╌>

S.D. County May Screen Defendants Who Seek Free Lawyer

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  robert-in-ohio  •  12 years ago  •  1 comments

S.D. County May Screen Defendants Who Seek Free Lawyer

SIOUX FALLS, S.D. Judge John Hinrichs knows at least some of the people who request and receive an appointed lawyer in Minnehaha County could have afforded to hire their own .

The former public defender recalls working on some cases for months, only to have the clients hire someone else with money they once said they didn't have.

But nobody knows how many people who apply for court-appointed counsel can afford to hire their own lawyers. Applicants aren't required to document their income or assets, and their statements aren't checked for accuracy. In South Dakota, there are no definitive guidelines for income requirements.

Yet the costs for those lawyers can be high, both in pure dollars and in extreme caseloads for public defenders and advocate's offices, who carry as many as 173 cases at a time for clients deemed indigent.

Between the public defender, the public advocate and the costs of assigning private lawyers in conflict cases, Minnehaha County will pay more than $3.8 million for indigent defense this year. The county attempts to recoup attorney fees in all cases even those that are dismissed but the payments don't come close to covering the cost.

So far this year, defendants have reimbursed the county $824,197.

Those issues have prompted some officials to propose asking the courts to set eligibility guidelines for out-of-custody defendants charged with misdemeanors and require applicants to document their income. The proposal also would provide a position to verify those applications.

Minnehaha County Public Defender Traci Smith says the goal is to make sure the people who most need representation are getting it. The system now is too wide open, Smith says. "It can take away from our ability to help the clients who truly need it."

Public Advocate Cindy Howard doubts that misuse of the system is widespread. But the issue has prompted other states to look into their own regulations. In Minnesota and Nebraska, tracking projects over the past decade failed to ferret out fraud or misuse on a level that justified continuing review.

The right to a lawyer is well established, protected by the Sixth and 14th Amendments in the U.S. Constitution. The U.S. Supreme Court affirmed that right in the case of Gideon vs. Wainwright in 1963.

The exact outlines of eligibility for court-appointed counsel vary widely.

In South Dakota, the eligibility law is fairly broad. It says that if a defendant or detained person could be jailed for an alleged crime and "does not have sufficient money, credit or property to employ counsel," the judge should assign a lawyer. The judge's decision is discretionary.

Lawyer fees can be thousands of dollars, and lawyers often ask for retainers up front. Poverty guidelines don't always tell the whole story.

"I know $40,000 a year seems like a lot, but if you have three kids and a house payment, where's that extra income going to come from? You're looking at $1,000 to hire a lawyer, and that's on the cheap side," Judge John Schlimgen said. "We've all raised children. We have some idea of the expenses involved."

On the Monday after the Thanksgiving holiday, more than 40 people in Hinrichs' courtroom were either assigned a public defender or had a previously assigned public defenders reappointed on new charges. People who ask for a lawyer generally get one, Hinrichs said.

The numbers were higher but logical, as most of those defendants were in custody because they couldn't afford to bond out of jail after their arrest. Minnehaha County's proposal concerns only those who bond out and then later ask for a lawyer.

"If they can afford to get out, that's some indication that they have the ability to access funds when they need to," said Judge Larry Long, who presides over the 2nd Circuit and is helping the county review the process.

Appointments are common with out-of-custody defendants, as well. Karl Thoennes, Court Administrator for the 2nd Judicial Circuit, tracked applications for out-of-custody defendants who made their first court appearance between Oct. 20 and Oct. 24. Out of the 390 cases set that week, 84 defendants asked for court-appointed counsel. Only three applications were denied.

(read more at)

http://www.usatoday.com/story/news/nation/2014/12/20/sd-county-may-require-accused-to-prove-they-cant-afford-lawyer/20715645/


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    12 years ago

Everyone is entitled to an attorney, no one disputes that but is everyone entitled to an attorney at government expense, if they are in a position to afford to pay for a lawyer?

That seems to be the question here.

The right to a lawyer is well established, protected by the Sixth and 14th Amendments in the U.S. Constitution. The U.S. Supreme Court affirmed that right in the case of Gideon vs. Wainwright in 1963.

The exact outlines of eligibility for court-appointed counsel vary widely.

One judge notes

"If they can afford to get out, that's some indication that they have the ability to access funds when they need to," said Judge Larry Long, who presides over the 2nd Circuit and is helping the county review the process.

What do you think is the right to a lawyer at government expense an absolute?

 
 

Who is online








55 visitors