California Drought 'Not Caused by Global Warming', official study finds
Dont blame man-made global warming for the devastating California drought, a new federal report says.
A report issued on Monday by the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration said natural variations mostly a La Nia weather oscillation were the primary drivers behind the drought that has now stretched to three years.
The studys lead author, Richard Seager of Columbia University, said the paper has not yet been published in a peer-reviewed scientific journal. He and NOAAs Martin Hoerling said 160 runs of computer models show heat-trapping gases should slightly increase winter rain in parts of California, not decrease.
The conditions of the last three winters are not the conditions that climate change models say would happen, Hoerling said. But he said La Nia, which is the cooler flip side of the warming of the central Pacific ocean, can only be blamed for about one-third of the drought. The rest of the causes can be from just random variation, he said.
Some outside climate scientists criticised the report, saying it did not take into effect how record warmth worsened the drought. California is having its hottest year on record, based on the first 11 months of the year and is 4.1 degrees warmer than the 20th-century average, according to the National Climatic Data Center.
This study completely fails to consider what climate change is doing to water in California, wrote Kevin Trenberth, head of climate analysis at the National Center for Atmospheric Research. He said the work completely misses how hotter air increases drying by evaporating more moisture from the ground.
In droughts, extra heat from global warming enhances the drying in a feedback effect, Trenberth and others said. But Hoerling said that is less of a factor in California because it is so near the ocean and its rain comes in storms coming off the Pacific.
Peer-reviewed studies are divided on whether the drought can be blamed on climate change. Others published earlier this year point more directly to changes in pressure of the Pacific that blocked rain from coming into California, but Hoerling and Seager dismissed them as not adequate.
Deke Arndt, climate monitoring chief for NOAAs National Climatic Data Center, said by some drought measures, the current California drought is slightly more intense than, but still comparable to, the late 1970s episode. Id put them at 1a and 1b on the list of historical multi-year drought episodes affecting California in modern times.

No argument that climate change is occurring and that society is accelerating it, but this study seems to challenge claims that the droughts are climate change rather than part of the normal cycle of things.
It wouldn't surprise me that this is part of a historical cycle. What is different now, than in the past, is that there is a lot more stress on the groundwater levels in the area. The population has significantly increased over time, and water use has gone WAY up. Not to mention there are more densely farmed areas, and manufacturing areas.
The geology of the area does not lend itself well to groundwater recharge/use. Simply put, the mountainous terrain increases runoff, the composition of the rocks to igneous renders the rocks unable to transmit or store groundwater well, and the few sand and gravel deposits are thin and have sharp boundaries. The California/Arizona/Nevada area have over used the resource to the point where it will already take thousands, if not millions of years to recharge the few viable aquifers. They have been "mining" the groundwater resource.
One can't help but wonder just what will happen out there, when the water runs out.
Dowser
Thanks for that feedback
Your explanation makes perfect sense and is easy to understand
Thanks. Simple is best, for me, always.
The Southern part of California has essentially been a desert for thousands of years. The only reason that it's habitable now is because the aqueduct has been bringing in water from the Colorado River since the 1930's. If the water runs out, they'll pump in some more from elsewhere, just as they are already doing.
Yeah, but where?
You can't put water where there isn't any.
If you could, I'd be a millionaire!
The key question for sure!
The other big sink for Colorado River water is Las Vegas . Given the choice of gambling or produce which would the rest of you choose ?
I've heard that they've been looking rather greedily at the Great Lakes, and have gotten a rather cold reception (as in "Not just no, but HELL NO") from the Governors of all the States and Provinces surrounding the Lakes.
I suppose that they could look at the Mississippi River Valley, or the Ohio River valley. The Great Lakes already have their own problems with lower groundwater tables... Unless they would be willing to provide some sort of solar power, then, I too would say Hell no.
One thing about it is we will have to make a choice one day for sure. The one thing we have the most is water, but usable water is a different thing. Like in Saudi Arabia, we may have to spend a lot of money to provide it where there is little.
I understand in Denver, the water is too alkaline to drink. I don't know this for sure, just have heard it and they have to have usable or drinkable water from elsewhere.
Years ago, about 25 years ago, there were all kinds of sand and gravel deposits just east of town... In fact, I had a job there to de-water the formations in order for the sand and gravel to be mined. They piped the water to a river, somewhere... No telling what it is like now...
Back in 1974, when I went with my folks, you could see the mountains from Limon, CO, on the KS/CO border. Then, 15 years later, in the late 1980s, you couldn't see the mountains from Denver.
Funny, isn't it? I mean funny peculiar, not HaHa funny...
Air pollution is a problem here ... but its much worse in China .
Actually CA, NV, CO, UT, AZ, NM WY and Mexico draw from the Colorado.
California also gets water from the Sacramento Delta, the aqueduct was built in the 1960's.
Arizona is the second biggest drawer of water from the Colorado.
Let Mexico take back Az . Those retirees ... hasta la vista !
With future uncertain, Colorado shields its water
....
Colorado wants to ensure its farms, wildlife and rapidly growing cities have enough water in the decades to come. It's pledging to provide downstream states every gallon they're legally entitled to, but not a drop more.
Well, I was there in February, and it certainly could have been cloudy all that time... I remember it being very foggy/smoggy. But I was out in the industrial part of town. I'm trying to think when it was, and I want to say about 1995... That era, anyway.
At Limon, in 1974, Daddy pulled off the road, and there were the Rockies, stretching from horizon to the opposite horizon. We were so excited! We had just made it through Kansas-- a looooong way. The air was like diamonds! We're not used to that here-- mountains WHUMP up out of the plains... Ours are more a gentle rolling hill, to sharper hill, to mountains. Of course our mountains are quite a bit more weathered, too! Maybe it was Pikes Peak-- how big is that? Does it go from one end to the other? You could see the snow on top... At the time, Daddy said Rockies, and we took him at his word.
Well, I was there in February, and it was foggy and rainy the whole time I was there. And COLD. I had to pace off 500' intervals for the wells. I was out there scrambling around, trying to watch the test driling crews and then driving away from that to go step off well intervals. UGH. Seems like I was only there for a week.
I was in the industrial section, about as far out from Denver proper, as one could get, and still be in Denver. I want to say it was 1995-ish.
I thought it was beautiful there-- the air was like diamonds, all those years ago in 1974. Daddy pulled off the side of the road, and we stood there, so excited! It's a long way across Kansas! The mountain range was crystal clear, although bluish, from the distance. You could see the snow caps on them. They were far away, but I didn't realize just HOW far away, until we drove the distance.
I always have loved Denver-- it's a great place and a beautiful city! I have no idea about their water supply-- other than years ago, we had to drill some heavy duty wells to de-water the sands and gravels for the mining operations. A 500' grid is pretty intensive. My only job was to oversee the drilling crews and pace off the well sites. I bet that now, that area is a large lake!
I meant no insult to Denver, Feronia-- I have loved that section of the country for a long time. I have a cousin that lives in Colorado Springs, now. She's a peach!
Thanks to everyone who has contributed feedback and perspective,
I seeded the article because I found it interesting (not that I knew anything about the actual problem) but I have learned quite a bit from this group of members.
That is why stay at NT, I learn things
Thanks
This comment disappeared, and then,voila-- it's back. So sorry for the double post!
Feronia,
What does Evergreen CO look like today? I spent a summer there helping my brother in law build his house.
Of course this was back in the day..late 1960's.
b f
I don't care what anyone says, that is funny and informative.
Thanks
Pikes Peak is a little over 14,000 ft.
I miss home.
I was stationed at Ft Carson in the 80's beautiful country for sure.
He lives in northern California now. Right on the CA. OR. border, Smith River CA.
Last time I was there was in the early 80's. It was stuck in the 30's then...LOL...No Starbucks either Feronia.
I, too, am having trouble with the site! Either that, or it is the usual OE, operator error.
Yes, it was just a slice, but it was so beautiful, and Kansas was soooooo looooong, it was, to us, spectacular!
NO university would have me teaching! I'm too practical, and they want theory. I enjoy practical applications! Not, the "we think it works this way" stuff. And I, too, can spend hours just looking at stuff... My husband gets rather annoyed. Any time we go to a restaurant, I'm digging in the gravel landscaping while we wait.
I think your right, Feronia. I think there are going to be water wars, and I think it is going to be ugly.
Evergreen caught in a time warp Feronia.
Was this a peer reviewed study, or was this just from some opinion blog?
check out the article, it talks to that question.
But in any case
I'm talking about BF's comment about drought being caused by a lack of rain....
What the hell Robert.... you not getting enough sleep at night, or just too much action in which case you don't care?
Wow that is so deep!
FLY
My bad, I thought you were discussing the article, call me crazy I guess!
b f
Around here the farmer's almanac is considered scientific data
TRILOBITES??? In Cincinatti? I'm on my way...
One thing no one has mentioned here is the billions of gallons of water that has been diverted in order to protect the Delta Smelt. This is significant when looking at the drought in Cali. I'm all for saving endangered species but it often goes way beyond common sense.
Pat, millions of gallons of water are drained from the Delta everyday to supply water to the Central Valley and LA. The delta smelt have nothing to do with the problems they are having. LA drained Mono lake and take the largest portion of water from the Colorado River.
It's a semi arid area, and the water consumption is beyond belief. Between golf courses, artificial lakes in the desert and the total waste of water is the problem. That along with the most severe drought in hundreds of years is nature telling them, ''wake up''.
I agree totally that nature is speaking, we need to listen. Thank you, Kavika for the information. I try to stay educated as best I can.
Pat, the Sacramento Delta is one of the most diverse areas in the US. Fishlife/wildlife/plantlife are amazing. The draining of the Delta for the past 50 years has had adverse affects. Taking more water would only add to the problems.
Northern California is in the same situation. Lack of water, wells are drying up in many small towns, water is being trucked into them.
It is a very serious problem Pat, 75 per cent of the state is in ''extreme drought'' conditions.
Frankly, the worst thing they could do is just what they're doing. They're crossing watershed boundaries by taking water from the Delta area and piping it somewhere else. Every watershed needs it's own area of recharge to maintain base stream flow, if nothing else. Taking water out of the water budget equation for the Delta is a foolish and short-sighted idea. By using the recharged water in another area, it is denying the Delta its life's blood.
Mickey
I lived in west Texas for a while and understand what you mean about natural landscaping in the yard.
It is both practical and in its own way very beautiful.