╌>

DA's Office Gave the Wrong Law to the Ferguson Grand Jury

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  a-macarthur  •  12 years ago  •  15 comments

DA's Office Gave the Wrong Law to the Ferguson Grand Jury

and may have done so with other Grand Juries!

Presenting reams of evidence that could benefit the defense of Ferguson officer Darren Wilson wasnt the only thing St. Louis County prosecutors did to bolster Wilsons case for escaping trial.

Prosecutors also made a mistake in the grand jury instructions that gave jurors a false impression about the law and provided Wilson with significantly more legal cover for the deadly shooting of Michael Brown than the law actually provides, according to a review of the transcript by MSNBCs Lawrence ODonnell.

Assistant District Attorney Kathi Alizadeh instructed grand jurors on how to decide the case based on a statute that was invalidated by the U.S. Supreme Court two decades ago. As ODonnell points out, that statute had not been valid for the entirety of Alizadehs legal career. That statute said that officers can use any force they deem necessary to achieve the arrest of a fleeing suspect. It does not preclude deadly force ,saying only that officers are justified in the use of such physical force as he or she reasonably believes is immediately necessary to effect the arrest or to prevent the escape from custody.

The U.S. Supreme Court nixed this law and others like it when it held in the 1985 case of Tennessee v. Garner that police officers could not use deadly force simply because a suspect was fleeing. They could only do so if that suspect also threatened the lives of others. A 1979 Missouri statute was never changed.

Alizadeh realized her mistake three months after she initially presented the statute to the grand jurors and disclosed the error. But at least according to the transcript, she never told them what exactly she did wrong or what had changed. She simply told the jurors to fold in half the paper they had been referencing for three months and gave them a new one with different instructions.

http://thinkprogress.org/justice/2014/11/30/3597641/this-prosecutor-mistake-skewed-the-law-in-darren-wilsons-favor/

" District Attorney Kathi Alizadeh instructed grand jurors on how to decide the case based on a statute that was invalidated by the U.S. Supreme Court two decades ago."

"Prosecutors also made a mistake in the grand jury instructions that gave jurors a false impression about the law and provided Wilson with significantly more legal cover for the deadly shooting of Michael Brown than the law actually provides "

Let's see how we spin this away.


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    12 years ago

Let the rationalizations and spin begin.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    12 years ago

Since Wilson was not found innocent or guilty that's not the function of a Grand Jury there is no "double jeopardy" issue. I would not be surprised (especially given the unrelated Garner Grand Jury fiasco) if Wilson was eventually indicted and tried.

The same for the police in NYPD (Staten Island/Garner).

Somewhere is the straw that will break the camel's back.

For the record, Judge Nelson in the Trayvon Martin/Zimmerman trial, gave the jury nebulous directions which led to Zimmerman's being found "not guilty."

The shit storm has been building and when a life is taken by a police officer or police officer want-to-be and then those entitled to their "day-in-court" have that literally and figuratively taken from them by a rigged system, what are they then to do?

In another thread, I reminded someone of the Warsaw Ghetto uprising in which Jews in Poland, knowing "the law" "permitted" their extermination, saw no other option but to "take it to the street."

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    12 years ago
So they were presented with the correct Supreme Court approved version of the statute before they began their deliberations. A lot of huff and fluff of no significance.I'm shocked the brilliant legal minds at thinkprogress weren't able to cite any actual authority that the prosecutors mistake constitutes an actual error that courts take notice of. Why could that be?The best they can do is offer tepid speculation without any legal precedent to justify their breathless hyperbole.
 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    12 years ago

So they were presented with the correct Supreme Court approved version of the statute before they began their deliberations. A lot of huff and fluff of no significance.

Sean,

But at least according to the transcript, she never told them what exactly she did wrong or what had changed. She simply told the jurors to fold in half the paper they had been referencing for three months and gave them a new one with different instructions.

she never told them what exactly she did wrong or what had changed. She simply told the jurors to fold in half the paper they had been referencing for three months and gave them a new one with different instructions.

she never told them what exactly she did wrong or what had changed. She simply told the jurors to fold in half the paper they had been referencing for three months and gave them a new one with different instructions.

she never told them what exactly she did wrong or what had changed. She simply told the jurors to fold in half the paper they had been referencing for three months and gave them a new one with different instructions.

See the significance? The GJ let Wilson walk based on a LAW THAT NO LONGER EXISTS!

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    12 years ago

There are basically two types of law stories that pop up on the internet, one type deals with issues that have actual legal implications, the other is chum for partisans and services the feeding frenzy of uninformed laymen that surround a controversial case but has nothing to do with actual issues that matter in deciding the case itself.

I've found it fairly easily to immediately distinguish between the two types. A legitimate story is published in a respectable outlet and cites the legal issue as hand as well the legal precedent that will decide the case. Look at the coverage of the Halbig case in respectable outlets for an example.

The chum cases are published on sites like Thinkprogress and insinuate wrongdoing or spotlight issues that have no legal significance. They identify some dastardly problem but utterly fail to identify what law or precedent makes their supposedly earth shattering discovery so important.

If there's any doubt whether this issue actually matters, look in the thinkprogress piece for any citation to a law or case the the DA supposedly runs afoul of by correcting the jury on the standard before they began their deliberations.

It doesn't exist, because what the DA did is perfectly legal. But that doesn't matter to the website if it generates clicks and keeps the outrage fomented.

he GJ let Wilson walk based on a LAW THAT NO LONGER EXISTS!

False. You are not entitled to make up facts. The DA gave the correct standard to the jury before it began deliberations.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    12 years ago

on't have to expect our prosecutors to follow the law

Show me the controlling law or precedent that the DA's actions purportedly ran afoul of. Until you can, your opinion is just an unsupported conclusion. It's like opining that Neil Armstrong never landed on the moon because you don't like Florida.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    12 years ago

Show me the controlling law or precedent that the DA's actions purportedly ran afoul of. Until you can, your opinion is just an unsupported conclusion. It's like opining that Neil Armstrong never landed on the moon because you don't like Florida.

Huh?

Ferguson Grand Jury Documents Released Reveal DA Did Not Even Charge Wilson

Shortly after the grand jury decision yesterday, so too was the paperwork from the jury.

Reams of transcripts, evidence reports, witness statements, and police documentation were all put online for everyone to go see what it was the grand Jury saw, heard, and understood. So far, the picture painted does not look good for Prosecutor Bob McCulloch.

In his entire opening statement from the first day of testimony, McCulloch mentioned Michael Brown four times, painting the case as being on Michael Brown. It was the shooting death of Michael Brown and the Michael Brown case, but strangely it lacked something entirely: It made no mention of the person the grand jury was there to evaluate indicting, Darren Wilson.

Mr. McCulloch discussed the role of the FBI, of how federal courts worked against state courts, but not a single mention of the man they were there to investigate.

In fact, going through the testimony, the first mention of Officer Wilson was done not by the prosecution, but by a witness, the on-scene medical examiner Sheila Whirley, who was the first person to examine Michael Browns body after the killing.

The prosecutor spent a lot of time discussing various unrelated aspects of Michael Brown, discussing his tattoos, his clothing, with this witness. But whenever the witness questioning began leading to homicide, the prosecutor changed the topic to some element of Brown which was almost perfectly fit to try and present him as some form of social reject who was destined to become a criminal mastermind.

Continuing, the witnesses, the evidence one would swear that this was a grand jury held to indict Michael Brown. The submitted evidence in the trial was overwhelmingly about Brown, with little evidence actually presented on Darren Wilson, the man the jury was there to determine indictments on. What did exist were a few medical reports and some police commentary on his behavior that day, which called him disheveled and claimed that was out of character for him.

Of note is one report that includes multiple statements by fellow officers on-scene, including Officer Wilsons immediate supervisor, covering what Wilson had claimed happened, but there is evidence in there which hurts Officer Wilsons case namely his own police vehicle.

Multiple officers all reported that Officer Wilsons vehicle was missing the front drivers side window, that it was shattered outward, and that blood was found on the outside of the vehicle. This directly contradicts Officer Wilsons claims that Brown was assaulting him through his open window and that he fired his weapon in self-defense while being assaulted.

If that is the case, how was his window blown out, from the inside? In addition, Wilson claimed to have fired two rounds from within his vehicle, but one of the empty shells was found outside of it, next to his vehicle. Taking Officer Wilsons third-party statement on face value, it does not explain this.

But this is one minor entry put in reams of documentation on Michael Brown. At this time, no copy of Officer Wilsons police record is clearly found within the evidence since released. There are three different narratives to be found as given by Wilson, with no indication which ones were given weight. The caller dispatch discredits the claim by Wilson that he was searching for the robbery suspect , or that he called in when he approached Michael Brown. Instead, dispatch was not notified of the shooting until much later .

Combining the evidence presented, the general lack of even mentioning the defendant at all, and that no explanation of the available charges for the grand jury were given, a picture is painted that the prosecution office was not there to indict Wilson at all.

Having read the reports, and even taking Officer Wilson at his word, he still violated police protocol and should have been indicted on negligence based on a review of the evidence presented. Not a career ending situation, but one which would still have penalized him nonetheless. But the failure to even give instructions to the jury, and the presentation of a plethora of non-related material which dominated over the direct case material related to Darren Wilson, hurts any claims that it was a fair deliberation. Combine these facts with the suspected tampering and we have a case which is now blowing up in the systems face.

The way in which the entire Michael Brown case has been handled is shameful. Even if Darren Wilson was indicted yesterday, the process was so badly mangled that it would have been a hollow victory. The way in which the prosecutor handled the case has now landed him in trouble with the National Bar Association , who released a statement pointing out the flaws in the manner which Bob McCulloch handled the case with the declaration that they are pushing for the Department of Justice to continue its own investigation.

Justice was not served, and the documentation released shows that the grand jury was not handled with due diligence. This is not the first case Bob McCulloch failed to handle properly. His history demonstrates a reluctance to hold police accountable . As the son of an officer killed in the line of duty , this can be somewhat understood, but his duty is to uphold the laws of the land, and if he was unable to handle the case to the fullest extent, he should have handed it to a special prosecutor, as the National Bar Association asked him to do.

Shame on Bob McCulloch. We expect better from those who are there to serve the public trust, for to violate that trust only brings ruin. Society exists on trust; it needs trust. By not pursuing this case properly, that trust is injured, if not shattered, for if we cannot trust the courts, who is left?

To answer your question, Sean which you need to rephrase so as to have it reflect reality and not be one of semantics

The way in which the prosecutor handled the case has now landed him in trouble with the National Bar Association , who released a statement pointing out the flaws in the manner which Bob McCulloch handled the case with the declaration that they are pushing for the Department of Justice to continue its own investigation.

McCulloch ran afoul of protocol, of public trust and of conflict-of-interests concerns he gave

  1. The appearance of impropriety -- a situation which to a layperson without knowledge of the specific circumstances might seem to raise ethics questions.
 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    12 years ago

False. You are not entitled to make up facts. The DA gave the correct standard to the jury before it began deliberations.

Nor are you. I gave the precise scenario as to how the jury was incorrectly instructed as to what Wilson was legally permitted to do and he walked as a result.

Forget the smoke screen of other websites I gave the particulars.

 
 
 
Spikegary
Junior Quiet
link   Spikegary    12 years ago
Mr. McCulloch discussed the role of the FBI, of how federal courts worked against state courts, but not a single mention of the man they were there to investigate.

Isn't the Grand Jury there to investigate whether a crime occurred and who, if anyone should be tried for the 'crime'? I'm nowhere near an expert in the law, but it seems that the source quoted above is a bit prejudiced.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    12 years ago

Isn't the Grand Jury there to investigate whether a crime occurred and who, if anyone should be tried for the 'crime'? I'm nowhere near an expert in the law, but it seems that the source quoted above is a bit prejudiced.

The role of the FBI and any alleged adversarial relationships between it and state courts had nothing to do with Michael Brown's death. On the other hand, mentioning the suspect had everything to do with it.

And this was only one item on a long list of protocol infractions.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    12 years ago

how the jury was incorrectly instructed as to what Wilson was legally permitted to do and he walked as a result.

There is zero evidence of causation anywhere on this thread. You assume the jury ignored the correct instructions they received from the DA without providing any evidence that they did so.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    12 years ago

e way in which the prosecutor handled the case has now landed him in trouble with the National Bar Association

What jurisdiction does the National Bar Association (an association of black lawyers) have over the DA?

What exactly does this trouble entail? Can the NBA in any way inhibit his ability to practice law?

AMAC., what precedent or statute did the DA run afoul of by correcting the standard of guilt before submitting the case to the GJ?

I'm not interested in some special interest groups caterwauling. If what the DA did was wrong and jeopardizes the verdict of the GJ, it must be covered by some controlling case or statute. If not, then is a whole to do about nothing.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    12 years ago

AMAC., what precedent or statute did the DA run afoul of by correcting the standard of guilt before submitting the case to the GJ?

She did not correct the standard in an overt, directly instructive manner, one that made it completely clear to totally disregard the previously-instructed, INCORRECT STANDARD.

What statute does a prosecutor need to require him/her to properly instruct a jury as to which law(s) determines how it is to reach its decision?

It's called Prosector Integrity, Sean.

Justice Scalia Explains What Was Wrong With The Ferguson Grand Jury

It is the grand jurys function not to enquire upon what foundation [the charge may be] denied, or otherwise to try the suspects defenses, but only to examine upon what foundation [the charge] is made by the prosecutor. Respublica v. Shaffer, 1 Dall. 236 (O. T. Phila. 1788); see also F. Wharton, Criminal Pleading and Practice 360, pp. 248-249 (8th ed. 1880). As a consequence, neither in this country nor in England has the suspect under investigation by the grand jury ever been thought to have a right to testify or to have exculpatory evidence presented.

This passage was first highlighted by attorney Ian Samuel, a former clerk to Justice Scalia .

In contrast, McCulloch allowed Wilson to testify for hours before the grand jury and presented them with every scrap of exculpatory evidence available. In his press conference, McCulloch said that the grand jury did not indict because eyewitness testimony that established Wilson was acting in self-defense was contradicted by other exculpatory evidence. What McCulloch didnt say is that he was under no obligation to present such evidence to the grand jury. The only reason one would present such evidence is to reduce the chances that the grand jury would indict Darren Wilson.

Compare Justice Scalias description of the role of the grand jury to what the prosecutors told the Ferguson grand jury before they started their deliberations:

And you must find probable cause to believe that Darren Wilson did not act in lawful self-defense and you must find probable cause to believe that Darren Wilson did not use lawful force in making an arrest. If you find those things, which is kind of like finding a negative, you cannot return an indictment on anything or true bill unless you find both of those things. Because both arecomplete defenses to any offense and they both have been raised in his, in the evidence.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    12 years ago

At no point did Justice Scalia say it was improper for the defendant to testify at a Grand Jury hearing or that it's improper for the prosecution to present exculpatory evidence to a grand jury. Scalia merely said the defendant doesn't have the absolute right for either. There's a world of difference between what Scalia actually wrote and what Think Progress claims he wrote.

If you can find authority that it's illegal for a DA to allow a defendant to testify before a GJ or to present exculpatory evidence, I'd love to see it. Otherwise, you are basically arguing that McCullogh simply didn't use his discretion in the way you would have liked him to, which is simply not a basis for overturning the verdict of the grand jury.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    12 years ago

At no point did Justice Scalia say it was improper for the defendant to testify at a Grand Jury hearing or that it's improper for the prosecution to present exculpatory evidence to a grand jury.

By allowing Wilson to do so, the prosecutor de facto allowed for what Scalia said was not the right of a suspect;

neither in this country nor in England has the suspect under investigation by the grand jury ever been thought to have a right to testify or to have exculpatory evidence presented.

I won't split hairs on this, Sean. The process was flawed in multiple ways.

 
 

Who is online

CB
Right Down the Center


81 visitors