╌>

The Absurd Claim that Only Republicans are to Blame for Cuts to Ebola Research

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  spikegary  •  12 years ago  •  1 comments

The Absurd Claim that Only Republicans are to Blame for Cuts to Ebola Research

WashPo Article

Republican cuts kill new Web ad by the Agenda Project Action FundThis ad is simply a more extreme version of a new Democratic talking point that GOP budget cuts have harmed the nations ability to handle the Ebola outbreak. It mixes statistics the budget for the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) cut $585 million (the ad offers no date range) with disturbing images of the outbreak and various Republican leaders saying variations of the word cut.A slightly more nuanced version of this theme was launched by the Democratic Congressional Campaign Committee, which in online advertising began to equate a congressional budget vote in 2011 with a vote for the House GOP budget in 2014 that supposedly protected special interests.The FactsBudget numbers are especially susceptible to manipulation in political rhetoric because they are often confusing. A presidential administration will propose a budget number for an agency, and then the House and Senate will haggle over the numbers. So politicians can pick and choose the numbers they want to highlight. The big boost in spending under the 2009 stimulus law and then the automatic sequester budget cuts in the 2011 budget agreement have further juggled the statistics.For the purposes of this fact check, we are going to rely on the historical numbers in official budget documents submitted to Congress by the NIH and the CDC. We double-checked a couple of years with NIH, and the differences amounted to rounding errors. This way, readers can examine the documents themselves.Generally, Congress gave the NIH about what the president requested sometimes more, sometimes less. In 2013, for instance, Congress gave the NIH more than what the White House had requested, but then $1.5 billion was taken away by sequestration.Whose idea was sequestration? It was originally a White House proposal, designed to force Congress to either swallow painful cuts or boost taxes. The law mandating sequestration passed on a bipartisan vote and then Republicans embraced it even more strongly when they could not reach a grand budget deal with President Obama.For fiscal year 2015, the documents show, it was the Obama White House that proposed to cut the NIHs budget from the previous year. Moreover, we should note that President George W. Bush, a Republican, is responsible for significantly boosting NIHs funding in the early years of his presidency.The high point for the Obama administrations request for NIH funding was in 2011, when the White House was seeking a budget fight with Republicans who had just taken control of the House. (No surprise thats also the year that the DCCC chooses to highlight a budget vote.)In the specific case of the NIH branch that deals with infectious diseases, funding jumped from $1.8 billion in 2000 to $4.3 billion in 2004 but funding has been flat since then. Funding in 2014 was again $4.3 billion. So thats effectively a cut over time.

Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Spikegary
Junior Quiet
link   seeder  Spikegary    12 years ago
The Pinocchio Test

On many levels, this line of attack is absurd.

Obamas Republican predecessor oversaw big increases in public-health sector spending, and both Democrats and Republicans in recent years have broadly supported efforts to rein in federal spending. Sequestration resulted from a bipartisan agreement. In some years, Congress has allocated more money for NIH and CDC than the Obama administration requested. Meanwhile, contrary to the suggestion of the DCCC ad, there never was a specific vote on funding to prevent Ebola.

Theres no doubt that spending has been cut, or at least failed to keep pace with inflation, but the fingerprints of both parties are on the knives. This blame game earns Four Pinocchios.

Glad to see, even the bastion of liberalism in Washington D.C. is starting to actually report the news instead of the abridged/approved version.

 
 

Who is online

Right Down the Center
Dismayed Patriot


84 visitors