╌>

Rookie Cleveland Cop Shoots, Kills 12 Year Old Boy Holding Fake Gun

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  jerry-verlinger  •  12 years ago  •  26 comments

Rookie Cleveland Cop Shoots, Kills 12 Year Old Boy Holding Fake Gun

FreeVector-CBS-Vector-Logo.jpg?width=100

Last Update Nov 24, 2014 4:06 PM EST

Tamir Rice, a 12-year-old Cleveland resident, went to the neighborhood playground Saturday with friends carrying a fake gun and waved it around. It cost him his life.

CBS affiliate WOIO in Cleveland reports one of the 911 callers said of the boy and his Airsoft replica gun at the time: "It's probably fake, but you know what, it's scaring the [expletive] out of people."

5971233_G.jpg?width=450

The 12-year-old boy shot in the police-involved shooting has been identified as Tamir Rice.
(Source: Attorney Timothy J. Kucharski)

Police showed up. One of the officers called to the playground saw the pistol sitting on a table or bench, and watched the boy grab it and put it in his waistband, Jeff Follmer, president of the Cleveland Police Patrolmen's Association, said.

The cops had not been told the 911 caller thought the gun could be a fake, Follmer said. The Airsoft replica gun, which fires the equivalent of BB pellets, was missing its orange safety cap, which is designed to indicate its status as something other than a deadly weapon.

airsoft.jpg?width=450 Cleveland police say this is the replica weapon they recovered from a 12-year-old who was shot by police on a rec center playground on Nov. 22, 2014. [WOIO]

The officers ordered Rice to put his hands up. Police officials said the boy instead grabbed for his fake gun in his waistband.

Deputy Chief Ed Tomba said: "That's when the officer fired."

Rice died the next morning. Officials said at a news conference Monday the cops were standing 10 feet away when one of them shot the boy.

Attorney Timothy Kucharski, who has been hired by Rice's family, told WOIO that "an innocent boy was shot and killed" by a rookie officer.

The two officers involved in the shooting have been placed on administrative leave, which is standard procedure. The Cleveland Plain Dealer reported that the other officer involved is a 10-year department veteran.

"This is not a black and white issue. This is a right and wrong issue. This is not a racial issue. This is about people doing their jobs the right way," said Kucharski.

The police department said it has collected surveillance video and other evidence and will present it to the county prosecutor's office. An official also said they have yet to formally interview the officers about the incident, and that the officer who fired the fatal shot was shaken by it.

Tomba said surveillance video of the shooting is "very clear" about what occurred, but he wouldn't discuss details of what it shows.

People representing the boy's family viewed the video Monday, but police didn't release it publicly because it is considered evidence and because they want to be sensitive to the family, the community and the officer, who is distraught, officials said.

After reviewing the evidence, prosecutors will present the case to a grand jury, which will decide whether the officer was justified in using force against the boy.

Donnie Pastard a local activist with the local anticrime group, Black on Black, told WOIO he doesn't think there was racial malice involved, but that doesn't excuse what happened.

"I do not think these police officers left home to kill a black child. But I do think there's training involved there. There's the race factor involved. This is something we gonna have to talk about, whether we like it or not," said Pastard.

A 14-year-old who was at the scene on Saturday told WOIO they warned Rice about playing with fake guns on the playground.

"It could have been prevented by him going home," he said. "I wouldn't want my life to end so young. Probably had a bright future ahead of him."

On Sunday, state Rep. Alicia Reece, of Cincinnati, announced plans to introduce new legislation requiring that all BB guns, air rifles, and Airsoft guns sold in Ohio be brightly colored or have prominent florescent strips, so there is no confusion. According to federal law, toy and replica guns must have an orange tip on the barrel.

For Deputy Chief Tomba, there could have been a simpler solution to the problem.

"When an officer gives a command, we expect it to be followed," said Tomba.


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
LynneA
Freshman Silent
link   LynneA    12 years ago

From what I've seen/heard it's a justifiable shot, tragically ending the life of a kid.Whether the 911 caller thought it was a real gun or not is irrelevant, the relevancy came when this young man decided to "play" with a gun in a park.Even with a florescent strip, do we expect LEO, in a nano-second, to determine a guns viability before discharging his weapon to defend himself?

If you're going tohave bb guns or real guns in your home you must take responsibility for events, known and unknown,related to owning them. Truly sorry this family will suffer the lose of their son and to the LEO who will life with the tragedy for the rest of their life.

 
 
 
jennilee
Freshman Silent
link   jennilee    12 years ago
If the orange cap was removed, then someone thought it would be a good idea to wave it around scaring peopleand that decision cost him his life. Police must make fast decisions regarding their safety and the safety of those around.
 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    12 years ago

I just posted another article about a rookie cop killing an innocent man in New York City on Friday (11/21/14). (That victim is also black.) The cop said the shooting was an 'accident', and it looks like that is the case. [ LINK ]

This is the comment I made regarding that article, which applies to many of the recent stories about police malfeasance, including the Wilson/Brown incident;

I have said over and over the training of police officers is not as important as thepsychological pre-screening of police academy candidates.

An officer may seem to be adequately trained when he or she graduates from the academy, but how well they are able to apply that training once they are in the field, will depend on their psychological ability to handle the enormous responsibility they take on once they are handed that badge and gun.

It is my opinion that the psychological pre-screening of police academy candidates is currently inadequate. The increased reports of unjustified police shootings, abuse and other misconduct would seem to support that opinion.

 
 
 
jennilee
Freshman Silent
link   jennilee    12 years ago
You have a point, but what about the other side of it? Parents need to teach children that not obeying a police officer could lead to a fatal mistake. I do not believe these officers wanted to kill anyone, but waving a gun is a sure fire way to die.
 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    12 years ago

Parents need to teach children that not obeying a police officer could lead to a fatal mistake.

I agree. In the Cleveland incident, I think the kid may have reached for his gun to show the cop the gun was not real. Which goes to your point about out the lack of proper training by the parents. When the cop said "raise your hands", had the kid been taught properly, he wouldinstinctively reacted by raising his hands. However, his immature decision to show the cop the gun was a toy was a fatal mistake.

IMO, the cop, seeing his suspect was only a child, should have told the kid not to move and asked him where he got the gun.

I do not believe these officers wanted to kill anyone, but waving a gun is a sure fire way to die.

Of course they didn't want to kill anyone. And confronting someone waving a gun goes to my opinion that manyofficersare notpsychologically capable ofhandlingcertain circumstances.

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    12 years ago

"Whether the 911 caller thought it was a real gun or not is irrelevant...."

(?!) Come on Lynn, the caller, probably realized it was a kid he was watching, and made it clear, more than once, that if was probably a fake gun. I assume he did that in order to help avoid a possible tragedy when the police showed up.

Didn't work.

The 911 operator, failing to transmit all of the information provided in the call, cost a family the loss of their son just before the holidays. A 12 year old boy lost his life because he was acting like a 12 year old boy, and a cop was acting like the typical overlyaggressive,triggerhappy cops we are seeing moreandmore all over America.

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi    12 years ago

We played with toy guns all our lives. The six-shooters looked like real Western guns and we had the holsters. My sister and I were Tomboys to the core and our male cousins and we played on the nearby playground with other kids with guns and rifles.

It's a different time, a different world. These toy guns with the tips on them that can be removed are not working. All toy guns should have the barrels painted half way down with the orange or yellow paint. That cannot be removed.

If a child is killed because he or she is brandishing a toy gun that has been painted over to hide the identifying paint, all police efforts should be focused on finding out how it happened, and the parents of the child and any other adults involved should have to serve a minimum of two years prison time for complicity in the death.... no plea deals.

It's the only way. And be damn sure to post this law on every telephone poll in both Spanish and English, Farsi, Chinese, and every other damn language of every immigrant in this country. If we are going to allow them we at least owe the children the protection from police who, rightfully, are wary of being targeted by gun-bearing minorities who feel they are being "oppressed."

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    12 years ago

I don't blame the cop one bit.

The cop gave the kid instructions to show his hands, the 2 1/2 seconds later he shot the kid.

I understand what you're saying about the risk Lynn, but there other professions that carry a higher risk than being a police officer. Every year hundreds of people leave home to go to work and never to return.

Occupational Fatality Rate :

H ow Policing Compares to the Top 10 Most Dangerous Jobs

The Census of Fatal Occupational Injuries is a great source of information, but like all statistics, it's the interpretation of the data that matters. The census produces a "fatality rate," detailing the number of individuals fatally injured per 100,000 workers. It also provides a raw number of fatal on-the-job injuries. Making the top 10 most dangerous jobs for 2010, the most recent year for which data is available, are:

  • 1- Fishers and related fishing workers, at a rate of 116 deaths per 100,000
  • 2- Logging workers, at a rate of 91 deaths per 100,000
  • 3- Aircraft pilots and flight engineers, at a rate of 71 deaths per 100,000
  • 4- Farmers and ranchers, at a rate of 41 deaths per 100,000
  • 5- Mining machine operators, at a rate of 38 deaths per 100,000
  • 6- Roofers, at a rate of 32 deaths per 100,000
  • 7- Refuse and recyclable material collectors, at a rate of 29 deaths per 100,000
  • 8- Drivers / sales workers and truck drivers, at a rate of 21 deaths per 100,000
  • 9- Industrial machinery repair and installation, at a rate of 20 per 100,000
  • 10-Police and sheriff's patrol officers, at a rate of 19 per 100,000
 
 
 
red shadow
Freshman Silent
link   red shadow    12 years ago

This is tragic and there is blame for many people.

Why would the police come within 10 feet of someone with a gun?

The parents should have told the boy not to take a toy gun to a public place and to obey police commands.

The 911 operator should have passed on the info that the gun was maybe a toy.

This is a very rare event but a kid is still dead. There is no good way to prevent this. Kids do not always obey parents. A toy gun painted fully bright orange could be painted black. a criminal could paint a real gun orange. As long as there are millions of guns people will at times be killed by guns.

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    12 years ago

Had she suggested it might be fake and they approached it as a fake gun in a more relaxed posture suppose it wasn't fake?

Cops are never relaxed when it comes to a possible gun situation, today they are trained to assume there may be a gun somewhere even when conducting a routine traffic stop.

Had 911 relayed the gun may be fake, the cops may have taken the precaution to insure they didn't find themselves killing an innocent person.

That speaks to Max's probably scenarios. What we have here again like so many other senseless shootings is the person not obeying LEO commands to the letter.

A 'person', yes. Tamir Rice was just a child.

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    12 years ago

Do you expect the cop to watch the kid grab for the gun and hope he doesn't get shot at? Not very realistic.

Don't be ridicules.

Police officers are supposed to be trained to assert authority and maintain control in confrontational situations. If this cop couldn't get a 12 year old kid to freeze or at least hesitate, long enough to evaluate his (the cops) situation correctly, then he does not deserve the responsibility he he was granted when he took possession of his badge and gun.

One nervous and jerky cop = one dead innocent kid.

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    12 years ago

If a child is killed because he or she is brandishing a toy gun that has been painted over to hide the identifying paint, all police efforts should be focused on finding out how it happened, and the parents of the child and any other adults involved should have to serve a minimum of two years prison time for complicity in the death.... no plea deals.

That's a little over kill. But I see your anger and frustration.

Anyway, it turns out the gun was not exactly 'fake'. I was a pellet gun that fires lead pellets (and sometimes also BBs) using compressed gas. They are not considered to be a lethal weapon and they are not required to have an orange tipped gun barrel.

It's the only way.

It's not the only way. Our streets will not be safe from under-qualified police officers until more adequate screening techniques are used when choosing police academy recruits.

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    12 years ago

It's my understanding that as soon as the cop gave instructions the kid reached for the gun.

It's my understanding cops very often lie on their police reports.

 
 
 
LoneRanger01
Freshman Silent
link   LoneRanger01    12 years ago

"The Airsoft replica gun, which fires the equivalent of BB pellets, was missing its orange safety cap, which is designed to indicate its status as something other than a deadly weapon." An inaccuracy in the report. The Airsoft replica does NOT and is NOT sold with an orange colorcap to indicate that it is NOT a real gun. So maybe some or most of the blame for this unfortunate incedent lies upon the shoulders of Airsoft.

 
 
 
LoneRanger01
Freshman Silent
link   LoneRanger01    12 years ago

2904_discussions.jpg 2905_discussions.jpg The both look real. the top gun is the "FAKE" but it shoots .177mm pellets or BB's. and is powered by an air cylinder. the reason it is sold WITHOUT the color cap is because it is considered a DANGEROUS weapon. That being said I have to ask, What was the parents thinking, when they were letting their 12 year old child play with a DANGEROUS weapon?

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    12 years ago

Why would the police come within 10 feet of someone with a gun?

I was listening to an interview with a police officer on CNN and that very question was raised. The officer said the entire protocol used in approaching this 'suspect' was contrary to common procedure.

According to the officer being interviewed, the squad car should have be stopped at a reasonably safe distance, facing the suspect, the officers should then have taken positions behind their car doors, drawn their guns and ordered the suspect (the kid) to drop his weapon, an action that required the kid to reach for and pull the gun from his waistband so he could drop it to ground.

The next 2 seconds would be critical, for if the kid looked like he was about to point the gun toward the cops, they would have no choice but to take him down, 12 years old or not. However, if the kid did drop the gun on the ground, which he apparently never had a chance to do,thecops would then be able to tell him tostep away from the gun and they couldhavesafely moved in and contained thesituation.

Kid goes home and has Christmas with his family.

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    12 years ago

That's the most ridiculous example I've ever seen to try and compare occupational hazard fatality rates in the same way as LE hazards.

What's ridicules is that you don't understand that a work related hazard is a work related hazard, be it from a gunwieldingperp or a 500 foot fall from a bridge, either way you leavethe job in a body bag. Also, both know there is a risk to be faced when they show up for work, more so for the bridge worker, but they both choose to go none-the-less.

Anyway, not all police officers that die on the job, die from gunfire, as Gunny pointed out, sometimes they are killed or die from other causes such as car crashes. Actually, according the Officer Down Memorial Page , between 2008 and 2013 886 officers died in the line of duty from various causes, of which 284 or 32% died from hostile gunfire.

Those numbers are what was used in calculating the risk factors in the 10 most hazardous jobs. Which btw, was compiled by Criminology Careers Expert , Timothy Roufa .

The real difference between police work and other hazardous jobs, is that when a mine machine operator or a logger makes a mistake he kills himself, when a cop makes a mistake he kills an innocent civilian ..... or 12 year old kid.

One other thing, there is no such thing as an 'accident', there are only mistakes.

 
 
 
Cerenkov
Professor Silent
link   Cerenkov    12 years ago
I agree. It wad a justified kill, although very tragic.
 
 
 
Cerenkov
Professor Silent
link   Cerenkov    12 years ago
Well said. It was justified but damn tragic.
 
 
 
jennilee
Freshman Silent
link   jennilee    12 years ago
Good question
 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika     12 years ago

You may want to read the attached link on information that has been made public about this LEO's past. Interesting to say the least.

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    12 years ago

But again how liberals choose to rationalize things is always a mystery to the sane person.

IMO, it's beyond yourintellectto understand the liberal rational, which over the years and through copious surveys, has been proved to be superior to the shallow, lessanalytical rational of Conservatives.

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    12 years ago

I hate to say it but it sounds what did was the right thing. They call it a "good shooting" and that the officer did nothing wrong. He followed his training as he should. The kid left him no choice.

You're wrong Randy, they call it a 'good shooting', but "they" are the cops, who make up their own rules as they go.

Yesterday I watched a newanalysis of the tape, and the cop fired his weapon less that 1 second after exiting the car. In other words, he jumped out of car and fired, no questions asked.

Normal procedure would have been to stop the squad car facing the suspect, get out of the car behind the door and order the suspect to "drop the weapon", or "show your hands" if the weapon is "holstered". If the suspect did anything other than what he was instructed to do the officer had the right to shoot without any further instruction.

In this case, no instruction or warning was given, the kid was shotimmediately. As for "good shoot", let a civilian review board make that decision, not the cops.

Also, once again a Grand Jury, after considering evidence presented by a less than unbias DA, came back with another 'No Bill'.

However, that ruling goes against what can be clearly seen on the tape, and this;

" Dec 12 (Reuters) - The death of a 12-year-old Cleveland boy fatally shot by police in November has been formally ruled a homicide, according to a county autopsy report released on Friday that found he was struck once in the abdomen. "

 
 

Who is online

Hal A. Lujah


88 visitors