Why The GOP's Lawsuit Could Sink ObamaCare
The Affordable Care Act is "here to stay," President Obama said in remarks in the Rose Garden on June 25, 2015. APThe Affordable Care Act is "here to stay," President Obama said in remarks in the Rose Garden on June 25, 2015. AP View Enlarged ImageThe House GOP's ObamaCare lawsuit looks like the most serious threat yet to a law that has survived two trips to the Supreme Court mostly intact.Just 10 weeks ago, President Obama cheered that his signature legislation was "here to stay" after six justices ruled that the federally run Healthcare.gov could issue premium subsidies.Yet this latest suit has the potential to undermine ObamaCare's already-shaky foundation.U.S. District Judge Rosemary Collyer ruled Wednesday that the House has standing to suethe Department of Health and Human Services for spending billions that Republicans say was never appropriated to reduce out-of-pocket expenses of low-income insurance customers.$136 Billion Is At StakeAt stake is $136 billion, or 19%, of the $735 billion in cost-sharing subsidies that the Congressional Budget Office expects will be spent over the coming decade.Here's an example of how these cost-sharing subsidies work: The cheapest silver plan in Miami carries a $10,000 deductible for a married couple. But with the extra cost-sharing subsidies paid directly to insurers like premium subsidies couples earning up to $23,595 who buy this same plan will have just a $1,000 deductible.The trouble for the Obama administration in this case, unlike the last one, is that Republicans have plenty of evidence to back their view of how ObamaCare is supposed to work.HHS' 2014 budget appropriation request for $4 billion to fund these cost-sharing subsidies that supplement the health insurance premium subsidies for low-income households.A Congressional Research Service analysis found that, "unlike the refundable (premium) tax credits, these payments to health plans do not appear to be funded through a permanent appropriation."A preliminary finding from the White House Office of Management and Budget that automatic budget cuts under sequestration would cut cost-sharing subsidies by 7.2%, or $286 million, in 2014, a further sign the funding was not automatic.Eventually, the administration decided that cost-sharing subsidies weren't subject to sequestration and didn't need annual appropriations. But that reversal makes it much harder to discredit the GOP position.Collyer ruled that the House had standing to sue "to preserve its power of the purse and to maintain constitutional equilibrium" between Congress and the executive branch. But she also delved into the appropriations process, citing the Government Accountability Office principle that "a direction to pay without a designation of the source of funds is not an appropriation."That appears to be the case with the cost-sharing subsidies: The law instructs the HHS secretary to require the cost-sharing subsidies and even to "make periodic and timely payments," but it doesn't identify a source of funds.House Speaker John BoehnerHouse Speaker John Boehner View Enlarged ImageStill, even if a court rules that cost-sharing subsidies must be appropriated and Congress resists, the government would still be on the hook, says University of Michigan law professor Nicholas Bagley. Because the law requires insurers to limit low-income enrollees' out-of-pocket bills, health plans will be able to sue to collect the cost of providing those extra subsidies, he argues.Off The Exchange?Another outcome is possible, perhaps likelier: If the government can no longer directly compensate insurers, they would be left with the option of raising premiums across the board to balance out cost-sharing expenses. But this would have several negative consequences.Read More At Investor's Business Daily: http://news.investors.com/091015-770364-house-challenges-obamacare-cost-sharing-subsidies.htm#ixzz3lZ5jb2hx Follow us: @IBDinvestors on Twitter | InvestorsBusinessDaily on Facebook
Tags
Who is online
83 visitors

Watching out for spending is not Obama's problem . It's only tax money . Why should that concern him ? /S