to the point where Major General James Post , the vice commander of Air Combat Command, allegedly said that "anyone who is passing information to Congress about A-10 capabilities is committing treason."

But regardless of what the Air Force wants, it seems likely that Congress will force them to keep the plane. A number of legislators believe the A-10 plays an important role in US warfighting. John McCain, a former Navy airman, is probably the A-10's highest-profile congressional supporter and he's also the new Chairman of the Senate Armed Services Committee.

"There has always been a congressional coalition in favor of the A-10, which is why the Air Force has never been able to kill it," Farley says.

"We're not in year one of this fight," Singer adds. "The Senate keeps getting its way because the Senate has a vote and Air Force budget writers don't."

From the point of view of the Air Force or others who want to kill the A-10, the effort led by McCain and his Senate allies might come across like just another case of Congress meddling in the Pentagon's business. But there's an argument that Congress is actually playing its role perfectly and doing the right thing here.

The military service branches are supposed to cooperate, but they often don't like to, and the A-10 is a great example of that. Close air support is an almost textbook case of an intra-service mission: the Air Force has the planes, but they're being used to back up the Army rather than perform Air Force specific jobs.

Without a mandate from Congress, it's unlikely that the Air Force would prioritize spending on CAS capabilities. And the Army may like the A-10, but not enough to take on the additional budget expense of funding its own platform. Simple inter-service politics favor weakening the US military's ability to perform a really important mission.

"If you let the services do just what they want to do, they are going to shirk on joint capabilities," Farley says. McCain and his allies intervening to force the issue is " absolutely how democracy and civil-military relations should function."

This airplane is hammering ISIS. So why is the Air Force trying to kill it? , by Zack Beauchamp , Vox


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Bob Nelson    11 years ago

Jeez... I miss Ike...

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika     11 years ago

Give me the ''Warthog or Spooky'' anytime.

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Bob Nelson    11 years ago

Yup.

About a dozen times: YUP!!!

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   96WS6    11 years ago

A perfect example of the undesirable effects of too much government/bureaucracy.

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Bob Nelson    11 years ago

You don't see it as more as more particularly a confluence of the military - industrial complex and inter-service rivalry?

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Bob Nelson    11 years ago

Spooky was nasty... but for remodeling the terrain, I preferred Arclight. Warthog is after my time.

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Bob Nelson    11 years ago

I never called Spooky, but I was in a couple joint ops where they played. They did a number, but nothing like an Arclight -- which was a B-52 out of Guam. The three or four Arclights I called seriously jumbled the terrain.

If you have a different memory, maybe they dropped their payload in more or less open patterns.

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Bob Nelson    11 years ago

Thank you.

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Bob Nelson    11 years ago

I think we called it Puff the Magic Dragon, and, yes, it was a C47. Like I said, I was never directly involved in any of their missions.

The Arclight was pretty simple. First, I had to get approval, in function of the target, and then it was just a set of coordinates.

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Bob Nelson    11 years ago

Cobras were cool, too.

"Pop smoke and duck!"

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   FLYNAVY1    11 years ago

Killer of an aircraft for sure......

As a Navy puke.... the only thing I'm going to add is what are the hours on these aircraft? Tactical aircraft are highly stressed in air to ground maneuvers. Air frames fatigue and become a danger to those flying them.

Surely we can find someone over at Northrup-Boeing that can duplicate the aircraft, and ship it to the Army to operate. Fairchild Aircraft is now aligned with a Germany company Dornier, so going back to them is not an option.

(No, I'm not real fond of the Air Force and their ascots...... Flair to land, Squat to pee.)

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Bob Nelson    11 years ago

I'm sorry, but I don't remember very clearly -- I know I've seen numbers, but I don't know where. I seem to remember that it depends on your yardstick. Compared to a fighter, not much...

Of course, on campaign, they tend to get shot up a bit...

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Bob Nelson    11 years ago

Awww... I am so-o-o-o disappointed...

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Bob Nelson    11 years ago

Vox has a good RSS stream.

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   1stwarrior    11 years ago

Interestingly, the Chiefs of Staff have been trying to get the 35 quashed and Congress refuses to do so. Why? Money in their districts. The 35 is a $112 M plane, excluding the engine. Have been testing since '03 and it's still a pathetic piece of work.

The F-22, the "other" killer in the game, is a $137M plane that still hasn't seen combat 'cause the filtration system can't handle the dusts and the oxygenation system for the pilots keeps on tripping out when needed.

The A-10, an $18.8 M aircraft, needs a remodeling, but it would be well worth it.

 
 
 
Jason T
Freshman Silent
link   Jason T    11 years ago

I absolutely love the sound of the A-10 and what it does to the bad guy. But I think nothing beats the hunter killer team of the cobra and super hueys now. They sounds pretty nice when they come on station and start to annihilate things. We never did get to use the spectra had them on station a few times but never needed them.

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Bob Nelson    11 years ago

the Chiefs of Staff have been trying to get the 35 quashed

That's not how I've heard it. The Air Force (hey! Top Gun and all that) is still solidly behind the F-35, while the Army sees a future with no decent ground support. The Navy and the Marines are ambivalent, since it doesn't look promising for the STOVL version.

But in any case, you are right that Congress doesn't want to hear about killing the F-35, for pork motives, i.e. government spending creating jobs...

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Bob Nelson    11 years ago

I saw one up close at the Yuma Marine Air Center a year ago. Looks really cool, but I don't think they have any flying yet.

Still see Harriers pretty often.

How is the C advancing?

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   FLYNAVY1    11 years ago

My contacts at Patuxent River Naval Test Center tell me off the record, that the Navy is going to lose both pilots and aircraft with the F-35.

To quote my friend: This is the worst aircraft the Navy has tried to land on a flight deck since the F7U "Gutless Cutlass".

The "C" variants did multiple catapult launchs and arrested landings on a carrier back in early November of last year without incident. The tests were done aboard CVN-68, USS Nimitz.

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Bob Nelson    11 years ago

Does anyone remember how long it took to get the Osprey operational?

Can the F-35 break the record?!?!

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   FLYNAVY1    11 years ago

Can the F-35 break the record?!?!

In the immortal words of Gene Autry....... Yup!

All while breaking the bank too!

It can't climb!, it can't turn!, it can't run!

If this doesn't clear up how bad the F-35 is for you, then you need to run for congress!

It doesn't have range, it carries fewer missiles that the aircraft it has to take on, Its payload as a strike aircraft is less than what it is suppose to replace, all at four times the cost of what it is replacing. Besides.... Stealth doesn't work in all weather.

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Bob Nelson    11 years ago

Why don't you give us your real opinion of this aircraft? I can just feel your enthusiasm, just about to burst free!

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   FLYNAVY1    11 years ago

Bob....

The Navy many, many, years ago learned that two engines for an aircraft that operates over water means survivability for the aircraft and the crew. This sucker has an engine problem and both it and the aviator are going into the drink. Aircraft at the bottom of the ocean are a very poor return on the taxpayers investment.

CoC prevents me taking the surgar coating off so I will leave you with this thought......

It is impossible to polish a turd!

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Bob Nelson    11 years ago

Considering the cost, this thing isn't sugar-coated. It is gold-plated.

Which doesn't mean it isn't a turd...

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   FLYNAVY1    11 years ago

The A-7E was our last single engine aircraft, and yes, it was a very cost effective attack aircraft at less than $3million a copy. As missions changed towards strike-fighters the need for dual engine aircraft from a performance standpoint became the rule. I will see if I can dig up the old statistics related to naval aircraft lost due to engine failure and post it.

One of the biggest crimes was allowing Dick Cheney to kill the F-14. The sucker had years left of life, and the changes being made towards strike capability while improving it's avionics was dropping its maintenance load. Dick Cheney hated the Grumman Corp, while he was at the same time the patron saint for Lockheed. Lockheed's only carrier based aircraft since the invention of the angled-deck was the S-3A Viking, and much of what they learned came from LTV, the maker of the A-7 and F-8. The Viking ended up being a very solid performer, but back in the 1980s we were still teaching Lockheed about corrosion control, and how to make aircraft that had to stand up to carrier deployments.

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   FLYNAVY1    11 years ago

So that maneuverability is not really desirable, at least that's what they keep saying hahaha

Hmmmmm... Lets see, you're carrying less ATA missiles while also having less maneuverability due to lower wing loading than your opponent. Do you really want to strap one of these things on and go looking for trouble?

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   FLYNAVY1    11 years ago

The defining matter in this though is that the USAF at a high level doesn't want to be committed to that role. If that's the case, they should just come out and say so, then advocate that the US Army's restriction on operating fixed wing aircraft be lifted, and transfer the A10's to the Army.

The USAF at any level has never wanted dirt duty. The A-10 is a perfect fit for the Army, and they know what to do with it. Lift the restriction, and give both services what they want.

Again, I don't know how many hours nor airframe stress these aircraft have accumulated. I know that they seem to be a damn fine weapon for what they were designed to do, while providing survivability for the crew.

 
 

Who is online

CB


119 visitors