╌>

If Supreme Court Strikes Federal Exchange Subsidies, Health Law Could Unravel

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  robert-in-ohio  •  12 years ago  •  6 comments

If Supreme Court Strikes Federal Exchange Subsidies, Health Law Could Unravel

Exactly what would happen to the Affordable Care Act if the Supreme Court invalidates tax credits in three dozen states where the federal government runs the program?

Legal scholars say a decision like that would deal a potentially lethal blow to the law because it would undermine the government-run insurance marketplaces that are its backbone, as well as the mandate requiring most Americans to carry coverage.

In King v. Burwell, the law's challengers argue that Congress intended to limit federal tax credits to residents of states running their own insurance exchanges. Currently only 13 states and the District of Columbia operate exchanges on their own; another 10 are in some sort of partnership with the federal government. Federal officials run the rest.

Should the justices find that subsidies in federal exchanges are not allowed, "I don't think there are any rosy scenarios," said Timothy Jost, a law professor at Washington and Lee University and a supporter of the law. "It's a complete disaster."

The immediate impact would be that the Internal Revenue Service would stop paying subsidies to those in federally run exchanges.

In 2014, more than 4.6 million people were getting those subsidies but the number is projected to grow to as many as 13 million by 2016.

Most of those who lose subsidies would no longer be required to have insurance, because they would fall into an exemption in the law for those who have to pay more than 8 percent of family income for premiums.

"Since a lot of people can't afford insurance without the tax credits, you're looking at a lot of people shedding coverage," says Nicholas Bagley, a law professor at the University of Michigan.

Those who hang onto their coverage and pay the premium without help "are likely to be sicker on average than the people who shed their coverage because they're the ones who need insurance the most," he says.

Indeed, the insurance industry argued in a legal brief for a related case that elimination of the federal exchange subsidies could seriously undermine those markets, creating an insurance death spiral.

"A sicker pool of consumers results in higher premiums, which causes an additional relatively healthy subset of participants to drop out, which in turn results in a further increase in premiums," the group's trade group, America's Health Insurance Plans, said in its brief.

Eliminating subsidies also would undermine the so-called employer mandate that seeks to require larger firms to provide coverage. That's because it requires employers to pay a fine if their employees obtain subsidies on the exchange. If there are no subsidies, there are no employer fines and thus effectively, no mandate.

So what could be done? Some have argued that states that rely on the federal government to run their exchanges could establish their own marketplaces. But legal experts believe that's problematic as well.

"The practical obstacle is that creating an exchange is not child's play," says Bagley. "They've got to be able to carry out a variety of functions," including working with consumer assistance groups and overseeing plan's compliance with the laws.

While some have suggested that states could create a "virtual" exchange on paper and then contract with the federal government to run it, Bagley says the law on the subject is pretty explicit. "States would have to do more than just the bare minimum," he said.

Timing and financing would also pose practical problems. The final deadline for states to apply for federal funding to establish an exchange has passed. And a Supreme Court decision is likely to come in late June of next year, which is after another deadline (June 15) for states to use their own funds to establish an exchange in time for the 2015-16 open enrollment season.

The political obstacles are potentially even bigger.

In six states, even if a governor wanted to establish an exchange, the state legislature has specifically taken that authority away , according to the National Conference of State Legislatures. Georgia became the seventh state earlier this year.

That means state legislatures will have to get involved, said Bagley.

And many "are full of new members after the mid-term elections who specifically campaigned against the ACA."

Still, not everyone is convinced all this would spell the ACA's end.

"Congress will step in," predicts health economist Tom Miller of the conservative American Enterprise Institute.

"We're going to have the kind of political give and take which was abbreviated and artificially truncated when the law was passed," he said. "It's not a pretty process, but that's why we have a government and we elect people."

http://www.npr.org/blogs/health/2014/11/26/366808795/if-high-court-strikes-federal-exchange-subsidies-health-law-could-unravel?utm_source=linkedin.com&utm_medium=social&utm_campaign=npr&utm_term=nprnews


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    12 years ago

I think it is unlikely that the SCOTUS will strike down the subsidies - but it is possible.

Rather than hating on the SCOTUS, hating on the people who brought the suit, or hating on one political party or the other - let's discuss what would happen and what would need to be done if the SCOTUS were to rule the subsidies illegal under the PPACA in states without a state exchange.

 
 
 
Larry Hampton
Professor Quiet
link   Larry Hampton    12 years ago

There are a lot of folks and businesses that have undergone, or are undergoing big changes, to try and adapt to the ACA. Alreadyconfusing and exasperating; this will make it even worse.

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika     12 years ago

Have to agree with you Larry.

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    12 years ago

Larry

Good point, any significant changes made suddenly and without a "path after the change" plan will be extremely disruptive to a process that is just beginning to run a little more effectively after the initial chaos.

If the SCOTUS were to strike the subsidies from non-state run exchanges, I would hope that it would be effective January 1, 2016 giving the administration time to work with the Congress to make changes to the PPACA to insure the nation is actually moving towards real health care reform and improvements.

 
 
 
Larry Hampton
Professor Quiet
link   Larry Hampton    12 years ago

...any significant changes made suddenly and without a "path after the change" plan will be extremely disruptive to a process...

The stated objective many Republicans have expressed, is to push the defunding, in order to see the entire thing collapse. Others seem to think that the flexing of partisan muscle will create a more balanced approachin the crafted law. That creates too much confusion for those trying to decide what to do about their family or business' health insurance.

...to insure the nation is actually moving towards real health care reform and improvements.

We need it badly. We already subsidise health care for those who can't afford it, so we may as well figure out a system that will work better for all. My main problem with the entire fiasco has been right from the get-go, that the cost of this would end up being footed by the Middle Class. The Middle class can ill afford any more bills, or confusion about how to pay those bills. We break the back of the Middle Class, and this country is doomed.

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    12 years ago

Larry

The PPACA was a small step - it did little to reduce the costs of healthcare it merely changed who was paying the exorbitant costs from the individual to the taxpayer

The PPACA should not and will not be repealed!

The PPACA should be and will be changed (additions, deletions, modifications to the Act) and hopefully it will then allow us to proceed towards more affordable and better healthcare for more people rather than simply shifting costs to the government/taxpayers.

I appreciate your feedback and perspective.

 
 

Who is online


shona1


68 visitors