╌>

50 Spies say ISIS Intelligence was Cooked

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  sean-treacy  •  11 years ago  •  11 comments

50 Spies say ISIS Intelligence was Cooked

Its being called a revolt by intelligence pros who are paid to give their honest assessment of the ISIS warbut are instead seeing their reports turned into happy talk.
More than 50 intelligence analysts working out of the U.S. military's Central Command have formally complained that their reports on ISIS and al Qaedas branch in Syria were being inappropriately altered by senior officials, The Daily Beast has learned.

The complaints spurred the Pentagons inspector general to open an investigation into the alleged manipulation of intelligence. The fact that so many people complained suggests there are deep-rooted, systemic problems in how the U.S. military command charged with the war against the self-proclaimed Islamic State assesses intelligence.

The cancer was within the senior level of the intelligence command, one defense official said.

Two senior analysts at CENTCOM signed a written complaint sent to the Defense Department inspector general in July alleging that the reports, some of which were briefed to President Obama, portrayed the terror groups as weaker than the analysts believe they are. The reports were changed by CENTCOM higher-ups to adhere to the administrations public line that the U.S. is winning the battle against ISIS and al Nusra, al Qaedas branch in Syria, the analysts claim.

That complaint was supported by 50 other analysts, some of whom have complained about politicizing of intelligence reports for months. Thats according to 11 individuals who are knowledgeable about the details of the report and who spoke to The Daily Beast on condition of anonymity.

The accusations suggest that a large number of people tracking the inner workings of the terror groups think that their reports are being manipulated to fit a public narrative. The allegations echoed charges that political appointees and senior officials cherry-picked intelligence about Iraqs supposed weapons program in 2002 and 2003.

The two signatories to the complaint were described as the ones formally lodging it, and the additional analysts are willing and able to back up the substance of the allegations with concrete examples.

One person who knows the contents of the complaint said it used the word Stalinist to describe the tone set by officials overseeing the militarys analysis.
Some of those CENTCOM analysts described the sizeable cadre of protesting analysts as a revolt by intelligence professionals who are paid to give their honest assessment, based on facts, and not to be influenced by national-level policy. The analysts have accused senior-level leaders, including the director of intelligence and his deputy in CENTCOM, of changing their analyses to be more in line with the Obama administrations public contention that the fight against ISIS and al Qaeda is making progress. The analysts take a more pessimistic view about how military efforts to destroy the groups are going.

The large number of analysts who complained to the Pentagon inspector general hasnt been previously reported. Some of them are assigned to work at CENTCOM, the U.S. militarys command for the Middle East and Central Asia, but are officially employed by the Defense Intelligence Agency.

The complaints allege that in some cases key elements of intelligence reports were removed, resulting in a document that didnt accurately capture the analysts conclusions, sources familiar with the protest said. But the complaint also goes beyond alleged altering of reports and accuses some senior leaders at CENTCOM of creating an unprofessional work environment. One person who knows the contents of the written complaint sent to the inspector general said it used the word Stalinist to describe the tone set by officials overseeing CENTCOMs analysis.

Many described a climate in which analysts felt they could not give a candid assessment of the situation in Iraq and Syria. Some felt it was a product of commanders protecting their career advancement by putting the best spin on the war.

Some reports crafted by the analysts that were too negative in their assessment of the war were sent back the chain of the command or not shared up the chain, several analysts said. Still others, feeling the climate around them, self-censored so their reports affirmed already-held beliefs.

While we cannot comment on the specific investigation cited in the article, we can speak to the process. The Intelligence Community routinely provides a wide range of subjective assessments related to the current security environment. These products and the analysis that they present are absolutely vital to our efforts, particularly given the incredibly complex nature of the multi-front fights that are ongoing now in Iraq and Syria, said Air Force Col. Patrick Ryder, U.S. CENTCOM spokesman. Senior civilian and military leadership consider these assessments during planning and decision-making, along with information gained from various other sources, to include the insights provided by commanders on the ground and other key advisors, intelligence collection assets, and previous experience.

Two of the officials who spoke to The Daily Beast said that analysts began airing their complaints in October in an effort to address the issue internally and only went to the inspector general when that effort failed. Some of those who complained were urged to retire, one official familiar with the report told The Daily Beast. Some agreed to leave.

In recent months, members of the Obama administration have sought to paint the fight against ISIS in rosy huesdespite the terror armys seizure of major cities like Mosul and Fallujah.

ISIS is losing, John Allen, the retired Marine general charged with coordinating the ISIS campaign, said in July.

I am confident that over time, we will beat, we will, indeed, degrade and ultimately destroy ISIL, Secretary of State John Kerry said in March, using the governments preferred acronym for the group.

No, I dont think were losing, President Obama said in May.

Yet a growing group of intelligence analysts persisted with their complaints.

http://www.thedailybeast.com/articles/2015/09/09/exclusive-50-spies-say-isis-intelligence-was-cooked.html

F


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   seeder  Sean Treacy    11 years ago

The reports were changed by CENTCOM higher-ups to adhere to the administrations public line that the U.S. is winning the battle against ISIS and al Nusra, al Qaedas branch in Syria, the analysts claim.

 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany    11 years ago
After Benghazi, I assumed that all intelligence in the Obama administration is subject to being altered to fit a political narrative. I read a variety of news sources to figure things out for myself.
 
 
 
Larry Hampton
Professor Quiet
link   Larry Hampton    11 years ago

Lying about the threat makes it a lot easier to convince some to...

head-in-sand.jpg

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    11 years ago

In related news :

Islamic State group's attacks in Saudi test security of hajj

....

"Daesh and its followers have made it very clear that Saudi Arabia is their ultimate target," Saudi analyst Fahad Nazer said, referring to the Islamic State group by its Arabic acronym. "Because of Mecca and Medina ... That's their ultimate prize."

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    11 years ago

I heard about this and to me it's pretty typical of just more lies from this administration. Telling the truth is illegal alien to them.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   seeder  Sean Treacy    11 years ago

Now we know why Democrats were so insistent somebody had to be cooking the intelligence about Saddam Husseins WMDs. Its because thats what they would have done themselves to fit their policy line.

Forgive the self-reference, but I couldnt help thinking of something I had in a column this week the second of two columns about Dana Perino and her wonderful new book: Putin was convinced that Bush fired Dan Rather. Bush tried to tell him otherwise: CBS News is a corporate entity, not a governmental entity, etc. To no avail. Putin insisted on saying in public that Bush fired Rather.

I think of David Pryce-Jones, and what he has said about the Arabs: They cannot believe that you havent done what they themselves would do. Or that you would not do what they themselves would do. This is a problem. Interesting, but a significant problem.

Someone once told me a story about Cambodian refugees in California. They were pulled over for speeding (or a broken tail light or something). They got out of the car and knelt with their hands behind their heads, waiting, evidently, to be executed. Its what they knew back home.

Read more at:

 
 
 
Larry Hampton
Professor Quiet
link   Larry Hampton    11 years ago

Not understanding historic, ME tribal thinking and instincts have caused us havoc, andwill continue to do so. To Westerners, admittingto weaknesscan be a path to strength. Not so to a tribal mindset; rather, it is seen as a sign of surrender and invites aggression. We willnot be able to negotiate with Iran or any other Middle eastern countryon anything, except from a position of extreme strength. To assume that we can successfully do so without basically clubbing them over the head andMAKING them do so, is nave and dangerous.

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   96WS6    11 years ago

"Transparency"

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   seeder  Sean Treacy    11 years ago

Great points.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    11 years ago

Related :

'Something's wrong': The ISIS intelligence scandal just hit Obama's inner circle

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   seeder  Sean Treacy    11 years ago

Great find. Thanks for sharing it.

 
 

Who is online






Hal A. Lujah


87 visitors