4 Reasons Why Consistently Strong Hiring is Failing to Boost US Inflation or Wages
This isn't explained in Econ 101.
Month after month, U.S. hiring keeps rising, and unemployment keeps falling. Eventually, pay and inflation are supposed to start surging in response.
They're not happening.
Last month, employers added a healthy 252,000 jobs ending the best year of hiring since 1999 and the unemployment rate sank to 5.6 percent from 5.8 percent. Yet inflation isn't managing to reach even the Federal Reserve's 2 percent target rate. And paychecks are barely budging. In December, average hourly pay actually fell.
Economists are struggling to explain the phenomenon.
"I can't find a plausible empirical or theoretical explanation for why hourly wages would drop when for nine months we've been adding jobs at a robust pace," said Patrick O'Keefe, chief economist at consulting firm CohnReznick.
Normally, with unemployment this low, the Fed would raise its benchmark interest rate to prevent inflation from spiking and the economy from overheating. Not this time. Though the Fed's record-low rates have helped support the economy since the 2008 financial crisis, those low rates haven't met their other goal of raising wages and inflation to normal levels.
As long as inflation stays consistently below its target, the Fed might feel pressure to delay a rate increase beyond midyear, when most economists have predicted a hike. Thanks in part to plunging oil prices, many economists now envision even less inflation this year than in 2014.
When the U.S. economy last enjoyed a similar hiring binge, in 1999, average wages climbed 3.6 percent, compared with 1.6 percent last year, according to the government.
So what explains consistently solid job growth without inflation?
Here are four crucial factors:
RECESSION'S LINGERING DAMAGE
Though the unemployment rate is back to a nearly healthy level, many other measures of the job market remain subpar.
There are still 6.8 million people working part time who can't find full-time jobs, up from 4.1 million before the recession. Each of those workers potentially competes with the unemployed for full-time work, thereby holding down wages.
And there are 2.3 million people who have recently stopped looking for work, some of them because they grew discouraged about their prospects. Others chose to return to school or to care for relatives. That's up from 1.3 million before the recession.
And a broader gauge of unemployment, which includes the officially unemployed as well as involuntary part-time workers and those who've stopped looking, is 11.1 percent. That figure has improved since the recession, but not as much as the official unemployment rate has.
The end of long-term unemployment benefits, which provided up to 99 weeks of aid until they expired a year ago, may also be contributing to lower wages, said Daniel Alpert, managing director at Westwood Capital, said.
That's because some of the unemployed have likely had to take lower-paying jobs. Retail or restaurant jobs that pay at or near minimum wage don't provide much more spending power than unemployment benefits did, Alpert added. That means the new jobs won't raise inflation much if workers can't afford to spend much more than they did when they were unemployed.
BLAME THE ROBOTS
What's happened in the auto industry reveals much about how the economy has been transformed and why a nearly normal 5.6 percent unemployment isn't igniting wages.
Sales of new cars last year reached 16.5 million, the best performance since 2006. But the gains have yet to restore every auto job lost to the recession let alone expand the industry's employment over the past eight years. The number of autoworkers remains about 160,000 shy of pre-recession levels of more than 1 million.
The reason: Companies fear returning to the days when they had too much factory capacity. So they're squeezing more production out of less capacity. Emerging from the recession, automakers reconfigured factory floors and added robots to produce more vehicles from fewer plants and fewer workers.
What's more, the United Auto Workers union agreed to wage cuts in an effort to help General Motors, Ford and Chrysler. New hires started at around $16 an hour, about half of what longtime workers earn.
Roughly a quarter of Detroit's factory workers now make the entry-level wage. Even longtime UAW workers haven't had an hourly pay raise since 2007, though they've received annual profit-sharing checks equaling about $4 an hour.
Similar trends have emerged at other factories and in other industries. O'Keefe notes, for example, that retailers are selling more goods than before the recession yet still employ fewer workers.
Though hiring has picked up in higher-paying industries, in many cases, wages are still lagging. Average pay at heavy goods manufacturers rose only 0.7 percent last year, less than half the economy-wide average. Pay for transportation and warehousing workers rose just 0.9 percent.
CHECK THE DEMOGRAPHICS
Seen more Uber-riding, Snapchatting millennials?
Since the start of graduation season in May, employers have hired an additional 1.67 million college graduates nearly 60 percent of all jobs added last year. In the past year, the number of 25-to-34 year-olds with jobs has climbed a solid 2.5 percent.
Because so much hiring has disproportionately occurred in recent months, Wells Fargo chief economist John Silvia figures that wages might be held down because many lower-paid entry-level workers are finding jobs. Their influx cuts into average wages while simultaneously reflecting the strength of job growth.
"Given that we've hired so many people in the last two or three months, you're bringing in a lot of new workers who will not be paid as well as experienced workers," Silvia said.
Dig a bit deeper and you find other age-based pressures: The number of workers older than 55 climbed an impressive 3.4 percent last year. But those employees likely maxed out their salary potential years ago and are unlikely to enjoy sharp pay hikes. The number of employed 35-to-54-year-olds the age group most likely to be in their peak earnings period rose less than 1 percentage point in the past year.
GLOBAL REALITY BITES
No matter how much the U.S. economy improves, American workers still face competition from billions of workers in China, India, Eastern Europe and elsewhere who weren't part of the global economy a decade or two ago.
That most of those economies, as well as Japan and the rest of Europe, are stumbling only intensifies the competition for jobs. Weak growth overseas has lowered interest rates and inflation and therefore tempered pay growth in many of the United States' competitors. That means U.S. workers face continued low-wage competition.
At the same time, the dollar's value is rising against other currencies, thereby making U.S. goods costlier overseas. This limits the ability of U.S. workers to secure higher pay. Many U.S. companies can move operations overseas.
O'Keefe notes that this trend increasingly hurts skilled U.S. service workers. Software engineers, legal researchers and IT help desk workers all compete with lower-paid workers overseas.
http://www.startribune.com/lifestyle/288186111.html?page=1&c=y

I came across this article and thought it made some insightful points about the failure of wages to rise as hiring has increased and the economy has improved.
I expect at least one member to sum up the problem as simply "corporate greed:, but I encourage him and everyone to read the article before they comment regardless.
There are some points I think most everyone can agree are true.
What do about that is where the differing opinions and approaches most assuredly exist.
Play nice and comment on the topic if you cab rather than simply blaming the corporations, republicans, democrats, Obama, etc etc - but if you cannot then make whatever comment on the article you like.
The face of the hammer found the head of the nail in the seed Robert.
Seems that the author hit the nail on the head with this article.
FLYNAVY
Thanks for the feedback, I also thought that the author provided an objective look at the issue and an explanation that it is a complex issue and must be addressed as such
Kavika
Thanks
Appreciate the feedback - I also thought it was a great article
a given in modern society
Profit will always be he underlying motive in free market businesses
The structure of wages, societal safety nets, social support processes and work/life balances will be a changing phenomena that will be addressed as the economy and the society evolves in coming years.
People will also have to embrace ad pursue the skills, training and experience that will be needed to get and keep "good" jobs in the evolving economy. The old "blue collar" jobs are not coming back - new technology based jobs are the future.
John
No, actually I have faith in the American way, the American spirit and the American people who have met economic and societal hardships and challenges in the past and overcome them and will do so again.
The "profit motive" as you so flippantly toss around is the basis of the economic mode that this country is built on, private ownership and opportunity to make a profit.
We are not headed for socialism or anarchy despite the fear mongering you provide and support in all discussions about the economy, the recovery and the future of business and jobs in America.
The economy must evolve and the society along with it and the balance of work/family, the social support network processes and structures will change and expand and the USA will continue to prosper and provide opportunities to all its people.
Remember the glass is really half full!
Yeah I think the author was being sarcastic with that remark.
Excellent seed, Robert.
Robert,
Let's go back to JR's first post:
Sooner or later, almost all work will be automated. The question must be, "Who should get the added value created by the automates?"
We are watching the triumph of the 0,001%.
No actually we are watching the natural evolution of the economy and the society
Automation and robotics are happening and will continue to happen - the process and those that implement it are not evil.
Changes to how people work, how they are paid, how the social support processes work in society will also continue to occur. There is no need to fear the future, but there is a need to accept that it is coming and begin to make the changes in education, social processes and business to accommodate what the future will bring.
All work may indeed be automated someday, but it will be much more later than sooner.
Appreciate the feedback
Thanks
I said nothing about "evil".
If the automates are private property, then only their owners will have money.
End of story.
Literally.
Not nearly so simple as you would make it
And I did say or mean to imply that you had said the corporations were evil, but it is a regular refrain from certain commenters.
The ability to purchase things and services will be a combination of income and social support nets in the future and if the evolution of the economy, and the society (private and public sectors) goes as it should then the ability to thrive will be widespread in the society.
And the story is ongoing
... which the ultra-rich, through their GOP puppets, intend to reduce to a bare survival minimum... or less...
Yes. But unless something very unexpected occurs, the end of the story is already known.
There is a LOT going on that is hard to put a finger on. Whenit comes to automation, and how it affects wages, the economy...
The US economy is tied to the global economy. Robots are put into use at different times, by different people, for different reasons. Trying to line all that up to get a real measurement of the change, as differing economies respond to one another,,,,well, that's going to be difficult.
Yes though,AI is huge and speciesal altering in it's implications.
Bob
Well you think you know the end of the story, but I haven't really met anyone who can actually see the future only their interpretation of what will happen.
There has been talk of changing the social support net for many years but nothing dramatic has happened and changes for the better can always be made.
Something needs to occur that is for sure, and sitting around wailing is not a positive in the process
Thanks again for all the back and forth
Automation is the reality and needs to be embraced understood and used rather than feared as some do.
The thing is, Robert, that I am just an interested bystander. The hot social safety net topics interest me... but don't concern me. My retirement is French, as is my health care.
I really, really hate to see my birth country, which was the light of the world in 1945, go so far astray in seventy years.
Agreed
Constantly increasing inequality is also the reality. Should we ignore it or do something?
This isn't fear-mongering. It is reality.
Bob
Perhaps the issue of income inequality should be addressed - wailing and whining about automation is not treatment for the disease it is kibitzing about the symptoms and causes with little chance of doing anything to positively affect the real problem.
Automation / AI / Robotics are not going anywhere and will only accelerate in expansion so economic and social issues need to be dealt with in the context of an "automation" society rather than a discussion of what can be done to limit the automation to save currently existing jobs.
Brian
Excellent point
Robert,
Who said anything of the kind? Did I? I think not! (This is not the first time that you have ascribed to me a position that I have never taken...)
Of course we should do everything we can to eliminate "toil" for everyone. Let machines do it!
Then comes the question of how the wealth created by the machines is to be distributed.
Or a discussion of how people will "earn" a living in the age of automation rather than how wealth will be distributed to them.
Just a thought
I made a general statement about wailing and whining and did not ascribe it to you. Perhaps the problem is a guilty conscience protesting too much
Robert,
You seem to make a lot of "general statements"... in response to my posts. If you don't want me to think you intended your "general statement" to apply specifically to me, then you might consider posting them elsewhere...
Or... alternatively... you are being totally disingenuous... but far be it from me to imagine such behavior from a straightforward, honorable person such as yourself...
---------------------------------------
In a world where robots do all the "toil"... what does the word "earn" mean?
Bob
What you infer from what I write is controllable only by you.
Take it for what it says, since that is what I mean.
As to what "earn" means I would refer you to a dictionary so that you will experience no confusion from how I might explain it
That is a truly remarkable statement, Robert.
You are an idiot! (What you infer from what I write is controllable only by you, so I hope that you will not take offense where none was meant... not to betotallydisingenuous myself...)
Robert...
I keep hoping that you will play it straight, because I get the feeling that you are interested in ideas.
But you spend too much time on the defensive. For example, your side-slip to the dictionary:
I offered you the opportunity to realize that "earn" may not make much sense in an automated world... but you refused reflection. You sent back the dictionary.
OK. So let's see how it applies in an automated world:
"(of a person) obtain (money) in return for labor or services": Does not apply, since robots do all labor and services. Nobody "earns" a salary.
"(of capital invested) gain (money) as interest or profit": No problem, the owners of the robots collect the machines' "earnings".
"(of an activity or action) cause (someone) to obtain (money)": Doesn't apply to people.
So...
Robert...
Since you have nothing more to say than "dictionary"... you are condemning all "not owners of robots" to starvation, and all "owners of robots" to great wealth...
Or maybe you'd like to give a little more thought to my question:
In a world where robots do all the "toil"... what does the word "earn" mean?
You are making a number of assumptions, here, and imposing them on the conversation. Then you complain that the conversation is incomplete! Yikes!
Oh? Why? That question is not at all supercilious. I invite you to really think about it. In a world of 90% automation... why isn't it 100%?
No, because that has not been the topic. But if you would like to discuss the "just salary" for those who "toil" until we reach "automation 100%"... I tend to be a fan of supply-and-demand. The salaries should be whatever it takes to draw "toilers" in a world where a decent living is assured without "toil".
(Let's be clear: there are lots of productive activities that are fun. I spent many years as a management consultant -- I enjoyed the work, made good money, and improved the operations of my clients. That was not "toil". Collecting garbage is "toil".)
No!! That is a presumption of "right of property" that excludes all but the 0.1%! Inheritance is (IMNAAHO) theft. I believe that no one needs more than a million dollars.
The overall worth of the US, divided by the population, is over a half-million dollars per person...
If the robots are "common property", then their "earnings" are common property. The government does not enter into the subject at all.
Same person who always has: me. I don't vacuum anymore, though... Roomba does...
Are you trying to say that we have reached the limits of automation?
Bob
I figured the name calling from you was not far off
You asked questions I answered them
You try to make what I say mean something that it doesn't and I call you on it and you resort to name calling.
I think you and I are done here
Enjoy talking with yourself
Robert,
You said that the reader is responsible for whatever he understands. My "idiot" sentence was intended to make you realize that that is just wrong. Apparently you took the insult to be my meaning and not just your perception. So... Now I want you to know that I do not think you are an idiot.
No. You avoided them. "kinda yes, kinda no" is not an answer.
When did I do this? When did you call me on it? I remember neither.
Look, Robert... All I have done is underscore a few instances of "approximate" reasoning. If I have taken the time to read your posts and to think about them, it's because I think you're someone capable of worthwhile conversation.
When I ask about good / bad corporations, I am not setting a trap. I am setting up a conversation on how we -- you and I -- define and measure good and bad. I suspect our criteria are different. Those differences are what are interesting to examine.
I am sorry to see you break off.