When is austerity a reasonable economic solution?
It's quite amazing that this question is still being posed, especially when the most prominent examples of its use have been nothing short of disaster. In particular in the Euro block and in the United Kingdom, with Austerity delivering pretty much what a polite person would call an anemic recovery. Now of course, it's difficult to say exactly what the solution really is, but that is the topic of yet another discussion.
With regards to austerity specifically, one can ask, can it ever be a reasonable solution to an economic problem. I hesitate to use the word 'justified' in this context as has been used repeatedly because the term justified implies a simplistic either or thought process, and with the economy being an extremely complex beast, it's probably not a reasonable question.
So, when can austerity be considered a reasonable economic policy. It's actually not that difficult to determine if and when austerity can be considered reasonable policy, but it's actually kind of difficult to explain it.
Essentially austerity as a policy can be reasonably applied if and only if the economic factors that exist in the economy are not going to be further harmed by the use of austerity. This can be simply described as, when the economy is growing, then the government should be applying austerity measures, and when the economy is shrinking, applying austerity will further shrink the economy.
Now of course, this sounds quite familiar, because it should, it's the basic premise of Keynesian economics, the concept of counter cyclical economic actions on the part of the government.
The reality of economics is that some concepts are used successfully in a very specific circumstance, and ultimately end up being considered a general rule. In the case of austerity, this is further compounded by the historical aspect and the world under a gold standard monetary system and classical economic theory (not that much modern economic theory is all that much better, but another day's topic).
In the case of austerity, it has been applied successfully in a number of situation, and appears to have been successfully applied in a number of others, but either was disastrous or have not had much impact. Lets look at these just to see the circumstances and conditions:
Estonia
After the 2008 crisis, Estonia also suffered a financial crisis, and as policy it committed to austerity measures. In doing so, the nation appears to have gotten back on its feet, but when one looks into the details of their 'recovery', it's clear that it's impact is much more muted, if not totally disastrous.
What has happened in that country is that the national wealth of the nation has dropped significantly, incomes have likewise dropped. Pension funds have lost much of their value, but another much less reported factor is that 20% of it's population just got up and left the country. Most of it's younger population left to find work in the rest of Europe (euro block) and the UK.
So while job growth is happening, and the level of unemployment has dropped, it's only done so as a massive permanent retrenchment and lowered economic presence of most of its population.
Success story, I think not.
Iceland
After the 2008 crisis, Iceland committed to austerity measures to try and right itself. So far, it appears to have worked somewhat, but this completely misses a simple reality of that nation's problems. Iceland didn't have an internal economic crisis as much as it had an external one. Almost all of it's economic problems were because of its involvement in the derivatives markets.
The nation of Iceland didn't have to apply austerity to get back on its feet, all it had to do as a nation was disavow any connection to external markets (which is another thing that the nation did in its response). So what was determined to be a solution, was actually more of a distraction. It's banking actions had more to do with any recovery than anything.
It should also be noted that both of the nations noted above are very tiny compared to many of the nations that continue to have problems today. Iceland has a population of under 400 thousand people, Estonia, just a few million people. Neither one of those nations have a global economic presence to make much of a difference either way.
The Success Stories
This brings us to the next two nations that applied Aausterity, and both were able to successfully apply those policies, at least mild austerity, and not seriously harm their respective nations economies. These nations are Ireland and Canada. Both nations applied austerity measures in the mid to late 90's, and did so with some success.
However, both nations had a very specific circumstance that made the policies work in that they were both exporting nations, with one nation being the primary destination for their exports, and additionally, and probably most importantly, conducted their austerity measures at a time where that primary export market was experiencing a boom economy. If that boom economy in their respective export market did not exist, then austerity would have led to economic disaster.
Now if we look at these very specific situations of where austerity was applied and was a reasonable policy choice, it should be pretty clear that the United States today, along with the UK, and the EUro block exhibit NONE of the conditions that would make austerity a reasonable policy choice.
Why we still talk about it as even possibly reasonable is probably a much larger mystery.

I agree.
I'm guessing that in the case of Canada you are referring to energy exports to the US . Was energy getting pricey in the latter part of the 90's ?
Inter-country economics can quickly get complicated . Thanks for supplying some details ... and for plunging into this important topic .
I'm not sure I understand what that means.
What are "trans-national financial/economic issues."?
What are thse issues that are today affecting the U.S.?
I think he's referring to things like the imbalance of trade in the US . We import more than we export .
Thanks for your insights . I'm going to research that ...