Scottish Police: We are Watching you Online, Don't Say Anything Rude
A few days ago, police in Scotland made this promise:And John Stuart Mill cried out from his grave.I would like to report that this represents little more than an idle threat, or, perhaps, that it is merely the product of a rogue and overzealous intern. But, alas, I cannot. As The Independents James Bloodworth noted this week, this is in fact rather typical. Around 20,000 people in Britain have been investigated in the past three years for comments made online, Bloodworth confirms, with around 20 people a day being looked into by the forces of the law, according to figures obtained under the Freedom of Information Act. Worse, some of these people have actually been imprisoned: among them, a woman found guilty of a public order offence for saying that David Cameron had blood on his hands, a man named Azhar Ahmed, who was prosecuted for an online post mocking the deaths of six British soldiers killed in Afghanistan, and a young man named Liam Stacey who tweeted something unprintable at a top-flight soccer player and was incarcerated for two months in consequence.They may soon be joined by another. As I write, a deliberately edgy columnist named Katie Hopkins is being looked into by police for having been a little unpleasant on the Internet. Taking to Twitter earlier this week, Hopkins offered a gratuitously crude criticism of an Ebola nurse, dismissively described the Scottish people as sweaty little jocks, and suggested (correctly in my view) that the countrys National Health Service sucks. These relatively mild provocations were enough to push the police into action. We have received a number of complaints regarding remarks made on Twitter, Detective Inspector Glyn Roberts told the press. Inquiries are ongoing into the nature of these tweets and to establish any potential criminality. Ominously, Roberts then sought to encourage les autres. Police Scotland will thoroughly investigate any reports of offensive or criminal behaviour online, he added. Anyone found to be responsible will be robustly dealt with.You will note with horror the illiberal conflation of the word offensive and the word criminal.That the civil authorities would consider that investigating Hopkins is an appropriate use of their power is extremely alarming. Once upon a time, the British government sought to export liberty; now, it seems, it is determined gradually to dismantle it. And yet, as ugly as the move is, it is by no means the worst part of this story. The worst part, per Bloodworth, is this:Meanwhile, an online petition calling for Hopkins arrest has amassed over 22,000 signaturesIn situations such as these, it is easy and tempting to blame the police for their excesses, and to contend with irritation that they should know better. And so, of course, they should. It is easy, too, to slam the British parliament for continuing to permit such behavior. And, of course, it should be so slammed. Nevertheless, the ugly truth here is that, like the Canadians and the Australians and the New Zealanders and pretty much every people in the world apart from the Americans, there is a significant contingent within the British electorate that believes that the state should punish people who utter words and sentiments that the majority dislikes. Of course the police are looking into the rude and the eccentric. Their employers want them to do exactly that, and there are no constitutional prohibitions to prevent them from doing so.Cultures rot from the bottom up. In a democracy, the authorities come to reflect societal trends both good and ill. How sad to see Adam Smiths body decaying in the streets.There are still 77 unsolved murders on Police Scotlands books. http://www.nationalreview.com/corner/395655/scottish-police-we-are-watching-you-online-dont-say-anything-rude-charles-c-w-cooke

The answer is to write volumes of confusing material that the cops are too ignorant to understand . My choice would be tech jargon ... Drop a few political comments in between with every other word , in color s.t. simple searches won't uncover it .
It's a travesty one even has to think in those terms.
A few more progressives appointed to the Supreme Court and the USA may be heading down the same path.
I have to admit that the Scottish authorities are going much too far ...
We're already there Sean. Most people just don't realize it and won't until it knocks on their door.
You're late to the party, conservative boys
It happened under George W. Bush!
It's one thing to spread your myopic demagoguery, and yet another to do so from a zeal-without-knowledge "mind" set.
Sixpick made a pronouncement; I set him straight on the timeframe and the guilty administration.
They're not related? Really? Aside from your typical righty conflation, Sean, do you think the government collects data for the hell of it?
But I'll tell ya' what; I'm going to bed now, but tomorrow, first thing, I'll send an e-mail to the NSA and ask what's up with the data mining thing. 'Course, I won't have to actually send them the e-mail because they'll have it (if you know what I mean).
I'm real tired of you boys calling everything that kicks your ass a little bit as "off topic," "not related," "deflection," deal with it or don't start these discussions that look like one thing but all lead down the road to liberal bashing.
First thing in the morning although they'll probably have read this so I won't have to send anything.
G'night boys.
Well, you're right in part of what you said A Mac. I don't particularly appreciate the two book rule either. You know the one where the liberal calls the the homosexuals bad names and the liberals don't say a think about it, but when the conservative says do what you like, but I don't care for it myself and the liberals go rabid.
You didn't set me straight in any way. Who do you think puts up these stupid intolerant rules for children. Who do you think expels a child for pointing their finger at another child and charges then like they have a gun. I promise you it isn't the Libertarians or the Conservatives.
It really doesn't matter whether it is liberal or conservative at this point in time. It's here and it's the government over the people, not by the people.
At the most basic level, the NSA is snooping on communications that are intended to be private. The citizens of Scotland are being arrested for statements made publicly on social media like Facebook and Twitter. Privacy rights have nothing to with tweets that are disseminated for the public
'I feel like a stranger where I live
As new figures show 'white flight' from cities is rising, one Londoner writes a provocative personal piece about how immigration has drastically changed the borough where she has lived for 17 years
Multicultural: the shops in Acton Vale, west London Photo: Jeff Gilber
"When you go swimming, its much healthier to keep your whole body completely covered, you know. The Muslim lady behind the counter in my local pharmacy has recently started giving me advice like this. Its kindly meant and Im always glad to hear her views because she is one of the few people in west London where I live who talks to me.
The streets around Acton, which has been my home since 1996, have taken on a new identity. Most of the shops are now owned by Muslims and even the fish and chip shop and Indian takeaway are Halal. It seems that almost overnight its changed from Acton Vale into Acton Veil.
Of the 8.17 million people in London, one million are Muslim, with the majority of them young families. That is not, in reality, a great number. But because so many Muslims increasingly insist on emphasising their separateness, it feels as if they have taken over; my female neighbours flap past in full niqab, some so heavily veiled that I cant see their eyes. Ive made an effort to communicate by smiling deliberately at the ones I thought I was seeing out and about regularly, but this didnt lead to conversation because they never look me in the face.
I recently went to the plainly named Curtain Shop and asked if they would put some up for me. Inside were a lot of elderly Muslim men. I was told that they dont do that kind of work, and was back on the pavement within a few moments. I felt sure I had suffered discrimination and was bewildered as I had been there previously when the Muslim owners had been very friendly. Things have changed. I am living in a place where I am a stranger.
I was brought up in a village in Staffordshire, and although I have been in London for a quarter of a century I have kept the habit of chatting to shopkeepers and neighbours, despite it not being the done thing in metropolitan life. Nowadays, though, most of the tills in my local shops are manned by young Muslim men who mutter into their mobiles as they are serving. They have no interest in talking to me and rarely meet my gaze. I find this situation dismal. I miss banter, the hail fellow, well met chat about the weather, or what was on TV last night.
Related Articles
Can you pass the British immigration exam?
27 Jan 2013Theresa May blocks moves to ease immigration rules
25 Jan 2013Police battling 7,500 crime gangs that cost the country 100 million a day
25 Jan 2013More worryingly, I feel that public spaces are becoming contested. One food store has recently installed a sign banning alcohol on the premises. Fair enough. But it also says: No alcohol allowed on the streets near this shop. I am no fan of street drinking, and rowdy behaviour and loutish individuals are an aspect of modern British ''culture I hate. But I feel uneasy that this shopkeeper wants to control the streets outside his shop. I asked him what he meant by his notice but he just smiled at me wistfully.
Perhaps he and his fellow Muslims want to turn the area into another Tower Hamlets, the east London borough where ''suggestive advertising is banned and last year a woman was refused a job in a pharmacy because she wasnt veiled.
On the other hand, maybe I should be grateful. At least in Acton there is just a sign in a shop. Since the start of the year there have been several reports from around London of a more aggressive approach. Television news footage last week showed incidents filmed on a mobile phone on a Saturday night, in the borough of Waltham Forest, of men shouting This is a Muslim area at white Britons.
The video commentary stated: From women walking the street dressed like complete naked animals with no self-respect, to drunk people carrying alcohol, we try our best to capture and forbid it all.
Another scene showed hooded youths forcing a man to drop his can of lager, telling him they were the Muslim patrol and that alcohol is a forbidden evil. The gang then approached a group of white girls enjoying a good night out, telling them to forbid themselves from dressing like this and exposing themselves outside the mosque.
Worse, though, is film footage from last week, thought to have been taken in Commercial Street, Whitechapel, which showed members of a group who also called themselves a Muslim patrol harassing a man who appeared to be wearing makeup, calling him a bloody fag. In the video posted on YouTube last week, the passer-by is told he is walking through a Muslim area dressed like a fag and ordered to get out. Last Thursday, police were reported to have arrested five vigilantes suspected of homophobic abuse.
There are, of course, other Europeans in my area who may share my feelings but Im not able to talk to them easily about this situation as they are mostly immigrants, too. At Christmas I spoke to an elderly white woman about the lack of parsnips in the local greengrocer, but she turned out to have no English and I was left grumbling to myself.
Poles have settled in Ealing since the Second World War and are well assimilated, but since 2004 about 370,000 east Europeans have arrived in London. Almost half the populations of nearby Ealing and Hammersmith were born outside the UK. Not surprisingly, at my bus stop I rarely hear English spoken. I realise that we cant return to the time when buses were mainly occupied by white ladies in their best hats and gloves going shopping, but I do feel nostalgic for the days when a journey on public transport didnt leave me feeling as if I have only just arrived in a strange country myself.
There are other cultural differences that bother me, too. Over the past year I have been involved in rescuing a dog that was kept in a freezing shed for months. The owners spoke no English. A Somali neighbour kept a dog that he told me he was training to fight, before it was stolen by other dog fighters. I have tried to re-home several cats owned by a family who refuse to neuter their animals, because of their religion.
In the Nineties, when I arrived, this part of Acton was a traditional working-class area. Now there is no trace of any kind of community that word so cherished by the Left. Instead it has been transformed into a giant transit camp and is home to no one. The scale of immigration over recent years has created communities throughout London that never need to or want to interact with outsiders.
It wasnt always the case: since the 1890s thousands of Jewish, Irish, Afro-Caribbean, Asian and Chinese workers, among others, have arrived in the capital, often displacing the indigenous population. Yes, there was hateful overt racism and discrimination, Im not denying that. But, over time, I believe we settled down into a happy mix of incorporation and shared aspiration, with disparate peoples walking the same pavements but returning to very different homes something the Americans call sundown segregation.
But now, despite the wishful thinking of multiculturalists, wilful segregation by immigrants is increasingly echoed by the white population the rate of white flight from our cities is soaring. According to the Office for National Statistics, 600,000 white Britons have left London in the past 10 years. The latest census data shows the breakdown in telling detail: some London boroughs have lost a quarter of their population of white, British people. The number in Redbridge, north London, for example, has fallen by 40,844 (to 96,253) in this period, while the total population has risen by more than 40,335 to 278,970. It isnt only London boroughs. The market town of Wokingham in Berkshire has lost nearly 5 per cent of its white British population.
I suspect that many white people in London and the Home Counties now move house on the basis of ethnicity, especially if they have children. Estate agents dont advertise this self-segregation, of course. Instead there are polite codes for that kind of thing, such as the mention of a good school, which I believe is code for mainly white English. Not surprising when you learn that nearly one million pupils do not have English as a first language.
I, too, have decided to leave my area, following in the footsteps of so many of my neighbours. I dont really want to go. I worked long and hard to get to London, to find a good job and buy a home and Id like to stay here. But Im a stranger on these streets and all the good areas, with safe streets, nice housing and pleasant cafs, are beyond my reach. I see London turning into a place almost exclusively for poor immigrants and the very rich.
Its sad that I am moving not for a positive reason, but to escape something. I wonder whether Ill tell the truth, if Im asked. I cant pretend that Im worried about local schools, so perhaps Ill say its for the chance of a conversation over the garden fence. But really I no longer need an excuse: mass immigration is making reluctant racists of us all.
~Link~
Don't worry, we're next.
The fact that a government does indiscriminate data mining is certainly a "smoking gun." The only "categorical" difference in what you posted and what I commented is the uncertainty of the ultimate objectives in the case of our government, and, the likely, only, "partial" disclosure by the Scottish police as to what they're doing.
And I didn't broach the "liberal" bashing, Sean, YOU DID!
Then Six piled on.
And Six, you want to talk "double standard?" How 'bout the conservative who gives tax breaks to the rich at the expense of the poor child who dies because his family can't afford health insurance -- or pandering to Christians while passing other un-Christ-like initiatives?
But these are somewhat generic say the word and I'll list specifics.
And, Sean, from the article
Do you assume that doesn't happen here?
The fact that a government does indiscriminate data mining is certainly a "smoking gun.
Data mining is a privacy issue, it has nothing to do with the first amendment rights of someone speaking openly in the virtual public square, which is what is being criminalized in Scotland.
How you believe data mining is a smoking gun on this quesiton is beyond me.
And I didn't broach the "liberal" bashing
Liberals and liberal jurists are much more amenable to speech codes and criminalizing speech than conservatives. I don't think that is particularly controversial. Scotland is, after all, one of the most progressive regions in the world.
Do you assume that doesn't happen here?
I'm not aware of the Obama administration investigating and punishing people for saying Obamacare sucks on twitter. Are you saying the Obama Administration is even more anti-first amendment than I believe?
I'm also not aware of an Americans being put in jail for calling someone a racial epitaph online. Do you have any evidence that theses things have happened?
Investigating someone for possible terrorist activities is not the same thing as investigating them for posting politically incorrect things. I trust you can see the difference.
You're splitting hairs. That which is posted "in private" and is data mined can be used as evidence, thus, potentially and realistically, is as "public" as is actual "public. The fact that so-called "private" e-mails, etc. are as accessible to the government through data mining and drone acquisition of cell phone information, etc., makes the notion of "privacy," a naive one, Sean.
Once anywhere in cyberspace, it's public as far as the government is concerned.
And again, YOU made this political with this.
If you believe that, you underestimate the the sophistication of the government; it's not about "ignorant cops."
What gives you so much confidence in that statement ? Cops are certainly ignorant about the Bill of Rights these days . Perhaps that would be a better topic than tech speak .