Open carry laws didn't stop cops from killing Tamir Rice or John Crawford
Police officers in Ohio shot and killed John Crawford in a Beavercreek Walmart and 12-year-old Tamir Rice outside of a Cleveland recreation center largely on the belief that they were carrying real guns. Both were carrying toy weapons, but the killings have sparked questions about why police were allowed to shoot two people for holding what appeared to be actual guns in a state where it is legal to openly carry them.
Legal experts say that open carry laws and the laws that govern police use of force don't really have much to do with each other. Here's why.
Open carry laws have little effect on legality of police use of force
Forty-four states allow their residents to carry firearms openly in public, according to OpenCarry.org . Thirty of those states don't require a permit to open carry. There are also varying regulations from state to state on where exactly an unconcealed gun is allowed. Ohio, for instance, allows open carry without a permit virtually anywhere with a major exception for keeping a gun in a car, which requires a concealed carry permit.
These laws generally allow people to carry guns in public without fear of arrest. Alan Gura, an attorney who helped fight gun-control laws in Washington, DC , said that, in a state where open carry is allowed, misuse of a firearm is definitely grounds for formal police intervention, but not mere possession.
However, the open carry laws have little to do with whether a police shooting is justified, experts say. As attorney and gun rights advocate David Kopel explained, police officers wouldn't be allowed to shoot someone just because he's wielding a gun where open carry is a legal. Under the two Supreme Court decisions Tennessee vs. Garner and Graham v. Connor that dictate police use of force, officers must show that they had an objectively reasonable belief that a suspect was a threat up to the moment the last bullet was fired.
"Let's say there's no open carry," Kopel said. "The officer has every right to intervene, to arrest, and so forth. But that doesn't mean you can shoot the guy." Unless that person brandishes his gun in a threatening manner, Kopel explained, a police officer wouldn't be justified in shooting.
Prior to the Crawford and Rice shootings, police officers reportedly heard from 911 callers that the suspects were waving firearms, which turned out to be toy guns, in a threatening manner. The legal question for the officers involved in these shootings isn't whether Crawford and Rice had a right to carry a gun in public, but whether they reasonably believed the reported threats were still present up to the moment they shot Crawford and Rice. Open carry laws don't play a role.
A grand jury declined to indict the police officer who shot Crawford. A grand jury in Cleveland will decide whether to indict Cleveland police officer Timothy Loehmann, who killed Rice, in the coming months.
Could black men who are openly carrying a weapon be seen as more of a threat than others?
Following the shootings of Crawford and Rice, many people questioned whether cops treat black people openly carrying guns differently than their white counterparts.
Charles Goodson, head of the Huey P. Newton Gun Club, called it a "valid argument." He said his predominantly African-American group, which holds regular open carry patrols and marches in Texas, has been harassed by heavily armed police in the past. In contrast, white open carry protests in the state faced limited police attention despite high levels of media scrutiny .
Jamelle Bouie , a writer at Slate, voiced some of his concerns on Twitter, which were further echoed by the hashtag #BlackOpenCarry .
Studies on implicit bias show cops may subconsciously perceive a black person with a gun as a threat more easily than a white person with a gun.
By putting police officers through a video game simulation , Josh Correll of the University of Colorado Boulder found cops generally pull the trigger more quickly against black suspects than white suspects when the suspect was seen carrying a weapon. That could suggest, Correll explained in August, that police officers may be more likely to incorrectly shoot a black suspect in a real-life environment.
"In the very situation in which [officers] most need their training," Correll said, "we have some reason to believe that their training will be most likely to fail them."
Open carry laws didn't stop cops from killing Tamir Rice or John Crawford , Vox

This is a test. How many visitors will post something pertinent to the seed? How many will just vent?
One of one....
One of two...
Two of three. Thank you, blue andbf!
Pure disruption. Interesting.
So , how many states have open carry laws ? If I'm not mistaken , when someone walks around on the street open carrying , people call the cops on him even though its legal ...
Those are both covered in the seed.
Sorry for my laxness . 44 states ... I'm astounded & not in a good way . Would you like to see a video of a white man being harassed by the cops for open carrying where its legal ?
There doesn't seem to be much of anything that stops cops from killing people.
We have laws that say one thing, and we have cops that believe the law is something else. Or perhaps their training is out of date and does not take into account current law.
Not particularly. I don't consider that two wrongs make a right.
You seem to be missing my point ...
I just read anews story that one of the ''open carry'' group that was running around Target and various resturants in Texas with long gunshas been arrested for a double murder. Seems she shot and killed her husband and step daughter.
I think you mean they have the power to do that , not the right . Of course that also applies to young white men as well ...
That isn't racism . It is also ageism & sexism since the victims are young & male . In fact cops also kill young white males ...
My point is just that these 44 states are not having a massive rush to open carry even if it is legal . The sight of a lone man carrying a gun [ a crowd toting guns even worse ?] brings complaint calls to the cops who are then forced to respond to the citizen complaints .
Yes, that seems very likely. And then things go downhill.....