╌>

Stalin not Crazy, just a Good Marxist.

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  sean-treacy  •  12 years ago  •  1 comments

Stalin not Crazy, just a Good Marxist.

Writing in The Atlantic , Anne Applebaum reviews the first volume of what looks like an interesting new biography of Stalin (it takes the story up until 1928). Critically, its author, Stephen Kotkin, appears to dispense with glib psychological alibi (tough childhood and so on) for what Stalin became, replacing it with the more sinister explanation that his actions were, in one sense, perfectly rational:

His violence was not the product of his subconscious but of the Bolshevik engagement with Marxist-Leninist ideology. This ideology offered Stalin a deep sense of certainty in the face of political and economic setbacks. If policies designed to produce prosperity created poverty instead, an explanation could always be found: the theory had been incorrectly interpreted, the forces were not correctly aligned, the officials had blundered. If Soviet policies were unpopular, even among workers, that too could be explained: antagonism was rising because the class struggle was intensifying.

And if you thinkthat thatsounds a lot likea true believer trying to square the teachingsof his faith with perennially inconvenient reality youwould be right. The frontierbetween avowedly atheistic communism, a political religion (as it has often been described) and more conventional religious belief isnot as clearly defined as is so often imagined. Trying to understand why Stalin was attracted to such a creed thus raises unsettling questionsover what we want to believe, and why that go far beyond the motivation of a series of communist fanatics.

Applebaum concludes:

In the contemporary West, we often assume that perpetrators of mass violence must be insane or irrational, but as Kotkin tells the story, Stalin was neither. And in its way, the idea of Stalin as a rational and extremely intelligent man, bolstered by an ideology sufficiently powerful to justify the deaths of many millions of people, is even more terrifying. It means we might want to take more seriously the pronouncements of the Russian politicians who have lately argued for the use of nuclear weapons against the Baltic states, or of the ISIS leaders who call for the deaths of all Christians and Jews. Just because their language sounds strange to us doesnt mean that they, and those who follow them, dont find it compelling, or that they wont pursue their logic to its ultimate conclusion.

Theres more to that argument, I think, in the case of ISIS. For all their immense faults, Putin and those that surround him do not strike me as people in the grip of some millennialist rage. The risks they take are, for the most part, carefully calculated. Yes, the tactics that they use can easily turn (very) murderous and, I suppose, under certain circumstances could even include detonating a nuclear weapon in the Baltics, but only if they thought they could get away with it . Despite his regimes sometimes oddly post-modern veneer, Putin is engaged in a variant of fairly traditional great power politics. He is neither on a mission to save the world, nor would he knowingly risk ending it. The same cannot be said of ISIS, believers in a new order where human considerations are meantto play only a supporting role. Given full rein and theright weapons there are fewlimits to what they might do.

http://www.nationalreview.com/corner/390636/stalin-sane-andrew-stuttaford


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   FLYNAVY1    12 years ago

Stalin's postwar goals were security for himself, his regime, his country, and his ideology, precisely in that order.

As it became obvious that Germany was on the verge of surrender, Roosevelt and Churchill envisaged a postwar settlement with the allied powers that would balance power while embracing principles to reduce the possibility of future wars in Europe. Stalin's view was a very different vision: a settlement that would secure his own and his country's security while simultaneously encouraging the rivalries among capitalist that he believed would bring about a new war. Capitalist fratricide, in turn, would ensure the eventual Soviet domination of Europe. In short, in chaos, there is profit.

Putin is a product of the Cold War. Having visited Russia in the last 18 months, I can say that many older Russians miss the old Soviet days. (for better or worse) A younger guide that we hired in St. Petersburg indicated that "Russians like to be told what to do." The concept of freedom and self determination has very shallow roots in Russia. Putin has revived much of the old Soviet nostalgia within the population. This too will disappear into the history books as the rest of us baby boomers die off.

 
 

Who is online

Right Down the Center
Dismayed Patriot


84 visitors