Obamacare vs. Supreme Court -- What people are saying about a second challenge to the health care law
Brian Beutler, New Republic: "The Supreme Court agreed to hear ( King v. Burwell ), a case that will determine whether the federal government can continue to subsidize private Affordable Care Act coverage in states that didn't set up their own insurance exchanges. ... The contested text could be fixed with a comically simple technical corrections bill, which Democrats would happily support. If Republicans ... use the ensuing chaos as leverage to extract unrelated concessions, it will cost people their lives."
David Catron, The American Spectator : "The law stipulates that all (subsidies) must be dispensed via exchanges established by the state. ... To the surprise and chagrin of the Obama administration, 34 states declined to do so. ... If the court rules against the government, it will simply mean that (the ACA) must be implemented as written. If the bureaucrats are required to do that, the 'reform' law will collapse under its own weight. It will have to be repealed and replaced."
John Yoo, National Review : "The statute denies subsidies to people who live in states without an exchange. This reading is not absurd, because it creates a powerful incentive for states to create an exchange in the first place. The obvious meaning of the text should only be discarded if it created absurd or ridiculous results. ... What judge can resist the chance to reach the right legal result, fix mistakes from the past and act with popular support? It's a Supreme Court trifecta."
Paul Krugman, The New York Times : "It's a ridiculous claim; not only is it clear from everything else in the (ACA) that there was no intention to set such limits, you can ask the people who drafted the law what they intended, and it wasn't what the plaintiffs claim. But the fact that the suit is ridiculous is no guarantee that it won't succeed. ... Too many Republican judges have made it clear that partisan loyalty trumps respect for the (law)."
Jonathan H. Adler, The Washington Post : "According to Krugman, the claim in King is based upon an 'obvious typo.' ... This is a popular argument among pundits, but it's not made by the government or more knowledgeable legal experts. ... In order for the government to (argue) that a statute does not mean what the plain text says (it) has to show that there is no conceivable possibility that the text was deliberate. ... Contemporary punditry can distort what is actually a serious legal debate."
http://www.usatoday.com/story/opinion/2014/11/10/obamacare-vs-supreme-court-opinionline/18821109/
Tags
Who is online
114 visitors

Personally, I was a little surprised that the SCOTUS took up this case, but it will make for some interesting debate when the oral arguments are heard.
If the language was put in the bill as an encouragement for the states to create the exchanges, as many believe, than the argument that it was a typo falls by the wayside.
"One problem with debating and discussing the issue in King is that many folks (pundits, bloggers, etc.) have very strong views about questions they clearly do not understand. Things that seem obvious to one side or the other are often wrong or legally irrelevant. People that are otherwise expert on health care policy become enamored with arguments that dont actually prove their case because they are not responsive to the other sides claims. For instance, those Gruber videos are fun, and make a point, but they dont prove the plaintiffs are correct on the merits. Professor Ziff, with whom I disagree on the underlying issue, had a thoughtful post on this problem that advocates on both sides would do well to consider.
For an example of someone making arguments that are not nearly as strong as he thinks they are it would be hard to do better than Paul Krugmans most recent column. In this piece, Krugman makes basic mistakes e.g. the plaintiffs case is not based on just one clause in the statute and insists that only an incredibly hostile reader could read established by the State to mean, well, established by the State. This would be news to the folks at CRS or those at the IRS who initially drafted implementing regs that tracked the statutory language. Even some folks on Krugmans side have conceded that the statutes words clearly say credits are only authorized in state-established exchanges, even if they believe this is what Congress clearly did not mean.