Ben Carson is a paradoxical figure: a genial fanatic
"What I neglected to consider was the possibility that the same electorate that would forgive Trumps boorish and often f alse statements would be equally indulgent of Carsons lack of policy expertise.In the Fox debate, Megyn Kelly called attention to Carsons long string of seeming embarrassing gaffes. Youve suggested that the Baltic States are not a part of NATO, just months ago you were unfamiliar with the major political parties and government in Israel, and domestically, you thought Alan Greenspan had been treasury secretary instead of Federal Reserve chair, Kelly chided. Yet Carson has been hurt no more than Trump by his record of clueless and mistaken comments.
Stylistically, of course, Trump and Carson couldnt be farther apart: Carson is as demure as Trump is bombastic, as modest as Trump is boastful, as gentle as Trump is aggressive, and as soft-spoken as Trump is loud. Yet despite these surface differences, the two men have much in common as anti-politicians. They are both candidates whose appeal lies in the fact that they are not polished in the familiar manner of professional pols and have been untainted by the compromises made by those who have actually held elected office.
But they are appealing to different sets of Republican voters. Leaving aside Trumps xenophobic immigration record, hes more moderate than Carson, and the other candidates, on a host of issues ranging from taxes to health care. While Trump has managed to gain traction with Republicans who identify themselves as moderate, Carson is making a more traditional pitch to the partys hardline conservative base. For those who arent on the far right, the dog-whistle references Carson made in the debate to Hillary Clinton following the Alinksy model and taking advantage of the useful idiots might seem like gibberish, for instance, but they are part of a familiar litany on the hard right, where Obama and the Clintons are seen as thinly disguised socialist revolutionaries. The same goes for Carsons argument that the tax code should be based on the Biblical ideal of tithing (conflating religion with secular policy making)and his waving aside of concerns about torture as political correctness.
The key to Carsons rise if that hes finding a niche for himself as both an anti-Trump and an anti-Obama. For Republicans who see Obama and social movements like Black Lives Matter as encouraging social breakdown and divisiveness, Carson presents himself as a reassuring model of racial reconciliation, a black man who eschews bitterness and can succeed without raising his voice about racism. I think the bully pulpit is a wonderful place to start healing that divide, Carson said at the first debate. You know, we have the purveyors of hatred who take every single incident between people of two races and try to make a race war out of it, and drive wedges into people. And this does not need to be done.
Carson is a paradoxical figure: a genial fanatic who combines extreme ideas with a comforting, trust-inducing persona. On a personal level hes much more winning thanTrump, but in policy terms no less frightening.
http://www.newrepublic.com/article/122827/why-ben-carsons-extremism-goes-down-easy
Tags
Who is online
99 visitors
