2014 may set a new temperature record. So can we please stop claiming global warming has “stopped”?
Senator Jim Inhofe, R-Oklahoma, gestures during his victory speech at the Republican watch party in Oklahoma City, Tuesday, Nov. 4, 2014. (AP Photo/Sue Ogrocki)
Speaking on the Senate floor in July, Oklahoma's James Inhofe -- soon to head, once again, the Senate's Environment and Public Works Committee -- made a claim that has become quite prevalent among skeptics of climate change skeptics.
"For the past 15 years," Inhofe said , "temperatures across the globe have notincreased."
Inhofe was offering one of the favorite arguments of skeptics, namely, that global warming paused or slowed down since the very hot year of 1998.
But the argument has one big problem. This:
Source: Japan Meteorological Agency .
What you're looking at is a preliminary assessment by theJapan Meteorological Agency (JMA) of how 2014's globally averaged surface temperatures compare with those of prior years, all the way back to 1891. Based on this data, 2014 was the hottest year on record for the globe. Thatsurpasses the year 1998 (now in 2nd place in the JMA dataset) and 2013 and 2010 (now tied for 3rd).
You'll also note, incidentally, that while the dataset is noisy, the upward trend is quite clear, and the decade of the 2000s is plainly warmer than the decade of the 1990s. So much for any "pause" in global warming.
Japan's is the first major meteorological outlet to pronounce on how 2014 ranks for temperatures. But if others -- the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration, NASA, andthe UK Met Office's Hadley Center -- concur with the agency, it could be a serious blow to the "pause" argument.
The strange idea that global warming has paused.Let's first considerthe "pause" notion itself. It went truly mainstreamin 2013, when the U.N.'s Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change released the first part of its much awaited Fifth Assessment Report.
In a poorly worded statement ,a leaked draft of the IPCC's report observedthat the rate of global temperature increase, during the 15 year period from 1998 to 2012, was somewhat less than the rate of increase from 1951 to 2012. In other words, while the IPCC didn't say the globe had stopped warming, it did suggest a situation that is a bit like a driver easing off the accelerator in a moving car.
This led to voluminous media coverage of the so-called "pause" and how much it allegedly undermined arguments about global warming -- an analysis by Media Matters of coverage of the IPCC report release found that 41percent of stories cited the "pause."
But as it turned out, this was all much ado about nothing. The IPCC would later emphasize , in its finished report, that "trends based on short records are very sensitive to the beginning and end dates and do not in general reflect long-term climate trends." Moreover, many scientists observed that using 1998 as a beginning date in the first place is misleading, because 1998 was a super hot El Nio year, and thus a fairly dramatic anomaly for the 1990s (as you can see in the chart above).
The weakness of the "pause" argument is perfectly captured in this GIF from the website Skeptical Science, showing that you can still have globalwarming even if you have shorter periodsduring which temperatures don't rise much:
In the end, then, the "pause" argument largely relies on the then-record temperatures of 1998 in order to create the impression that there's been little or no global warming ever since.
Yet the fact remains that the 2000s were considerably hotter than the 1990s , and indeed, in most datasets 1998 isn't even the hottest year any longer. Without even taking 2014 into consideration at all, NASA considers 1998 merely the fourth hottest year (behind 2010, 2005, and 2007, and tied with 2002) and NOAA considers it third (behind 2010 and 2005).
So what happens to the "pause" if 2014 now becomes the hottest year?
A possible temperature record for2014.At least for some expert agencies, 2014 is looking more and more like it will surpass 1998 and all other contenders. And this is particularly remarkable because unlike 1998, 2014 is not an official El Nio year (these years tend to be hotter).
We've already seen the Japan Meteorological Agency's preliminary analysis. NOAA and NASA are slated to jointly release their assessments of 2014's temperatures on January 16. The Hadley Center, meanwhile, just affirm ed that 2014 was the hottest year on record for the UK in particular -- and it is also expected to weigh in on temperatures globally soon enough.
So what can we expect from these agencies?
As far as NOAA goes, a 2014 record seems pretty likely. "NOAAs in the bag," says John Abraham , a climate scientist at the University of St. Thomas in Minnesota who tracks global temperatures carefully, and has himself already declared 2014 a new record temperature year.
Indeed, while NOAA has only released global averaged temperature analyses through November so far, its last release included this helpful figure,showing where 2014 currently stands in the record books, and what would have to happen in order for it to set a new record(or fail to).Basically, it looks pretty hardfor 2014 to fall short, assuming last month's temperatures were reasonably warm:
NOAA .
As for NASA and the Hadley Center, it remains to be seen. When it comes to NASA, Abraham says he sees "probably a 60 to 70 percent chance theyll break the record."
So at this point, it seems likely that for at least someof the official agencies, 2014 will go down in the record books.
Pausing the "pause."So can 2014's temperatures finally silence global warming "pause" mongers, like Inhofe?
I asked several prominent climate scientists this question. "The record-breaking temperatures should put to rest once and for all the silly claim by contrarians that climate change has somehow stopped or stalled," observedclimate researcher Michael Mann from Penn State. "In fact, the warming of the globe continues unabated as we continue to burn fossil fuels and increase concentrationsof planet-warming greenhouse gases."
"2014 is now the warmest on record by only a tiny amount," added Kevin Trenberth, a much cited climate researcher at the National Center for Atmospheric Research. "Nevertheless it continues the human-induced upward trend in temperatures that has been evident since the 1970s. Starting trends in 1998 is quite misleading. Undoubtedly Mother Nature will continue to surprise us, but we should expect continued increases in extremes of temperature, heat and wild fires, and stronger storms and more intense droughts."
In fairness,in a technical sense 2014 is just another year and just another data point. Despite the January ritual of tallying up each year's temperatures and ranking it against prior years, what actually matters (as always) is the trend, not the individual year. But as we've seen, the global warming trend is intact -- 2014 may just be an exclamation point on top of it.
Indeed, this year -- 2015 the temperatures of 2014 could take on major significance. After all, the world is now racing to complete a global climate agreement this December in Paris. A new temperature record for 2014 would surely light a fire under negotiators.
Meanwhile, there remains a 65 percent chance that we'll see an El Nio -- which could also help drive a new temperature record -- in 2015.
2014 may set a new temperature record. So can we please stop claiming global warming has stopped? , b y Chris Mooney , Wonkblog , Washington Post

"Global warming has stopped" is a Big Lie, a lie that Very Important People repeat and repeat and repeat, until the general public thinks that there must be at least a grain of truth.
"The Pause" is a lie. The people who repeat it are liars or dupes, and in either case are active accomplices in the murder of the planet.
So... you already knew about the statistical anomaly that is 1998, and how it creates a false "plateau".
Interesting.
The alternative would be to see a total creep, every time he looks in a mirror. Most people, when they are doing something despicable, will try to convince themselves that there's a good reason for it.
Holy S***!
Robert... if you don't know what a linear regression is, and how it is established... you should avoid getting involved in a conversation where numbers are present...
Wow...
Did you read the seed, Robert? The whole point of the article is that when you are treating a subject like global warming, you don't get to choose the slice of data that serves your purposes. You must take ALL the data.
You don't get to start a new series at ever hot-point anomaly, and thus see a series of flats -- that's "How Skeptics View "Global Warming". It is invalid use of the data.
You have to start as far back as you can, and take all the data. That's why the regression starts forty years ago, and is continuous.
Once again, Robert... if you do not understand numbers... you should not talk about them...
Wow, Robert... Wow.......
Stop digging!
'97% Of Climate Scientists Agree' Is 100% Wrong
Please, Robert...
Stop digging...
I can't answer that without violating the CoC ... but I suppose I could give them advice about removing their head from whatever dark place it is inserted .
Didn't you know that the Washington Post is more scienterrific than those 2 agencies ... combined ?
With you, Robert, I never know whether its bad faith or ignorance that underlies your posts.
If 2014 does indeed turn out to have been the hottest year in history, then that fact would make the year significant. Duh.
You CAN look at fifteen years as significant... on the condition that you explain why you used those particular start/end years. And that reason cannot be "because 1998 is an obvious outlier, so starting there gives me the result that I want". Duh.
Bad faith or ignorance?
Well we have global warming" up to our waists this morning and the wind chill is 16 degrees below zero. I am going outside to clear the "climate change" off the driveway, before the next band of lake effect snow arrives.
I am not confused in the least, the smiley face means I was making a joke -
Some call it global warming, some call it climate change - potatoe / potato
1,523 years - 1,523 years - that's the cycle. Learn it and remember it. Quit screaming "the sky is falling, the sky is falling."
Oh... It's both! Bad faith and ignorance...
The sky is not falling.
The planet is warming.
Do you see the difference, now?
I see the difference but do you ?
Gee Bob - that happens every 1,523 years and has for as long as the scientists have been able to obtain that data from their field work.
Yes, the earth is warming - as it has done cyclically since the beginning of time - and will continue to do so - every 1,523 years. Then it cools off - again - for 1,523 years so it can restart the cycle and get warm again.
Do YOU see the difference?
Where did you "learn" this amazing "fact"? It's probably worth visiting... for the comedy...
Anyone who repeats the "Pause" lie is contributing to the death of the planet.
What do you not understand, there?
The assumptions in this silly-ass blog piece are not to be taken seriously but you seem to . Why is that ?
...
...
...
And, there are many more references/critical studies on the 1500 year cycle.
I'd recommend you do some research before you post a thread of this magnitude.
Have fun Bob ...
Notice how I de-escalated ...
Great job
That says much more about you , Petey, than about the article.
OK , I'll bite . What does it say about me ?
Mouse ,
It appears that 1st has stuck a fly in the ointment . At least one of those links was pro-warming . And what does that demonstrate ? Clearly it shows your broad brush rejection was not the result of actual examination of the material . But thanks for playing ... I say playing because clearly you are not working .
Apparently you haven't read your own links....
Clearly you haven't read any of them . The dialogue here is just a pretense .
Wonkblog is not "silly-ass". Your using those words shows you don't know anything about Wonkblog, but feel comfortable expressing an insulting and dismissive opinion. That makes you a lightweight, either intellectually or morally. Or both.
Or... You're just thoughtless.
I suppose that's not as bad.
Here's what that says about you . You are once again finding your "gods" online . Like Krugman [but not as educated] wonkblog is drawing conclusions about scientific topics without the background to do so ... in other words silly-ass .
1st Chart; they are claiming about .75 degrees average climb differetial over 125 years,
2nd Chart; They are claiming a .5 degree approximate climb over the last 40 years,
3rd Chart; Comparing certain years to the previous century's average, picking only two years out of six to make a point. (smacks of cherry picking data here) nevertheless the difference they are talking about is measured in the HUNDREDTH'S of a degree compared to a century of data. (and threr are a couple of those greyed out years I would like to discuss but they have been conveniently left out.
The charts taken in their plain meaning don't show a damned thing, at least to anyone with a brain who can plainly read a chart. I see no increase in global warming here, but I do see the cyclic warming of the planet as explained to me in junior high science class.
All of the charts go to show that the Global warning alarmists have a long way to go to prove anything, and that only if anyone accepts these charts as saying anything other than what is normal.
These charts do not prove what the claimant is claiming. In fact they don't prove anything at all except that the average temps will change from year to year.
Most fifth graders being taught basic science can tell you that.
Find it yourself you lazy-assed bastid !
Look, Petey...
1st posted a bunch of links, supposedly in support of a 1523-year climate-change cycle. Since most of those links do nothing of the sort... I concluded that 1st had copy / pasted the links from some nutcase denialist website, without ever looking at them. Which deserves the mocking laughter I gave it.
So THINK for a second, Petey! If I know what those links say, I have to have looked at them.
But if anyone thinks I'm going to do their homework for them, they'd better think again. Do you imagine that I care what nonsense 1st believes? Do you imagine that I would try to convince a denialist? Talk about futility!
Guess since I work in the field of studying climate change I should have a much better knowledge base than someone just wanting to make a mark on the NT forum, eh?
Thanks ! Shit was what I was aiming for ...
Did you notice the sources of the graphs in the seed?