The Great Immigration Betrayal
The Great Immigration BetrayalNOV. 15, 2014Ross DouthatIN the months since President Obama first seem poised as he now seems poised again to issue a sweeping executive amnesty for millions of illegal immigrants, weve learned two important things about how this administration approaches its constitutional obligations.First, we now have a clear sense of the legal arguments that will be used to justify the kind of move Obama himself previously described as a betrayal of our political order. They are, as expected, lawyerly in the worst sense, persuasive only if abstracted from any sense of precedent or proportion or political normality.Second, we now have a clearer sense of just how anti-democratically this president may be willing to be.The legal issues first. The White Houses case is straightforward: It has prosecutorial discretion in which illegal immigrants it deports, it has precedent-grounded power to protect particular groups from deportation, and it has statutory authority to grant work permits to those protected. Therefore, there can be no legal bar to applying discretion, granting protections and issuing work permits to roughly half the illegal-immigrant population.This arguments logic, at once consistent and deliberately obtuse, raises one obvious question: Why stop at half? (Activists are already asking.) After all, under this theory of what counts as faithfully executing the law, all that matters is that somebody, somewhere, is being deported; anyone and everyone else can be allowed to work and stay. So the president could temporarily legalize 99.9 percent of illegal immigrants and direct the Border Patrol to hand out work visas to every subsequent border crosser, so long as a few thousand aliens were deported for felonies every year.The reality is there is no agreed-upon limit to the scope of prosecutorial discretion in immigration law because no president has attempted anything remotely like what Obama is contemplating. In past cases, presidents used the powers hes invoking to grant work permits to modest, clearly defined populations facing some obvious impediment (war, persecution, natural disaster) to returning home. None of those moves even approached this plans scale, none attempted to transform a major public policy debate, and none were deployed as blackmail against a Congress unwilling to work the presidents will.And none of them had major applications outside immigration law. No defender of Obamas proposed move has successfully explained why it wouldnt be a model for a future president interested in unilateral rewrites of other areas of public policy (the tax code, for instance) where sweeping applications of discretion could achieve partisan victories by fiat. No liberal has persuasively explained how, after spending the last Republican administration complaining about presidential signing statements, it makes sense for the left to begin applying Cheneyite theories of executive power on domestic policy debates.Especially debates in which the executive branch is effectively acting in direct defiance of the electoral process. This is where the administration has entered extraordinarily brazen territory, since part of its original case for taking these steps was that they supposedly serve the public will, which only yahoos and congressional Republicans oppose.Continue reading the main storyContinue reading the main storyContinue reading the main storyThis argument was specious before; now it looks ridiculous. The election just past was not, of course, a formal referendum on the presidents proposed amnesty, but it was conducted with the promise of unilateral action in the background, and with immigration as one of the more hotly debated issues. The result was a devastating defeat for Obama and his party, and most polling on unilateral action is pretty terrible for the president.So there is no public will at work here. There is only the will to power of this White House.Which is why the thinking liberals move, if this action goes forward, will be to invoke structural forces, flaws inherent in our constitutional order, to justify Obamas unilateralism. This wont be a completely fallacious argument: Presidential systems like ours have a long record, especially in Latin America, of producing standoffs between executive and legislative branches, which tends to make executive power grabs more likely. In the United States this tendency has been less dangerous our imperial presidency has grown on us gradually; the worst overreaches have often been rolled back. But we do seem to be in an era whose various forces our open-ended post-9/11 wars, the ideological uniformity of the parties are making a kind of creeping caudillismo more likely.But if that evil must come, woe to the president who chooses it. And make no mistake, the president is free to choose. No immediate crisis forces his hand; no doom awaits the country if he waits. He once campaigned on constitutionalism and executive restraint; he once abjured exactly this power. There is still time for him to respect the limits of his office, the lines of authority established by the Constitution, the outcome of the last election.Or he can choose the power grab, and the accompanying disgrace. http://www.nytimes.com/2014/11/16/opinion/sunday/ross-douthat-the-great-immigration-betrayal.html?ref=opinion&_r=2

I take the Constitution very seriously, he told a Pennsylvania town hall in 2008. The biggest problems that were facing right now have to do with George Bush trying to bring more and more power into the Executive Branch and not go through Congress at all, and thats what I intend to reverse when Im President of the United States of America.
In 2011, he told a Univision town hall that there are enough laws on the books by Congress that are very clear in terms of how we have to enforce our immigration system. To ignore those congressional mandates through executive order, Obama said, would not conform with my appropriate role as president.
I know some people want me to bypass Congress and change the [immigration] on my own, he told the National Council of La Raza that year. Believe me, the idea of doing things on my own is very tempting. I promise you. Not just on immigration reform. But thats not how our system works. Thats not how our democracy functions. Thats not how our Constitution is written.
Obama seemed frustrated when pushed on the subject of deportations during a roundtable with Latino reporters in September 2011.
I just have to continue to say this notion that somehow I can just change the laws unilaterally is just not true, he said. We are doing everything we can administratively. But the fact of the matter is there are laws on the books that I have to enforce.
A heckler in 2013 urged him to take executive action on the matter, and Obama actually turned around at the lectern to respond directly.
If, in fact, I could solve all these problems without passing laws in Congress, then I would do so, he said. But were also a nation of laws. Thats part of our tradition. So the easy way out is to try to yell and pretend like I can do something by violating our laws, and what Im proposing is the harder path which is to use our democratic processes to achieve the same goal that you want to achieve.
...
As Douthat writes:
"But if that evil must come, woe to the president who chooses it. And make no mistake, the president is free to choose. No immediate crisis forces his hand; no doom awaits the country if he waits. He once campaigned on constitutionalism and executive restraint; he once abjured exactly this power. There is still time for him to respect the limits of his office, the lines of authority established by the Constitution, the outcome of the last election"
If president Obama wants his legacy to be that he turned the country into a banana republic no different than those that misgovern most of the third world, he probably can't be stopped. But his legacy will be ruined and he's assure himself a position as one of the worst presidents in this country's history. He can vie with Buchanan for that title.
Yes, said all the Indian tribes when thewhite man showed up. There fixed it for you.
In your version, you keep trying to justify genocide.
Have a great day Robert, you always stay true to form.
John - Big Oak did not attack your comment - why do you have to attack his?
Robert - we've had this/these discussions before - you continue to compare apples to oranges - totally inappropriate.
Obama's violation of the Constitution has nothing to do with the invasion of the Americas and the massacre of millions.
Oh, like to make it a "living" document???
More so his narcissist self.
Two more years of playing defense. You don't score many points that way, but if you don't play defense against a team that is determined to beat you into the ground you will certainly lose everything.