╌>

Does The Fifth Amendment Still Matter?

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  sean-treacy  •  12 years ago  •  32 comments

Does The Fifth Amendment Still Matter?
A number of commentators have argued tonight, with no challenge by their media interviewers, that even if the evidence was insufficient to indict Officer Darren Wilson, justice would have been better served if the grand jury had indicted anyway. That way, the reasoning goes, we could have had a public trial in the light of day where everyone could have seen that the case was insufficient. That, we are to believe, would have made it easier for the community to accept the result.The interests of the community, however, are not the only ones in the equation, much less the most important ones. What about the interests of the suspect? Those are the interests the Constitution addresses.The Fifth Amendment states: No person shall be held to answer for a capital, or otherwise infamous crime, unless on a presentment or indictment of a grand jury.The Constitution does not consider the grand jury to be a rubber stamp. It is a core protection. It stands as the buffer between the government prosecutor and the citizen-suspect; it safeguards Americans, who are presumed innocent, from being subjected to the anxiety, infamy and expense of a trial unless there is probable cause to believe they have committed a serious offense.And put aside the constitutional argument. Rabble-rousers want Wilson indicted, despite the lack of probable-cause evidence, on the theory that it would be more just to have a public trial in a case where a man has lost his life. But why would it not be equally justifiable to argue that, because a man has lost his life, the ultimate trial jury should also ignore the law and convict, despite an even more stark lack of murder evidence beyond a reasonable doubt? At what point do we stop enabling the grievance industry to override our core constitutional protections?If we are going to uphold our Constitution, it does not matter that thoughtful commentators suppose a public trial would best serve the community. The Fifth Amendment holds that a person has the right not to be subjected to a public trial i.e., the right not to be indicted unless the state can prove to a grand jury that there is probable cause to believe he committed a crime.Officer Wilson had a constitutional right not to be indicted in the absence of sufficient evidence. That right to individual liberty outweighs the medias abstract claim that a public trial would serve the public interest. http://www.nationalreview.com/corner/393439/does-fifth-amendment-grand-jury-protection-still-matter-andrew-c-mccarthy

Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    12 years ago

Meanwhile back in Chicago....

The fifth amendment means nothing as long as your priorities are mixed up.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   seeder  Sean Treacy    12 years ago
Not panicking, just trying to educate the ignorant. Pay attention and you'll walk away a more informed person.
 
 
 
Jim Cassity
Freshman Silent
link   Jim Cassity    12 years ago

John that is not how a grand jury works. A grand jury gets all evidence both accusatory and mitigating, when deciding if there is sufficient evidence to establish probable cause. If the Grand jury was only able to see specific evidence there would never be a no true bill issued from a grand jury.

If the prosecutor would have taken it directly to trial the judge would have held a probable cause hearing and would have probably dismissed the case due to lack of probable cause. If that would have happened it would look even more like the system is rigged.

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   1stwarrior    12 years ago

John - if I'm not mistaken, I gave you this information once before -

While all states have provisions in their laws that allow for grand juries, roughly half of the states don't use them. Courts often use preliminary hearings prior to criminal trials, instead of grand juries, which are adversarial in nature. As with grand juries, preliminary hearings are meant to determine whether there is enough evidence, or probable cause, to indict a criminal suspect. Unlike a grand jury, a preliminary hearing is usually open to the public and involves lawyers and a judge (not so with grand juries, other than the prosecutor). Sometimes, a preliminary hearing proceeds a grand jury. One of the biggest differences between the two is the requirement that a defendant request a preliminary hearing, although the court may decline a request.

Grand Jury Proceedings

Grand jury proceedings are much more relaxed than normal court room proceedings. There is no judge present and frequently there are no lawyers except for the prosecutor. The prosecutor will explain the law to the jury and work with them to gather evidence and hear testimony. Under normal courtroom rules of evidence, exhibits and other testimony must adhere to strict rules before admission. However, a grand jury has broad power to see and hear almost anything they would like. However, unlike the vast majority of trials, grand jury proceedings are kept in strict confidence. This serves two purposes: It encourages witnesses to speak freely and without fear of retaliation. It protects the potential defendant's reputation in case the jury does not decide to indict.

The Grand Jury's Decision and a Prosecutor's Discretion

Grand juries do not need a unanimous decision from all members to indict, but it does need a supermajority of 2/3 or 3/4 agreement for an indictment (depending on the jurisdiction). Even though a grand jury may not choose to indict, a prosecutor may still bring the defendant to trial if she thinks she has a strong enough case. However, the grand jury proceedings are often a valuable test run for prosecutors in making the decision to bring the case. If the grand jury chooses to indict, the trial will most likely begin faster. Without a grand jury indictment, the prosecutor has to demonstrate to the trial judge that she has enough evidence to continue with the case. However, with a grand jury indictment, the prosecutor can skip that step and proceed directly to trial.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   seeder  Sean Treacy    12 years ago
"But you seem to be saying that we should follow the fifth amendment, which we do."Many professional commentators, who should know better, have made the exact opposite argument,that "community justice" or whatever you want to call it, demands that the constitutional rights of officer Wilson should have been tossed aside and that he should have been subjected to a show trial."Darren Wilson is free to go."So what? You get caught up one small portion of the issue while the larger issue of protecting the constitutional rights of all citizens is what matters. It's important to understand just how at odds the "put him on trial no matter the evidence" line of thinking is with our constitution.."they have every right to advocste for reforms"Of course they do. Advocate all you want that the traditional role of the grand jury to act as a shield of citizens should be removed and that grand juries should only be presented with limited and distorted pictures of evidence. I'm sure that'll be a real popular arguememt.
 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   seeder  Sean Treacy    12 years ago
John, a prosecutor has a sworn ethical duty to only move forward with a prosecution if he believes he has sufficient admissible evidence to win a conviction at trial. If he can't even secure an indictment based on all of the evidence at hand he is breaching his duty by trying to secure indictments based on misleading the jury by presenting a distorted version of the evidence.

Obviously, in this case, with the defendants version of events supported by physical and eyewitness testimony, there is no way that a jury could find officer Wilson guilty beyond a reasonable doubt. Knowing he had no chance win a conviction, the DA probably should not have even gone to the grand jury.

The grnad jury functioned exactly as it should have. It looked at all the evidence and couldn't see a basis for trial. Think about the alternative you support basically submitting propaganda to the jury to secure a phony indictment.

How is it in the compatible with justice to indict someone based on a misleading picture of the evidence at hand. No reasonable person can argue that is a good or fair system. The grand jury process is already heavily weighted against the dependent as he can't challenge witnesses or evidence, it would completely dismantle the protective role of grand juries intended by the founders if prosecutors simply turn the grand jury into a show trial.
 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    12 years ago

The Fifth Amendment is not an issue in this case; WILSON SHOULD NOT HAVE BEEN ALLOWED TO ADDRESS THE GRAND JURY prospective indictees virtually NEVER ARE CALLED TO DO SO, UNCHALLENGED AND ON THEIR OWN BEHALF.

At one point, PROSECUTOR McCULLOUGH SAID TO WILSON IN THE PRESENCE OF THE GRAND JURY, "THIS MUST BE HARD FOR YOU?"

The f'n PROSECUTOR coming to the DEFENSE of Wilson! What a pile of fraudulent crap!

AND WILSON WAS NEVER CROSS-EXAMINED! CROSS-EXAMINATION IS HOW WITNESSES STORY/CREDIBILITY IS ASSESSED.

Fifth Amendment my ass.

Understand the process and recognize when it's been co-opted via the conflict-of-interests officials and those with agendas.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    12 years ago

Apparently there was none, or not enough incriminating evidence, to indite.

In fact, McCullough said "there was conflicting evidence."

There's conflicting evidence in virtually every case AND AN INDICTMENT FOLLOWED BY A TRIAL IS HOW THE CONFLICTING EVIDENCE IS EVALUATED. And under oath, witnesses are cross-examined and often made to address every word of their testimony.

And prosecutors are not generally allowing exculpatory evidence to come before a grand jury, and do you know why

BECAUSE THEY'RE F'N PROSECUTORS!

For the Grand Jury to come to a conclusion on whether he was within Missouri law they would need to see all the evidence.

AND THAT'S WHY THERE ARE INDICTMENTS THAT LEAD TO TRIALS!

 
 
 
Larry Hampton
Professor Quiet
link   Larry Hampton    12 years ago

McCullough saying "this must be hard for you," means nothing.

I'm pretty sure I have heard prosecutors say such things before too, in an attempt to throw the witness off-guard. it's a common ploy.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    12 years ago

Is it necessary to go to trial to refute those accounts, if forensic evidence supports the defendants version?

Yes, Mike, it is. The forensic evidence is subject to cross-examination in a transparent public trial.

"Conflicting evidence" is one of the main reasons for an indictment. Grand Juries do not determine innocence or guilt; the prosecutor has acted like a defense attorney from day one.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    12 years ago

Wilson did not have to testify. But since he was a witness to an event where he is not charged, it is more than reasonable, and logical, that he would be called to testify.

Every alleged-indictee is a presumed "eye witness" to the event for which he may be charged. And it is rare when one gets to testify on their own behalf before a grand jury. The prisons are filled with "eye witnesses" who never got to chat before a grand jury.

Since we're being "logical."

Wilson didn't need to plead the Fifth Amendment BECAUSE HE WAS NEVER CROSS-EXAMINED (sometimes big letters are necessary) by the so-called "prosecutor."

When a prosecutor really wants an indictment, you would not expect the grand jury process to look anything like what happened in Darren Wilsons case. The prosecutor would have no obligation to put forward the conflicting eyewitness testimony, or introduce pictures of Officer Wilsons injuries although grand jury members could ask for them if they somehow knew they existed.

Instead, the prosecutor could put forward only the first few witnesses corroborating his own theory, along with the evidence that Wilson fired ten shots from a substantial distance away.

Eventually, all the exculpatory evidence would have to be shared with the defense before trial, under a line of cases that started over fifty years ago with Brady v. Maryland .

But once charges are on the table, the prosecutor has enormous leverage in bargaining for the kind of plea he wants a case like Wilsons, for example, might even include the threat of the death penalty.

McCullough clearly did not do what his prosecutorial role called for.

Quips-R-Us has returned.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   seeder  Sean Treacy    12 years ago

"NY WITNESSES TO THE SHOOTING OF MICHAEL BROWN MADE STATEMENTS INCONSISTENT WITH OTHER STATEMENTS THEY MADE AND ALSO CONFLICTED WITH THE PHYSICAL EVIDENCE. SOME WERE COMPLETELY REFUTED BY THE PHYSICAL EVIDENCE. AN EXAMPLE -- BEFORE THE RESULT OF AN AUTOPSY WAS RELEASED, WITNESSES CLAIM THEY SAW OFFICER WILSON STAND OVER MICHAEL BROWN AND FIRE MANY ROUNDS INTO HIS BACK. OTHERS CLAIM THAT OFFICER WILSON SHOT MR. BROWN IN THE BACK AS MR. BROWN WAS RUNNING AWAY. HOWEVER, ONCE THE AUTOPSY FINDINGS WERE RELEASED SHOWING MICHAEL BROWN HAD NOT SUSTAINED ANY WOUNDS TO THE BACK OF HIS BODY, NO ADDITIONAL WITNESSES MADE SUCH A CLAIM. SEVERAL WITNESSES ADJUSTED THEIR STORIES IN THEIR SUBSEQUENT STATEMENTS. SOME EVEN ADMITTED THEY DID NOT WITNESS THE EVENT AT ALL BUT MERELY REPEATED WHAT THEY HEARD IN THE NEIGHBORHOOD OR ASSUMED"

Is this what you meant by his "conflicting evidence" statement,becauseI don't seeanything else close to that claim in his statement.

Obviously,inconsistentand changing stories donot support an indictment.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   seeder  Sean Treacy    12 years ago

ILSON SHOULD NOT HAVE BEEN ALLOWED TO ADDRESS THE GRAND JURY


The exact opposite is true. Most defendants are not allowed to testify before a grand jury by their own attorney because it's typically insanely bad strategy to allow the prosecution a chance to examine a defendant without a defense lawyer present in the room.

The only time competent counsel will allow their client to testify before a grand jury is when they have absolutely nothing to hide. The reason being, if, as in most cases, the prosecution has enough to secure an indictment, the defendant's sworn testimony can then be used against him.


Any prosecutor would be overjoyed to have the chance to interrogate a defendant under oath during a grand jury hearing. It's one of the biggest possible advantages the prosecution can receive, which is why defense counsel rarely let their clients testify.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   seeder  Sean Treacy    12 years ago

Did she testify before the grand jury?

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    12 years ago

Sean, the physical "evidence" and its corroborators are subject to cross examination; THAT'S WHY THERE ARE TRIALS.

Obviously,inconsistentand changing stories donot support an indictment.

But "conflicting evidence" (McCullough's own words) generally does. And not all of the witnesses changed or recanted their testimonies.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   seeder  Sean Treacy    12 years ago

It's my contention it doesn't matter.

(1) the standard for indictment is not a scintilla of evidence, it's a preponderance. If the standard was a scintilla, I could indict you tomorrow for the Kennedy assassination and the murder of Mike Brown. Simply claiming something is theoretically possible is not sufficient.

(2) Which witness still claims Brown was shot in the back after the autopsy results were revealed? They changed their stories so her possibility that was shot in the back is actually irrelevant.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    12 years ago

WILSON SHOULD NOT HAVE BEEN ALLOWED TO ADDRESS THE GRAND JURY

I agree.

Sean, tell me why almost no potential-indictees get to testify before grand juries; why was Wilson an exception to that reality?

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    12 years ago

And Melenik was misquoted in the St. Louis Post Dispatch and the NY Times. The Times subsequently admitted so and what JR quoted above is her actual position.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    12 years ago

Did she testify before the grand jury?

Did McCullough call her to testify, Sean?

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   seeder  Sean Treacy    12 years ago

Can you please point to where McCollough described the evidence as conflicting. I'd love to see that in context.

He did say individual witnesses provided inconsistent statements that were inconsistent with prior statements they made.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   seeder  Sean Treacy    12 years ago

orian Johnson's grand jury testimony claims Brown may have been shot from behind.

What does that even mean? Either his accomplice saw Brown shot from behind or he didn't. If his answer was "maybe" its not actual evidence, its a guess.

McCulloch dismissed testimony from people who said Brown may have been shot from behind as being unreliable , when McCulloch has no right to do tha

You are correct, that's why he didn't do it. All of the evidence was presented to the grand jury, it's the grand jurors who decided what testimony was believable and what wasn't. McCullough just provided a summary of the evidence to the media, the jurors actually evaluated the evidence.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   seeder  Sean Treacy    12 years ago

So the case against McCullogh is that he didn't mislead the jury into a sham indictment and instead let them evaluate and assess all of the evidence.

How terrible!

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    12 years ago

The Fifth Amendment to the United States Constitution provides that "No person shall be held to answer for a capital, or otherwise infamous crime, unless on a presentment or indictment of a Grand Jury which makes the argument regarding Wilson's right to evoke it a circular one. Having Wilson (a suspect) testify on his own behalf before a grand jury is analogous to auditing one's one tax return.

And without cross-examination, Wilson was an advocate without an opposition.

Michael Brown, like Trayvon Martin, was unable to testify.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    12 years ago

Update at 9:43 p.m. ET: Physical Evidence And Conflicting Accounts

Having announced the jury's decision, McCulloch stressed the importance of physical evidence in the case. He then ran down a long list of various witness accounts in which people gave different versions of the events that transpired after Wilson and Brown began the encounter that left Brown dead in the street.

* When Prosecutor McCullough states last night at great length, that there were conflicting eyewitness testimonies ... wouldn't a jury accepting this great number of conflicting eyewitness testimony as a reason to pursue indictment and probable cause.

McCullough spoke at length about how many eyewitnesses testimonies were found to be untrue compared with physical evidence. Since there is no cross-examination by the G.J. and all eyewitnesses were presented in front of the G.J.....who is McCullough to say that any eyewitness testimonies were not credible unless that's how the prosecutor presented it.

I also noticed that in his speech last night he said how Michael Brown bull rushed Darren Wilson just prior to being shot dead. Although that is Wilson's testimony, there are conflicting testimony so how dare McCullough state publicly this one-sided description as if it were undisputed.

* So much was not mentioned by McCullough (how far was Michael Brown's body from Darren Wilson? What is the explanation and Wilson's defense for each of the 12 shots fired? etc). And so much was said about the case by McCullough that defended Wilson and denigrated any evidence/testimony to the contrary.

...

And

Ferguson Grand Jury Faced Mass of Evidence in Decision, Much of It Conflicting

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    12 years ago

And in testifying, made himself subject to comparison to his own testimony,

In the absence of cross examination

Oh, yeah, now I see.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    12 years ago

It is not rare that he "GETS" to testify. It is rare that a person will think that testifying is the wise option.

No, it's actually rare; 14% of suspects is the high water mark (NY, 2004).

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    12 years ago

Are you really having that much difficulty with this?

Let me help you understand, Robrert G most suspects don't get to testify WITH THE PROSECUTION PROVIDING THEIR EXCULPATORY EVIDENCE.

My fault for assuming I wouldn't need to make the obvious distinction.

But now we're on the same page.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    12 years ago

He was cross examined by the prosecuter,

No, he was defended by the prosecutor (his assistants).

The GJ questions were softballs read the transcript.

If Wilson was charged by information by prosecutor, the case would've been heard in open court -- for all to see. if Wilson was charged by information, a judge would make the determination of probable cause after listening to evidence presented by the prosecution in a courtroom.

McCullouch chose the grand jury route, which is not public. Further, if an officer states that he felt his life was threatened at any point during an altercation, it's almost unheard-of for an officer to be indicted by a grand jury.

s_grand_jury.html

And

Officer Darren Wilsons grand jury testimony is downright unbelievable. And we mean that in the most literal sense of the term: its difficult or impossible to believe. Dont just take it from us: CNN legal analyst Sunny Hostin called the testimony fanciful and not credible when she skewered St. Louis County Prosecuting Attorney Robert McCulloch for asking softball questions during the cross examination.

When a prosecutor has a prospective target, a suspect, a defendant a prospective defendant inside of the grand jury, thats the prosecutors chance to cross-examine that person, Hostin explained on a CNN broadcast.

These prosecutors treated Darren Wilson with such kid gloves. Their questions were all softballs, he wasnt challenged, he wasnt pressed. It was just unbelievable to me the way they treated him in front of that grand jury.

The proceedings themselves are as unbelievable as the content of Wilsons testimony that the officer wasnt required to provide an immediate statement to the police, so that he had a month to think about his testimony, to think about how he could depict Mike Brown as a savage.

On a technicality, I will say Wilson was "cross-examined" however not in a manner or forum that fit the definition and intent of same.

  1. In law, cross - examination is the interrogation of a witness called by one's opponent.
    Wilson had no opponents in the prosecutor's office.
 
 
 
Steve Ott
Professor Silent
link   Steve Ott    12 years ago

Anything You Don't Say Will Be Used Against You

If Wilson had been anyone but a cop in California, his silence would have called for a guilty verdict.

First: There is the theory of the Fifth Amendment.

Second: There is the practice of the Fifth Amendment.

The theory goes back to the Magna Carta.

In practice, prosecutors, and the public in general, have felt and acted as though an individuals silence meant guilt. If you are not guilty, why wouldn't you talk, if you are guilty, of course you won't talk. Rather like the NSA saying that if you have nothing to hide, why are you against us?

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    12 years ago

You'll just have to live with the injustice, I guess.

I guess.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    12 years ago

Hostin used to be on Faux News. That means she is a congenital liar, doesn't it?

Even a blind squirrel finds an acorn once-in-a-while, Robert G.

But I'll remember your admonishment next time you wax-Fox.

Thanks for the heads-up.

 
 

Who is online

Hal A. Lujah


88 visitors