How Did Obama Lose American Voters?
In December 2012, 56 percent of Americans approved of President Obamas leadership. About 40 percent disapproved.
Today, those numbers are almost precisely reversed , a fact that Democrats were made keenly aware of in the fall campaign and in the midterm elections.
The publics confidence is gone, and it doesnt seem to be coming back, says Ross Douthat at The New York Times .
So what happened?
Mr. Douthat offers not a unified theory but four partial ones: Republican intransigence, an incomplete economic recovery from the Great Recession, Obamacare and foreign policy crises.
Indeed, partial theories are popular among observers, and many land onsimilar issues. In anaccount of Obamas second term, Juliet Eilperin and David Nakamura, writing at The Washington Post , detail what amounts to awar of attrition between the White House and Congress, with each side blaming the other for a lack of progress on legislation of any kind.
What all the partieshad to show for it, after multiple failures on policy and a government shutdown, was nothing but disapproval, The Post reporters write: The presidents approval ratings took a nose dive, and Congresss were even worse.
For Andrew Sullivan at The Dish , a fanatically obstructionist and increasingly extreme GOP wanted to undermine the president with a strategy hatched privately before Obama even took office.
They judged early on that the real promise of Obama his ambition to transcend the old politics in favor of pragmatic reform could be killed if they simply refused to play along, Mr. Sullivan writes.
On the economy, Peter Foster at The Telegraph says: Since Mr. Obama took office facing the worst economic crisis since the Great Depression, unemployment has fallen from 10 percent to 6 percent and American businesses have created 10 million new jobs thats more than Japan, Europe and every other advanced economy combined.
Problem is, he adds, many of those jobs are McJobs that is, low-paid and part-time work that dont leave people feeling better off. On top of that, in numerical terms, G.D.P. has risen by 8 percent since Mr. Obama took office, but median household incomes are down.
Mr. Douthat agrees: Even with the improving employment picture this recovery is still basically a disappointment, especially for the middle class, and adds that it isnt necessarily a case study in the economy not mattering. Its an example of voter patience persisting for a while, and finally running out.
The most persuasive answer to the question where did Obama go wrong? was the botched roll-out of healthcare.gov, Mr. Sullivan says. No one else can be blamed for this, and it hit the presidents ratings like a ten-ton truck.
Mr. Douthat points to competence as a general concern for the public with this administrationandidentifiesthe roll-outas a key moment: The health care law is Obamas signature issue, it remains largely unpopular (even if support for full repeal is weak), and its initial stumbling coincided with the sharpest second-term drop in the presidents approval.
Yet for Mr. Sullivan, this is only the start of the narrative: What this superficial version of events misses is what happened next. The truth is: the Obama team subsequently achieved a near-miraculous rescue of Obamacare, achieved real success in enrollment, and have seen core healthcare costs slow down in such a way that could yet shift our long-term fiscal liabilities for the better.
Still, as Mr. Foster points out, Like George W. Bush after Hurricane Katrina, Mr. Obamas approval numbers never recovered from the sight of his flagship piece of legislation capsizing so ignominiously before it had even left the harbour.
Mr. Douthat suggests that the president had an edge that Democratic politicians often lack: The public trusted him on foreign policy.
But, he writes, one crisis after another Syria, Ukraine, ISIS, Ebola eroded that trust and made Obamas position irrecoverable.
While acknowledging that Mr. Obamas refusal to engage in the theatrical parts of the presidency looks terrible during crises, Danny Vinik at The New Republic , like Mr. Sullivan, defends the president on issueslike ISIS, at least on substantive grounds: Its more important that the president craft effective policy responses to crises. Obama has done that and the media coverage has missed it completely, focusing instead on Obamas rhetorical shortcomings and downplaying his policy successes.
Conor Friedersdorf at The Atlantic has an entirely different log of reasons to disapprove of Mr. Obamas performance. His list includes warrantless wiretapping, a failure to punish illegal torture, a costly and ruinous war on drugs, the unacknowledged moral costs of drone strikes, the presidents secret kill list, an out-of-control national-security state and the presidents persecution of whistle-blowers and journalists whove worked with them.
Confronted with all of those transgressions, more than four in 10 Americans still approve of the job Obama is doing, Mr. Friedersdorf writes. And most of them are loyal Democrats. Partisanship and tribalism are overriding the moral compass of too many liberals.
For Elias Isquith at Salon , the root of the presidents problems is not to be found in specific events or issues but in his temperament.Many moderates see Obamas penchant for working from within the system rather than trying to disrupt it as a real plus.
But, he asks, was this temperamental conservatism the wrong fit for the current era, when major reforms are so desperately needed?
Mr. Isquith turns back to a 2009 Harpers article by Kevin Baker , predictingthat Mr. Obama would fail, because he would be unable to seize the radical moment at hand.
For Mr. Isquith, Rather than recognize how ideological and partisan realignment and polarization had effectively changed the rules of the Senate, the president went looking for consensus where none existed.
At this point, there is no question that President Obama will fall short of initial expectations, Mr. Isquith says. But more than the failure to pass any one particular bill, the disappointment stems from the presidents dogged insistence on being a reformer during a radical era.
But perhaps our focus on the presidency is itself skewed. The presidency is the central element in our political system, but as Aaron David Miller writes , maybe the problem is our expectation of the presidency itself.
He argues at Foreign Policy (and in his book The End of Greatness: Why America Cant Have (and Doesnt Want) Another Great President): The centrality of the presidency must be reconciled with the limitations of the office and the constraints that bind it. The presidency has always been an implausible, some might even say an impossible, job. But the following mix of challenges and constraints some old, some new has made the post-World War II presidency harder still: constitutional and practical constraints on the office itself; the presidents expanding reach and responsibilities; the expanding role of a government we trust less, even when we demand more from it; Americas global role; and an intrusive, omnipresent, and nonstop media.
Greatness in the presidency is too rare to be relevant in our modern times and driven as it is in our political system by big crisis too risky and dangerous to be desirable. Our continued search for idealized presidents raises our expectations and theirs, skews presidential performance, and leads to an impossible standard that can only frustrate and disappoint. To sum up: We can no longer have a truly great president, we seldom need one, and, as irrational as it sounds, we may not want one, either.
He concludes: Historic greatness in the presidency has gone the way of the dodo. And it is unlikely to return any time soon.

And in conclusion
Mike
Appreciate the perspective, I am sure those points stick in the craw of others as well
There are so many reasons it's hard to keep track of them all. The national debt and his proposed budgets, the drone attacks, the lies, the failure of Obamacare, domestic spying, targeting of political opponents and failure to take responsibility for his mistakes are just a few.
Dean
All issues and actions that have been prevalent in the administrations of most (if not all) previous presidents.
Deficits are coming down and logically if deficits are eliminated then the debt should start to be reduced, there is a degree of support from both sides of the aisle on drone attacks, the PPACA is not perfect but neither is it a failure - a little rebuttal to a couple of your points
Thanks for sharing your perspective
RIO On the deficit end of things, the only reason that it is being held in check is because congress is in gridlock, it is not because of any great policy changes coming from this administrations. I think that a large portion of the American people are starting to realize that they were fleeced by president Obama, and congress who campaigned on being the most transparent presidency in history. The economy is still struggling, just because the unemployment numbers are looking better, the labor participation rate is abysmal worst in 30 years. The economy has shifted to a part time, low paying jobs economy, as seen by the overall drop in take-home pay.
The PPACA did not do what it was touted to do which was bring health care costs down. My insurance has gone up 60% the first year the PPACA was enacted and 60% again this year, If this is indicative of what is happening across the nation as renewals are coming due, it will not be good for attitudes about the PPACA.
Most american's could give a crap less about the drone attacks as they are struggling enough to keep food on the table and a roof over their heads. The president is unwilling to face the American people and say my administration screwed up on XXX but this is what we are doing to improve it. They instead blame republicans, or phony scandals, they withhold documents from congress who has the authority of oversight on such things, and stymie any investigations into the truth.
I my opinion it is not what has happened as much, as it is the way in which the administration has reacted to what has been happening.
Robert G
Always appreciate vitriol and rhetoric rather than discussion /s
Thanks for sharing
Jim
I disagree about the peoples' views on drones.
Your insurance cost is anecdotal and not necessarily indicative of overall performance of PACA, the law is a step in the right direction but I agree there is more to be done. So far the Republicans have not said what more they would do or what exactly they want to fix other than the medical device tax repeal which is appropriate in my view.
Deficit reduction has indeed been forced by austere spending authorizations, but just like the president getting the blame for rising deficits (when Congress authorizes lavish spending) so too does he get credit when the deficit goes down in this case
Thanks for your perspective
RIO
I agree my insurance cost is anecdotal at this time but it may be indicative of what is coming across the nation, as renewal notices are just now arriving in mail boxes across the country. Only time will tell, if there are major shifts in which policies are renewed or if they choose to go with a lower priced option, with higher deductible and co-pays due to cost. Again if people get the feeling that they are paying more for less it will have a huge impact on theattitude toward the PPACA law.
Before the PPACA law when insurance costs would rise people would be mad at the insurance companies. Now there is a shift in dynamics, due to the government regulating which policies are to be sold, part of that blame will now be shifted more towards the federal government and the PPACAthan the insurance companies, right or wrong that is human nature. Most people will not do the research to find out why their insurance premiums are rising, they just know that they went up and the government is now controlling which plans may be sold, so blame will automatically default to the PPACA.
I also agree that republicans have not came out with a plan. The PPACA may have been a place to start, but it did not an any way effect the costs of healthcare, as health insurance and health care costs are totally different things. I have spoke with many doctors in my community and they are telling me that costs to provide healthcare are still rising at an increasing rate. Until we focus on the actual cost of healthcare, health insurance will continue to go up.
Owning and operating a retail store I have the opportunity to talk with many customers, and drone strikes are way down the list of worries at this time, I think that it is more general than just drone strikes. I think people see it more as our blood and treasure being spent in these third world countries, when there are plenty of problems that need to be fixed here. Most people that I have spoken with want us to get the hell out of these places, and spend the money here at home and put people to work.
Deficit reduction indeed starts with the congress and how money is appropriated. But the president has to put the final stamp on all the bills. Like the president said the buck stops with him!
Jim
I agree it may be predictive, but it may not
The PPACA did no reduce costs, it merely changed who is paying
That was Truman not Obama
Agreed, so the credit for the falling deficit goes to him as the blame for rising debt goes to him
That descriptor can be applied to most politicians these days
Surely there is a honest politician out there somewhere
Correlation does not in and of itself prove causation
Brings to mind a line from the movie "Paint Your Wagon"
"Wait a minute!" "You can't buy a woman for money!"
Response.....
"You just try and get one without it!"
Same same.
No argument that when you find a crooked politician you will find money as well
But that does not mean that we cannot find a honest politician (at least one) out there somewhere