Are We to Be Blamed for the Migrants' Predicament?
BICSKE, Hungary If he ever got the chance, hed settle in the United States, Rzgar Abdul said. But for now, he lives in this spare, barracks-style refugee camp, placing much of the blame for his squalid existence on the United States.
After all, the Islamic State proliferated when U.S. forces pulled out of an unstable country. And that proliferation forced him to leave his home, said Abdul, 28, who is from the Iraqi city of Kirkuk.
Iraqs problem is Americas problem, said Abdul, who said he was a translator for the United States during the Iraq war, making him a target. This crisis is Americas problem. In Iraq, Syria, all over, the U.S. did not do enough.
From the squalid migrant campgrounds in Hungary to the offices of Europes elected officials, many others also saw the swell of migrants crossing borders as evidence of a failed U.S. foreign policy. Even as President Obama declared that the country would extend asylum to 10,000 Syrians, many blamed the United States for the migration crisis that has walloped Europe.
In Germany, it is rare that the distant reaches of the political left and right agree on anything. But they do now: The United States is at fault.
Sahra Wagenknecht and Dietmar Bartsch, deputy chairpersons of the Left Party in the German Parliament, last week savaged U.S. policy in the Middle East.
Killer gangs, such as the Islamic State, were indirectly supported and without hindrance supplied with money and weapons from countries including those allied with Germany, the two alleged in a policy paper, apparently referring to early efforts to back rebels fighting the government of Syrian President Bashar al-Assad.
Others have argued that the United States did not do enough to back the rebels and remove Assad.
When the Left Party is right, it is right, Alexander Gauland, deputy chairman of the conservative and populist Alternative for Germany party, said in an interview with the right-wing German weekly Junge Freiheit. America bears a lot of blame for the flow of refugees.
Officials in the United States call the criticism overblown. The CIA spent $1billion to fund early efforts to unseat Assad. Others have argued that no one could have foreseen the magnitude of the war in Syria.
http://www.msn.com/en-us/news/world/frustrated-migrants-blame-us-for-their-predicament/ar-AAeboFI?li=AAa0dzB&ocid=U305DHP
Tags
Who is online
83 visitors

I wouldn't say we are totally to blame, but certainly part of the blame falls on us.
amibv, I feel that there are a few things that prevent them from rebuilding their own county. The main reason being that any show of independence, or trying to establish calm will result in their death and that of their family.
ambiv, I don't believe that many of them regard Iraq as their country. It was thrown together after WWI by the British without regard to the history/culture of the area.
The same can be said of Syria. Both have been held together by tyrants for decades.
And many have died fighting over the years. Ten's of thousands of them. What we are seeing now, is something that should have been seen by our political leaders before they got us involved in Iraq. The history was there for them to see, but as usual they ignored it.
We are partly responsible of that there is no question.
100% responsible? No emphatically no.
History is repeating itself.
Just look to Yugoslavia for the example of what happens to made up nations when the population has no choice in the matter.
Apply the same thinking to the peoples crossing the southern border of this nation, and the ideas expressed in that article ring true.
What does that say about Mexico?
VERY GOOD point Feronia! Kudos!
Love the truth coming out - yes - but, think again - what countries "jumped" into the Middle East after the Ottoman Empire fell? England, France - to build back onto their "lost" Empires and they left failed states in/on every turn.
''What does that say about Mexico.'' To my knowledge Islam is not the religion of Mexico, nor any of Central or South America. Sosome of the points of the article, IMO, don't apply.
Most countries in the Americas have elected governments. Are they honest or corruption free, no, but then again neither is the U.S. Are any of them failed states? Some are very close or have been in the past.
The author of the article, makes some very good points, and I believe are part of the situation that exists today.
To me, much of what is happening in the ME is a reminder of what happened in Yugoslavia. Milosivic decided to bring back the Serbian Empire or Greater Serbia. What he brought back was genocide, mass immigration out of the area and a bloody war, that still requires UN troops there. Was religion involved in this, oh hell yes it was.
There is no one answer thatfits all with the ME. Lebanon was the ''Riveria'' of the ME. Educated, advanced, with Muslims/Christians enjoying a stable country. Then it went to shit. Outside forces changed the face of Lebanon. Syria and Iran being the two main culprits.
What I'm saying is that the solutions are very complex and many different avenues must be addressed before any solution can be implemented. Is the U.S. Europe or countries in the ME capable of doing this. I actually don't think so.
On a micro scale just review/study the Balkan war, 20 years later UN troops are still there. Is that what will be required in the ME? I sure as hell hope not.
You break it, you own it. Simple, but fitting.
Is that question for me Feronia?
I do agree with many of the points in WSJ.
Here is a link to a report done by the Cato Institute. Quite interesting and I believe adds points to the WSJ article.
IMO, there are three things that have held most of the ME in the 19th Century. Oil, power and religion. Most every conflict/intervention can be traced to anyone of those three items.
I agree.
I believe that it is religion driven as much as religion drives culture but not any farther then that.
The point are applicable to any culture driven mass exodus.
There are a lot of points in agreement with what is happening in Mexico. As the drug gang culture has become the dominant culture.
Think it can't happen to us? Let one subsect of our culture gain power supremacy over all the other and watch it happen.
These people are fleeing the cultures of violence and absolute tyrrany that have taken hold of their nations. If you wish to call what they do genocide so be it, it fits as well as any other.
but the reality is when one subsect of a population decides to do their own thing and destroy anything that tries to prevent them from such a taking, that is what you get, a mass exodus of those unwilling to submit.
Eventually all that is left are those who have no other place to run to. Then the real war of extermination starts.
The ME, has become an explicit war of submission or extermination. The antithesis of a free society.
We need to be careful we don't lose the freedom we take for granted. But we also have to be careful that we don't become what we hate in trying to keep our freedom.
If there is any nation on the planet capable of resolving the dilemma it's the US, but the real problem is we don't appear to have the fortitude to actually do it.
As far as the former Yugoslavia? there will be UN troops there until the hatred passes, which could be forever.
Memories of hatred are the hardest to dissipate. Just look at the racial angst in this country for proof. Then you add in those who push and foment hate, and you get the ME.
The way to stop it, is get the hell out of the way, let them have their hate, or, go in with everything you have and exterminate the fomenters.
Your only two options.
Neither is a good one.