╌>

How the Far Left Hijacked a Cat Calling Debate and Started to Eat Itself

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  sean-treacy  •  12 years ago  •  5 comments

How the Far Left Hijacked a Cat Calling Debate and Started to Eat Itself
A video depicting a woman walking around New York City and, through no fault of her own, being intermittently approached or cat-called by strangers has become an Internet sensation this week, racking up hits and provoking outrage across the political spectrum. In the course of just a few days, millions upon millions of people have shared the piece, almost all of them appending to the link their own passionate disavowals and earnest calls to action. Initially, its progenitor, a group named Hollaback, expressed the hope that the piece would make an impact. Quietly, they must be thrilled with the result: In a single week, the spot has had 15 million views, an achievement that places it firmly in the viral hall of fame. Publicly, however, the outfit has been forced to apologize, its victory having turned somewhat sour. What could possibly have happened?As it has grown in popularity, the video has been transformed into a blank canvas, onto which Americas brave advocates of hyphenated-justice have sought to project their favored social theories. Evidently unwilling to let the spot stand on its own, Purdues Roxanne Gay wrote sadly that its difficult and uncomfortable to admit that we have to talk about race/class/gender/sexuality/ability/etc, all at once. Alas, she was not alone. Soon, the claims of sexism had been joined by accusations of racism and of classism, Hollaback had been forced to acknowledge that it had upset the more delicate among us, and those who had celebrated the video had been denounced as unreconstructed bigots. By this process was its message diluted and appropriated, the countrys most prominent peddlers of grievance and discord electing to squabble and bicker over its meaning, and to strip it of its value in favor of their own, fringe fixations.The fact that the video chooses to showcase the experience of a white woman experiencing harassment almost exclusively at the hands of black and Latino men, Brooklyn Magazines Kristin Iverson proposed earlier this week, is a pretty clear indication of who the audience for this video is supposed to be, namely, those who seek to protect and defend innocent white women, aka the already existing societal power structure. This theme was picked up in more explicit terms elsewhere, the less direct references to the power structure quickly giving way to overt accusations of white supremacy. Thousands of satisfied racists are sharing that viral catcalling video, griped Lindy West at the Daily Dot, lamenting that its creators had imposed manipulative, specific, politicized constraints on the issue of street harassment and thereby permitted the bulk of the audience to divorce themselves from the problem. Yesterday, the Roots Dion Rabouin dispensed with euphemism entirely, confirming that some of the videos intentional choices seem to play on the Birth of a Nation trope that white women simply arent safe from sex-crazed black and brown men. How thats for a thumb in the eye for the millions who shared the spot on their Facebook pages?In the exquisitely calibrated judgment of The Nations racial justice guru, Aura Bogado, the spot was deeply problematic, serving not to highlight the frequency with which women are bothered on the street, but instead perpetuating the myth of the cult of white white womanhood by literally placing this white woman in neighborhoods where men of color will be the ones who catcall (or, in some instances, say hello to) her. Doing so, Bogado writes, makes it appear as if men of color are the perpetrators of all that is bad on this planet, which can only be balanced with the exigent need to therefore save white women above all else. The only solution, she says, is to remake the video with a universalizing cast: the camera centering on, say, a black trans woman.Quite why there would be nothing manipulative, specific, or politicized inherent to a project such as this is never adequately explained. Indeed, if Bogado got her way, I daresay that we would face a different set of problems. Were a black trans woman to be filmed being catcalled or criticized even once by a white construction worker, many of those who are currently twisting themselves into knots would no doubt write four-hour operas on the incident. All told, it is more likely to be the case that Bogado and her fellow travelers are vexed by this video not because there is anything much wrong with it, but because it does not offer a message that is useful to them. Thus must a tool intended to raise awareness about a social ill be destroyed in the name of justice. Its a funny old world.Consider how far its critics are stretching to discredit the experiments results. On Wednesday, Roxanne Gay suggested with palpable irritation that the racial politics of the video are f****d up. Like, she didnt walk through any white neighborhoods? For her part, Salons Emily Gould went full circle, seeking to justify the behavior of the maligned cat-callers by submitting that they had been forced into it by the actions of white people writ large. This kind of harassment, Gould wrote, can be a way marginalized groups talk back to the white gentrifiers taking over their neighborhoods. In and of itself, this view strikes me as being grotesquely condescending the perverse cousin, perhaps, of precisely the sort of racial stereotyping that progressives believe they have been divinely called upon to destroy.To contend that the minorities depicted in the video are mere victims of circumstance and that they have been forced by their conditions into badgering innocent women on the street is to contend that those minorities lack agency, intelligence, sensitivity, and the capacity to reason that they are child-like figures who act on their base instincts and who need excusing and explaining by their betters. Oddly enough, it is also to contend that the victim was either a white gentrifier herself, or a proxy for white gentrifiers, and that she therefore deserved the treatment she received. This presumption, it should go without saying, is typically anathema to the arbiters of feminist thought. One cannot help but wonder whether, weighed down by their own contradictions, the champions of empowerment have at last become what they despise themselves?Certainly, one has to wonder how Gould and her ilk came to their peculiar conclusions in the first instance. As Michael Luciano notes at the Daily Banter, pace Gays implication, the woman in the video, Shoshana Roberts, did walk through white neighborhoods.If SoHo and Greenwich Village two of the neighborhoods in the video arent white neighborhoods for New York City, I dont know what is. Roberts can also be seen near the Port Authority, which is neither a black nor a white neighborhood. Its just a hellhole.This episode, Luciano confesses, illustrates neatly why liberals such as myself are feeling less at home on the Left these days. Some liberals, he grumbles, simply couldnt let the video stand as a testament to the bullshit that women go through. That the racial makeup of the harassers was not perfectly even, Luciano argues, yielded an unacceptable narrative, even if that narrative is comprised entirely of subtext. To criticize this video because it may have captured an uncomfortable reality, he concludes, is to entirely miss the point, which is that street harassment is a problem no matter whos engaging in it.Continued http://www.nationalreview.com/article/391610/how-far-left-hijacked-cat-calling-debate-and-started-eat-itself-charles-c-w-cooke

Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   seeder  Sean Treacy    12 years ago
"To contend that the minorities depicted in the video are mere victims of circumstance and that they have been forced by their conditions into badgering innocent women on the street is to contend that those minorities lack agency, intelligence, sensitivity, and the capacity to reason that they are child-like figures who act on their base instincts and who need excusing and explaining by their betters. Oddly enough, it is also to contend that the victim was either a white gentrifier herself, or a proxy for white gentrifiers, and that she therefore deserved the treatment she received. This presumption, it should go without saying, is typically anathema to the arbiters of feminist thought. One cannot help but wonder whether, weighed down by their own contradictions, the champions of empowerment have at last become what they despise themselves?"
 
 
 
Larry Hampton
Professor Quiet
link   Larry Hampton    12 years ago

Saw this when it went up the other day. Funny, within 24 hours I saw at least a half -dozen news segments about the video, all with their own take and interpretation, nearly completely losing the essence of the videos intent. Pathetic.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   seeder  Sean Treacy    12 years ago

It's always interesting to watch what happens when identity groups clash.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   seeder  Sean Treacy    12 years ago

That's funny..

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   96WS6    12 years ago

I watched this video and didn't even notice the racial aspect until it was pointed out.

 
 

Who is online

devangelical
Dismayed Patriot
CB


87 visitors