╌>

The Depression that was Fixed by Doing Nothing.

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  sean-treacy  •  11 years ago  •  19 comments

The Depression that was Fixed by Doing Nothing.
To combat the Great Recession and its long-lingering aftermath, leading central banks have pulled some $10 trillion out of thin air. Governments of the worlds principal economies have rung up almost $20 trillion in deficit spending. We often hear that the authorities have done too little. Perhaps they have done too much.Not so long ago, the authorities did hardly anything. In response to the severe, little-known economic slump of the early 1920s, they virtually sat on their hands. It is an often forgotten episode that suggests the potential for constructive federal inactionand underscores the healing power of Adam Smith s invisible hand.Beginning in January 1920, something much worse than a recession blighted the world. The U.S. suffered the steepest plunge in wholesale prices in its history (not even eclipsed by the Great Depression), as well as a 31.6% drop in industrial production and a 46.6% fall in the Dow Jones Industrial Average. Unemployment spiked, and corporate profits plunged.What to do? Nothing was the substantive response of the successive administrations of Woodrow Wilson and Warren G. Harding. Well, not quite nothing. Rather, they did what few 21st-century policy makers would have dared: They balanced the federal budget andvia the still wet-behind-the-ears Federal Reserveraised interest rates rather than lowering them. Curiously, the depression ran its course. Eighteen months elapsed from business-cycle peak to business-cycle troughfollowing which the 1920s roared.The adage that the past is a foreign country is especially apt in economics. In 1920, macroeconomics had yet to be invented. People spoke of prosperity and depression but not of a national economy. Still less did they identify an organic whole for the government to manage. Intervention came later; by 1929, central bankers had begun to dabble in the technique of price-level stabilization. After the crash, President Herbert Hoover famously pressed employers not to cut wages.Laissez faire had its last hurrah in 1921. In the 1920 Republican Party platform, the only comment on national economy had to do with the stewardship of the federal finances.Borrowing and interest-rate suppression during World War I had fostered a postwar boom. Imbibing the inflationary ether, Harry Truman, then in his mid-30s, opened a new haberdashery in Kansas City. General Motors built the worlds largest headquarters building in Detroit. National City Bank , forerunner to todays Citibank , overexpanded in Cuba.The sky took its time in falling. A belated monetary tightening compounded the hardship of plunging pricesa combination that battered bankers, laborers, farmers, corporate titans and small businesspeople alike. By the close of 1920, Billy Durant, the flamboyant chief of GM, was broke and jobless. A year and a half later, the future 33rd president of the U.S. and his haberdashery partner were out of business, and the mighty City Bank was nursing its self-inflicted wounds in Cuba.All this made 1921 a grim time. There had been a flu pandemic and a Red Scare. Labor and management were at each others throats. Prohibition had closed the bars and taverns (or driven them underground). Someone had fixed the 1919 World Series. And the Federal Reserve, determined to protect the purchasing power of the gold dollar, actually raised interest rates in the face of collapsing business activityto as much as 8% in 1920. Without a federal safety net, people got by on savings, wits or charityor they didnt get by.In the absence of anything resembling government stimulus, a modern economist may wonder how the depression of 1920-21 ever ended. Oddly enough, deflation turned out to be a tonic. Pricesand, critically, wages toowere allowed to fall, and they fell far enough to entice consumers, employers and investors to part with their money. Europeans, noticing that America was on the bargain counter, shipped their gold across the Atlantic, where it swelled the depression-shrunken U.S. money supply. Shares of profitable and well-financed American companies changed hands at giveaway valuations.Of course, the year-and-a-half depression must have seemed interminable for all who were jobless or destitute. It was, however, a great deal shorter than the 43 months of the Great Depression of 1929-33. Then too, the 1922 recovery would bring tears of envy to todays central bankers and policy makers: Passenger-car production shot up by 63%, for instance, and the Dow jumped by 21.5%. From practically all angles, this newspaper judged in a New Years Day 1923 retrospective, 1922 can be recorded as the renaissance of prosperity.In 2008, as Lehman Brothers toppled, the Great Depression monopolized the market on historical analogies. To avoid a recurrence of the 1930s, officials declared, the U.S. had to knock down interest rates, manipulate stock prices to go higher, repave the highways and trade in the clunkers.The forgotten depression teaches a very different lesson. Sometimes the best stimulus is none at all.Mr. Grant is the author of The Forgotten Depression: 1921: The Crash That Cured Itself. http://www.wsj.com/articles/the-depression-that-was-fixed-by-doing-nothing-1420212315

Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   seeder  Sean Treacy    11 years ago
Harding, an underrated President, oversaw a quick, powerful recovery from a depression. The contrast between the dynamic recovery under Harding and the current administration's ongoing stagnation from a recession could not be greater.
 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    11 years ago

Oddly enough, deflation turned out to be a tonic. Pricesand, critically, wages toowere allowed to fall, and they fell far enough to entice consumers, employers and investors to part with their money. Europeans, noticing that America was on the bargain counter, shipped their gold across the Atlantic, where it swelled the depression-shrunken U.S. money supply.

That was back in the day when the money supply was the amount of gold . It was a very different era . But there may be a good point about the salutary effects of a mild deflation ...

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    11 years ago

No, deflation would be very very bad in today's context.

Even a mild one ?

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    11 years ago

What makes today different in that regard compared to the Harding era ?

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    11 years ago

it increases the relative debt of a company relative to its capacity to service that debt

That's quite interesting . I'm going to need to research that more . But wasn't that also true in Harding's era ?

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    11 years ago

There are certain properties to a traditional gold standard based currency that necessitate an inflationary/deflationary cycle which doesn't exist in a fiat system.

I appreciate your attention to the details . This is outside of my area of expertise but I still find it extremely interesting . I don't suppose you can link to the math of those ideas ... that would be my strength.

 
 
 
Steve Ott
Professor Silent
link   Steve Ott    11 years ago

Government is not always the answer.

Thank Gridlock for Economic Turnaround

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    11 years ago

It is my understanding that Japan has experienced deflation for many successive years . But it's economy has not collapsed . Perhaps your perception of the dangers of deflation is overblown ?

 
 
 
Steve Ott
Professor Silent
link   Steve Ott    11 years ago

The current government is then art heat thing from the answer.

I seem to have lost my Babel fish.

So, if in the 1920s, it wasn't government or the private sector that fixed things, who did? The white mice running this experiment?

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    11 years ago

Thanks for addressing my issue directly . Well done . Your explanations show a broad grasp of the factors in international economics .

 
 

Who is online