╌>

The Strong Dollar Is Always Good, Except When It Isn’t

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  robert-in-ohio  •  11 years ago  •  9 comments

The Strong Dollar Is Always Good, Except When It Isn’t

United States Treasury secretaries routinely say that they favor a strong dollar, regardless of circumstances or economic conditions. And the dollar is strong right now, thanks in no small part to actions by foreign central banks.

The European Central Bank significantly loosened its monetary policy on Thursday, in the process driving down the euro and bolstering the dollar. Measured against a basket of currencies, the dollars value has soared 19 percent since May, and the momentum seems to be building.

A strong dollar has always been a good thing for the United States, Treasury Secretary Jacob J. Lew declared not long ago, a position that he has restated frequently.

But is it really a good thing for the United States and the global economy?

In 2011, Timothy F. Geithner, then the Treasury secretary, said, A strong dollar will always be in the interest of the United States . He uttered that mantra even though leading economists at the time were noting that the dollar was actually weakening and the shift was in the best interest of the United States. A weaker dollar meant that American exports were more competitive in world markets and consumption of imported goods was declining. In turn, that trimmed Americas trade and budget deficits, stimulated the domestic economy, and helped to spur job creation.

A weaker dollar was, arguably, one of the reasons for the health of the American economy, compared with other nations. The stronger dollar that has resulted from that period of American advantage could reverse some of the progress that the United States has made. Thats not obviously a good thing for the United States.

Paying ritualistic homage to the dollar isnt limited to recent Democratic administrations. After leaving office, Paul ONeill, Treasury secretary under President George W. Bush in 2001 and 2002, recalled those years: I was not supposed to say anything but strong dollar, strong dollar. I argued then and would argue now that the idea of a strong-dollar policy is a vacuous notion.

No matter. The dollar is a potent symbol of Americas global power, and United States government officials habitually bow to it, even when their comments arent firmly linked to policy or geopolitical reality, said Eswar S. Prasad, a Cornell University professor of economics who is the author of the The Dollar Trap, a study of the dollars role in global finance.

The notion that a strong country always has a strong currency isnt something that many countries subscribe to, he said. As a continental power that doesnt rely on exports to the extent that many other nations do, he said, the United States has been able to sustain the illusion of the importance of a strong currency, but really, when the dollar is fairly strong, as it is now, its a mixed blessing for the economy of the United States.

Disentangling the factors that affect foreign exchange rates and that make the dollar strong isnt simple. Supply and demand in the marketplace can be masked temporarily by canny trading and improper market activities.

For the most part, though, it appears that the dollar has strengthened for substantive reasons: It has become more attractive than other currencies, on a relative basis, because its linked to the American economy, which has been growing more rapidly than those of most other developed countries.

Whats more, the monetary cycle in the United States has diverged from that in many other countries: The Federal Reserve has signaled that it is considering interest rate increases, and it has ended bond purchases or quantitative easing . That reflects the growth of the American economy, a big contrast with Europe and Japan, which are struggling. Last week, the European Central Bank embarked on a new, 1 trillion euro ($1.16 trillion) campaign of quantitative easing, and it has been further lowering interest rates that are already extraordinarily low and sometimes in negative territory.

In Japan, the central bank has also been aggressively expanding its quantitative easing program and keeping interest rates low.

Furthermore, the dollar has worldwide appeal as a safe haven, a destination currency in times of global trouble. That role is likely to become more crucial now that the Swiss franc, another traditional haven, has begun to gyrate wildly in value. That has occurred since Jan. 15, when the Swiss National Bank eliminated the francs peg to the euro and started charging banks interest of 0.75 percent to hold their reserves.

The Greek elections on Sunday, which have already unnerved financial markets, could well add more immediate luster to the dollar.

Whether this is truly good for the United States is another matter.

There are some clear benefits, which Mr. Prasad enumerated. Global money flooding into dollar-denominated investments tends to lower interest rates in this country. That typically makes home mortgages cheaper, and a variety of assets more valuable, including houses, bonds and stocks. Americans abroad can buy more with dollars, and imported goods like clothing are cheaper. Add that to the windfall for consumers coming from lower oil prices and it could stimulate the economy.

But there are obvious problems, too. There could be negative spillover effects in emerging markets, where corporate debt has increasingly been dollar-denominated. As that debt becomes more expensive in local currencies, financial stress is likely to heighten.

American exports tend to become more expensive abroad, too, hurting businesses that make them and reducing the rate of job creation. If the dollar were to become much stronger and it persisted, there will be an outcry, Mr. Prasad said.

More than 40 percent of revenue for the companies in the Standard & Poors 500-stock index come from abroad, and those with significant foreign operations will have earnings problems, if they havent hedged their currency exposure.

(read entire article at)

http://www.nytimes.com/2015/01/25/business/the-strong-dollar-is-always-good-except-when-it-isnt.html?rref=homepage&module=Ribbon&version=origin&region=Header&action=click&contentCollection=Home%20Page&pgtype=article


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    11 years ago

All of which suggests that a strong dollar isnt entirely and always good, whatever the Treasury secretary says. But it is something we will have to learn to live with.

As a strong dollar emerges and it looks like it will hang around for a bit, the U.S> economy and the U.S. people are going to need to be prepared to embrace the bad effects that may emerge along with the benefits that will come with a strong dollar in the global economy.

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    11 years ago

slarti

Thanks for the feedback and the perspective, as always the issue is a little clearer after your feedback.

I agree with your point

There needs to be a stable base from which the economy works from.

I am just not sure what that "stable base" is at this point

you are creating mutually destructive moving targets

That sure doesn't sound good

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    11 years ago

Thanks for that feedback

Hopefully, it will not take long to fix it, hopefully.

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    11 years ago

You are probably right, but hope springs eternal!

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   Bob Nelson    11 years ago

Money is a commodity. It's price is partly purchasing power, partly supply-and-demand, partly current interest rates and partly expected interest rates.

Right now, it looks like money dealers are betting heavily on America's economy against Europe's. (The bet looks pretty good to me.)

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    11 years ago

Interesting perspective thanks for sharing

That same bet has been made before and paid off for a while and then didn't - cyclical economic activity in part and in part an indication of our economy recovering a little faster as parts of the global economy continue to struggle

 
 

Who is online

CB


119 visitors