Three Reasons 'Obamaleave' is (Might Be) a Bad Idea
President Obama is seeking a new federal law that would mandate that employers provide their workers with up to seven paid days of sick leave annually. There are at least three reasons why the enactment of "Obamaleave" would be a bad idea.
First, a federal paid sick law would complicate administration of mandatory paid sick leave laws in the handful of places that have adopted paid sick leave laws of their own. The provisions of those laws vary. California's law requires employers of any size to provide up to three paid sick days annually to qualifying employees, with the employee allowed to use those sick days for his own illness or to care for the illness of a broad range of relatives. Connecticut's law is limited to employers of 50 or more and allows the employee to use those sick days to care only for herself, her child, or her spouse. Connecticut's law also, however, provides for the equivalent of two more days of sick leave per year than California's law.
Where federal and state employment laws differ on the same topic, as in the case of the minimum wage, the more employee-friendly law generally applies. It is unlikely that a federal paid sick law will be written in such a way as to trump, or preempt, all state paid sick leave laws. Sorting out which provisions are more or less employee- friendly than the federal law will be a challenge.
Second, the states that have employer-funded, job-protected paid leave laws have enacted those laws only very recently. The paid sick leave law in Connecticut went into effect in 2012. Massachusetts enacted its law by ballot this past fall. California's paid leave law went into effect this January. According to The New York Times , a member of the president's Council of Economic Advisers has said that "evidence" shows that paid-leave programs help workers without cutting into employer profits. What evidence? The right to accrue paid leave under California's law will not even kick in until July 1. Any "evidence" can only be based on Connecticut's two-years of experience and that of a small number of cities with such laws. Is that really enough to validate the enactment of a nationwide employer mandate?
The great Supreme Court Justice Louis Brandeis once wrote that a "state may, if its citizens choose, serve as a laboratory; and try novel social and economic experiments without risk to the rest of the country." Why not wait to see what actually comes of these experiments in the laboratories of democracy that have enacted them? The federal Family Medical Leave Act, providing for 12 weeks of unpaid job-protected family leave annually, was not enacted until 1993. That was at least a half dozen years after the first state enacted such a measure. Let's wait.
Three, one of the arguments used to justify this measure is that the United States is one of only a few countries without paid sick leave for employees. So what? The American economy is on the rebound even as the economies of many other developed and developing countries are struggling. The argument that we should adopt workplace policies found abroad is singularly unpersuasive just now.
This is not to say that it is a bad idea for employers to provide paid sick leave. It obviously is better for sick employees to stay home rather than come to work in an impaired capacity and to infect others. It may also be better for employees with sick loved ones to stay home to care for them rather than to work distracted. Offering such a benefit makes a company a more attractive prospective employer.
But whether an employer must pay for sick leave is not cost-free. It matters in a way that may elude statistics. What of that job that is not created because of the expense of the mandate or the cost of replacing the temporarily absent worker? Can any federal subsidy of the kind the president is including in his proposal fully compensate for that?
President Obama's paid sick leave proposal is unlikely to be enacted by a Republican Congress. With all of the talk of the projected dysfunction of divided government, we should not overlook its greatest blessing. Divided government stops either side's worst ideas from becoming law.
http://news360.com/article/274710746#
Commentary by Dan Eaton, a partner with the San Diego law firm of Seltzer Caplan McMahon Vitek where his practice focuses on defending and advising employers. He also is a professor at the San Diego State University College of Business Administration where he teaches classes in business ethics and employment law.
Tags
Who is online
89 visitors

An interesting (one-sided) look at the president's proposal.
I agree that improvements to the Family Medical Leave Act can and should be made, but am not sure that a federally mandated paid family leave framework is the answer
States are taking on and addressing this issue and we should let the "laboratories of democracy" work the kinks out of this complicated issue with the private sector.
Government is stepping into areas they shouldn't get in to.
They should only be able to decide, if at all, if a company should be allowed to have policies of their own and on what legal, not moral, basis.
slarti
I agree the paid leave policies have existed in the private sector for years, and they have existed as part of the company offered benefit plans without government mandate.
Perhaps it should continue thusly.
I believe I said in my first comment that it was a view entirely from one side of the issue
John
I didn't know you had a sense of humor
I knew I could count on you for the "evil corporations" comment, thanks.
1stwarrior
I totally agree that paid leave programs should be the purview of the private sector, not another government mandated benefit.
Paid sick/family leave is part of the benefits/compensation package offered by many companies and comprises a part of the employee's total compensation
Talk about the pot calling the kettle black!!!
If you ever had an article or comment without a severely slanted point of view, it would not be so much funny as astonishing
I have no issue with sick pay, only that it should be a private sector matter, part of the employee's compensation package and not a government mandated benefit.
You post enough evil corporation articles so that no one else needs to.
Corporate greed - your pat answer to all economic issues -- no thought required, good for you right.
Slartibartfast,
Yay!!
jennilee
You make a good point, it must have just been blind luck that past generations of businesses and the workers in them have managed to make anything of themselves at all.
Thanks for the feedback and the perspective on the issue
Once again,Slartibartfast,
Yay !!
The good old days... ... weren't!
slarti
But they made progress, and each generation was better off than the one before it
-- Thomas Hobbes, 1651
John
Thanks for providing your stock comment "corporate greed" - saves you the pain and agony of thinking up anything to say
Bob
Thanks
Always appreciate cut and pasteinsight from smart people
Slarti
In the 20th century and in many cases into the 21st century as well
And your are correct about the industrial revolution and now we have automation/AI/robotics - the current "industrial revolution"
Might have been the huge infrastructure investments, (post WW II), orthe huge investment in middle classgiven tothe millions of returning vetsthrough the GI Bill's benefits, or perhaps it wasthe strength of the Unionsafter the wargiving the working man more say at the table.
Of course those were just pieces of the puzzlemaking upwho does well in America andwho struggles but it's telling to me that investments in infrastructure & ourcitizens these days are down,(fought against tooth and nail by some), and the Union's power hasalso waned duringthis time of a shrinking, ever more struggling, middle class.
A H
Thanks for the perspective on the issue
What you describe, seems to me to be making wise choices and seizing opportunities that were available to take great strides forward as an economy and a country.
Thanks again for the feedback
jennilee
That is how I was raised to believe was the way to live one's life. Sounds like you have a lot of folks to be proud of in your family past and present.
Thanks for that perspective
Great original thinkers such as yourself must make allowances for those of us who recognize that there have been smarter people, since the world began.
Yup! The best way to happiness is through poverty.
Greed is intrinsic to corporations. Their purpose is to maximize shareholder dividends. To make as much money as possible. That is the nature of the beast.
No one is surprised by predatory behavior in a predatory animal. It is the nature of the beast.
Why should we be surprised by greed in corporations?
Some people are not only surprised... they refuse to recognize an obvious fact.
Bob
We should not be surprised by the drive for profit in corporation, it is the basis of the free market process
You make excellent points, thanks for sharing them
Bob
I certainly do not think of myself as some great thinker, the point I thought you might get from the comment was that I wanted to hear what you thought about the quote that you cut and pasted in addition to the words of the intellectual.
NO actually the best way to happiness and security is through hard work and focus on your objectives, but you know that I am sure. It is clearly possible to be happy and relatively secure without being "wealthy"
But I love sarcasm, so thanks for the perspective
Robert,
Why did you swap "drive for profit" for "greed"?
If we find the same trait in a person, we call it "greed". Why do you sanitize it when you describe a corporation? Is there something holy about corporations, that forbids blasphemy?
I find the drive for profit (personal accomplishment and wealth accumulation) in an individual admirable as well, and the "drive for profit" is the primary purpose of a business and not simply "greed" as many like to shout and repeat over and over.
Do you agree that "the drive for profit" (in either persons or corporations) leads to asocial behavior?
After all "me, me, me, me..." inevitably leads to disregard for others...
Not necessarily, some of the most profitable companies and richest individuals are model citizens and give back as well as fill a role as positive members of the community
So... you may be able to name one or two... and on the other side it is childs-play to name hundreds of polluters, etc...
Do you really believe, deep down in your marrow, that there are as many "good citizens" as there are villains?
Really?
Microsoft, Berkshire Hathaway, Starbucks,
Gates, Buffet
I think there are Excellent, Good, Average, Bad, and Very Bad corporations just as there are the same categories of people.
That does not answer my question, Robert. Not even close. It's weaseling.
Are you saying "I think there are Excellent (90%), Good (5%), Average (3%) , Bad (1%), and Very Bad (1%) corporations just as there are the same categories of people."
Or are you saying, "I think there are Excellent (1%), Good (3%), Average (7%), Bad (20%), and Very Bad (70%) corporations just as there are the same categories of people.'
I'm asking your opinion, Robert. If you say you think that most corporations are honorable, respecting law and morality (almost) all the time, because that is the right thing to do... then I will not argue with you. I just want to know what you believe...
LOL!
Lordy every time I hear that old, " We were poor but we were Happy!", stuff I can't help but to flash back to that great Monty Python skit, " Four Yorkshiremen ".
In case the video link doesn't work or for those laboring under restrictions like our buddy Buzz.
Couldn't be farther off topic, but I am sure someone will enjoy it, so thanks for sharing I guess
???
jennilee's post is on topic -- get's an enthusiastic thumbs-up from you, but this is off topic?
How do you figure?
Different opinions on something between you and I - imagine that!
I stated my opinion, but thankedA H for the comment as I was sure that someone would enjoy it, apparently you did.
Quit whining
Wow...