Ex-UPS driver's pregnancy bias claim at high court
WASHINGTON Peggy Young only has to look at her younger daughter to be reminded how long she has fought United Parcel Service over its treatment of pregnant employees, and why.
Young was pregnant with Triniti, who's now 7 years old, when UPS told Young that she could not have a temporary assignment to avoid lifting heavy packages, as her doctor had ordered.
"They told me basically to go home and come back when I was no longer pregnant," Young said in an interview with The Associated Press. "I couldn't believe it."
She sued the Atlanta-based package-delivery company for discriminating against pregnant women. She lost two rounds in lower courts, but the Supreme Court will hear her case Wednesday.
The 42-year-old Young, who lives in Lorton, Virginia, said her persistence is not only for herself. "I am fighting for my two daughters and I'm fighting for women who want to start a family and provide for the family at the same time," she said.
UPS spokeswoman Kara Gerhardt Ross said the law is on the company's side. "UPS did not intentionally discriminate," Ross said.
The outcome could have wide-ranging effects.
Three-quarters of women entering the workforce today will become pregnant at least once while employed, and many will work throughout their pregnancies, employment discrimination expert Katherine Kimpel wrote in a court brief. Some will experience complications or physical effects that cause them to ask their employers for a change of duties or other modifications, Kimpel said.
Young's case hinges on the Pregnancy Discrimination Act, a law that Congress passed in 1978 specifically to include discrimination against pregnant women as a violation of the 1964 Civil Rights Act. Congress acted after the Supreme Court, then composed entirely of men, said workplace rules that excluded pregnant workers from disability benefits and insurance coverage did not amount to sex discrimination under the landmark civil rights law.
http://www.msn.com/en-us/news/us/ex-ups-drivers-pregnancy-bias-claim-at-high-court/ar-BBgbSv8

One of the potential downfalls I see for this possible case is -
"In 2006, Young, then in her mid-30s, took a leave of absence to undergo in vitro fertilization in her desire to have a third child."
She "intentionally" put herself in a health situation - something that is verboten in an employer's eyes.
What say you A. Mac?????
''UPS spokeswoman Kara Gerhardt Ross said the law is on the company's side. "UPS did not intentionally discriminate," Ross said.''
Did they unintentionally discriminate???
I disagree about her putting herself in a health situation....That would mean that employees that have dangerous hobbies should be subject to the same discrimination. IE: skydiving, scuba diving, motorcycle riding, or any other of the hundreds of ''hobbies'' that are dangerous.
Kavika - the people who do get involved in "extreme" hobbies have to, in most cases, have supplementary insurance because a primary won't cover their activities. Companies are not bound to insure "risk-takers" because they can cause undo premium increases for the company if the risk-taker is injured.
I "think" the light duty thing was passed after she left in '09 -
"UPS itself has changed its policy so that pregnant employees will be eligible for light-duty work. "UPS believed it was appropriate to update its workplace policies so that we can attract and retain the best workforce we can," Ross said."
1st, that would not be the case in the corporation that I worked for. Over all employment was in excess of 20,000 and there was no prohibition against many of the hobbies that I engaged in, including sky diving.
My point being that UPS is behind the curve on this one. It may be intentional or not, but I would think they would have had a plan for this. From later decisions it seems that they didn't.
Totally concur.