What’s Really Going on with Holder’s Civil-Rights Crusade against Police Departments -- Federal investigations of the Garner and Brown cases are just a pretext. NRO, Andrew C. McCarthy 12/6/2014
Civil-rights investigations in Ferguson and Staten Island? No, what denizens of St. Louis and New York City ought to be worried about right now is...the crime wave overtaking Seattle.
If you dont understand why, then you probably thought Obamacare was about covering the uninsured. Like its health-care reform campaign, the Obama Lefts civil-rights crusade is about control central control of state law enforcement by Washington.
The deaths of Michael Brown in Missouri and Eric Garner in New York are each tragic in their own way. But in neither is there a federal civil-rights case to be had. To think otherwise, you have to be getting your advice from Al Sharpton the huckster confidant of President Obama and Attorney General Holder.
The law of civil rights requires the government to prove beyond a reasonable doubt that the defendant, usually driven by racial prejudice, willfully acted violently in these cases with the evil purpose to deprive a person of specific federal rights. Lets put aside the utter absence of proof that race had any bearing on what happened in Staten Island, for example, where police supervised by an African-American officer came to the scene because of complaints about Garner by local business owners. It is virtually impossible to prove a civil-rights violation when there is no denying that police were engaged in a good-faith arrest and were put in the position of using force because a suspect resisted.
In Ferguson, Michael Brown did not merely resist arrest. Having just robbed a store, he was the aggressor in a confrontation with a police officer, who was made to fear for his life. And in Staten Island, there may be a real question about whether one police officer used excessive force under the circumstances; but there is no question that some quantum of force was appropriate in arresting a physically imposing suspect who insisted he would not be taken into custody and waved his arms to prevent the cops from cuffing him.
Federal civil-rights cases are much harder to make than state homicide cases. They are supposed to be. They were conceived as a rare federal intrusion on the sovereign police power a state exercises within its territory. When police are engaged in an arrest because a crime really has been committed, and they use force because the suspect really does resist, the claim that they were actually scheming to deprive the suspect of his civil rights is asinine. The time to worry about the deprivation of civil rights, as Messrs. Williamson , Cooke , and Goldberg point out, is when progressives enact overbearing laws that criminalize things like untaxed cigarette sales, not when police dutifully carry them out.
Eric Holder knows this as well as anyone. The bloviating he is doing today about Ferguson and Staten Island is of a piece with the bloviating he was doing two years ago about Sanford, Fla. As I observed of the Trayvon Martin killing at the time , the attorney general huffed and puffed about bringing a civil-rights case against white Hispanic George Zimmerman, but he was never actually going to file one . It would have been even more embarrassing than the trumped-up murder case he and Sharpton browbeat Florida into charging the one the jury threw out in nothing flat.
Holder and his constitutional-scholar boss are not banging the civil-rights drum because they believe these are prosecutable cases. It is just a pretext for unleashing Justice Department community organizers on state and municipal police departments.
The government cannot win a standalone loser of a civil-rights prosecution by crying, Disparate impact! Individual cases that have been demagogued by the racial-grievance industry become high profile. Once public attention is riveted, the legal and logical flaws become obvious. When people start looking long and hard, the institutionalized racism canard is exposed. For guys like Sharpton, thats bad for business.
But the Justice Department civil-rights investigations Holder is fond of announcing are not like public trials. They occur out of the public eye, where feverish Justice Department claims are not aired and scrutinized. More significant, they happen with the air of extortion created by the nearly $28 billion in funding Congress keeps giving Justice every year, no matter how many congressional investigations it obstructs, how many false statements its officials make, and how much it politicizes law enforcement. The investigations are taxpayer-funded jihads that states, cities, and towns know they lack the resources to fight off.
Here is how the game works. Holder streams in behind a tragedy that Sharpton and Obama have demagogued. He announces a civil-rights investigation. Eventually, he backs down from the threat of an indictment in the individual case, never conceding that the supporting evidence was not there, usually citing some strawman injustice that has nothing to do with the matter at hand in Florida, for example, it was stand your ground gun laws that purportedly needed reforming. But, the attorney general is pleased to add, the original civil-rights probe of the non-crime has metastasized into a thoroughgoing civil-rights probe of the state or local police departments training, practices, and...drumroll...institutional racism.
You never get to see what that investigation turns up. States and their subdivisions know they cannot afford to go toe-to-toe with the Beltway behemoth. Big cities, moreover, are governed by Democrats sympathetic to the Obama/Holder race obsessions theyre happy to have the feds come in and hamstring police with social justice guidelines that would be a hard sell politically. So the Justice Department makes the locals an offer they cant refuse: A consent decree that makes the Treaty of Versailles look like a slap on the wrist. This device is the license by which the Obama administration is remaking state law enforcement in its own image.
How do they get away with this? Well, Obamacare may be the most notorious reform progressives have foisted on an unsuspecting nation in modern times, but its not the only one. In 1994 the last time before 2009 that Democrats controlled the White House and both congressional chambers they rammed through a monstrosity known as the Violent Crime Control and Law Enforcement Act. A Clinton deputy attorney general named Eric Holder was among the first to exploit it.
Consistent with the Lefts view of the states as cauldrons of racism, the statute criminalizes any government authority that engage[s] in a pattern or practice of conduct by law enforcement officers...that deprives persons of [federal] rights, privileges, or immunities. It is the civil-rights laws writ large imposed on whole cities rather than threatened against individual police officers and citizens. And for good measure, the act encourages the attorney general to file civil lawsuits in federal court to obtain appropriate equitable and declaratory relief to eliminate the [offensive] pattern or practice.
Under this scheme, there are now more than 20 major American cities and their police departments beholden to the Obama Justice Department. On Thursday, in fact, Holder took time out from stirring the Staten Island pot to pounce on Cleveland, which is still reeling from last months racially charged case involving the death of twelve-year-old Tamir Rice.
The boy was reportedly pointing a gun at people in a park, prompting an emergency call to police, one of whom tragically shot him to death only to find that the gun was a BB gun. Again, other than the happenstance that the boy was black and the officer was white, race had no bearing on the case. But that didnt stop Holder from invoking the boy, along with Garners death in Staten Island, in announcing that Justices investigation had found a pattern or practice of excessive force used by Cleveland police. As he spoke, he was flanked by Mayor Frank Jackson, the Democrat who presided over this allegedly rogue police regime for the last decade upon inheriting it from Jane Campbell, the last mayor...a Democrat who, youll be shocked to learn, moved on to Harvards Kennedy School to teach how cities should be run. Mayor Jackson has, of course, agreed to the installation of a monitor, who will see to it that Cleveland police conduct themselves in an Obama-compliant manner.
Seattle is another of the big cities that has been snagged by the DOJ. It has been under a consent decree since the Justice Department targeted it in 2012 for a pattern or practice of violations, allegedly including subjecting individuals to excessive force in particular, using excessive force against persons of color, and escalating situations and using excessive force when arresting individuals for minor offenses.
You may recall that the tide of rampant crime in New York City was turned when, under Mayor Rudy Giuliani, the police began cracking down on minor offenses not untaxed cigarette sales but real violations that had nearly destroyed the citys quality of life. What ensued was a miraculous transformation, with the Big Apple becoming the safest big city in America.
That policing model is under attack now just as the NYPDs extraordinarily successful counterterrorism model has been undermined by Obamas Homeland Security Advisory Council. As Holder was making his Cleveland splash, Bill de Blasio, New York Citys hard-left mayor, opportunistically and in the absence of any evidence pointed to Garners death as proof that the way we go about policing has to change....People need to know that black lives and brown lives matter as much as white lives.
Holder announced that the Justice Department, which is already monitoring the NYPD, will conduct a civil-rights investigation into Garners death. Yes, thats how it always starts.
Meanwhile, Seattle has been making announcements, too. It seems crime in the Emerald City has been skyrocketing since the Justice Department came in to, er, help. Homicides up 21 percent, car theft up 44 percent, aggravated assaults up 14 percent, and so on.
Welcome to Change: produced and directed by the Obama Justice Department and coming soon to a town near you.
Andrew C. McCarthy is a policy fellow at the National Review Institute. His latest book is Faithless Execution: Building the Political Case for Obamas Impeachment .

Seattle is another of the big cities that has been snagged by the DOJ. It has been under a consent decree since the Justice Department targeted it in 2012 for a pattern or practice of violations, allegedly including subjecting individuals to excessive force in particular, using excessive force against persons of color, and escalating situations and using excessive force when arresting individuals for minor offenses.
You may recall that the tide of rampant crime in New York City was turned when, under Mayor Rudy Giuliani, the police began cracking down on minor offenses not untaxed cigarette sales but real violations that had nearly destroyed the citys quality of life. What ensued was a miraculous transformation, with the Big Apple becoming the safest big city in America.
That policing model is under attack now just as the NYPDs extraordinarily successful counterterrorism model has been undermined by Obamas Homeland Security Advisory Council. As Holder was making his Cleveland splash, Bill de Blasio, New York Citys hard-left mayor, opportunistically and in the absence of any evidence pointed to Garners death as proof that the way we go about policing has to change....People need to know that black lives and brown lives matter as much as white lives.
Holder announced that the Justice Department, which is already monitoring the NYPD, will conduct a civil-rights investigation into Garners death. Yes, thats how it always starts.
Meanwhile, Seattle has been making announcements, too. It seems crime in the Emerald City has been skyrocketing since the Justice Department came in to, er, help. Homicides up 21 percent, car theft up 44 percent, aggravated assaults up 14 percent, and so on.
Welcome to Change: produced and directed by the Obama Justice Department and coming soon to a town near you.
I'm not sure now the JD monitoring SPD is responsible for an increase in crime. Would you explain that to me.
Over the years, before Holder, many police departments have been monitored by the JD. LA, in which I lived, was, and surely needed to be.
I would like you to explain to me why Cleveland PD don't need some guidance? Their record isn't something to be proud of.
Their hiring practice's are rather shoddy. I hope that youread the background on the cop that shot 12 year old. Incompetence at it's finest.
Crime in Seattle had been in steady decline for 27 years through 2011.
In 2012 DOJ targeted the city for its pattern or practice of violations, allegedly including subjecting individuals to excessive force in particular, using excessive force against persons of color, and escalating situations and using excessive force when arresting individuals for minor offenses.
Since then the police have backed off enforcement and crime has been skyrocketing .
Coincidence?
Len, one of those ''individuals'' code for people of color,was John T. Williams who I knew and was shot dead by a LEO. You may want to goggle it. And it was the tipping point for the JD to become involved.
Me, being one of those ''people of color'', have a much different take on it then you do. Since we actually experience the ''excessive force''.
I also read a long version on the Indian Country websitedetailing the encounter:
...
It was horrible.
There is no doubt officers make errors. I was once a jury foreman in a civil trial wherein a womansued the county for her car being hit by a county ambulance near an intersection. The ambulance driver had since become an officer and testified in uniform.
The officer asserted that the driver had violated a crosshatched area, which she denied. During deliberations I sent my question to the judge: "Did the woman receive a ticket?" The response: "You have gotten all the testimony you are going to get."
The jury voted 9 to 1 in the county's favor. When we delivered the verdict the judge asked who the dissenter was. The question surprised me but I raised my hand. I got some satisfaction in feeling that, in the second-part damages trial, my dissenting vote will help the woman get at least a partial award.
What my experience drove home is that jurors are reluctant to disbelieve an officer.
There is no doubt that officers err. But Ilike to think such errors are rare.
Absent evidence (as in the Williams case)or lack of same (as in my case) I would give an officer the benefit of the doubt. It seems like DOJ wants to remove this benefit and put the shoe on the other foot.
McCarthy is the prosecutor who obtained conviction of the blind sheik in the first World Trade Center bombing. I read him often on NRO.com and consider him brilliant.
"Excessive force" means different things to different people. Holder would consider any force excessive except when black on white. He refused to indict the Philadelphian Black Panthers when they intimidated voters during the 2008 election.
At Holder; right?
Len, JohnT was only the last of a long list of minorities in Seattle that suffered at the hand of the cops. You can go back to the 1960's and 70's, during what was called the ''Fish Wars''. Where Indians were beaten, arrested and charged with crimes that that were bogus. Today those Indians that protested and fought an unjust systems are tagged with criminal records. They were within their rights and it was the systems that was breaking the law, not the Indians. It was their protests that changed what was racism and unjust arrests to a more favorable situation for the tribes. BTW, these rights are all spelled out in treaties which the establishment chose to ignore.
That is why, I have,and always will protest against unjust treatment and laws.
From the history of the SPD, I would not be willing to give the LEO's the benefit of the doubt. Their history tells you that is a dangerous path to follow.
Fair enough! I first learned the truth about maltreatment of native Americans from a high-school history teacher who told us to get those prejudicial cowboy movies out of our minds, and I don't doubt what you write, just as I don't doubt the evil perpetrated on other minorities.
Perhaps Holder's strong medicine was good for a spell and we will end up with a just middle ground, God willing.
''Perhaps Holder's strong medicine was good for a spell and we will end up with a just middle ground, God willing''.
Agreed.
You mean BOTH of them was that before or after a Phiily cop told them to move on and they did so without incident?
Summary hyperbole/misrepresentation is no substitute for the facts.
Eric Holder believes all cops are racists, targets unconscious bias
By Paul Sperry
Following the Eric Garner verdict, New York cops can look forward to having their heads examined for unconscious bias by federal thought police unleashed by Attorney General Eric Holder .
The NYPD can expect to undergo the same kind of de-biasing training that Holder put departments in Seattle, New Orleans, St. Louis and several other cities through while investigating them for alleged civil-rights violations.
Federal trainers teach cops not only to think twice about stopping or questioning suspects of color, but also to ignore signs of criminal behavior and threat indicators theyve gleaned from years of street experience. That puts their own lives in danger and risks the safety of residents.
The Justice Departments unprecedented shift from prosecuting intentional discrimination to investigating unconscious or implicit bias began long before Ferguson , Mo. Its part of a racial justice movement launched by the Obama administration to reform the criminal-justice system.
In the past five years, Holder has more than doubled the number of police department probes compared with the previous five years, opening more than 20 investigations and pressuring 15 consent orders to stop biased policing and other alleged violations.
Whats striking about these federally mandated orders is the lack of evidence investigators found to show cops stopped and arrested black people simply because of bias. They assumed, but couldnt prove, they targeted blacks due to an automatic and unfair association between them and crime and not because they actually committed crimes.
More:
...
Eric Holder believes all cops are racists, targets unconscious bias
And of course, this is something verifiable you just look in his heart and there it is.
This is the kind of shit we've come to expect from haters
Paul E. Sperry is a conservative pundit, author, investigative journalist, and Stanford University Hoover Institute media fellow. [1] [2] In the wake of the Fort Hood Shooting , he gave an interview to Coast to Coast AM on November 7, 2009, about his co-authored book Muslim Mafia . [3]
Len, I pointed out to you why Seattle needed JD intervention. Cleveland has been all over the news, up to and including tweets from cops about N****R..New Orleans PD,is a post child for corruption among a host of other offenses. including murder.
Also, PD's throughout the country have been supervised by the JD. Long before Holder was AG. It's an on going problem and when it's pointed out people want to stick their heads in the sand or fingers in their ears. It's real, it happens on a regular basis.
The best thing is for the ''good cops'' to break that blue line and quit protecting the ''bad cops''. Yes Len, I do believe there are a lot of good cops. But I'm realistic enough to know that there are plenty of bad cops.
Maybe it's because a lot of unarmed black people are being killed by police officers Duhhhh.
Exactly How Often Do Police Shoot Unarmed Black Men?