╌>

The Single Most Important Factor in Improving Education: Great Teachers

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  robert-in-ohio  •  12 years ago  •  3 comments

The Single Most Important Factor in Improving Education: Great Teachers

Joel Klein, CEO at Amplify, a new education subsidiary of News Corporation

Nothing matters more to a child in the classroom than his or her teacher. We have all encountered both exemplary and awful teachers, and our common experience tells us that a great teacher can rescue a child from a life of struggle.


But what makes for a great teacher? For generations, educators operated on the belief that great teaching was mostly an art, which the talented refine in the privacy of the classroom over many years of work. Like old-fashioned doctors in solo practice, superior teachers gained great wisdom in their daily work, which they added to their extraordinary personal qualitiescreativity, character, intelligenceto yield the consummate educator. Think Sidney Poitiers Mark Thackeray in To Sir with Love or Richard Dreyfuss as Glenn Holland in Mr. Hollands Opus .

The trouble with the romanticized idea that teachers should be self-directed, creative, and wholly autonomous professionals is that it all depends on the individual. Yes, some educators grow and develop on their own initiative. But this model assumes that all teachers will naturally progress and negates the possibility that any educator can be coached or challenged to improve. And because teaching happens behind closed doors, this conventional wisdom protects less-competent teachers from being assessed and, if necessary, removed. Truly awful teachers can effectively commit malpractice (like bad doctors) against thousands of unsuspecting students throughout a 30-year career and still collect the same pay, benefits, and pensions as their most effective peers.

Early in my tenure as New York City schools chancellor, where I served from 2002 to 2011, an essential truth emerged in my effort to understand the problems of the city schools. To put it bluntly: many of the people who had entered the teaching profession were not sufficiently skilled, and too often they lacked real expertise in their subject areas.

Most of these people care deeply about the children they are responsible for, and many work hard to try to learn the subject matter they teach, but the truth is they often come unprepared, and, even if they try to catch up, they usually dont.
In the 1990s, college graduates who became elementary-school teachers in America averaged below 1,000 points, out of a total of 1,600, on the math and verbal Scholastic Aptitude Tests (SAT) given to high- school seniors; in New York City, when we began, the citywide average for all teachers was about 970.

Teacher quality is a deeply sensitive and long-developing problem that isnt easy to fix. Many teachers are terrific, but many others simply dont have the knowledge and skills, even if they have the heart, to be effective instructors. That basic recognition necessarily limits what you can do in turning around a school system like New Yorks, especially when the teachers union is hell-bent on protecting even the least qualified of its members.

The Cost to Fire a Bad Teacher: $300,000

Like anyone who first encounters the teachers contract in New York City, I had trouble believing that certain parts of it were real. For instance, fully half of all job openings in the schools could be claimed by veteran teachers solely on the basis of seniority. It didnt matter whether the principal or other faculty wanted to hire the teacher for the job. And it didnt matter that a particular teacher had bad evaluations at other schools or a string of complaints trailing him. If he wanted the job, and he had seniority, he got the job. The process was so ridiculous that, even midyear, after a terrific new teacher had been hired, she could be bumped out of her job by a more senior teacher in search of a placement. If the kids suffered as a result of the change, so be it.

Many senior teachers looking for spots had been excessed by other schools. An excessed teacher hadnt been fired. Instead, her job had been eliminated, ostensibly through no fault of her own, and she was therefore eligible to claim an opening elsewhere. Insiders talked about an annual ritualcalled the dance of the lemonsin which un-wanted instructors were excessed and shuffled around. Good teachers were never excessed and the young, inexperienced ones invariably were already in the toughest assignments where they suffered burnout at a shockingly high rate. Children who attended schools dominated by excessed and inexperienced teachers paid the price.

In September 2002, right after I started, the principal of a Manhattan high school recruited two new science teachers who had voluntarily participated in a two-week summer training program without being paid. They were eager to work at the school, and the principal was thrilled to have them. Several weeks into the new school year, however, the principal received a call from our human resources office and was told that the two new teachers were out and had to be replaced by two excessed teachers, one of whom had just received an unsatisfactory performance rating at another school. Hard as it is to believe, this kind of thing happened all the time.

Worse than the lemons were teachers who had earned such serious complaintsincluding sexual abuse of studentsthat they were under disciplinary review. Because the union contract called for a Kafkaesque arbitration system, with dozens of steps and procedures that limited how quickly things could move, we couldnt legally fire, or stop paying, these teachers for years. To keep them away from students, school officials barred the worst from classroom assignments and required them to appear every morning at special reporting centerseuphemistically called rubber roomswhere they idled away their time.

On any given day, hundreds of teachers dwelled in these places, doing nothing, in order to receive their pay and benefits. The problem of the rubber rooms was so outrageous that the press periodically checked in on the practice and reported with utter amazement that it was still going on. In 2000, before Bloomberg became mayor, the Daily News discovered that 372 teachers were reporting to rubber rooms, where they spent school days watching Jerry Springer, playing jacks, counting ceiling tiles, whatever.

All of this insanity was made necessary by contract provisions, reinforced under state law, governing how and when a teacher can be terminated. To fire a single teacher took an average of almost two and a half years and cost the city over $300,000. Even after enduring this lengthy process, the city usually couldnt fire the teacher. The arbitrators who decided these cases had to be approved by the union, which had no interest in selecting people who would fire teachers.

This made it virtually impossible to remove a teacher charged with incompetence. A recent study showed that, between 1997 and 2007, only twelve teachers were terminated for incompetence, or about one per year out of a workforce of more than seventy-five thousand. According to the author, who examined the record of every case, Teachers who had years of unsatisfactory ratings; who were proven over months of hearings to be grossly incompetent; who were verbally and physically abusive to children, parents, and colleagues, or who simply failed to come to work for days and weeks on end were returned to the classroom. The study concluded, In practice, teachers are dismissed only if they are proved to have been grossly ineffective and incorrigible, without even a re- mote possibility of improving.

(At Governor Andrew Cuomos behest, the legislature in New York amended the law in 2012 to help speed up the process, but it still takes way too long, and, in the end, almost no teacher is removed for incompetence.)

The lemons and the denizens of the rubber rooms not only deprived students of the good teachers they deserved, but they also cost a fortune. Even at the low end of the pay scale, each year that one of these teachers remained on our payroll amounted to the equivalent of three thousand new textbooks or eight hundred classroom computers. We were dealing with well over a thousand of them annually.

Attracting the Best to Teaching

Of course, as with anything in education, every issue could be considered from a myriad of perspectives, and the minute you start talking about the quality of the people entering the teaching profession, you immediately hear about low pay, declining respect, and worsening conditions.

In New York City, though, we found that, with proper recruitment, support, and incentives, school systems can increase the numbers of teachers who are both temperamentally and intellectually equipped for the modern classroom. We accomplished this by making the city schools an exciting place to work, bringing in partners to aggressively recruit talented new teachers, and significantly improving our compensation system. When the unions allowed us, we used incentives to encourage good teachers and principals to serve in schools where they were needed most, and we created mentoring and peer group programs so teachers could share what they knew about best practices in the classroom.

But if we are to raise the quality and the performance of teachers across the country, more effort must come from the profession itself. This could begin with an honest assessment of the system that educates and certifies those who become teachers. Today, despite some recent improvements, we are still not getting the best students to go into teaching; most of the college students who go into teaching rank well below the top third of their class and many still come from the bottom third. They often attend college programs that are so weak that they have been described as an industry of mediocrity by the National Council on Teacher Quality. The councils 2013 Teacher Prep Review was based on a study of more than one thousand undergraduate programs that train new teachers. Of these, fewer than 10 percent earned a rating of three stars or higher, on a scale of four. Only one, Ohio State, earned three or more stars for programs that educate both elementary- and secondary-school teachers.

Young teachers are not well served by the profession as they enter it. Too often they are hired to provide instruction in subjects outside their areas of academic expertise. This mismatch surely affects both student achievement and teacher satisfaction. Overall, the image of todays teacher in a big urban system is that of an overworked, isolated, and bureaucratically oppressed man or woman struggling to educate students who can be exceedingly difficult to reach. Although many teachers in New York and other big cities defy the odds and do well, too often the stereotype is borne out.

Teaching is a challenging job, as anyone who has stood before a classroom will attest. But if you look carefully, you can find places in the world where teachers as a group enjoy greater success, more job satisfaction, and higher social standing than they do in America. In China, Japan, Finland, and several other countries, teachers are accorded the same level of respect as doctors. In South Korea, a recent survey found that almost half of parents would encourage their child to become a teacher. This view was shared by just a third of American parents.

Among the Western industrial nations, Finland stands out for its consistently high scores on international achievement tests. Ninety-three percent of Finns graduate from high school and fully two thirds of the countrys high-school graduates go on to college. These results have attracted a great deal of attention among Americans in part because Finland wasnt always at the top of the heap. Forty years ago, its schools ranked near the bottom in Europe. Their success today began with a commitment to reform back then, showing that sound policies can lead to much better academic outcomes.

The thing that immediately stands out is that, unlike in America, Finnish teachers are drawn from the top 10 percent of their college classes. As one commentator recently noted, gaining admission to a teacher-training program at Finnish universities is as difficult as winning admission to MIT. Teachers are expected to become genuine subject experts in the fields they will teach.

The Finnish model teaches us that, if we are serious about improving the quality of the people who go into teaching, we need to begin by asking more of the education schools that train our teachers. Far too many of these schools function as indiscriminate revenue sources for universities and colleges, accepting underqualified students and their tuition dollars for programs that are academically weak. To solve this problem, states could institute rigorous examssimilar to the bar exams for lawyers or licensing tests for doctorsthat graduates would have to pass in order to be cleared for the classroom, an idea that Randi Weingarten, the American Federation of Teachers president, has also championed. In addition to testing pedagogy, these exams would require prospective teachers to demonstrate real subject-matter knowledge, something that is largely ignored today.

Whatever else we do, we need to make teaching a well-respected profession that attracts our best college graduates and requires that they have the training in the subject area they will teach as well as in pedagogy and classroom management. To accomplish this, we need to pay teachers well and base their overall salary on merit and performance, not length of service. Lets also give them the tools and curriculum supports that modern technology can readily make available so we can help them be better at their craft and use their valuable time most effectively. And reflecting the professionals that all our educators must be, let every school create a culture of accountability, where every adult strives to do better for every child every day.

These are lessons of hope, and they are readily attainable.

This article is adapted and excerpted from Joel Klein's new book, Lessons of Hope: How to Fix Our Schools .

Klein served as chancellor of the New York City Department of Education from 2002 to 2011. Earlier in his career, he served as U.S. assistant attorney general in charge of the Antitrust Division of the U.S. Department of Justice, deputy White House counsel during the Clinton administration, and CEO of the U.S. arm of Bertelsmann. He currently works as executive vice president at News Corporation and CEO of its education division, Amplify

https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/article/20141108135615-141964205-the-single-most-important-factor-in-improving-education-great-teachers


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    12 years ago

I found this look at education, education reform, teachers and student outcomes from a person directly involved in education for many years to be very interesting.

This article is adapted and excerpted from Joel Klein's new book, Lessons of Hope: How to Fix Our Schools .

Klein served as chancellor of the New York City Department of Education from 2002 to 2011. Earlier in his career, he served as U.S. assistant attorney general in charge of the Antitrust Division of the U.S. Department of Justice, deputy White House counsel during the Clinton administration, and CEO of the U.S. arm of Bertelsmann. He currently works as executive vice president at News Corporation and CEO of its education division, Amplify.

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    12 years ago

I'll be honest with you Robert. I didn't read every word in this article. My eyes are tired and I just skimmed the last half of it, but right off the bat to hell with these rubber rooms. I know a lot of teachers who would love to qualify to be a teacher by having to be in the top 10% of their class instead of competing with all the other graduates who barely made it through college. And there's more to it than just the teachers. These parents who aren't worthy of being parents should have their asses kicked.

It doesn't look like you're getting anywhere with this article since it has been up for 4 hours and you have 2 comments, one being mine and the other being your comment, so I want to tell you a story.

Yesterday on my way to Florence, SC I was traveling through a little town and saw a man selling apples, watermelons, tomatoes and a few other fruits and vegetable along side the road in the middle of this little town. I wanted some fresh tomatoes and usually the ones in the major grocery stores can still look the same after sitting on the table for two or more weeks, which kind of scares me actually.

So I stopped and took a look at his tomatoes. I could see right away they were home grown, no gassing and looked great. There was a little boy about 10 years old there. When the tomatoes were put on one of those old time scales with the little arm like a clock they weighed 3.5 pounds. The man had them priced at $1.50 per pound, so I asked the little white boy how much the price of the tomatoes would be. He looked at that 3 and that line between the 3 and 4 and said $4.50. I told him the weigh was three and a half pounds and said "What's half of $1.50. He said the price would be $4.75.

Anyway I noticed the boy was cross-eyed. He seemed to be a very nice kid and the man told me he wasn't his son, but just a little boy that came by and he let him help him, paying him a little or giving him some fruit or vegetables. The man told me his mother had 5 children by 5 different dads and was a pill addict. I almost want to go to the school Monday and see the principal and carry it further than that if necessary to get that boy's eyes fixed. I thought what that boy's future would probably be growing up under the conditions he was growing up in and how much different a person he could turn out to be if those conditions were turned around with loving parents who guided him in the right direction. I don't think I could teach in a class all day long staring at a cross-eyed child in the face knowing I hadn't done all I could to correct his visions, let along his living conditions. How often do we see situations we could possibly be effective in making a difference do we go on about our lives without a third thought about them?

Certainly we as stewards of our children, shouldn't we not only be held responsible for the children as well as the quality of the teachers who teach them? And when we find discrepancies shouldn't we be more inclined to act on them to correct them or should we read about it in the newspaper years later how it turned out?

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    12 years ago

I didn't read every word in this article.

Well okay then and thanks for the anecdote

The children are the future and their education is certainly important as is their safety and welfare. If every parent, grandparent, aunt, uncle, brother, sister, etc took responsibility for caring for and teaching the children of their families the problem would disappear.

 
 

Who is online



devangelical
Dismayed Patriot


102 visitors