The Obama Bounce
![]()
Dean Baker is, of course, right: this is not a boom, and comparisons to the 1990s are insane. Still, growth has clearly picked up, and the public seems to be noticing . So what can we say about the Obama non-boom?
Id argue that much of what were seeing reflects the tapering off of austerity. The US has never had a proclaimed austerity plan, UK style, but weve had a lot of the thing itself, especially from cutbacks in state and local spending. Spending hasnt rebounded yet, but at least it has stopped shrinking:
And its important to realize that, despite all the rhetoric about how Obamacare / antibusiness rhetoric / Kenyan Islamic atheism is destroying business, the private sector has actually been relatively strong under Obama. Heres employment:
Since Obama took office, weve gained 6.7 million private-sector jobs, compared with just 3.1 million at the same point under Bush. But under Bush wed added 1.2 million public sector jobs, while under Obama weve cut 600,000. The point is that relatively good private sector performance has been masked by public-sector cutbacks; this is the opposite of what you usually hear, but thats no surprise.
What about the prospects looking forward? As Ive pointed out before, business investment has been relatively strong throughout. Residential investment, however, has been very low since 2006, suggesting that theres a backlog of pent-up demand, which should come into play in an improving job market. So thats one source of strength. Also, low oil prices are going to be mostly positive, although with some adverse regional effects; more on that in a later post.
Overall, then, the next year and probably the next two years are likely to be pretty good. This doesnt mean that the overall track record of policy has been good weve wasted trillions in foregone output, damaged the lives of millions if not tens of millions. But it will feel a lot better than the years before.
"... under Bush wed added 1.2 million public sector jobs, while under Obama weve cut 600,000."
Tags
Who is online
91 visitors

Personally, I think a society is sick if it can consider the economy to be booming, while unemployment remains high and salaries remain flat.
How did America come to consider the DOW to be a more significant measure than unemployment??
In fact, less Americans work than at the time of his inauguration.
Jeez... If I wanted a demonstration of denialism, I couldn't have asked for better. I wouldn't have dared put this up, in mockery! It is so far over the top that I would have backed off...
But here you are, Sean... and I kinda doubt that this is mockery, coming from you.
It is fascinating to watch the contortions of the Obama-haters, at every bit of good news...
C'mon mr. Data lover. I made a specific argument that opens itself to being rebutted with actual facts. That is, if you are capable of engaging in an actual dialogue. Or is juvenile whining and offering unsubstantiated opinions the sum total of your skills?
In other words... you invented pure BS... and now you want me to present facts.
--------------
I shouldn't laugh. I'm afraid that this demonstrates that you really do not understand what "facts" are.
That's sad.
C'mon, Gunny! You can do it! I know you can do it!
You can say, "Obama is doing this right".
C'mon, Gunny! You can do it!
If it were possible it would be a very simple thing to prove me wrong since I'm making a very specific data based argument. Do you understand what data is? Once your comfortable with that term, I'll even be so kind as to start you on the path of how to prepare a proper rebuttal.
First, find the total number of native born Americans employed employed pre recession. Then look at the number of native born Americans employed in November 2014. (Hint: there are fewer)
Second, look at the number of legal and illegal immigrants employed pre recession verses today (Hint: there are more)
Given that, please demonstrate that my statement that all of the net jobs created since the recession have gone to immigrants is wrong.
Here's what's actually sad . Neither you nor Krugman mentioned anything about the changes to average weekly wages . Are they up ?
Par for his course and agenda ...
Ummmm..... Neither of us mentioned that because... that was not the subject...
We didn't mention several zillion other subjects, for the same reason.
But... if you followed PK as assiduously as I, you would know that he has insisted several times, recently, on the fact that wages are NOT rising. This is important because it indicates that we are still a long way from full capacity.
Hi, Max...
Obviously not. I don't know how to have a thoughtful conversation with someone who pretends to understand a concept, while demonstrating that he does not.
Ignorance is not a barrier to thoughtful conversation, but bad faith is.
Max,
The posts were replies to me, and I seeded the article. To my mind, they were insults, presuming that I would not notice their being nonsense.
Ignoring the better measure of a problem for an inferior one is called intentional bias or cherry-picking . It's blatantly political but with no redeeming qualities ...
So ... this is one of your "ignore the important facts" articles for trivial BS?
WTF??
The economy is kinda sorta a BIG topic. People write books about it.
And people write columns about... particular aspects of the economy.
People write books about cars, too. And columns about particular aspects of cars. If I write an article about "headlights", I'll give numbers like candlepower. Should I give numbers for tire pressure? Am I "ignoring the better measure" just because you are fascinated by tires?
The "better measure" is the one that deals with the particular aspect at hand.
You are free to post on whatever aspects of the economy you like... but you don't get to decide the topic of my posts.
Gee, it's so kind of you to say upfront that you are going to criticize me for using an insult that I did not use...
I said you were tossing around concepts that, on the basis of your own posts, it appears you do not understand. You proudly trot out the Phillips Curve, although it has nothing to do with the seed, other than both touching on employment.
Krugman is talking about employment and demand, not employment and prices. Gah!
Well DUH!! That is true (on the condition that I understand your non-standard term " full economic capacity" correctly) of any economy at any time, under any conditions. Therefore it is "true", but totally useless...
Wow. Your posts demonstrate that you are in over your head... but YOU ASKED NO QUESTIONS! You might want to practice what you preach...
I asked you no questions because there were none to be asked. I didn't ask about unicorns, either...
But OTOH, I am so-o-o-o-o-o impressed by your rubbing shoulders with Krugman, Piketty and Stiglitz...
Hey! I just realized... Do you sometimes write economics articles over on NV? Oh, wow.... That is cool...
OK,Slartibartfast...
Cancer medicines can have some nasty side effects, so maybe that explains things.
We should stop here...