╌>

More Jobs is Not Enough

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  robert-in-ohio  •  11 years ago  •  28 comments

More Jobs is Not Enough

After the worst economic downturn since the Great Depression and a slow and plodding recovery, things are looking up. The economy grew at a sizzling 5% annual pace in the third quarter of last year. And more than 1.5 million jobs were created from June to November, the best six-month stretch since 1999-2000.

With that momentum, combined with falling gasoline prices, 2015 is likely to be a good year, notwithstanding Monday's stock market sell-off.

But more jobs alone is not enough to break out the champagne. With all that is working in favor of the economy now, job growth should be a given. What America needs is a raise.

The past 15 years have not been great for the non-wealthy. Adjusted for inflation, median household income (now at $51,939 ) is 9% below where it was in 1999. It went sideways from 2000 to 2007, then fell from 2008 to 2011, and has started to perk up only lately. This has to change.

On the economic front, it's easy to see the harm of stagnant wages. Companies sitting on record amounts of cash have been reluctant to invest in hiring or capital improvements. Their unwillingness to spend means less money for workers and contractors, which in turn means weak demand, continuing the cycle.

On the political front, stagnant wages erode people's faith in government while making them more susceptible to fringe arguments of the far right and far left.

What to do? The first step is to understand that stagnant wages do not have a simple cause or a simple solution. They are not the result of a wealthy elite rigging the system against the middle class, as Sen. Elizabeth Warren, D-Mass., argues. Nor are they caused by too many regulations, a refrain of conservatives.

They are the product of historic shifts. Stunning technological advances have eliminated millions of jobs a trend that's sure to continue.

At the same time, rising global competition is pressing wages downward even as it adds new markets for American products.

Neither trend can be reversed by act of Congress. Economic forces are far more powerful. Even so, government can take actions to help cope with them.

Minimum wage increases, now sweeping through state legislatures, are one such step.

So is saner fiscal policy. This year, Washington will raise roughly $3.3 trillion in taxes, mostly from the young, productive and healthy. And it will spend roughly $3.9 trillion, mostly on benefits for the retired, the unproductive and the unhealthy.

Deserved or not, those benefits swallow up money needed to sustain and grow the economy, particularly by investing in infrastructure, education and science. This year, the government will spend $1.14 trillion on health care, more than 11 times the $98 billion it will spend on roads, rails, ports and airports all sources of high-wage construction jobs, and all vital to long-term growth.

After 15 years of wage stagnation, it's time for a change. Lower gas prices will put money in people's pockets, and perhaps that will finally persuade companies to spend. In the meantime, Congress should do its part. An economy that produces mostly for the well-off is nothing to celebrate.

http://www.usatoday.com/story/opinion/2015/01/05/stagnant-wages-jobs-economy-congress-editorials-debates/21306485/?csp=Opinion


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    11 years ago

A good friend here on NT, has taught me through his articles and comments that the U.S. economy needs to be retooled, that the recovery and reemergence of a strengthened middle class is not a simple problem and will not be accomplished with a singular, simple solution.

The USA Today editorial board seems to echo that view, in this editorial.

Jobs are needed, good paying jobs are needed and an increase in the minimum wage is needed, but most of all we cannot continue to bounce along with the same economic and monetary policies and programs that have been ineffective in recent years and think that raising the minimum wage is going to fix everything.

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   Bob Nelson    11 years ago

I have always been astounded that Americans measure the health of their economy in GDP... or even worse, in DOW.

The only number that seems important to me is median income.

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   Bob Nelson    11 years ago

I was born and raised in the US; and have lived in France for most of my adult life. I have both passports. When I first arrived in France in the early 70s, the material standard of living (as measured very unscientifically in terms of color TVs per household) was moderately behind the American.

I was more deeply surprised by the lack of multi-lane highways. America was just finishing the Interstate system (so there were almost no pot-holes... yet...), while in France a five hundred mile trip from our home in Lorraine to my mother-in-law's home in Brittany was a twelve-to-fourteen-hour over-night drive... despite 90 mph out-of-town speeds -- no speed limits back then!.

For forty years, every year, the newspapers said that America's GDP grew by a point or two more than France's GDP. I'm no mathematician... but the little calculator program that lives on one corner of my computer desktop says that 1,5% compounded over forty years should just about raise the American economy to the double of the French.

Today, France's material standard of living (as measured very unscientifically in terms of big flat-screen TVs) is, still, moderately behind the American. Same as forty years ago.

And during these forty years... France has built -- and maintained (cough, cough) -- its highway network. And also built a high-speed rail network. And also built nuclear power plants that cover 80% of needs. And... and... and...

Basically, it seems to me that France has done better, fundamentally, than the US. Contrary to the numbers .

I tried to understand. For some years, I imagined that perhaps "socially stimulative investments" such as highways, bullet trains, health-care, unemployment benefits, and so on (which are indisputably better in Europe than in the US) carry some sort of "social return on investment" that augmented French/European competitivity without appearing in those manifestly misleading GDP numbers.

Then, a few years ago, an excellent article by an economist named Zencey gave me a better explanation: GDP is simply... false. GDP measures turnover, not added value. If I sell you my house for a million dollars, and then you sell it back to me for exactly the same amount, GDP has gone up by two million dollars, despite there being no added value at all.

... All those gazillion dollars sloshing around Wall Street, for no added value at all... While China actually makes stuff, and Germany actually makes stuff... and even France actually makes stuff! You know: those bullet trains, and Airbus, and those nuclear plants, and......

Using GDP to measure a nation's progress is like using a ship's wake to measure its progress. More "churn" does not necessarily mean more speed...

If GDP is not a valid instrument... then what? Well... let's go back to the beginning: "life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness". To me "life" in an advanced society means far more than "birth". "Life" means things like a minimum wage... whether employed or not. "Life" is good health-care, accessible for everyone. "Life" is leisure time, with family and friends or just by myself... but my time, not some boss's! "Life" is each person being able to fulfill whatever their capabilities may be, through good education opportunities at all ages. Or we could put all these same items in the category "the pursuit of happiness". Indeed, there are quite a few attempts these days to quantify "happiness".

America never leads the "happiness" indexes...

More recently, I asked the same question ("Where did the difference in GDP growth between the US and France go?") of Brad DeLong, a leading Keynesian economist and professor at UCal Berkeley. He says it was almost entirely captured by the 1%, and thus never appeared in any average American's life.

That is a very depressing idea... and in light of the avalanche of "inequality" articles that are flooding the econoblogosphere these days, depressingly likely to be true...

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    11 years ago

I am not an economist, nor do I attempt to play one here on NT.

I appreciate the feedback and perspective.

You make some interesting points that I am not knowledgeable enough about.

I lived in Europe (Germany)for a significant period (nearly 13 years in the 70's and 80's) and enjoyed and envied some aspects of the way things were done and disliked others. Perhaps someone with a more indepth economics background (or at least more opinions) will speak to your specific points.

Thanks for providing the info and references, I will certainly check out some of the stuff when I get some extra time.

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    11 years ago

Happiness indices are even more subjective than financial/economic ones in my view

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   Bob Nelson    11 years ago

even more subjective

An indicator is just that. You get out of it what you have put in. You measure... something... and if you're very, very clever, you will create indicators that provide pertinent counsel for piloting your car, or economy, or whatever...

If we think that the DOW is the most important indicator for the nation, we will establish policies that promote growth in the DOW... even if those policies have negative effects on other aspects of the nation.

That's America in a nutshell, IMHO...

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    11 years ago

The fact that things are only measured and reported that support a specific expert's point of view, or a certain political party's agenda is indeed a problem. Molding data analysis to prove whatever people want it to prove is a primary skill set in Washington and the state capitals.

I think all measurements are important, they are not all things (or sometimes anything) to all people, but the confusion comes with "experts" attempt to market ideas and policies of one kind or another based on how they interpret and trumpet certain of the indicators while not addressing others.

You are right that that what is important to those in power is what gets the attention, more than what is important to the general citizenry - hence the disconnect between walls street and main street.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    11 years ago

It depends on what your goal is . The health of the economic position of middle class is one such goal ...

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    11 years ago

If you take a global perspective the results look a lot different . The Chinese middle class is doing quite well these days ...

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   Bob Nelson    11 years ago

There MUST be a way to come up with an indisputable number or small set of numbers, that the average American can understand, that gives us all a true snapshot of the health (or lack of) our economy. A set of numbers that neither party can credibly dispute.

In a country where a moderate-conservative President is commonly called communist, where death panels are fantasized to prevent people from getting health care, where half the population believes the world is 6000 years old, ... ... coming up with something "that neither party can credibly dispute" is "unlikely"...

Frown.gif Frown.gif

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    11 years ago

Mickey

People, especially political parties, tend to pick and choose which statistics they want to use to prove there point

Very true!

There MUST be a way to come up with an indisputable number or small set of numbers, that the average American can understand, that gives us all a true snapshot of the health (or lack of) our economy

You would think, but if there were I am sure that we would have already seen them and that both sides of the fiscal argument would have endorsed or denounced them soundly. Smile.gif

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    11 years ago

Petey

Well that is a good thing for them

Mickey

The jobs we offshore to China are not going to the middle class, but rather to mostly low earners

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    11 years ago

Bob

coming up with something "thatneither party can credibly dispute" is "unlikely"...

Unfortunately that is true, but the pursuit of that is the key to real change and improvement in the government and society and that is what true moderates work towards

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   Bob Nelson    11 years ago

the pursuit of that is the key to real change and improvement in the government and society

I think not. There are just too many people who fit facts to their dogma. America will have to have reality smack it in the face again and again, before the denialists are thrown out of power.

The sad thing is that they may destroy the planet before they are brought down.

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    11 years ago

Bob

Appreciate you perspective, but giving up on trying to effect change is not the answer

Thanks for all the back and forth and all the input you provided on the thread

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    11 years ago

Indeed

A very smart woman once said, "wanting something, but being unwilling to work for it, is foolhardy"

She was my grandmother and according to my grandfather she was never once wrong in her entire life. Smile.gif

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   Bob Nelson    11 years ago

Sisiphus worked very hard to get that boulder to the top of the hill...

It's all well and good to exhort people to hard work... but if there is no chance of success, the exhortation is to self-destruction.

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    11 years ago

Bob

Iappreciate and support your right to give up, go for it or rather don't go for it!

No worries from here.

And according to the legend, Sisyphus never gave, but rather continued to try and to get and keep the stone at the summit for eternity.

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   Bob Nelson    11 years ago

Iappreciate and support your right to give up

I wasn't talking about myself. I was lucky: a male WASP born into a middle class, reasonably well educatedfamily.

So of course I have had a comfortable, interesting, fulfilling life.

But I don't kid myself. If I had been born otherwise... ... ...

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    11 years ago

Bob

Yeah I was lucky too.

I was born into a dirt poor farm family of 8 kids, with parents that valued education above all else. I completed high school, went into the service, got a college education and had a successful post military career and a, now happily and mostly securely retired.

But I don't kid myself, if that old woman hadn't taught us not to give up and to work hard, it could have been otherwise.

Thanks a lot for all the back and forth.

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   Bob Nelson    11 years ago

But I don't kid myself, if that old woman hadn't taught us not to give up and to work hard, it could have been otherwise.

Sure.Your being white and male didn't hurt, either.

Look... I'm not denying the importance of a work ethic. Of course it's important.

I am saying that since we do not all start at the same point, the same effort is not required of all of us. Some of us -- the Walton kids -- are born zillionaires. Most of us... are not.

All the statistics say that the probability of dying in the same wealth quintile where you were born is very high and getting higher all the time. I do not believe that all the rich have the greatest work ethic and that all the poor have the worst. Do you?

I am wary of simple formulas.

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    11 years ago

Bob

I think that work ethic and the desire to succeed and better oneself is an individual things and an individual responsibility. You are correct people start life's journey at different points and different types and amounts effort may be required to better oneself - that is the challenge of life that we must all either take up or not.

You are wary of simple formulas,probably good thing and I am wary of someone who tries to make race the basis of all things.

Choices and challenges to overcome are what we face in life and it is important the we choose wisely and work hard at the challenges - at least that is how I see it.

Thanks again for the back and forth

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   Bob Nelson    11 years ago

I am wary of someone who tries to make race the basis of all things.

Did I do that? I said "male WASP". Why do you take note only of the "W"?

Male WASP:

  • Men have an easier time than women.
  • Whites have an easier time than Blacks.
  • Anglo-Saxons have an easier time than Latinos, Indians, whatever.
  • Protestants have an easier time than Catholics, Jews, whatever.

Male WASPs have to screw up to screw up.

What part(s) of this reasoning is false?

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    11 years ago

Bob

You must have a bit of a guilty conscience.

I d not say that "you" did that, I did not even imply it, though you inferred it thusly, I said people not "Bob".

Though you did point out that

Sure.Your being white and male didn't hurt, either.

Generalizations (stereotypes) are often misleading, I know many people who are white, and male and Christian and have made very good live for themselves from humble beginnings.

I also know people who are female, black and agnostic/atheist that have done the same.

The discussion is about economic recovery and we have wandered off about you and me - let us end that train f thought and focus on general recovery

 
 

Who is online