╌>

Republicans Declare War Against Social Security On First Day Of New Congress

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  cm  •  11 years ago  •  151 comments

Republicans Declare War Against Social Security On First Day Of New Congress

Republicans Declare War Against Social Security On First Day Of New Congress

Author : Stephen D Foster Jr January 7, 2015

Republicans started working immediately against the best interests of the American people by declaring war on Social Security on the very first day of the 114th Congress.

Soon after the GOP officially took full control of the legislative branch on Tuesday, Republicans approved a new rule that experts say will allow conservatives to use Social Security as a hostage in future budget battles.

According to Talking Points Memo :

The largely overlooked change puts a new restriction on the routine transfer of tax revenues between the traditional Social Security retirement trust fund and the Social Security disability program. The transfers, known as reallocation, had historically been routine

In short, Republicans are hoping to strangle the Social Security Disability Insurance program to death as part of a concerted effort to hurt Social Security while forcing Democrats to agree to cut benefits.

TPM reports that the rule:

would still allow for a reallocation from the retirement fund to shore up the disability fund but only if an accompanying proposal improves the overall financial health of the combined Social Security Trust Funds, per the rule, expected to be passed on Tuesday. While that language is vague, experts say it would likely mean any reallocation would have to be balanced by new revenues or benefit cuts.

Seeing as how Republicans loathe taxes, its unlikely they would agree to balance reallocations through revenues, which means they would slash benefits instead.

The current SSDI fund is estimated to dry up by 2016 if another reallocation of funds doesnt take place before then. But the Center for Budget and Policy Priorities says the fix would be easy. The Social Security retirement fund contains $672 billion. The SSDI program contains $140 billion. The CBPP pointed out that a transfer of funds from the former would keep both solvent through 2033. In other words, the new GOP rule is totally unnecessary unless they want to attack Social Security and use it as leverage to force Democrats to agree to all Republican demands.

As the CBPP further noted:

By barring the House from approving a clean reallocation in 2016, the rule will strengthen the hand of lawmakers who seek to attach harsh conditions (such as sharp cuts in eligibility or benefit amounts) to such a measure.

The hostile move against Social Security outraged Democrats, but no one blasted the GOP like Senator Elizabeth Warren did on her Facebook page .

Its ridiculous but not surprising that on the very first day of the new Congress, Republicans are manufacturing a Social Security crisis to threaten benefits for millions of disabled Americans including 233,260 in Massachusetts alone. We cant turn our backs on the promises weve made to our families, friends, and neighbors who need our help the most. House Republicans should stop playing political games to put Americas most vulnerable at risk.

Clearly, Republicans are hell bent on destroying the programs that have made America strong since the 1930s. Every single social program that helps prevent Americans from ending up in poverty is now threatened by the GOP. A simple transfer that has occurred many times in the past is all that is needed to fix the problem, or better yet, just pass a law applying the payroll tax to all income over $100,000. Then Social Security and SSDI would be infinitely solvent. But Republicans would rather hold the program hostage because even if Democrats refuse to give in to Republican demands the GOP would still win because SSDI would have no more funds left, thus depriving Americans who have disabilities of the funding they need for their own care. And you can bet that once Republicans kill this program, theyll set their sights on killing Social Security entirely.

http://www.addictinginfo.org/2015/01/07/republicans-declare-war-against-social-security-on-first-day-of-new-congress/


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
CM
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  CM    11 years ago

Think it can't happen to you??? Think again, the GOP will stop at nothing to destroy Social Security and all those who feel secured with their Social Security and VA Benefits, they will be gunning for you soon, Maybe the Illegal President from Kenya will try to save Y'all, why should he, if I were him, I would let those GOP Voters suffer the consequences of their Votes, everyone will suffer for having a Republican Congress...

 
 
 
Dean Moriarty
Professor Silent
link   Dean Moriarty    11 years ago

I've been strongly opposed to SS all my life same goes for my father before me and his father before him. It's a ponzi scam that steals from one and gives to another. I quit paying into that fiasco at the age of 32 and wish I'd done so earlier in my life.

 
 
 
deepwater don
Freshman Silent
link   deepwater don    11 years ago

There are some 50 million seniors and soon to seniors who receive Social Security. Do these asshole think they can buck us and take away or change our benefits? They better think again. Of course if you voted for these guys, then you must suffer(and agree with)the consequences of their actions. Or you could just send your Social Security or VA check back to John McCain,et.al. to send bombs to Iraqnam and Vietghanistan.

 
 
 
CM
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  CM    11 years ago

Those of us who have held Legal Jobs for the past 40, 50 or more years and paid into Social Security, expects to be paid when we retire, I don't expect the ones who have not contributed would give a damn..so, you don't have to care...I hope you are not looking to collect on SSI, the program that is given to those people who have not worked or contributed to social security, become disabled and then given SSI payments, As far as I am concerned, you didn't contribute, you should get nothing...

 
 
 
CM
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  CM    11 years ago

Do these asshole think they can buck us and take away or change our benefits?

Yes they do and they did..

Or you could just send your Social Security or VA check back to John McCain,et.al. to send bombs to Iraqnam and Vietghanistan.

I'M sure they will gladly cash the checks....These GOP Politicians are Thieves, Scam Artists, they don't give a damn..they are Millionaires and they could care less about "US" the "Stupid Americans" what other words would you describe Americans who votes for these people, knowing, from history, they have done "NOTHING" for working people, "NOTHING" but because their is a Black Man who is now President they would rather "THE THIEF" sorta reminds me of another person who was trying to help mankind and they would rather have the thief than that person saving their hinds...

 
 
 
CM
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  CM    11 years ago

Think about the Republican Mindset Folks, they have started destroying Social Security, they want to destroy Medicare, they Have voted to destroy Obamacare, they have cut funding to VA, they put $Billions into Weapons of War, just do the MATH...They are getting rid of the OLD and POOR and wants only the YOUNG and STRONG...If you cant see that, YOU ARE BLIND!!!!!!

 
 
 
deepwater don
Freshman Silent
link   deepwater don    11 years ago

Other than Dean, who I respect, but never agree with, where are the RWNJ who blindly vote Faux not-News(aka R), who support "their' elected representation? Awfully quiet. Must be running to SS,VA,to see if their money is still there.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    11 years ago

So protecting the Social Security Trust fund from being raided is somehow declaring war on it?

It's amazing the shit you fall for.

 
 
 
CM
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  CM    11 years ago

Its amazing the "SHIT", YOU!!! fall for, today it is the SSDI then it will be the Retirement Fund, if you think this stops here, Republicans are more gullible than I thought...this is just a test to see how far they can go, with voters like those putting these IDIOTS into office, they will be doing a lot more damage...

So protecting the Social Security Trust fund from being raided is somehow declaring war on it?

Protecting my "ASS" Bull Shit...they have declared war on the Elderly and Sick...Period!!!!

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    11 years ago

No Sean, it's a ruse Republicans don't have the political balls to raise taxes on the wealthy or extend the SS payroll tax on those making more than roughly $100,000/year. So the individual making, say, $10 million/year doesn't pay into the SS Trust Fund on his last $9,999,000 of income!

Is that fair?

In short, Republicans are hoping to strangle the Social Security Disability Insurance program to death as part of a concerted effort to hurt Social Security while forcing Democrats to agree to cut benefits.

The ultimate Republican fuckover of the working man is to privatize SS and funnel the contributions to Wall Street.

Wake TF up folks!

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    11 years ago

Answer me this, does protecting social security funds from being used to fund other welfare programs make it more or less likely that social security benefits will be cut in the future?

 
 
 
CM
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  CM    11 years ago

The ultimate Republican fuckover of the working man is to privatize SS and funnel the contributions to Wall Street.

That's It!!!! They have been talking about this since I worked in OIL/Gas Industry in Texas in the 1980's When GHW Bush(Daddy) was President, they were talking about that then, they are still talking about that now, that is their GOAL, then when the Market drops and they steal all our Money, we will be "FUCKED"...strong language, I know, but its true...

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika     11 years ago

Interesting Dean, there are few occupations that aren't required to pay into SS. RR workers, teachers etc. Are you in that category?

 
 
 
CM
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  CM    11 years ago

Answer me this, does protecting social security funds from being used to fund other welfare programs make it more or less likely that social security benefits will be cut in the future?

Ridiculous, Its not hard to fix, increase the maximum contribution from $118K to say $160K @ 6.20% and increase Medicare from $1.45 to maybe $2.00, the Actuaries working for the GOVT. knows what the increase needs to be, but the scumbags in the GOP refuses and therefore in their views, everyone should suffer because of their cowardice bunch of asses!!!

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    11 years ago

does protecting social security funds from being used to fund other welfare programs

Verify that please.

And BTW,

And before I answer any more questions, Sean, you will have o address my comment. Here's more.

Lifting the cap to remove the exemption from payroll tax on income over $110,100 wouldnt change the top marginal rate. It would change the taxpayer's effective rate.

Broaden the base an possible even lower the rate; that's the painless and most equitable solution.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    11 years ago

The initial influx would be a windfall for Wall Street then the cry will go out THE MARKET'S OVERBOUGHT then the plunge and the death of the SS benefit to many while the brokers get their cut regardless.

Republicans who advocate this are essentially thieves in bed with other thieves who own their asses.

Wake TF up!

Who are you people who buy the bullshit?

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    11 years ago

Teachers in fact pay into SS, Kavika.

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika     11 years ago

My mistake Mac. So the number of occupations that aren't required to pay into SS is even less than I thought.

 
 
 
CM
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  CM    11 years ago

Wake TF up!

Who are you people who buy the bullshit?

Well, those are haters of Obama and all they see is Black...

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    11 years ago

They worship at the feet of their patron panderer Rush Limbaugh! Remember his, "I hope he (Obama) fails" statement?

How fucking dumb does someone need to be to not understand if a President fails (particularly in establishing some degree of fairness and equity in the country), unless that someone is independently wealthy, THAT HE FAILS ALONG WITH THE PRESIDENT?

Blind, dumb, willing dupe fools.

The game is rigged by the rich and for the rich and the haters cheer them on.

FYI: The first reference to "the dumbing of America" was made thus

"The mind of this country, taught to aim at low objects, eats upon itself." Ralph Waldo Emerson offered that observation in 1837, but his words echo with painful prescience in today's very different United States. Americans are in serious intellectual trouble -- in danger of losing our hard-won cultural capital to a virulent mixture of anti-intellectualism, anti-rationalism and low expectations.

WAKE THE FUCK UP!

 
 
 
CM
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  CM    11 years ago

This 20% cut, doesn't only affect people getting a check it affects all disabled people, those in nursing homes or assisted living centers, care workers, it will have a devastating effect on everyone who are truly sick and cannot get any help..I guess the phrase "Just Die Already" is the GOP Motto..

 
 
 
CM
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  CM    11 years ago

Self Employed are required to pay FICA at 15.30% for social security and medicare...if that's the case, I hope they have their medical insurance and not going to the emergency rooms as (Romney) suggested, which sends my costs higher...

 
 
 
CM
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  CM    11 years ago

The program needs to be reformed. Ownership needs to be established. Establishing ownership will allow theaccumulatedwealth to bepassed on to the children o the deceased.

Have you ever heard of this program???

Social Security Survivors Benefits: Protection You and Your Family Can Count On

Most of us don't like to talk about death or even think about it. But wouldn't you feel better knowing that, if you or your spouse were no longer living, Social Security would help take care of your family?

If you are working and paying into Social Security, some of the taxes you pay go toward survivors insurance. In fact, if you currently have life insurance, the value of your private policy is probably less than the value of the survivors insurance you have under Social Security.

  • When you die , members of your family could be eligible for benefits based on your earnings. Planning For Your Survivors explains how you earn benefits and who qualifies for them.

  • If your spouse or parent dies , you and your family could be eligible for benefits based on their earnings. Read If You Are the Survivor to learn about the survivors benefits that may be available to you and your family.

Note : If you are married and both of you are wage earners, you should consider survivors benefits from both perspectives.

Anything in addition to Social Security, its time to get a Life Insurance Policy...

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    11 years ago

Its not hard to fix, increase the maximum contribution from $118K to say $160K @ 6.20% and increas

The point is that the bill passed by the House doesn't cut SS benefits and actually protects SS by keeping SS funds from being diverted to other programs. To turn that into some sort of attack on the SS retirement funding is disengenious to say the least.


If you want to finance other welfare programs, figure out a way to pay for them and make a proposal to do. Don't take from SS Retirement funding to do so.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    11 years ago

Republicans don't have the political balls to raise taxes on the wealthy or extend the SS payroll tax on those making more than roughly $100,000/year.


That has nothing to do with the House Bill to protect SSretirementfunds.

But did I miss where Democrats acted on that whenPresidentObama had veto proof control of Congress?Or was long term funding for SS not an issue a few years ago?

Blaming this on Republicans when it was in the Democrats complete power to act on the issue is typical whiny liberal blame deflection. You want the Republicans to do what your own party completelyfailed to do, even though this is an issue liberalssupposedlycare about.

 
 
 
CM
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  CM    11 years ago

That has nothing to do with the House Bill to protect SSretirementfunds.

But did I miss where Democrats acted on that whenPresidentObama had veto proof control of Congress?Or was long term funding for SS not an issue a few years ago?

Blaming this on Republicans when it was in the Democrats complete power to act on the issue is typical whiny liberal blame deflection. You want the Republicans to do what your own party completelyfailed to do, even though this is an issue liberalssupposedlycare about.

All of This, BS

7.65% is payroll deducted (FICA) Social Security 6.20% Medicare/Disability 1.45% ...

What Welfare Programs are you talking about??? Get the correct information then have a conversation, what you state are Lies....Social Security has Survivor benefits that is already been paid for by payroll deduction...prove you welfare argument, which you cannot..it does not exist...

 
 
 
Dean Moriarty
Professor Silent
link   Dean Moriarty    11 years ago

I quit paying myself a salary in 97 and my income comes from an llc that owns buildings and equipment that I lease to my defense and aerospace design and manufacturing business. I still have to pay payroll taxes but I avoid paying into SS personally.

 
 
 
Dean Moriarty
Professor Silent
link   Dean Moriarty    11 years ago

That's what happens when you allow the government to steal your earnings. They can do whatever they want and there is very little you can do about it.

 
 
 
CM
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  CM    11 years ago

MM, they have cut SSDI by 20% starting in 2016 e.g if you get $1000.00/month it will now be $800.00 if $2000.00 it will now be $1600.00, as per the article Democrats cannot do anything to change that...we could be looking at another demonstration of old and sick folks when the word get around..

 
 
 
CM
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  CM    11 years ago

Most of us have Legal Jobs, we are required to pay into Social Security and Federal Taxes, The Thief is that Republican Congressman from Texas that wrote that bill and the Republicans that voted to pass it..those are the thieves...

 
 
 
CM
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  CM    11 years ago

This is what Republicans voted for in November 2014...First, SS disability benefits, followed by survivor benefits, and finally the old-age pensions. Eradication of the safety net was a clear mandate by the voters,

The next step will be forced bankruptcies of all the municipalities so they can reorganize the unfunded retirement funds to pennies on the dollar. Move Social Security into the stock market so Wall Street can bleed the trust fund by 2%/year in transaction fees. Eliminate all taxes on the wealthy and make up the difference by selling the National Parks for drilling, mining, and landfills...

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   Bob Nelson    11 years ago

Why is this news?

Of course the Republicans have immediately begun their assault on the social safety net. That is why they were elected. That is their program. The social safety net cost tax money that could/should be going to their masters, the 0.1%.

This is NOT news! Anyone who has half a brain knew that they would do this.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    11 years ago

And by the way, SS IS NOT GOING BROKE; IT HAS A SURPLUS OF TRILLIONS!

But it won't if the Republicans give it Wall Street.

Wake TF up ill-informed haters!

Social Security isn't dying, but it's time to kill off the rumors of its demise. Let's take a look at the latest financial report from its Board of Trustees.

What's the report?

On July 28, the Social Security Board of Trustees released the 2014 Annual Report to Congress. It gives a 75-year projection of Social Security's finances, from Social Security actuaries.

Is Social Security going broke?

Far from it. The Trustees' Report presents these data:

  • Social Security has $2.76 trillion in trust fund reserves, similar to reserves held by banks or insurance companies.
  • Social Security reserves are still growing and will continue to grow through 2019.
  • Beginning in 2020, program costs are projected to exceed income, shrinking the trust funds.
  • The trust funds will be exhausted in 2033, the same as projected in the 2012 and 2013 reports.
  • After 2033, income will cover 77% of scheduled payments.

No way. There are plenty of articles showing that Social Security has lost money every year since 2010.

Read the fine print. Starting in 2010, Social Security expenses exceeded "noninterest" income primarily payroll taxes. But that ignores Social Security investment gains. Do you ignore gains on your investments? If you take all income into account, Social Security had a surplus of $32 billion on 2013 operations.

...

The game is rigged by the rich in favor of the rich.

It's frightening that those who want to bash Obama will run with the lies to "validate" their hatred of Obama and cut off their ignorant-fool noses.

Now watch; these facts will be ignored as if I hadn't posted them and the rhetorical question/lies will, rather than actually rebutting the facts, perpetuate more bullshit from the sell-out legislators and the haters who are suckered by them and big money.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    11 years ago

What are you talking about? No one is talking about privatizing SS and no one is disputing these facts.

In fact, that's why Republicans passed the bill they did, so SS will continue to remain solvent until 2034.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    11 years ago

Please,please show me where Republicans cut SSDI by in this bill. That is, if you want to have any credibility. If not I assume you would rather continue spewing nonsense that bears no relationship with reality. Seriously, put up or shut up.

I will explain it again. This bill simply keeps the SS retirement fund in a "lockbox" and ensures that the surplus won't be used to cover other welfare programs. That's it. Everything else is your fantasy.

Most sane people believe that protecting SS retirement funds is a good thing. Apparently you don't. Good luck getting supporton your campaign to raid the SS surplus.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    11 years ago

No Sean; what they are trying to take credit for is taken care of without their Republican bullshit legislation intended to cut benefits and tax recipients BUT CALL IT "KEEPING SS SOLVENT."

IT'S A LIE.

And if the Republicans have their way, you will be hearing about privatizing SS.

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man    11 years ago

Well what do you expect, this article the people that wrote it and most of the responses are typical democrat overblown hysterical rhetoric.

I've grown used to it.

Of course anything the republicans do when in control of the congress is going to be a war on the American people.

Every bit as much as the other side claiming that the democrats were destroying the fabric of the country when you guys were in control.

It was childish then, it's childish now.

That's the Democrat Mindset Folks, in a nutshell!!!

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man    11 years ago

It's brainless plain political articles like this that make this as bad a place to talk than any other.

Death and destruction from the other side.

When are we ever going to learn?

Never

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   Bob Nelson    11 years ago

Democrats built the social safety net, against constant Republican resistance. Republicans have taken every opportunity to reduce the safety net.

Of course Republicans will use their control of Congress to reduce the safety net. Anyone who imagines anything else is delusional.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    11 years ago

2 conflicting comments in this article :

1]

Republicans started working immediately against the best interests of the American people by declaring war on Social Security on the very first day of the 114th Congress.

2]

In short, Republicans are hoping to strangle the Social Security Disability Insurance program to death as part of a concerted effort to hurt Social Security while forcing Democrats to agree to cut benefits.

The 1st one was a broad brush accusation that the Repubs are working against the "best interests of the American people" . But actually they are defending the social security program against massive fraud by malingerers , stealing the funds that should be paying for retirement .

I'm going to remember the site addictinginfo.org . Lies are indeed addictive ...

 
 
 
CM
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  CM    11 years ago

Please,please show me where Republicans cut SSDI by in this bill. That is, if you want to have any credibility. If not I assume you would rather continue spewing nonsense that bears no relationship with reality. Seriously, put up or shut up.

Is this all you were told to say regarding the SSDI cut by a Republican Congressman from Texas, is that all you were told to say, where is your proof that 20% SSDI will not be cut, YOU!!!!! put up your proof or Shut Up!!!!!! By the way, if you have not yet reached the age of 50's soon the body starts to break down, a person starts feeling all sorts of aches and pain, visiting the doctors office more frequently, that's the beginning when people start realizing they cannot continue and apply for disability, the population is getting older, the baby boomers are getting older...so, if a person is lucky they may be able to live to their 80's and not have to see doctors or even need Medicare, don't think that will happen...

First on the list: Cut the disabled people

On the first day of the new Congress, a Texas Republican is leading an effort to make deep cuts in Social Security Disability Insurance (SSDI) to take effect within about a year. Democrats appear to have little recourse due to the recent election results. Fraud in SSDI is not a major problem despite Republican claims and mythmaking by NPR and 60 Minutes . The inspector general found only about 0.4 percent of cases were approved by fraudulent judges.

More and more people are on disability. This reflects an aging and sick population, not fraudulent activity. Demographics explains most of the increase. See Just The Facts on Disability .

Republicans fought against SSDI throughout the 50s its passage was a dramatic story that few know or remember today. The current "crisis" is a manufactured one , part of the long-view Republican strategy to eliminate SSDI and a broader attack on Social Security. In 1983, a Republican effort moved funds that had been allocated for the disabled into the Social Security Retirement program, artificially creating an imbalance that is coming due today.

The New Republican Attack on Social Security Starts Now .

Why Defending Social Security Needs to Be Next on Obamas To-Do List

[People in power] use the word reform when they mean privatize, and they use strengthen when they really mean dismantle. They tell us theres a crisis to get us all riled up so well sit down and listen to their plan to privatize Democrats are absolutely united in the need to strengthen Social Security and make it solvent for future generations. We know that, and we want that. (Senator Barack Obama, 2005)

This makes me sad. My mother was on SSDI. There was no way she could work, she could barely stand up for more then a few minutes at a time.. and even then she couldn't really stand straight. I can't tell you the number of times she fell because she thought she could walk farther then her back would let her. Without her SSDI, we would have been homeless.

On the first day of the new Congress, republican lawmakers review the budget and ask, "are there no workhouses, no prisons?" announce bold new "Reduce the surplus population" plan.

Straight Talk on Social Security :

"Heres what Social Security is not:
going broke;
a Ponzi scheme;
expected to stop paying out benefits in your lifetime;
bankrupting our nation or future generations."

 
 
 
CM
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  CM    11 years ago

It's brainless plain political articles like this that make this as bad a place to talk than any other.

Death and destruction from the other side.

When are we ever going to learn?

Never

ANOTHER DUMB AND BLIND!!!!!!!

 
 
 
CM
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  CM    11 years ago

The 1st one was a broad brush accusation that the Repubs are working against the "best interests of the American people" . But actually they are defending the social security program against massive fraud by malingerers , stealing the funds that should be paying for retire

BS!!!!

You can continue believing the Republican Lies, you have no choice you were convinced, now, you are about to see who they really are and it will affect all of us....

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man    11 years ago

Nowhere near as dumb and blind as you!!!!!!!

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    11 years ago
For the final time, this bill does not cut SSDI! Anyone who claims it does is lying.

If I'm wrong it should be very easy to demonstrate it. Please point out the statutory language authorizing any cuts to SSDI. Hell, even cite a mainstream news source claiming that this bill mandates cuts to SSDI.

Whack job liberal sites that offer unsupported( and unsupportable )conclusions are useless for any purpose other than scaring the ignorant. Conspiracy theories and deliberately vague warnings about republican intent prove nothing to anyone who actually cares about the issue at hand.
 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    11 years ago

For the final time, this bill does not cut SSDI! Anyone who claims it does is lying.

Really?

Republican Congress Launches With Back-Door Attack On Social Securi...

POSTED ONJANUARY 7, 2015 AT 12:39 PM

Republicans are starting the new Congress by attacking Social Security funding t hrough a subtle, obscure policy measure buried in the gigantic bill that establishes parliamentary rules for the new session.

The rules measure, passed late Tuesday after other day-one business like formal swearing-in ceremonies for members were completed, escalates the threat of a significant cut to Social Security Disability Insurance (SSDI) within the next two years. The measure bans a common accounting technique that the people who manage Social Security funding have used many times in the past to prevent benefit cuts. The two funds that comprise the Social Security system have essentially borrowed from one another as necessary over the years to ensure that benefits can be paid in full each year. SSDI, which is the primary program for providing federal benefits to people unable to work due to disability, is projected to hit a shortfall in late 2016. Reallocating revenue from the much larger Social Security retirement benefits fund to SSDI would cover the shortfall, and trust fund managers have performed such reallocations 11 times since the late 1950s.

But the Republican rules package prohibits Congress from authorizing such a transfer. That will force a showdown over how to finance disability benefits sometime in the next two years, with the threat of a nearly 20 percent cut to SSDI payments looming over the debate. The measure was overshadowed in the news by a separate rules package measure that threatens to rig the legislative process in favor of trickle-down tax policy , until the beginning of this week when critics began to decry the change.

The Center on Budget and Policy Priorities called the rule an attempt to pit retirement and disability beneficiaries against each other that misrepresents how the two funds operate, and pointed out that the only reason SSDI is in funding trouble next year is that it got short-changed by the past two reallocations of funding between disability and retirement benefits. Sen. Elizabeth Warren (D-MA) accused the GOP of inventing a Social Security crisis that will threaten benefits for millions & put our most vulnerable at risk. Sen. Sherrod Brown (D-OH) called it a dangerous new rule that will set the stage to cut benefits for seniors and disabled Americans, and pointed out that reallocating funds between the accounts is so uncontroversial that President Reagan oversaw four of the 11 times it has been done in the past.

Rep. Tom Reed (R-NY), who is taking credit for engineering the rules change, has received significant campaign financing from at least one well-heeled conservative supporter of cutting Social Security. Reed has gotten over $134,000 in contributions from people tied to vulture capitalist Paul Singers firm Elliott Management, according to the Center for Responsive Politics. Singer is most famous for his battle to force the nation of Argentina to prioritize debt payments to Elliott Management over public expenditures for its 41 million citizens. But the generous Republican donor is also a sharp critic of American government spending and has called for cutting benefits in Social Security, Medicare, and Medicaid.

Reed told the Associated Press that his rules proposal is intended to force a reckoning over social insurance spending. We need real reform, he said, and this makes that real reform that much more likely. Leaving aside the question of what Reed means by real reform, and the fact that the proposed reallocation would have extended disability funding by 17 years while reducing retirement f... , the move is raising serious procedural concerns among retiree advocates.

Social Security experts Nancy Altman and Eric Kingson labeled the move hostage-taking to force changes that the American people do not want to a vital program in a piece for the Huffington Post. Reeds rule means that we could be facing a deadline, and certainly over the last couple of years ,weve seen Congress seemingly unable to pass bills, even with deadlines in front of them, the American Association of Retired Persons David Certner told the AP.

The other political ingredient in the debate Reed and the GOP are trying to force is years of skewed media coverage of the disability insurance system. Reports that SSDI is riddled with fraud and overrun with false claims have showed up in an ideologically diverse array of news sources over the past two years, from public radios This American Life to CBS 60 Minutes to the conservative media machine . The reality is that just 41 percent of those who apply for disability benefits receive it thanks to the programs uniquely strict eligibility rules and stringent, multi-layered application process. Among those who do clear the programs hurdles and enroll, fraud is extremely rare. A 2011 Government Accountability Office report found an erroneous payments rate of just 0.6 percent , among the lowest of any government program, and President Bushs Social Security Administrator estimates waste, fraud, and abuse account for less than 1 percent of SSDI spending. But the reality of the program such as the fact that disability insurance is getting more expensive because of long-anticipated demographic shifts has likely already been lost in the trans-partisan furor over a supposed epidemic of freeloading.

...

 
 
 
CM
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  CM    11 years ago

For the final time, this bill does not cut SSDI! Anyone who claims it does is lying.

Gosh!!!! You are uninformed...they have you bound...you can't even recognize

reality...

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    11 years ago

Well, those are haters of Obama and all they see is Black...

http://www.politifake.org/image/political/1101/you-just-might-be-a-liberal-the-race-card-don-t-leave-home-w-political-poster-1293921693.jpg

http://www.kevinpezzi.com/blog/images/shout_racist.gif

http://georgiaconservative.net/wp-content/uploads/2012/12/ExpressRaceCard.jpg

Feel free to use these anytime you want.

 
 
 
LynneA
Freshman Silent
link   LynneA    11 years ago

Perhaps this will help articulate why the 2015 procedural rules change implemented by the House is either 1. true cause for concern or 2. time toyawn. Ultimately, we'll know in 2016 as the SSDI fund will require additional dollars to maintain the current level of payments.

IMO, the GOP would rather cut dollars out of the program(s) than remove the wage cap. The 2016 timing will befascinatingas the GOP may have to weigh the "entitlement" versus the "vote"!

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    11 years ago

What Welfare Programs are you talking about??? Get the correct information then have a conversation, what you state are Lies....Social Security has Survivor benefits that is already been paid for by payroll deduction...prove you welfare argument, which you cannot..it does not exist...

Sean was actually talking about the long term funding of Social Security, not the benefits you are referring to CM. As you will see Social Security is in real jeopardy and your solution could have a place in my opinion, but not the total solution.

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    11 years ago

For the final time, this bill does not cut SSDI! Anyone who claims it does is lying.

Sean, you're not going to get your answer I'm sorry to say. I mean MM put up how stupid you were in so many words. CM put up how you can't see reality and A Mac put up an article from "Think Progress". Two no sources and one far left source, but no credible source to provide facts, only outrage provided by "Addicting Info" another far left site. In fact as John would say, all the sites that are putting this information out are not credible sources. This has nothing to do with anyone on this site and only offers additional methods to supplement Social Security benefits, which neither of my parents lived long enough to receive one cent. What happened to my inheritance? Badfish has the right idea and some of the ideas here are worthy in my opinion to take a look at as well, but if it was fossil fuel they would be reminding us it is a limited source for energy and we need to look into other alternatives.

No different than when Hillary Clinton stood on the Senate floor and condemned George Bush for taking too much power from the other branches of the government, but when Obama changes Obamacare completely on his own numerous times, gives amnesty to millions on his own, has his czars and organizations enforce new rules without the influence of the other branches it's OK.

 
 
 
CM
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  CM    11 years ago

Sean was actually talking about the long term funding of Social Security not the benefits you are referring to CM. As you will see Social Security is in real jeopardy and your solution could have a place in my opinion, but not the total solution.

Social Security is not in trouble Six, if you listen to Right Wing talkers, you'll be convinced it is, its all Lies!!!

As a result of changes to Social Security enacted in 1983, benefits are now expected to be payable in full on a timely basis until 2037, when the trust fund reserves are projected to become exhausted. 1 At the point where the reserves are used up, continuing taxes are expected to be enough to pay 76percent of scheduled benefits. Thus, the Congress will need to make changes to the scheduled benefits and revenue sources for the program in the future. The Social Security Board of Trustees project that changes equivalent to an immediate reduction in benefits of about 13percent, or an immediate increase in the combined payroll tax rate from 12.4percent to 14.4percent, or some combination of these changes, would be sufficient to allow full payment of the scheduled benefits for the next 75years.

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    11 years ago

The social safety net cost tax money that could/should be going to their masters, the 0.1%.

Sorry Bob, but the 0.1% are doing better than they ever have since Obama became president with complete control of all three branches for nearly 2 years and the the Republicans have not been able to get a single policy passed in the last 6 years.

During the meantime the workforce is now at 1970 level, 50 million on food stamps and I swear I see everyone of them at grocery stores and convenience stores every day. We need an environment that promotes jobs, education isn't worth a hoot without a job on graduation day. The National Debt is about $18 trillion now and is almost impossible to pay off based on our GDP and lack of tax payers.

And of course the answer is to give everyone a raise, import long term expenses of supporting children and their families by the thousands if not millions. And then give everyone a free education.

Cloward and Piven tried this a number of years ago in NYC and the number of people on the entitlement number increase to a point where 1 out of every 3 people there were receiving benefits. It almost bankrupted NYC and would have had Gerald Ford not saved them.

 
 
 
CM
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  CM    11 years ago

That is NOT what social security is, sorry.

Maybe its time for you to learn about social security, your 8 word sentence is not information...

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    11 years ago

A Mac, have you noticed how well Wall Street has been doing for a few years now. It wasn't the Republicans doing, I assure you, although I don't care for them either. We're not down to the bone as Nancy Pelosi said. We have many things we could eliminate, but Obama's solutions have not brought anything down, only increase the cost of them.

 
 
 
CM
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  CM    11 years ago

I know why self employed pays 15.30%, did I not state that???

 
 
 
LynneA
Freshman Silent
link   LynneA    11 years ago

OK, I get you're not a fan ofthe President but that has what to do with the posted article or link I posted?

 
 
 
CM
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  CM    11 years ago

You didn't pay enough into it to cover the massive expansion of the program. That is the fundamental problem with both the SSDI and Medicare. Contributions aren't high enough to cover the costs. Of course they are popular programs, people have been getting something that they didn't pay the true cost of.

Workers pay what is required, what needs to be lifted is the cap at $118K, lifting that cap will bring more funds into the system...

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    11 years ago

Slartibartfast. Exactly.

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    11 years ago

ANOTHER DUMB AND BLIND!!!!!!!

I really don't think that is the case. You have a bunch of Liberal sites jumping on this without any actual facts.

It's time to lead from the front and prepare for the future and stop leading from behind and waiting until the problems can not be solved. By then all these politicians will be long gone. remember Barney Franks? Isn't he the one who said he didn't see anything wrong with the housing market? Well....... never hear from him anymore, probably running a private escort service now and pays no taxes because he gets a big check every month for destroying the housing market.

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    11 years ago

I'm not too sure if Slartibartfast is not a fan of the President, after all we disagree most of the time and I'm definitely not a fan of Obama, but it is because of his home and foreign policies.

I mean when you let ISIL have free travel across the desert and get set up in the Iraqi towns before deciding to do anything at all you have to wonder whose side he is on. I belief in the ole "Nip it in the bud", not let it get a really good foothold before doing little to nothing.

You know Iran is Iraq's biggest military supporter. Where do you think that will lead?

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    11 years ago

http://mercatus.org/sites/default/files/SS%20Deficitsmaller_0.JPG

http://stmaryvalleybloom.org/socialsecurity2034.jpg

http://disruptivethinkers.org/wp-content/uploads/Social-Security-Deficit.jpg

I don't think we should wait until the disaster hits us in the face before we start to secure the future of Social Security and Disability Income (which is already starring us in the face). I think if the parties work together which hasn't been the case lately maybe we can make some headway. I really think we have a problem here, but we really have some other problems that are far worse in my opinion if things don't change in our world.

 
 
 
CM
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  CM    11 years ago

Six...I am certainly not going to put anything from Fox News or any right wing news, I do not believe their LIES...I put up what I have evidence of, buried in the bill on the first day of this new congress was the 20% cut to SSDI from Congressman (R) Johnson of Texas, what else do you need to know???

On Day One, the new Congress launches an attack on Social Security

Well, that didn't take long.

As one of its first orders of business upon convening Tuesday, the Republican House of Representatives approved a rule that will seriously undermine efforts to keep all of Social Security solvent.

The rule hampers an otherwise routine reallocation of Social Security payroll tax income from the old-age program to the disability program. Such a reallocation, in either direction, has taken place 11 times since 1968 , according to Kathy Ruffing of the Center on Budget and Policy Priorities.

But it's especially urgent now, because the disability program's trust fund is expected to run dry as early as next year. At that point, disability benefits for 11 million beneficiaries would have to be cut 20%. Reallocating the income, however, would keep both the old-age and disability programs solvent until at least 2033, giving Congress plenty of time to assess the programs' needs and work out a long-term fix.

The procedural rule enacted by the House Republican caucus prohibits the reallocation unless it's accompanied by "benefit cuts or tax increases that improve the solvency of the combined trust funds," as paraphrased by the National Committee to Preserve Social Security and Medicare.

In practical terms, the advocacy committee says, that makes the reallocation impossible; it mandates either benefit cuts across the board, which aren't politically palatable, or a payroll tax increase, which isn't palatable to the GOP.

The rule change reflects the burgeoning demonization of disability recipients, a trend we've reported on in the past . it's been fomented by conservative Republicans and abetted by sloppy reporting by institutions such as NPR and "60 Minutes."

Disability recipients are easily caricatured as malingering layabouts by politicians, academics and journalists too lazy to do their homework. They'll say disability benefits are easy to obtain, so lavish they discourage work, and convenient substitutes for welfare payments. None of that is true.

As I reported in 2013, Social Security's disability standards are stringent. To be eligible you must have worked at least one-fourth of your adult life (typically from age 22 on), and been employed in at least five of the previous 10 years. Children qualify under Supplemental Security Income, and workers younger than 31 have to show employment in half the years since they turned 22.

 
 
 
CM
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  CM    11 years ago

This has nothing to do with anyone on this site and only offers additional methods to supplement Social Security benefits, which neither of my parents lived long enough to receive one cent.

If you were a minor, you would have gotten benefits...

 
 
 
CM
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  CM    11 years ago

What Revolution??? FICA has been 7.65% from the 1990's its time to increase the contribution and lift the cap...

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    11 years ago

I'm not a fan of either party. I consider the two basically the same. They say the best job to have is a government contract, like taking money from a baby. I hope you are providing something worthwhile because too many aren't. The government is like a giant Santa Claus to many.

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    11 years ago

I think it is more a cluster fuck SSDI program myself. But many have chosen to travel that road since finding a good job has become more difficult and practically anyone can get on disability if they have the right support and a little problem that can be exaggerated somewhat. This is just my opinion.

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    11 years ago

Your chart is pointless. By that date the baby boomers will mostly be gone, so a better picture of how to continue SS will exist.

Let's hope so. Actually they aren't my charts. They are charts by the Social Security Administration and the Congressional Budget Office which are continually changing as we know anyway. They are only projections and like the ACA the CBO was saying a year ago they didn't know what effect it would have and now I guess they've decided to project something, although it keeps changing as well.

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    11 years ago

You are talking about the Social Security Disability Insurance, correct? Aren't they both administered by the Social Security Administration?

 
 
 
LynneA
Freshman Silent
link   LynneA    11 years ago

Six,

My purpose in the link was to address the banter about the 20% cut in an attempt to keep the thread on topic. Was hoping people would read the verbiage before the charts to gain an understanding of the rules change.

I attempt to viewissues as a learning experience and tire of the Republican/Democrat sandbox play that drives much of the "talk" here. Both parties are cut from the same cloth....weft and warp Grin.gif

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    11 years ago

A Mac put up an article from "Think Progress".

With SPECIFICS THAT DEBUNK SEAN'S CLAIM.

I don't do pronouncements UNLESS I POST THE FACTS THAT SUPPORT THEM. And unlike the those who post from sources I regularly challenge, I tell exactly why I challenge them AND DO SO IN CONJUNCTION WITH SPECIFIC REBUTTAL INFORMATION.

You cite the fact that I posted information but FAILED TO ADDRESS THE CONTENT OF THE INFORMATION. The article I posted gave names, numbers, DETAILS it's not credible for you to accuse my comment of not being credible when you don't rebut or address one word of it.

But here's your chance pick apart the information I posted not by declaring in advance and summarily, that anything disparaging your (Sean's) opinion is a lie, rather BY SHOWING WITH COUNTER-INFORMATION THAT IT IS A LIE.

If you can't do it, you need to either acknowledge the veracity of the information or back off.

Go for it.

 
 
 
CM
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  CM    11 years ago

I have for many years really surprised at how little was been deducted for FICA, especially the 1.45%, I have always thought there should be a greater contribution to Social Security, Medicare and Disability, If citizens are made aware of the costs involved in getting older, the medical and other living expenses, i don't think there would be much objection, when we have jobs and going about our daily lives, we don't think about it much, but as soon as illnesses sets in and more and more people has to stop working before reaching retirement age, we understand the necessity of having a strong retirement and disability in place..

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    11 years ago

in the face of what many consider a more severe crisis that led to the Great Depression, basically sit on its perverbial arse and do dick shit all, because THAT is what has led to this.

Got any specifics on the economic recovery to back that up? Is there anything Republicans did to slow the recovery (which took place in spite of their killing jobs bills and failing to bolster consumerism by increasing the minimum wage -- which BTW is 70% of the American economy)?

I hate f'n pronouncements that have no accompanying specifics to back them.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    11 years ago

When those accuse others of PLAYING the race card when they LIVE it, I must cry "foul."

 
 
 
CM
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  CM    11 years ago

The charts DELIBERATELY do not reflect the part of the law that indicates that the Social Security Administration cannot pay out one cent that isn't allocated to it.

I understand and agree with your statement...

Social Security Disability, that's a different matter. It's going to run out of funds in a year or two, and ultimately, because the nature of the program has changed so much since it was created (it's been expanded significantly), it probably should be merged with a large number of other programs that currently exist, and run out of the general fund, not through a social security trust.

I don't think I agree with SSDI been merged with other funds and be run out of the general funds, that would be commingling funds, I don't agree, I think it should be run out of the Social Security Funds but there needs to be greater contribution, that 1.45% is too small there isn't enough been contributed...

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    11 years ago

That has nothing to do with the House Bill to protect SSretirementfunds.

It is a way around raising taxes by expanding the base that pays into SS so that those making more than $104 thousand/year as in MILLIONS get to avoid paying on, say their last $9-plus millions of earnings!

By expanding that base, the rate could be lowered!

But that would make rich people get pissed off.

Again I say, Wake TF up.

Cutting benefits on people who are poor and/or disabled to ALLEGEDLY FUND SS WHICH HAS A MULTI-TRILLION DOLLAR SURPLUS IS A CRIME BEING PERPETRATED BY THE CRIMINAL RICH AND THEIR BOUGHT LEGISLATORS.

I challenge anyone to viably show my specifics are not correct.

No f'n pronouncements just show where I erred or back off.

 
 
 
CM
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  CM    11 years ago

Medicare is another really big issue that is probably going to hit in 8 to 10 years or so, (so many people like to criticize Ryan's voucher plan, but the reality is, his timelines for that plan are after the HI Trust is depleted, so changes are going to have to be made anyways).

Uhh!!!! Medicare, you know, if the ACA (Obamacare) is done correctly, we probably could have Medicare and Obamacare and be on the right track with both, too much politics going on, in and out of D.C..

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    11 years ago

That is NOT what social security is, sorry.

Rather than tell us what it's not, how 'bout you tell us what it is.

The program's sustainability depends upon the payout rates and Social Security tax rates, the number of workers supporting each retiree, the rate of productivity growth among the remaining workers and the mechanics of how the excess contributions to the Trust Fund are handled (e.g. a "lock box" and for what sort of asset). In order to support the same living standard as before, as the ratio of retirees to workers temporarily increases due to the retirement of the Baby Boomers, the productivity among the working population must increase and/or Social Security Trust fund savings must be used. Productivity has consistently increased, but it is unclear if the rate of increase will be adequate going forward. This productivity growth, and/or consumption of savings, is required because there are fewer workers available to produce the same amount of goods and services. If productivity does not rise fast enough to offset the loss of productive workers, and if accumulated savings in the trust fund are not adequate to fill this gap, then per-capita benefits would decline.

That is why it makes sense to expand the base and require contributions be made on all earnings while lowering the rate for all paying into SS.

All that would require would be for legislators with the balls to require the wealthy to pay on all income.

Oooops!

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    11 years ago

Lift the cap without lifting the benefits, and you make social security unconstitutional. Lift the cap, and lift the benefits, and you just transfer the problem from one side of the ledger to the other.

Lifting the ceiling -- EXPANDING THE BASE AND REQUIRING THAT ALL WHO PAY IN AND DO SO ON ALL INCOME WHILE lowering the rate, makes it unnecessary to change the benefits and keeps the fund solvent forever.

Why are the rich able to rig the game? oh, yeah because they can afford their own personal legislators and write the laws for them to push through on their behalf.

WTF was I thinking?

 
 
 
CM
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  CM    11 years ago

The main issue that I have with funding SSD through SS is that not everyone is ever going to need it. Almost everyone is going to receive Social Security, and almost everyone is eventually going to receive Medicare. SSD is very different in that respect. It really is a social program, and not a service funding program. (SS is essentially forced retirement savings, medicare similar except with health care).

Understand and agree with your assessment...

Couple that with the expansion of the SSD program itself to cover matters not part of the original program (SSD was only ever intended to cover a person as a bridge between a workplace injury and retirement age, situations like what MM is in was never in its intended mandate). That expansion of function has created a costing problem that is almost impossible to receive proper funding for, and one that isn't, everyone pays into, and everyone receives relative to.

Ok, Agree...

THAT is why it it should be merged with a whole bunch of other programs, each with their own administration overhead, and rolled into the General Fund, which by the way is where Medicaid is funded from.

This is where I have a problem, I can see each program having its own administrator, I just don't have the confidence, I would want to be sure that when A client or recipient of SSD reaches retirement age, they will continue to receive their benefits, I know it can be done, actually, its fairly easy to be done, I sure hope the people running these programs has the competence...But I get your point... Here's the thing, leave the SSDI under the umbrella of the SSA, but replenish the SSD portion from the general funds, as needed...

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    11 years ago

not sure how that helps. You lower the FICA rate, ok, but then you increase the cap, ok, but you also have to increase the cap on benefits (which is the very specific piece that you seem to have ignored, how convenient of you).

No you don't; the benefits can stay level while the billions and billions not currently taxed, even at a lower than current rate, keeps the fund solvent. The uber-wealthy won't miss the money and the middle class will pay in at a lower rate.

BY THE WAY; SINCE "CORPORATIONS ARE PEOPLE, MY FRIENDS," make them pay into SS based on their yearly profits!

Whaddya' say Mitt?

And yet again, this completely ignores the very basic point of this entire discussion article. It isn't about Social Security Insurance, it's about Social Security DISABILITY insurance.

The handwriting on the wall is clear the next attempt will be to throw Wall Street a windfall by privatizing SS.

 
 
 
CM
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  CM    11 years ago

Now of course, that would require that Congress be serious about the issue, and quite frankly, NEITHER party is really all that serious about it. If they were, we wouldn't be talking about this because the SSD problem would have been dealt with more than a decade ago.

This is where my lack of confidence comes in, thanks for the discussion Startibartfast, it was very good..thanks...

 
 
 
CM
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  CM    11 years ago

I think that publicity of cuts for the disabled would force Congress to act. This is not something then can just side through quietly. There are far too many disability agencies and organizations who will raise holy hell about it the closer it gets. It won't happen. I haven't the slightest doubt in the world that my disability benefits will not be cut and that this time in 2017I'll be getting the same plus a cost of living increase next January and January 2017.

MM, We will all get the word out so that congress will act and not cut the program...I bet you are right, it will not be cut...

 
 
 
CM
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  CM    11 years ago

Republicans have made dismantling our Social Security system their top priority now that they have control of Congress. Their first act was to change the rules of the House of Representatives to create a phony crisis in the next few years, in a clumsy attempt to divide the American people.

Rep. Tom Price (R-GA), who now sits in Paul Ryans old Budget Committee chair, is going even further about his plans for Social Security. When speaking at a conservative conference earlier this week, Price said:

Whether its means testing, whether its increasing the age of eligibility . whether its providing much greater choices for individuals to voluntarily select the kind of manner in which they believe they ought to be able to invest their working dollars as they go through their lifetime. All those things ought to be on the table and discussed."


Raising the retirement age? Cutting middle class benefits and gambling them on Wall Street? Thats unacceptable. We cant let Chairman Price and his Republican colleagues turn retirement into a luxury for the super-rich.

Tom Price wants to be to Social Security what Paul Ryan was to Medicare: The phony savior who tries to sell it for scraps.

We knew 2015 was going to be a fight. Stand with us today as we fight to turn the tables on House Republicans.

Thank you for standing united in fighting to protect and expand Social Security.

Michael Phelan
Social Security Works

 
 
 
Dean Moriarty
Professor Silent
link   Dean Moriarty    11 years ago

They make spam filters that can send that crap directly to your trash bin.

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   Bob Nelson    11 years ago

I really, really do not understand how there can be any debate here. The Republican Party has clearly tried to undo Social Security at every opportunity. Eliminating the social safety net is coded into Republican DNA.

Of course they will try to dismantle SS, now that they control Congress.

That's what America wants, judging from electoral results...

 
 
 
CM
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  CM    11 years ago

It doesn't matter what you have to say DM, you are not a contributor per your own admission, SO, You don't have an argument in this fight...

 
 
 
CM
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  CM    11 years ago

That's what America wants, judging from electoral results...

Based on misinformation, you would think that's what Americans want, the misinformation from the right wingers, we will hear from American Voters after they notice the first cuts in their checks, then we can make judgements...

 
 
 
Dean Moriarty
Professor Silent
link   Dean Moriarty    11 years ago

I know my family has been opposed to SS since its inception and I know I'm not alone.

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   Bob Nelson    11 years ago

If you mean that American voters didn't know that Republicans intend -- always , ever since FDR -- to dismantle the social safety net... then I agree!

Which goes to show how foolish that electorate is...

102.gif 102.gif 102.gif

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   Bob Nelson    11 years ago

Gee! Hooda thunk it??

 
 
 
CM
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  CM    11 years ago

I know my family has been opposed to SS since its inception and I know I'm not alone.

Maybe, you've been breaking the Laws for three generations, do ya think????

 
 
 
CM
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  CM    11 years ago

Yep!!!! they Listen to Limbaugh and all the other Liars not to leave out Fox News, in other words, most are not intelligent enough to hear both sides of an argument and make an informed decision, they do as they are told based on who is better looking or not, I don't know the mindset...

 
 
 
Dean Moriarty
Professor Silent
link   Dean Moriarty    11 years ago

They've been opposed to it since the beginning and have paid even though they believe it is wrong and immoral. I quit contributing to it personally at the age of 32 and wished I'd found a way to do so sooner. I don't know how much the government stole from my parents or grandparents.

 
 
 
CM
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  CM    11 years ago

I mean if you own your own company or are self -employed and can afford to retire on the money you get from it, more power to you! Congratulations on your hard work at doing so!

MM, I have heard about persons who have been self employed some more that 40 years, did not contribute to FICA, that means they did not file taxes for several years, they reached the age of retirement, they are too sick and tired to works, did not have enough investments and needed Social Security, the same system they hated all their working lives, guess what, they are collecting based on a previous marriage of 10 years or more and had been divorced for more than 25years, the same system that person had said was no good, had to now rely on it, from what I have heard, people like those gets the minimum, but, they do get something as well as medicare...

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   Bob Nelson    11 years ago

I have heard about persons

Anti-government "principles" are really really powerful... until hunger and sickness strike...

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   Bob Nelson    11 years ago

It's wrong that the get anything.

I don't think so. It's wrong that they ever were allowed not to contribute. A system is "universal" or it isn't...

 
 
 
CM
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  CM    11 years ago

I agree with both of you MM and Bob Nelson, but its the law, so they receive those benefits and yes that $104.00 has to be paid..well, its something anyway...

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    11 years ago

The 114th Congress has begun with a Republican party that is emboldened and as determined to cripple Social Security as they have been since President George W. Bush's disastrous 2005 effort to privatize it.

Georgia Republican Rep. Tom Price has taken over the House Budget Committee from Rep. Paul Ryan, and has even bigger ambitions to destroy the program than his predecessor, now even talking about privatization, something Ryan would only extend to Medicare.

Price told the Heritage Action for America Conservative Policy Summit on Monday that he wants to "begin to normalize the discussion and debate about Social Security." By "normalize, he means cut it:

Price and his fellow Republicans in leadership have set the stage to begin this effort, and as usual did it with some hostage taking . This time the hostages are about 11 million people who receive Social Security disability benefits. That program is expected to hit a shortfall next year, and benefits will be automatically cut unless the program gets an influx of cash. This has happened in the past, in both the retirement and the disability programs. What has always happened in the pastwith no big controversyis that Congress has authorized the transfer of funds from one of the programs to the other. But last week the House passed a new rule that says Congress can't do that any more unless they also take some action to "fix" (read slash) the Social Security system.

Republicans are pretending that this move was a way to keep the undeserving disabled people from stealing older Americans benefits. They're trying to pit one group against another, in hopes that they'll scare enough seniors to get the support to push it through. But what they're really doing is setting up the retirement system for the kinds of "reforms"including privatizationPrice laid out.

Those who will begin by questioning the credibility of the source, go right ahead; BUT DO IT THE WAY I DO, THAT IS, BY PROVIDING INFORMATION THAT SPECIFICALLY REBUTS THE CONTENT WITH WHAT YOU DEEM TO BE THE FACTS.

 
 
 
CM
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  CM    11 years ago

The Coordinated Attack On Social Security:

In their first two weeks controlling Congress, Republicans on Capitol Hill have launched a sustained, coordinated attack on Social Security. They are trying to divide us by pitting disabled workers against retirees through rules changes and alarming rhetoric. We have fought back and made this a national story...

Sen. Rand Paul piled onto the attack from Rep. Tom Price, the new House Budget Committee Chairman, who called for cuts through an increase in the retirement age and privatization. And this comes straight after the House GOP caucus changed the rules of the House of Representatives to force a phony Social Security crisis.

This week, while stumping in New Hampshire, Sen. Rand Paul (R-KY) flippantly attacked Americans living with disabilities in an attempt to appeal to the extreme right-wing:

You know, over half the people on disability are either anxious or their back hurts. Join the club.

Social Security Works Executive Director, Alex Lawson fired back immediately:

Contrary to Sen. Pauls claims, America has one of the strictest disability standards in the developed world. One in five men and nearly one in six women die within five years of being approved for benefits. Sen. Paul should be ashamed of himself for attacking Americans living with disabilities, many of whom are veterans.



We need to make sure that Democrats and President Obama hear that Social Security remains the third rail of American politics. It is going to take a united front across the country to push back on these attacks and make sure our elected officials get the message: Expand, dont cut Social Security!

Thank you for all that you do for the future of Social Security.

Michael Phelan
Social Security Works

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    11 years ago

History Suggests Social Security Insolvency Is Coming Sooner Than Projected

This years Social Security trustees report was released with little fanfare, as the projected date of Social Securitys financial insolvency held steady at 2033. [1] Many analysts and lawmakers have pointed to 20 years of alleged solvency as an excuse to delay meaningful Social Security reform. However, if history is any guide to future solvency, the Social Security program could become insolvent much sooner than 2033.

Past Reforms Have Failed

Social Security has been reformed numerous times throughout history, often in response to deteriorating program finances. In 1977, lawmakers enacted reforms to Social Security that were expected to keep the program solvent over the next 50 years. [2] But just six years and one double-dip recession later, Social Security was confronted with immediate insolvency. In 1983, Social Security was mere months from being unable to send out benefit checks due to lack of finances.

Lawmakers enacted new reforms that year that were projected to make the trust fund solvent over at least the next 75 years, including gradually increasing the normal retirement age by two years, bringing previously exempt workers into the Social Security system, accelerating scheduled tax increases, raising tax rates for the self-employed, and taxing a portion of benefits for higher-income earners. [3]

Following the 1983 reforms, the annual Social Security trustees report asserted: On the basis of all but the most pessimistic of the four sets of assumptions used, the program is now estimated to be financially sound over the next 75 years. [4]

Seventy-five years of future solvency meant the program was sound through at least 2058. Yet once again, the projected solvency of Social Security was too optimistic. Ten years later, the projected date of insolvency moved up by 22 years to 2036. Now, 30 years after the 1983 reforms, the projected date of insolvency has moved up by 25 years to 2033.

Economic and Demographic Changes

Although Social Security was intended to be self-sustaining over the long term, its financing is susceptible to factors unforeseen by its creators. As the United States has undergone significant demographic and economic changes over the decades since Social Securitys inception, Social Securitys projected date of insolvency has drawn closer.

Some of the reasons cited by the trustees for these declines over the years have included decreased mortality, lower birth rates, higher incidences of disability, lower economic growth, reduced average hours of work, lower interest rates on the trust fund, and higher inflation. Additionally, legislative changes, such as enhanced and new benefits, have affected Social Securitys solvency.

Insolvency Will Likely Come Even Earlier

Over the past five years alone, the projected date of Social Security insolvency has declined by eight years. This most recent decline in projected insolvency is largely the result of the 20072008 recession. While some of the sources of reduced solvencysuch as lower economic growth, lower wages, increased disability incidence, and lower birth ratesare hopefully temporary, other consequences of the recession are unlikely to be reversed. For example, the Social Security trustees now project lower average hours of work and higher rates of disability incidence well into the future, and the lifetime earnings of the long-term unemployed are likely to be permanently lower.

Aside from a short period in the late 1990s and early 2000s, when the exceptionally strong economy pushed Social Securitys projected solvency date forward, Social Securitys financial trajectory has been decidedly negative. If the historical pattern of declining solvency continues, the Social Security trust fund could become insolvent in 2024, a full nine years sooner than currently projected. [5]

Absent a bailout from general revenues, insolvency will result in immediate, across-the-board Social Security benefit cuts of about 23 percent. [6] Such benefit cuts would be particularly harmful to current retirees. The average 70-year-old today is probably not expecting to see the day that Social Security becomes insolvent. But if actual insolvency comes just 11 years from now, rather than 2033, that is just what will happen.

Moreover, such drastic benefit cuts could come at a time when the most vulnerable Social Security recipients are neither prepared nor capable of sustaining substantial cuts in income. Those approaching retirement need time to plan and adjust their savings well in advance of any changes to Social Security. Waiting is simply not an option.

Ad Hoc Reforms Do Not Work

As history has demonstrated, ad hoc reformseven those as significant as the 1983 reformswill not generate lasting solvency for Social Security. Within just five years of the massive 1983 reforms, the Social Security trustees projected that the program had already lost 10 years of solvency.

Furthermore, focusing on solvency over the 75-year horizon generates a false sense of security and can encourage reforms that initially boost Social Securitys finances but ultimately generate larger liabilities than assets.

As it exists today, Social Security attempts to be both a defined-benefit and defined-contribution program. But with both the benefits it pays and the contributions it receives being subject to demographic and economic uncertainties, it is impossible for Social Security to maintain financial balance over the long run. To make Social Security permanently solvent and affordable, it should be converted it into a defined-contribution program, and benefit eligibility should be indexed to changes in life expectancy.

Life expectancy in the U.S. has risen by 17 years since Social Securitys inception. [7] Indexing Social Securitys retirement age to life expectancy would prevent the program from paying out benefits for decades longer than originally planned. Furthermore, Social Security benefit eligibility and levels may need to be adjusted based on earnings profiles to better align each generations benefits with their contributions.

Fix Social Security Once and for All

Although Social Security is projected to remain solvent through 2033, its annual cash-flow deficits are already adding to federal deficits. As a Heritage Foundation report shows, Social Security ran a $55 billion cash flow deficit in 2012, and over the next 10 years, it will add nearly $1 trillion to U.S. deficits. [8] Moreover, history suggests the actual date of Social Security insolvency could come much sooner than 2033, perhaps as early as 2024just 11 years from now.

The current Social Security system is neither self-sustaining nor a true anti-poverty insurance program. These flaws could be fixed by indexing Social Securitys eligibility and benefits to changes in factors such as life expectancy and wages and by limiting benefits to those who need them most while providing a minimum benefit that would keep all beneficiaries out of poverty.

~Link~

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    11 years ago

I've never tried eating Wheaties and piss, but I don't think I will have to in order to say I know already I wouldn't like it.

Please enlighten me. I'm game.

 
 
 
CM
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  CM    11 years ago

LMAO!!! Funny Slarti: I think Six is trying to show the need for cuts and I am trying to show how much the GOP doesn't care about the elderly and disabled..why just go to cutting poor people's source of livelihood, why not find other ways of funding a program that needs funding...

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    11 years ago

No, I'm not trying to show the need for cuts. Where does the money come from to pay Social Security Disability and where does the money come from to pay Social Security? Are they doing just fine as they are?

As I understand it, neither are doing well. With people making less money, paying less into it, more people being added to the programs, both of them, doesn't anyone see a problem here?

I think I've shown where there have been tax increases and extended contribution ages on several occasions and as I understand the future is looking bleak as far as funding either enough to keep them from running into major problems without looking for ways to sustain them.

 
 
 
CM
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  CM    11 years ago

Six, People are applying for disability because people are sick, some illnesses are visible, others are not..as we age, the body breaks down, sometimes to the point of no return to normal, that's when people realizes they cannot go any further and seek another way, even a machine breaks down after many uses, much less flesh and blood..

 
 
 
CM
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  CM    11 years ago

MM, please don't worry about it, I only put the article up to show what the GOP is up to doing, I don't want you to be depressed about it...it work out somehow...

 
 
 
CM
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  CM    11 years ago

I agree MM, there is a lot on talk on the internet about this SSD rules change, so we will see...

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   Bob Nelson    11 years ago

History Suggests Social Security Insolvency Is Coming Sooner Than Projected

A study from the Heritage Foundation... Jim DeMint's outfit. Dedicated to ending Social Security.

Finds problems with Social Security.

And the sun rose in the east, too...

 
 
 
LynneA
Freshman Silent
link   LynneA    11 years ago

Most Senators claim there is unwarranted fraud in the SSDI program yet put forth a rules change that doesn't address what they believe to be the underlying problem. If the SS systems integrity and lack of funds is due to fraud, wouldn't we want to address that first?How about funding for additional inspectors, hey they could work with the....IRS fraud division!!

This is political pandering to the base, the GOP leadership is not stupid enough to cut SSDI.Red meat idiots feeding on the scraps tossed their way!

 
 

Who is online

Dismayed Patriot


99 visitors