Why Liberal Compassion is an Inane Basis for Political Action
There is always inequity in life, an American president declared. Life is unfair.
The president was John F. Kennedy, speaking in 1962.
Today its hard to picture even a losing Republican nominee for president speaking so brusquely about the cosmic injustice of it all.
Where life deals a low blow, shouldnt government step in to call a penalty?
Today, compassion fuels the American political bus. No one can expect to lead the country without proving that he or she feels our pain.
That is a fatuous basis for policy, notes political scholar William Voegeli in a calm and reasoned book that carries the impishly inflammatory title, The Pity Party: A Mean-Spirited Diatribe Against Liberal Compassion.
Compassion creates a co-dependency between the empathizers and the empathizees: Liberalism is an alliance of experts and victims, in the words of Harvards Harvey Mansfield.
To top that up to 51% of the voters, says Voegeli, liberals argue that those who do not recognize the expertise of the experts are stupid, preferring ignorance, and those who do not recognize the victimhood of the victims are wicked, lacking compassion.
If the empathizees ever disappeared (by, say, having their miseries extinguished) then the empathizers would lose their purpose, the soothing soul balm of caring.
Thats why, no matter how much money gets poured into poverty alleviation ($22 trillion, not including Social Security or Medicare, in the last 50 years), You will never hear the words Phew! We cured poverty.
Indeed, official poverty measures simply leave out anti-poverty benefits. Thats like saying youre carless if you were forced to accept a Chevy paid for by other taxpayers.
So the poverty rate never really changes its been around 14% or so for the last half-century even as living standards for todays poor surpass those of yesterdays middle class.
Ah, but the poor are less healthy, argue liberals. True. But whose fault is that? Many avoidable illnesses that disproportionately afflict the poor are traceable to ill-advised consumption, not deprivation.
Smoking causes lung cancer (poor people are more likely to smoke) and overeating causes Type II diabetes (poor people are fatter).
Soon the literal and figurative fattening of the underclass will be so hard to ignore that poverty will be redefined as simply a state of mind: If you feel bad about others having more than you, youre poor.
If you dont feel bad about these peoples bad feelings, youre inhuman.
It shouldnt surprise us that liberalism tends to hold sway among those who place little stock in religion.
Not only does church charity disrupt the notion that only expert-based government can be trusted to alleviate human suffering, but liberalism provides a competing, earthly ecstasy.
Pity is about how deeply I can feel, argued political theorist Jean Bethke Elshtain. And in order to feel this way, to experience the rush of my own pious reaction, I need victims the way an addict needs drugs.
The warm syrup of righteousness liberals pour all over themselves glues their eyes shut.Liberal compassion also suggests a lack of limits.
Were selfish for thinking of our children as our children: As Melissa Harris-Perry averred on MSNBC, We have to break through our kind of private idea that kids belong to their parents or kids belong to their families and recognize that kids belong to whole communities. Once its everyones responsibility and not just the households, then we start making better investments.
It takes a village. (Its important to frame liberal policies as benefitting children, as Marian Wright Edelman theorized back in the early 1970s, because unlike adults their story cant be complicated by questions of what they deserve).
Our hearts need to be unbounded, our love without limit. And yet politics is all about tough choices. Child care or old-age pensions? Raises for teachers or maintenance for bridges?
There isnt enough funding for everything. Do those who arent seeking work deserve as much unemployment benefit as those who are?
If we cant distinguish the more deserving from the less, and if resources are finite, then who is best able to monetize liberal compassion?
The ones with the best lobbyists. Except they arent called lobbyists, usually. Theyre called advocates. Theyre called social justice crusaders. Theyre called saints, like Marian Wright Edelman.
Finally, Voegeli points out that liberal compassion leads to bullst. The warm syrup of righteousness liberals pour all over themselves glues their eyes shut.
Just Wednesday, after President Obamas policies received a humiliating rebuke in the midterms, he continued to press his agenda anyway, citing early-childhood education as something that we know works.
But as Joe Klein wrote in Time magazine, Head Start simply does not work. Thats $180 billion taken away from American families, to virtually zero effect.
Unless the point is good intentions, and if so, Obama ought to be president of another institution the Road to Hell Paving Co.
http://news360.com/article/265423706#
Tags
Who is online
114 visitors

An interesting look at assumptions, conclusions and false cause and effect relationships that influence policy.
I do not agree with all the points of the article or disagree with all of them, but I found it very entertaining and figured it would generate comment from both sides of the political aisle.
The Kennedy quote is typical of the stereotyped label placed on all conservatives by some liberals and is as false as the conservative labeling of all those receiving government assistance as being undeserving "welfare queens".
Enjoy
flameaway
Thanks for the perspective - good points
I don't think that the author is saying that "all" compassion is politically motivated, but that actions and positions are undertaken by "some" under the guise of compassion when it fact it is politics at play.
Again thanks for the feedback and the points made
John
Thanks for the perspective and feedback
Regarding your point
A question - Is the reverse also true?
As long as we have an economic system that allows newfood stampsall the time, no one should complain about billionaires.
That is an answer to a question, but not to the one I asked.
Assuming your point is true,shouldn't the reverse also be true? Yes or no
I did not suggest getting rid of the social safety net, which I think will always be necessary to some extent.
The question stands
John
I asked for a yes or no and you did not answer the question
You have no idea what I think and I did not make an assertion, you did I asked if the inverse of the assertion was also true. You dodged the question.
You are free to dance and spin and not answer questions to your hearts content, you practice it all the time.
Thanks for sharing your views