Republicans Make 1+1=3
Yesterday, the GOP House changed how the fiscal costs of legislation are calculated:
The House on Tuesday adopted a controversial rule to require macroeconomic scoring on major legislation in the new Congress, which opponents say will politicize impartial budget analyses. So-called dynamic scoring typically offers a more favorable view of cutting taxes, which is part of why Republicans support the method.
Chait claims the new GOP Congress is going after math itself:
The new, dynamic CBO will be systematically biased to make conservative proposals appear misleadingly cheap and liberal proposals misleadingly costly to the public fisc. This would be true even if the Republicans were soliciting a fair range of forecasting perspectives. By its design, the dynamic scoring rule allows the party in power to game its effects. It applies dynamic scoring only to legislation affecting 0.25 percent of Gross Domestic Product. As Chye-Ching Huang and Paul Van de Water point out, congressional leaders can manipulate this requirement easily: They can break up large pieces of legislation into smaller bills to avoid dynamic scoring, or combine smaller pieces into a major bill, if needed to make their agenda appear more affordable. Dynamic scoring is subject to abuse by its very design.It is possible the Republicanized CBO continues to function in some distorted form, advancing Republican legislative goals by passing off slanted analysis as impartial. Or it is possible it simply loses all of its previous credibility and mutates into another partisan mouthpiece. Either way, the Republican right has struck a powerful blow against the sort of academic expert they have always loathed.
Shaun Donovan, the OMB Director, is upset by the rule change:
While all budget estimates are uncertain, there is substantially more disagreement among economists and experts about how policy changes affect the macroeconomy than about most other scoring issues. This helps explain why estimates from different CBO models of the long-run growth effects of a 10 percent tax cut differed by a factor of 15 and ranged from positive to negative when dynamic scoring was used .
But Keith Hennessey defends dynamic scoring:
We know that some policy changes can increase (or reduce) the size of the economy, and that to assume otherwise is wrong. The longstanding scoring process is biased against policies that would increase economic growth, and biased for policies that would shrink the economy. The size of the effect of large and broad-based reductions in tax rates is uncertain, but were pretty darn sure its not zero. Certain immigration reforms would increase domestic labor supply and increase economic growth. More accurate scoring would incorporate both types of effects.
Mark Thoma is unsure that the rule change will make a big difference:
How much of an impact would this change have? If the best evidence on this question is taken into account , not as much as Republicans hope. When previous tax cuts are examined econometrically, the impact on economic growth is hard to find. There does appear to be an effect according to some of the research (but not all), but the effect is relatively small certainly not big enough to make a significant change in the budgetary impact.
So why are Democrats alarmed?
Some Democrats worry that CBO director Elmendorf will be replaced by someone willing to cherry pick the evidence on tax cuts to benefit Republican proposals and minimize benefits of the change to Democratic legislation. That would politicize an institution that has done its best to evaluate the budgetary impact of legislative proposals based upon solid evidence rather than politics and ideology and do great harm to an important part of the legislative process.

Making reality fit dogma...
As I continued my morning, I found this interesting counterpoint:
E.J. Dionne and Dynamic Scoring: Getting the Story Backward
No. Wrong. NEVER said that.
PK has always been very careful to be precise about deficits, precisely because of the lies that are spread through ignorance or willful deceit.
This is the kind of throwaway falsehood that makes me wonder about you... Is it due to ignorance or willful deceit?
Give me a link. I am willing to bet that you cannot.
He is not foolish enough to hand that kind of phrase to his adversaries.
Formulation is important. The quasi-quote you attribute to Krugman contains "deficits don't really matter". That's precisely the sort of formulation that he avoids like the plague, because people will repeat just those four words.
I'm not talking about Keynesian economics, here. I am talking about communication. Krugman is pretty good at it. (In writing, anyway. He's not always tough enough in verbal jousts.) He knows that his adversaries will pounce on any misstep.
Let's go back to your post:
Why "left"? Bruce Bartlett is on the left??
You give lip service to context with "at least in the short term", but then you throw that caveat out the window with "well either they do or they don't".You quasi-quote Krugman (falsely, I am sure) and then you ignore your own quasi-quote!
At best, this is sloppy thinking. Or maybe it is intentional obfuscation.
...
KRUGMAN: Important political fact, which is that whatever you would do with the deficit, the public won't notice. In 1996, a majority of Republicans thought that the deficit had increased under Clinton, even though we had in fact...
ROBERTS: Balanced the budget.
KRUGMAN: ... been on an incredible run. So no, I mean, the deficit doesn't matter. The economy matters. And that's why somehow or other, Obama has got to get jobs being created.
'This Week' Transcript for Nov.29, 2009
Do you also go in for Biblical clobbertexting?
This is a transcript of extemporaneous talk. In the context, it is clear that Krugman means "In the public's mind, deficits don't matter; the economy matters." He is not saying that deficits actually do not matter.
Thank you for demonstrating that people are instantly ready to pounce on particular words, while completely ignoring the context.
Yeeeesh!
Agreed. I think both you and Bob have made many good points. I myself am a fan of Krugman and have heard him say the same thing about deficits many times. I don't believe it is an attack to say that he made that statement. Don't know why Bob is so hung about claiming he did not.
Let's be clear. We agree on the economics.
I am protesting your formulation.
Krugman is a particular case. He is two personalities at once: a highly respected economist and a political advocate.
He is careful to keep the two aspects separate, but his adversaries are not. On the contrary, they intentionally blend the two. They arrive at the notion that Keynesianism is leftist.
Conservatives work very hard to control debate through control of the vocabulary used in the debate. You say Bruce Bartlett is no longer a conservative because he has been drummed out of the GOP. That means you have (probably unconsciously) accepted the GOP's amalgamation of "conservative" and "Republican". One cannot be one unless one is the other.
And Keynes is leftist because Krugman is leftist.
And other similar nonsense... that people accept without thinking...
Formulation is important. See how easily context is ignored .
Then why do you insist so heavily on the categorization?
Personally, I don't think economics has any political color, any more than, say, climate science has a political color...
We've mentioned Bartlett, who had the personal and professional honesty and courage to say what he saw as the truth, to people who want to hear only the party line. He did not change his political beliefs; he just looked at the data.
I very much doubt that Martin Wolf is a flaming liberal on political issues.
What do you mean, here? Bush's deficits were totally anti-Keynesian. He lowered taxes during prosperity. That is not at all the counter-cycle that Keynes suggested.
This is one of PK's constant themes: that Republicans do not in fact give a hoot about the deficit. On the contrary, they create deficits with glee, because then they can use "reducing the deficit" as an excuse for gutting social services.
Arrogant? That's an interesting choice of words. I don't think I have ever seen him being arrogant, not have I read anything that I would qualify that way. Perhaps we use the word differently.
He knows what he is talking about, and does not suffer fools easily. If someone puts forth an opinion, without data to back it up, Krugman will often respond with mockery. Well... Economics is supposedly a science. Opinion without data should be anathema.
He invents useful terms. VSP (Very Serious People) are those who know stuff... without any basis... and who then make policy -- Wolfgang Schable is the prototype. The Confidence Fairy. The Bond Vigilantes.
He documents his own positions, and roasts anyone who cannot do the same. Is that "arrogance"?
From Mr. Krugman's blog, March 25, 2011
I agree with you, I just provided the link to how where Mr. Krugman made the remark
Thank you, Robert!
Thank you!
Bob
No worries, I just happened upon it and it clearly shows that Mr. Krugman said that "deficits don't matter right now" and provided his views on why deficits cannot be ignored total.