Gun Rights Versus Anecdotes
Gun Rights Versus Anecdotes
Which side wins depends on whether one can reason or simply react emotionally.
For a while back in the Winter, a retired philosophy professor (who wants to remain anonymous) and I exchanged a few emails and, from him, snail mail, discussing gun rights. After not hearing from him for several months he very unexpectedly mailed me a large envelope containing forty-nine newspaper clippings with many reports of shootings and a few anti-gun rights op-eds (and, strangely, a pro-gun op-ed by John Lott). He also included a fund raising letter from the Brady Campaign, another one from the Children's Defense Fund Action Counsel, a magazine ad from the Center to Prevent Handgun Violence, and a hand written note. Especially surprising for their absence were any articles from scholarly source. Are there no scholarly articles in favor of gun control? He sent almost all anecdotes from mass media sources leaning heavily towards the New York Times and the Philadelphia Inquirer. One would expect better from university professor.
Read the rest at http://theinternationallibertarian.blogspot.com/2015/01/gun-rights-versus-anecdotes.html

Let's think about this. The seed is a blog post, basically a front office for a repository of "information" called " Gun Facts ". An amazing collection of truth, half-truths, and outright lies.
For example, this combination of property crime and handgun supply . If a reader isn't careful -- or somewhat aware of gun ownership in America -- this graph makes a clear correlation.
So the fall in property crime is not related to gun ownership. Something else is going on. Correlation is not causation... But hey! Who cares about truth?
This is how gun-lovers sell their tripe. A bit of truth, lots of misleading half-truths, and some outright lies.
Everyone should take a look at " Gun Facts ". It is truly remarkable...
My blog "a front office" for Gun Facts? That's a new one. Anyway, Bob, you're comparing 2 different things. You may be right that the number of people owning guns has gone down (though I'm not one to say that the NYT is an impartial source) but that doesn't mean that there aren't more guns out there. No "...lots of misleading half-truths, and some outright lies" here.
"...the fall in property crime is not related to gun ownership."
Yes, & the same can be said about murder. Maybe you didn't notice this sentence in my article, "Deal with the social dynamics that are the real problem and, when it comes to crime, guns become irrelevant."
You prove what I wrote, that "The gun rights haters' case is all smoke and mirrors." Let's just have an honest & calm discussion, shall we?
I'm sorry, but this is one of those topics where "honest and calm" are impossible. When you begin by doubting an information simply because it appeared in the Times, ignoring the fact that the graph is sourced elsewhere, you've pretty well demonstrated what I mean...
Tell me you don't know and use "Gun Facts"...
On the other hand you ignore the points I make in my article & go off on a tangent about Gun Facts (which is only referenced once in my article, BTW)....I guess I can't have an honest & calm discussion with you.
No Darren, you CANNOT have a serious discussion about guns on this site with anyone that calls themselves "Liberal" or "Democrat"
You might as well ask them to give up taxing and spending as social requirements.
It's just too emotional for them.