╌>

When Life Hands You Yemen … Make YEMENADE! by A. Macarthur

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  a-macarthur  •  11 years ago  •  19 comments

When Life Hands You Yemen … Make YEMENADE! by A. Macarthur

Since Yemen appears to be one of the countries that is a safe haven for terrorists, would it not make sense to render parts of it (and other safe havens for terrorists) uninhabitable?

Countries/powers that comprise the so-called "civilized world," IMO, need to combine forces and declare to all countries knowingly and approvingly harboring terrorists, that

if within a stipulated time frame, their governments and citizenries do not begin actively the outing, forcing into exile and/or eradicating known, violent radical extremists, portions of their lands will be rendered uninhabitable.

Let civilized nations unite and declare that no "safe haven" for terrorists shall continue to remain as such.

Drop the leaflets, state the time frame, and, make clear the consequences for failing to demonstrably prove compliance by action.

The Rules-of-Engagement (ROE) have been established by terrorists terrorism goes on because, to a great extent it hides behind the bodies of innocent people. That creates the dilemma "Their Innocent People or 'Ours'?" The answer is rhetorical, tragic but also clear and ultimately, most probably unavoidable.

When life hands us Yemens make YEMENADE it's time to start squeezing the Yemens.


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    11 years ago

My liberalism is not without limitations.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    11 years ago

Well ... if you don't set up a way for inhabitants to move elsewhere you may be causing a lot more problems than you're solving . After all , the majority of inhabitants even in Yemen are merely bystanders . The same approach applied to South Chicago would be as disastrous .

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    11 years ago

The residents of South Chicago have not declared de facto war on the civilized world; and when its criminal residents perpetrate their crimes, they are in fact subject to the disdain of their neighbors and the arm of the law when apprehended. South Chicago as an entity, is not offering a safe haven to criminals and looking the other way it is an unwilling victim.

Nor does South Chicago, unlike Yemen et al, serve as a kind of "state sponsor" of criminality.

"State Sponsors of Terrorism" is a designation applied by the United States Department of State to countries which have "repeatedly provided support for acts of international terrorism ." [1] [2] Inclusion on the list imposes strict sanctions .

The countries currently on the list are Cuba , Iran , Sudan and Syria .

The list began on December 29, 1979, with Libya , Iraq , South Yemen , and Syria . Cuba was added to the list on March 1, 1982 and Iran on January 19, 1984. Later North Korea in 1988 and Sudan on August 12, 1993 were added.

Correct me if my distinction is incorrect.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    11 years ago

No , it mostly makes sense to me . I wonder if Iran was ever removed from that list ...

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   Bob Nelson    11 years ago

We should have taken this approach, as of the beginning of the Afghan War. We had no intrinsic problem with the Taliban. They were not nice, but not our problem. Then they gave safe haven to al Qaeda. We should have been clear right from the start that we would attack the Taliban to the degree they protected al Qaeda. Then, when we chased al Qaeda out of the country, and the Taliban out of power, we should have declared "Mission Accomplished" and come home.

Our military should be armed and organized for rapid intervention, more than for protracted war. Go in, kill the bad guys, and come home. If our target is beyond striking distance of our ground forces, we should announce that the zone will be bombed flat... and then do it. Host countries would quickly become less hospitable.

Civilians in such zones are like the hostages in the kosher supermarket: they are the victims of the hostage-takers, not of the forces that kill the hostage-takers.

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    11 years ago

Our military should be armed and organized for rapid intervention, more than for protracted war. Go in, kill the bad guys, and come home. If our target is beyond striking distance of our ground forces, we should announce that the zone will be bombed flat... and then do it. Host countries would quickly become less hospitable.

OMG-- I thought you were a liberal?

(And anyway, that would be Islamophobic...then the UN would debate it-- the General Assembly would debate it. even pass a resolution condemning it. Putin would have harsh words! And various UN agencies would condemn Israel.

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   Bob Nelson    11 years ago

I like to cite French policy in Africa. France did not ask the UN for anything before sending the Legion to save Mali from an Islamist/ethnic insurrection.

Went in, killed the bad guys, got out. (Well... mostly...)

Or in Cte d'Ivoire a decade ago. A rebellion was getting a bit too bloody -- France does not interfere in bloodless coups -- so France called on both side to cease fire. The Ivoirian President didn't like the idea and sent one of his half-dozen fighter planes to strafe a French outpost. The soldier was killed. The next day, there were no more Ivoirian war planes. The President was gently ousted... and eventually tried for war crimes...

Or Monrovia, almost fifteen years ago, now... Liberia is traditionally in America's sphere, but when a bloody revolt closed in on the capital, threatening massacre, America refused to act. French Marines went in and took off about 500 refugees, mostly foreigners, including about a hundred Americans.

France's policy in ex-colonial Africa is known as "Franafrique". Basically, it is non-interventionist, unless things start getting too bloody. There are French military outposts scattered all across the region, proof that the locals, while not liking neo-colonialism, prefer having a guard-rail.

I flew through N'Jamena (Chad) a dozen years ago, during a period of great tension between the governments of Chad and France. As we walked across the tarmac to our aircraft, we could not help noticing two jet fighters and an aerial tanker sitting in obvious readiness, further along. The aircraft bore no markings, nor did the (White) soldiers guarding them...

Franafrique has been constant, since independence of the countries. In contrast, the Brits just pulled out... completely. From Biafra forward, all the really bloody episodes in Africa have been in the ex-British (or ex-Belgian) sphere. None in Franafrique. The policy has continued for more than half a century, regardless of changes in governments, either in France or in Africa. Because it is a good policy, mutually beneficial to all concerned.

America has had no constant foreign policy since the fall of the USSR. It needs one...

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    11 years ago

If my article is read carefully, it will be seen that I HAVE NOT ADVOCATED KILLING INNOCENT RESIDENTS OF STATES THAT SPONSOR TERRORISM.

Specifically, I wrote

if within a stipulated time frame, their governments and citizenries do not begin actively the outing, forcing into exile and/or eradicating known, violent radical extremists, portions of their lands will be rendered uninhabitable.

However many million gallons of (i.e.) cat urine required to render an area the size of "X" -- is my first "weapon" of choice; the idea is to literally SQUEEZE the square miles of livable land down to a point where a given State Sponsor must do something regarding harboring/sponsoring terrorism lest its population be forced to exist on a postage stamp-sized parcel of the earth.

Kill the terrorists of course as opportunities arise; and give "innocent" human shields a dilemma as the "civilized" world has a dilemma (noted my the article).

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   Robert in Ohio    11 years ago

I certainly support the engagement and elimination of violent terrorists and their ability to spread their terror around the world.

It sounds as if you are advocating the creation of an oligarchy of the most powerful nations in the world, to decide who lives and who dies and tocreate environmental disasters that will take generations to recover based on what they see as "the right way to live".

It would certainly be an oligarchy of the powerful, because a group that engaged in the actions you describe and inferwould certainly not be part of the "civilized world", at least as I understand civilized.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    11 years ago

The orchestrated slaughter of innocents to satisfy an agenda is what is "uncivilized." To attempt to eradicate the perpetrators of such an agenda is NEWTONIAN.

"For every action there is, etc., etc. ."

No one "wins" in a war of ideologies. There are only victims or survivors.

Which shall we be?

A dilemma by definition offers choices none of them ideal.

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   Robert in Ohio    11 years ago

A Mac

It sounds like you are advocating "by whatever means necessary" without regard to the inhumanity or uncivilized nature of those "means". You are suggesting the eradication of innocent peoples' places and means of living in order to punish the perpetrators of similar agendas against others. Ironic.

What if the oligarchy of "civilized" nations decided to impose your solution on the U.S. Great Plains?

Would the ends still justify the means? Would you still support the solution?

Or is the solution only appropriate for "them" and "there", but no here at home?

Advocating violent, terrorist tactics to battle terrorism seems wrong on its face

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    11 years ago

What if the oligarchy of "civilized" nations decided to impose your solution on the U.S. Great Plains?

The residents of the U.S. Great Plains as an entity, have neither perpetrated acts of terrorism, nor, are residents in a jurisdiction that sponsors terrorism or harbors terrorists.

Again, my idea is Newtonian -- reactive, not pro-active. I have no illusions, the so-called civilized world is not without its own dirty hands (for example, what has been done to indigenous people in the name of "civilization"), but first-things-first, survival being the immediate priority.

Advocating violent, terrorist tactics to battle terrorism seems wrong on its face

I haven't done that please re-read what I have advocated.

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   Robert in Ohio    11 years ago

The residents of the U.S. Great Plains as an entity, have neither perpetrated acts of terrorism, nor, are residents in a jurisdiction that sponsors terrorism or harbors terrorists.

In your opinion, with which I agree, but the oligarchy of "civilized" nations might disagree and then the Midwest would be screwed under your approach.

You have advocated rendering portions of sovereign nations uninhabitable and in the process would likely ill many people either immediately or over time as a result. That is terrorist activity.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    11 years ago

What war has been without collateral damage? And, are the aggressors in war the initiators those who, by virtue of being thus, establish the ROE are they to be spared the collateral damage they precipitated?

Victim-provoked aggression is the logical reality to be expected by those who strike the first blow. "Turn-the-other-cheek" as a working philosophy in the real world likely results in additional slapped cheeks.

But, all right; give me an alternative, VIABLE solution to mine.

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   Robert in Ohio    11 years ago

A Mac

There is no single solution in the battle with terrorists, and you know that, but your solution is certainly not answer in my view.

With all respect, you continue tojustify your approach which I find unjustifiable, so I think we should agree to disagree at this point.

Thanks for the back and forth.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    11 years ago

Fair enough; we are at an IMPASSE.

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   Bob Nelson    11 years ago

It sounds as if you are advocating the creation of an oligarchy of the most powerful nations in the world, to decide who lives and who dies

How is this new?

...and tocreate environmental disasters

WTF?

---

I repeat: America needs a policy. There must be reasonably open criteria for designating "terrorists" and "terrorist havens". I remember far too well in 2003when French Foreign Minister Dominique de Villepin said at the UN that if America went ahead with its invasion of Iraq, the most likely result would be the destabilization of the entire region.

We cannot have this kind of arrogance from any one of the Western powers. If there is no concensus, there must be no action.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    11 years ago

Synthesize it!

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   Bob Nelson    11 years ago

I'm a liberal and I feel the same way.

National defense is not a left / right topic.

 
 

Who is online

Dismayed Patriot


99 visitors