╌>

"Your spending is my income and my spending is your income" by Slartbartfast

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  slartibartfast  •  12 years ago  •  32 comments

"Your spending is my income and my spending is your income" by Slartbartfast

Ever since the 2009 crisis, we have heard Economist Paul Krugman make the following statement:

"Your spending is my income and my spending is your income"

Or something to that effect. Personally, I have never been all that comfortable with that statement, but not because it isn't correct, because it mostly is, but mostly because it is a disturbing oversimplification of a pretty basic economic concept. It's unclear where this particular statement was coined, but it appears to have come from the development of Modern Monetary Theory, which seems to be yet another modern economic theory which tries to explain everything about economics through the optics of a very narrow aspect of the economy, in the case of MMT, monetary policy.

Having seen this though, it does a really good job of explaining why I have never been comfortable with it, and why it's probably not something that Krugman should continue saying, in particular because Krugman is a Keynesian economist, not an MMT advocate.
Now for those that don't know about Paul Krugman's background, he is an economist that has spent much of his academic research career on international trade. His ph.d and his Nobel Prize award were for work based on that research, and in this area, Paul Krugman is quite frankly brilliant.

His understanding of monetary policy and central banking however is much less adept. That isn't to say that he can't figure it out, but it just doesn't seem to be his interest, which is understandable, because monetary policy is for the most part mechanical in nature, and not all that interesting from an academic or research point of view. But it is extremely important to understand that it really isn't his strength, but he also doesn't really talk much about it either, so it is not something that he pretends to be an expert in either.

Now, when it comes to Keynesian economics, it is important to note that Keynes never wrote about income as revenue, or revenue as income, and the problem with the above statement is that it makes it far too easy to confuse the two. They are very different. In his writing, Keynes always treated margin as the ultimate business objective from an economic perspective, not revenue. He understood very clearly that if a business has no margin (profit), then it cannot stay in business. Anyone that has read Keynes with an objective view would understand this.

However, Keynes also understood that in the context of economic activity, if everyone saves, then ultimately nobody saves. In economics terms, this is referred to as the "paradox of thrift". This is where the above quote is completely accurate, and it is this concept which is the prime driver of his idea of countercyclical spending, because in times of economic contraction, someone needs to spend, and during that downturn, it is the government that is the only entity that can spend, and should spend until private sector spending can resume, at which point the government should stop spending.

What is missing from all of this however is the scenario where the 'private entities' (businesses and consumers) cannot spend (as opposed to choosing not to spend, which is what one would see in a 'cyclical' recession). Currently we are in a position where the private entities that need to spend cannot spend, and those that can spend have no need to spend.

This is creating a serious disconnect between the normal supply and demand pressures. It also throws a kink into the entire Keynesian philosophy, because there is nothing that we can do from a Keynesian perspective to try and bring the economy back to a point where those private entities can or need to start spending again.

It might be best to think of it this way. Someone is bleeding from an artery, so how do you save that person's life. Well you can start to transfuse blood into that person, thereby making sure that they don't bleed out and die, but is that really solving the underlying economic problem? No it isn't, because there is nothing in that process that allows one to remove one from that transfusion. It creates a requirement for a continual supply of blood. Unless one is taking steps to fix the artery, the underlying problem isn't solved.

Unfortunately, just hooking the economy up to that transfusion of money is the only solution that seems to be working, and BOTH parties basically only have that to offer (though each party presents it in different ways, to meet the needs of each party's constituency). Both parties ignore the simple reality that margin or profits are what is really important when it comes to digging us out of this economic dilemma, which has been referred to as "Secular Stagnation", a very apt description by a very repugnant, if not extremely smart, if not brilliant economist, Andrew Summers.

To the main point, no Paul Krugman, your spending is not my income, it is my revenue, and if my costs are higher than my revenue, then I still go out of business. But if you want to take that to the consumer side, if my costs as a consumer are higher than my wages, then the only thing that can be done is to increase my wages, but that is again going to increase my costs, which will then bring my wages below the cost.

Now of course, he knows this, his textbooks which cover this are among the best economics textbooks that exist today, but when he makes these comments, what everyone needs to understand is that he is making a political statement as much as he is making an economic one. What we need is a little bit more economics, and a lot less politics.


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man    12 years ago

But if you want to take that to the consumer side, if my costs as a consumer are higher than my wages, then the only thing that can be done is to increase my wages, but that is again going to increase my costs, which will then bring my wages below the cost.

There is another thing that can be done, reduce costs below wages. What your describing above is the current liberal political mantra of what needs to be done. In essence so spending (your revenue) can continue. (or hopefully increase) But it doesn't take into account economic realities of the profit driven model.

This article touches on that reality, in that if there is no profit, they why bother trying.

Margin, is innate to the human psyche in both it's forms, it is natively understood. It takes two forms. the difference between what is coming in and what is going out. (which is it's base form) and the difference in what needs to be borrowed to support the outlays, or support what generates the outlays.

One side is a value based system or ideal, the other is a debt driven system/ideal.

Humans innately understand both. a value based system is preferable to a debt driven one, but we usually wind up with a debt driven one because of the model used to manipulate the system in attempts to make it profitable all the time.

Currently both political sides support the debt driven model and it's roller coaster economic patterns of boom and bust. Economists are still, at this late date, trying to find the "Sweet Spot" of market forces to make the economies around the world both profitable and self sustaining.

We need to get back to a valuation driven model, and remove the desire to increase profit at the expense of debt which is passed on to others. To do that, we need people that understand that the blind drive for profit cannot the driving force in economics, sustainability must be the driving force.

But to do that, we need to teach morals and ethics, that one doesn't need any more than what makes them comfortable and sustains them.

Greed is the enemy, debt is its weapon, and it is all consuming.

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   Robert in Ohio    12 years ago

Slarti

Very interesting article and a somewhat clearer picture of complex issues (monetary policy and the recovery) than is proffered by the politicians or the talking heads that advocate for the politicians.

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man    12 years ago

That statement is too generic to really mean anything, Will wait for your return to elaborate.

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man    11 years ago

Thank you for clarifying,

100% agreement.

They can claim recovery all they want, but for those who really understand, it just isn't there, yet.

You can't have a recovery without spending, but you can't have one either with too much spending.

Interest rates are being held artificially low. when they bring them back up to norms, hard inflation will start and we will see the real result of all the government largess.

the rise in prices we have currently been experiencing for the last few year is nothing to the rise we will see when they start easing the freeze on interest rates

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    11 years ago

Another point besides the amount of spending might be what the spending goes towards ...

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    11 years ago

Putting myself in Krugman's shoes I can understand the desire to favor the strictly quantitative approach .
For one thing when you start to specify how to spend money you draw criticism about supporting special interests .
Perhaps the answer is to talk about what sectors to avoid spending in . For example , it might be better to avoid the luxury goods sector if only because it would not circulate the funds widely . [This is off the top of my head & not a detailed analysis .]

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    11 years ago

He only needs to say, "we need fiscal policies that promote new industries, and replacement economic activities" but he only really talks about income redistribution, and not the this, that and the other things that will make that redistribution much more sustainable.

The issue of new industry is hard to discuss without talking about the issue of labor costs in China . That is still a problem today even though it has gotten to be less of a problem ... And I'm guessing that talking about the price of labor in the US is a dangerous topic .

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    11 years ago

If we continue to try and compete with China on low margin industries, then yes, we will lose every time.

Unfortunately that is not the only issue . There is also the expansion of automation in US industry . That's why I said that the topic is dangerous ...

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    11 years ago

Starti from here :

The question of automation by he way was the same question that was running through the economy with industrialization and the with mass production.

I don't think it is exactly identical . Industrialization and mass production allowed whole new industries to develop that turned luxury goods into products for the masses . Where can you find similar outcomes with automation ?

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    11 years ago

Obama's concept of new industry WAS green industry . But that has not produced much in the way of new employment . Can you suggest other ideas for today ?

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    11 years ago

Just out of curiosity what is your impression of this :

 
 
 
Steve Ott
Professor Silent
link   Steve Ott    11 years ago

If We Only Spent All the Money, Then Everyone Would Be Prosperous!

What would happen if we quit giving our money to the government and just spent it ourselves?

 
 
 
Steve Ott
Professor Silent
link   Steve Ott    11 years ago

Perhaps you can provide some history. (I only took Eco because it was required.) What government investment was it that made the US the economic leader of the world?

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    11 years ago

Your focus on that single number without the rest of the details does not demonstrate real interest . This is an entirely new cycle that exceeds the performance of steam which is still being used exclusively since the industrial revolution . This involves a different state of matter [a supercritical fluid ] which has very different characteristics from the standard liquid to gas cycle formerly employed .

In my experience those in the economics game are seldom adept at dealing with engineering concepts . Instead they focus only on single numbers and ignore more dramatic changes that engineering can bring about .

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    11 years ago

Fair enough . But the last time I dealt with a finance expert on this site he completed ignored basic energy computations claiming that monetary considerations were the only thing that mattered . He is no longer with us for various reasons ...

 
 
 
Steve Ott
Professor Silent
link   Steve Ott    11 years ago

And you are quite certain of this?

While it is true that it had the largest percentage of world GDP from the 40s to the 70s, it still had the largest percentage beginning in the early 1900s.

 
 
 
Steve Ott
Professor Silent
link   Steve Ott    11 years ago

Not a problem. I never know when I will actually be able to respond. I currently work in litigation support and my work is driven by court ordered deadlines.

 
 

Who is online


104 visitors