The Myth of the Good Guy With a Gun
Audry Miller is comforted by community activist Andrew Holmes during a memorial service for her 11-year-old granddaughter, Shamiya Adams, on July 20, 2014, in Chicago. Adams was killed when a stray bullet flew through an open window and an interior wall and struck her in the head.
Suppose a criminal has just broken into your house brandishing a firearm. You need to protect yourself and your family. Wouldnt anyone feel safer owning a gun? This is the kind of narrative propagated by gun advocates in defense of firearm ownership. It preys on our fear. Yet, the annual per capita risk of death during a home invasion is 0.0000002, which, for all intents and purposes, is zero.
Despite the astronomical odds against being killed, this fear of home invasion often drives people like Becca Campbell of Ferguson, Missouri, to gun ownership. This past November, Campbell was riding home in a car with her boyfriend after purchasing a gun, preparing for the unrest expected to follow the grand jury decision about whether to pursue criminal charges against the policeman who killed Michael Brown. She joked that were ready for Ferguson , waving the gun. Distracted, the boyfriend ran into the car ahead of them, and the gun fired, killing Campbell.
The Myth of the Good Guy With a Gun , b y Evan DeFilippis and Devin Hughes , Slate

The "protect your home" gun-nut articles I have seen have always been a series of vignettes, hoping that people will forget that in a nation of 300 million, anything and everything will occur.
This article has its stories, but more importantly, it has study after study and then again studies . Or this study , this meta-analysis , or this national survey .
For example:
And one more study , for the road...
Why you don't act like a moron when you have a gun. If the idiot hadn't been playing with it then she would still be alive. Don't see how this article debunks the good guy with a gun.
You didn't read the seed, did you, Robert? Between its posting and your response, you didn't have enough time.
Gun-nuts are fascinating people -- they can be fairly reasonable about most topics, but become utterly irrational on guns. I haven't seen a psychological analysis, but I'll bet that it would be fascinating.
Of course you don't -- you didn't read it.
Ummm.... the last line of the seed is:
Yup! I agree with you on this... It would be a good idea to link to the Slate article.
Good guy, bad guy, home invasion, self defense, gun nut, anti-gun. all worthwhile topics. Perhaps it should be about stupid people with guns. And this lady is definitely stupid! I own three guns. Rifle, shotgun, used for self defense against running into a cougar or bear in the woods. I also have a 9 mil handgun, properly registered and have a concealed permit as per the laws in WA state. I am for background checks, registered ownership and would never consider joining the NRA, Just stating my personal position on the gun situation.
This guy is dead and this woman is at fault through outrageous stupidity on both their parts. Hard for me to generate any sympathy for either one.
I visited a Gun Fair once. Scary: so many Rambo wannabes with crazy eyes.
You didn't read the seed, did you Don?
Ummm..... if you scroll down to the middle of the page to which the link, The Myth of the Good Guy With a Gun , will take you, you will find the text I posted.
If you do not know what "scroll" means, just ask. I will explain...
I'm glad you agree. And I'm sure you base your agreement on your own experience of gunshows. Why don't you tell us?
Nope. I just know someone bought a gun because they imagined they may need to defend themselves, did not know what they were doing, and shot and killed someone else. I call that stupid, idiotic, and sad. You guys can argue statistics, facts, fiction and theory. I don't give a shit! All I know is that this lady is stupid.
Here in Colorado with our make my day law your life does not need to be in danger to shoot a home invader. What is the percentage of home invaders that are there to steal you possessions? We have the right to shoot them if they break into our homes here and what better tool to use than a gun? Yes, we have a low percentage of home invasions here in Colorado. The vast majority of gun owners in the USA are good guys. Often just knowing a good guy has a gun is enough to make a bad guy search for victims elsewhere. It sends a strong message to potential thieves, break into someones home and risk a lead slap in the face.
That is a gun-nut in a nutshell!
Bob, enlighten me. Are you referring to me as a 'gun nut'? if you are, nothing could be farther from the truth.
OK. Then "nut" will have to do. Or maybe "wingnut", since a total disregard for data is a unifying characteristic of that demographic.
He reminds of one of the good guys with a gun that stormed the beaches of Normandy. If the French didn't have such strict handgun laws they wouldn't have the no go zone known as the Eiffel Tower where lawless pickpockets run rampant victimizing unarmed good guys.
How about the risk of being injured or raped ? Those are a lot greater ...