Why can't people stop screaming at each other, (or why is it that both the left and the right miss the bloody point)
The referenced post: Obama vs. Poor
Yesterday (or the day before) a post went up regarding the ACA and how medicaid expansion is hurting those that get it because many doctors will refuse to see new patients that use medicaid.
After that, a bevy of arguments from the usual suspects (both left and right) was the predicted result, and comments were closed to stop it (hence this).
Here's the thing, every single "point of fact" in the source article may be true, yet the entire story is nothing but political fecal matter (yeah, I am NOT a fan of the PPACA, so don't think I am defending it).
Here's the problem with the story. The assumption was that the people that are receiving this medicaid expansion had health insurance previously, and therefore had appropriate health care coverage.
The truth is in fact the opposite. Almost EVERY person that will receive medicaid expansion will be getting health insurance coverage for the first time.
So while the story makes it sound like the PPACA made the situation worse, the reality is, if doctors are refusing to receive new medicaid patients, the situation is really exactly the same, not worse.
BOTH sides of this issue completely ignored that little bit of reality.
Another point about how political this original story really is, a point was made about rationing, but he ignores the very simple reality that the United States ALSO rations health care. It rations it in one of the most evil ways, it does so based on the ability of one to pay. Hey, if we are going to find that acceptable, lets just make the use of roads subject to the same conditions. Oh wait, you can't afford these prices to use the street in front of your home so that you can go to the grocery and buy food, yeah well sucks to be you doesn't it. What, you can't afford to use the street in front of your home to get to work to be able to pay for the use of that street, sucks to be you I guess.
Stop the insanity folks, and the insanity is on BOTH sides of the aisle.

I would imagine doctors refusing medicaid patients depends on which state you reside, In New York from what I have heard, they will always take those patients, I suppose their fees are guaranteed...
With Medicaid Expansion the guidelines were based on that of CMS, so if States are allowing inferior care, they would have to step up their care to match with CMS, I wonder, could that play a role in refusing the Expansion...
Slarti, regarding your point about things being "the same" and not worse - I would have to say that given the stale scenario we have had over the past few decades now, "same" actually indicates "worse". Things were meant to change for the better, but the fact that they didn't, is tantamount to them getting worse. Sometimes, worse is just another word for "bad" when it remains bad for a long time.
I have to say this regarding the ACA, I have a family member who had no health insurance but had a preexisting condition, had no hope of getting surgery until ACA, was able to purchase own policy and got the surgery needed, in that person's case, the ACA was a God Send...so it depends on who you talk to...
Slarti
Isn't part of the point, hat as part of the PPACA implementation and the Medicaid expansion proposal that doctors would be paid the Medicare rather than Medicaid rates for the first two years and that temporary provision is now expiring - leading to doctors being less likely to take on new Medicaid patients?
Just wondering
You are missing the point
People are covered by Medicaid and doctors can choose to accept Medicaid patients or not accept Medicaid patients or to stop accepting Medicaid patients (with notice to patients).
SO patients who are or will become eligible for Medicaid will have fewer doctors to choose from because the reimbursement rates have dropped and doctors are deciding to not treat Medicaid patients..
Calm down and think a minute.
If a doctor decides to stop seeing Medicaid patients, even those that already have the coverage will have to find another doctor.
New people become eligible for Medicaid (even without the expansion) every day and those people will have a harder time finding a doctor.
You are belaboring one point (a good one), that people without coverage who now cannot get Medicaid are no worse off, but that is not the only aspect/link between the PPACA and Medicaid.
Thanks for the feedback
ACA may just keep the status quo from a medical service standpoint, making it neither worse nor better.
Accepting your assumption, which I for one don't, what does it actually do then?
Transfer wealth.
If it doesn't change medical delivery, it's just pushing money around.
And we all know who benefits from that, politicians and corporations. sadly it is only they who benefit, everyone else got the shaft despite liberal mantra's to the opposite.
The point, I was making, is that the Medicare reimbursement rates are higher than the Medicaid reimbursement rates and as part of the rollout of the PPACA the Medicaid rates were temporarily the same as the Medicare rate which made finding the doctors much easier for new and existing Medicaid patients.
The temporary increase in rates to make it look like things were better than they really were is the point I was making and that is PPACA related.
Or, doctors decided to ride the train until fare being paid was lowered and now are getting off.
But yes that is the point and the reason that the number of doctors accepting Medicaid from existing and new Medicaid patients is declining.
Thanks for all the back and forth.