╌>

The Fundamental Economic problem that we face,

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  slartibartfast  •  11 years ago  •  13 comments

The Fundamental Economic problem that we face,

Most of the time, we spend our 'blog' time arguing about this or that, usually with political acrimony, with the end effect of ignoring the big bullseye target (yeah the one that just decided to lay off 20K Canadians in rushing home in a way similar to the US military in the war of 1812).

Well here's something that should succinctly illustrate what our problem is. This doesn't change with the economic numbers over the last 6 months of official figures (remember, the first quarter of 2014 showed a decline in economic growth).

2654_discussions.jpg Now, to explain this graph, this is a graph that for a short period of time, 2006 to the current time frame, shows the growth in GDP in the United States. The graph is what is known as a logarithmic graph, which means it is only showing the exponential part of growth. To simplify this, all that means is that it really only shows the growth on a year to year basis, rather than cumulative. (It doesn't make a non logarithmic graph wrong, it just shows something else).

Now this graph is really quite useful, because what it does is show a previous trend (the very light blue line labeled 2003-2007 trajectory). This trend actually should be labeled, 1945-2007, because for the most part, this has been the general economic trend in the United States, post WWII and the actual measured growth rates have essentially hovered above and below this trend line.

The financial crisis that occurred in 2009 changed that, and obviously it has changed it for the worse. What we see here is that our economic growth pattern has in fact returned to what is roughly a 3% growth trend, the same trend that existed prior to the crisis, but at a much lower level, about 7% if one were to eyeball the graph (some data that I have seen, but was not used to create this graph shows about a 10% permanent drop in GDP for the United States).

Now, what this graph doesn't show is what happened during the previous bubble, which the then administration also unfortunately did nothing to stop. (I have that graph somewhere else, on another computer). What that graph shows is that during the dot com bubble, GDP growth significantly exceeded the 3% growth trend illustrated here. This is actually what one should expect during a bubble, significantly higher economic activity as the bubble propels spending. This also happened during the run up to the 1929 stock market crash between the 1927 and 1929 time frames (the real period that the buildup occurred preceding that crash).

What is extremely telling is that before the 2008 crash, there was no bump. We had a multi trillion dollar bubble occurring during the real estate bubble, yet we didn't have the economic boost beyond the trend line to show for it.

What does that mean? It means that the economic bubble that we were experiencing during the latter part of the Bush administration was in fact really a period of recession, only hidden by that bubble. This bubble was essentially economic destruction.

Now we can talk and blame the Bush administration till the end of time, but the reality is, the Bush Administration is gone, has been for 6 years now. What we have is the clean up. And THIS Is where we needed strong leadership from the current administration, and THIS is precisely where it has failed outright. From the get go, this administration treated this economic situation as though it was just a regular recession. It isn't, and the amount of lost opportunity to transform the economy in positive ways will cost the nation for generations. Currently, the cost has been estimated to be around the cost of WWII in adjusted dollars (Martin Wolf: The Shifts and the Shocks: What Weve Learnedand Have Still to Learnfrom the Financial Crisis - 2014) . That's pretty significant if you ask me considering what WWII cost.

So what is the solution? It is unclear at this point what the solution really is. Ultimately though, what we need to stop doing is treating this like a regular cyclical recession, and start treating it for what it is, a major structural economic problem, one that is affecting us in many ways, lost wages, unrealized economic potential, and on a more social level, increased political polarization and extremism.

Most of all, we need a government that understands this, and this is where the most unfortunate aspect of these most unfortunate series of events lies. We don't We had an administration that spent its last few months trying to prevent total collapse, followed by a government that has been essentially bereft of ideas, and an opposition that had nothing but destructive ideas, to go along with the destruction that the opposition promoted in the previous administration.

Additionally, this also does not mean that we get government out of this, because, and this is unfortunate, it needs to be yet again said, it was the private sector that got us into this mess in the first place, though the government DID have a strong helping hand.

Until we realize this, this stagnant crap will be our future. and if we don't realize it, that is what we will deserve.


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Steve Ott
Professor Silent
link   Steve Ott    11 years ago

Are these numbers adjusted for inflation, and if so, from what year?

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    11 years ago

What logarithmic graph ? Was this supposed to be a test of numeracy ?

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   FLYNAVY1    11 years ago

The wold has changed so very much since 2000, yet I don't believe that the majority of Americans have contemplated let alone grasped the differences that are impacting our economy.

You are correct that the economic destruction that was 2008-2009 was manufactured by the private sector with a strong helping hand through deregulation enabled by congress years in advance of the mess. Right now as I see it, I don't see any way of getting the the lid closed on Pandora's box. This mess is here to stay.

Somewhere along the line the idea of financial profit is going to have to be rejected as it serves too few in the world at the expense of the rest. I know it is a hard concept to get one's head around. But how do we get the world to the point where we value knowledge over accumulation of wealth? The most important natural resource humans have is our ability to think, reason, and solve problems. How do we move our species forward without having to calculate an ROI based on financial return?

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   Robert in Ohio    11 years ago

slarti

A complicated thing (at least for me)

Am I correct in understand that the use of the logarithmic graph, rather than a ? exponential graph ? that the noise of inflation, real dollar value, etc is eliminated?

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   FLYNAVY1    11 years ago

The weakening of Glass-Steagall from the 1960s on, through amendment, or outright repeal section by section played a very big part in it. By the time sections 20 and 32 were eliminated by Gramm-Leach-Bliley, things were simmering. GLBA allowed the consolidation of investment banks, commercial banks, investment and insurance companies under one roof, and did not provide any empowering regulatory body to oversee these consolidated behemoths. The SEC sure as hell didn't have any regulating power.

In doing so, the banks with the help of shoddy underwriting, and shadow banks began to operate more like the betting casino that is Wall Street. So a big YES to deregulation being the cause of things. Everything that Glass-Steagall regulated from the 1920 crash had been undone by 2000.

"Where there is greed, there is a way......"

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   Robert in Ohio    11 years ago

Appreciate the clarification

 
 

Who is online

CB


93 visitors