╌>

With Landrieu’s Loss, the End of an Epoch (and a history lesson on Southern Voting)

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  sean-treacy  •  12 years ago  •  5 comments

With Landrieu’s Loss, the End of an Epoch (and a history lesson on Southern Voting)

S enator Mary Landrieu of Louisiana is finally on her way out; her defeat in yesterdays runoff election putsan exclamation point at the end of the long story of the Democratic partys decline in the South. And good riddance Louisianans have already had the sense to give themselves an excellent, forward-looking governor, and they deserve a better senator, too.

Naturally, this will be seized upon as an opportunity to proclaim the grapes sour: The Democrats, being intellectually dishonest, cling to the myth that the two parties switched places on racial issues in the 1960s, that Senator Landrieus troubles are a consequence of that reversal, and that the general Southern realignment is evidence that the Republican party is a comfortable home for bigots, Confederate revanchists, and others with dodgy racial politics.

This is a strange line of argument, and an indefensible one once the evidence is considered. Democrats remained the favored party in the South for decades and decades after the passage of the landmark Civil Rights Act of 1964, controlling a majority of governorships, Senate seats, state legislative bodies , etc., well into the 21st century.

A few obvious questions: If white Southerners were really so enraged about the Civil Rights Act of 1964, and if they switched to the Republican party to express their displeasure, then why did they wait 30 years before making that preference felt in House elections? Why did Dwight D. Eisenhower a supporter of civil-rights legislation who insisted on the actual desegregation of the armed forces (as opposed to President Trumans hypothetical desegregation) and federal agencies under his control win a larger share of the Southern vote in 1956 than Barry Goldwater, the most important Republican critic of the 1964 Civil Rights Act, did two cycles later? Why did Mississippi elect only one Republican governor in the entire 20th century, and that not until 1992? Why didnt Alabama have a Republican governor until 1987? And why did Louisiana wait 60 years to eliminate its last Democratic senator in favor of a candidate from the party of Condoleezza Rice, Ben Carson, Allen West, Mia Love, Tim Scott, and that not-very-white guy who serves as governor of Louisiana? White supremacy should be made of sterner stuff: Did somebody forget to tell Louisiana state senator and newly confirmed Republican Elbert Guillory that hes black ?

Strange that redneck bigots would wait for so many decades to punish the Democrats for giving up cross-burning; my own experience with that particular demographic suggests that its members do not in general have that sort of attention span.

There has, in fact, been a realignment in the party preferences of both black voters and white Southern voters a trend that dates not to the Democrats decision to abandon white supremacy as a plank in their party platform but to an earlier period, namely, the New Deal. By 1946, the majority of black voters in congressional races were pulling the Democratic lever that is, black voters switched to the Democrats at a time when Lyndon Johnson wasnt just blocking civil-rights bills but blocking anti-lynching legislation . The last Republican presidential candidate to win the black vote was Herbert Hoover.

Similarly, the migration of white Southern voters to the GOP did not begin after the fight over the Civil Rights Act of 1964. And why would it have? Despite the principled opposition of Barry Goldwater, a lifelong NAACP member who nonetheless believed that the bill gave the federal government too much power over state and local matters, Republicans supported the Civil Rights Act of 1964 at significantly higher levels than the Democrats did , just as Republicans, Goldwater included, had fought for the Civil Rights Act of 1957, passed on Republican votes over Democratic obstruction and signed by a Republican president.

In reality, the Republican party in the South was not the party of peckerwood-trash segregationists; the GOP made its first Southern inroads among relatively affluent, educated, suburban voters, i.e., basically the same people who were Republicans everywhere else in the country, and the Southern voters least interested in segregation. And that began in the 1920s, not the 1960s. But it really picked up during the New Deal, with Franklin D. Roosevelts support among Southern white voters diminishing as his Prussian-style command-and-control economic fantasies became more audacious.

When Democrats push their trading places legend, they insistently (and dishonestly) ignore that their party, which was the party of Southern voters before Lyndon Johnson finally got on the right side of the lynching-law issue, was also the party of Southern voters long after Democrats finally packed away their white hoods for good. Instead, they will point to the presidential-election maps, which tell a different story.

Unquestionably, Barry Goldwater had a better year in 1964 when it came to Southern electoral votes than Republicans at the time could normally have expected, but Republican presidential victories in the South were hardly unprecedented: Hoover had won Texas, Florida, Virginia, Tennessee, Kentucky, and North Carolina, while Al Smith carried the rest of the South from Louisiana to South Carolina in spite of the anti-Catholic sentiment in the region. Indeed, this election, which brought many working-class whiteethnic Catholics into the Democratic camp for the first time, probably had a more important effect on the emerging Democratic coalition than any action on civil rights did, there having been practically none on either side for some time. Similarly, Republicans had a pretty good showing in the South in 1952, with Eisenhower winning Texas, Florida, Virginia, and Tennessee, along with a with the rest of the country outside the South.

Continued...

http://www.nationalreview.com/article/394137/landrieus-loss-end-epoch-kevin-d-williamson


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   seeder  Sean Treacy    12 years ago

In reality, the Republican party in the South was not the party of peckerwood-trash segregationists; the GOP made its first Southern inroads among relatively affluent, educated, suburban voters, i.e., basically the same people who were Republicans everywhere else in the country, and the Southern voters least interested in segregation. And that began in the 1920s, not the 1960s. But it really picked up during the New Deal, with Franklin D. Roosevelts support among Southern white voters diminishing as his Prussian-style command-and-control economic fantasies became more audacious.

When Democrats push their trading places legend, they insistently (and dishonestly) ignore that their party, which was the party of Southern voters before Lyndon Johnson finally got on the right side of the lynching-law issue, was also the party of Southern voters long after Democrats finally packed away their white hoods for good....

. From George Wallaces infamous stand in the schoolhouse door to Barack Obamas , embarrassing racial politics are the Democrats bread and butter. And what happened in the 1960s wasnt the parties changing places on racism and civil rights; it was the Democrats some of them, at least joining the ranks of civilized human beings for the first time.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   seeder  Sean Treacy    12 years ago
It must be sad to see your cherished myths debunked.
 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   seeder  Sean Treacy    12 years ago

Do you understand the basic principles of argument John? Before you call a statement of fact "laughable" it behooves you to be able to actually debunk that statement, which you obviously failed to do so.

Williamson's statement, that R epublicans supported the Civil Rights Act of 1964 at significantly higher levels than the Democrats did , is 100% true.

And Lyndon Johnson' statement that the 1964 Act would cost theDemocratsthe South "for a generation" was undeniably false , as Williamson amply demonstrates.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   seeder  Sean Treacy    12 years ago

Things have changed John, an early 60s liberal like JFK would be a modern conservative. Hell, his economic policies make Romney look like a socialist.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   seeder  Sean Treacy    12 years ago

"e people in 1964 who would share present day GOP sentiments did not vote for the Civil Rights Act,"


The current Republican position on Civil Rights is the position of liberal Hubert Humprhey in 1964. From the debate about the 1964 bill:

"Strong opposition to the bill arose from senators who suggested it would be interpreted so as to call for quotas and preferences, and that it would be used to upturn union seniority systems. n36 Senator Humphrey, the bill's principal sponsor, made numerous statements flatly contradicting those suggestions: "Title VII prohibits discrimination. In effect, it says that race, religion, and national origin are not to be used as the basis for hiring and firing. Title VII is designed to encourage hiring on the basis of ability and qualifications, not race or religion." n37 "Race shall not be a basis for making personnel decisions."

Any Democrat who made that argument today would be thrown out of the party.

 
 

Who is online

Right Down the Center
devangelical
CB
Tacos!
Dismayed Patriot


79 visitors