Right Thing … Wrong Reason!
One or two (possibly more) NT regulars and I, never agree on virtually any/all political issues. But, ON ONE PARTICULAR ISSUE MY MOST STRIDENT DETRACTOR, AND THE MOST FREQUENT, AND, THE ONE MOST LIKELY TO GO AD HOMINEM AND PERSONAL
IS RIGHT! HE'S RIGHT!
But for the wrong reason.
One can almost take it to the bank (so-to-speak) when a black kid is killed by a white cop, a vigilante cop-wannabe (like a George Zimmerman) or, when a black man selling cigarettes on a city street dies of a heart attack because six police officers restrain him, throw him to the sidewalk, choke him, step on his head, and ignore his many exhortations, "I can't breathe," then leave him there in an unconscious state, failing to call for medical help when that kind of story hits the news
COUNT ON MY DETRACTOR TO POST A COMMENT OR A SEEDED ARTICLE ABOUT BLACK KIDS IN CHICAGO OR PHILLY BEING KILLED BY OTHER BLACK KIDS and that he will make it an editorialized statement to the effect that (paraphrasing)
"The only time liberals (like me and Al Sharpton et al) bitch about black people being needlessly killed, is when they are killed by white people."
Take it to the f'n proverbial "bank!"
But here's the thing about that. If those times were in fact the only times liberals and the media openly lamented the senseless, needless murders of African Americans, MY DETRACTOR WOULD HAVE NO SEEDED ARTICLES TO POST LAMENTING THAT VERY THING -- there'd be, as he paradoxically, oxymoronically contends, "NO OUTCRIES!"
Ya' can't have it both ways.
And yet, MY DETRACTOR IS CORRECT TO A DEGREE; He's "in the ballpark" (Wrigley Field or Citizens Bank Park perhaps) but (continuing the metaphor) he's also committing an ERROR. And I believe the error is intentional! Or, possibly a hidden ball trick, a spit ball or a knock down pitch.
And here's how I see it.
If there's no media coverage on black on black shooting, as previously posited, how come my detractor always manage to find the story with the photographs to post on the site to, in self-contradiction, say "there's no coverage of black on black shooting, or, that no one cares about black on black shooting, or, that no one reports about black on black shooting except when a white person kills a black person?
I'll answer my own rhetorical question.
My detractor's so-called concern about black kids who kill other black kids isn't because he truly cares, rather, it's to divert attention away from the fact that white cops and white vigilantes shoot and kill unarmed blacks at an alarming rate and all too often are either not indicted -- indicted, but only after suspicious delays and protests -- and/or, are found innocent by virtue of some NRA lobbied-for and paid-for bullshit law like "Stand Your Ground."
Further, my detractor never mentions the guns used in these killings -- the illegally obtained guns that are being used by black kids to kill other black kids, nor, does he mention the gun show loophole which enables the killers to obtain the guns without background checks (documented as a major source of their procurement).
My detractor is correct in citing the all-to-meager coverage and reporting of "black-on-black" murders; after all, the media are predominantly owned by wealthy whites and cater primarily to white audiences (with notable and significant exceptions).
But in my opinion, it is an outrage and an hypocrisy and a racist tactic to cry crocodile tears over murdered inner city blacks TO DIVERT ATTENTION FROM THE TRAYVON MARTINS, the MICHAEL BROWNS and the BLACK MAN CHOKED, THROWN TO THE SIDEWALK, STOMPED ON AND PILED UPON BY SIX NEW YORK COPS UNTIL HE DIED OF A HEART ATTACK.
Bitching about the right thing but doing so for the wrong reason needs to be called out every time.
And I just did.

Yes. My article is contentious and specific. And it's clearly stated.
I expected hot disagreement but let's see if we can have it without the personal attacks.
Hitler and Mussolini were whites who killed millions of other white people. If we use the same reasoning/tactic as that of my detractor and his ilk (as per this discussion), should we forgive or minimize the significance of the Hitler/Mussolini killings because there are times when a a black person kills a whiteperson? Should we overlook the black murderer's deed because, "WTF, whites have been murdering other whites in massive numbers throughout history," or, should we conclude, "Murder is murder and any life ended needlessly is a tragedy"?
" COUNT ON MY DETRACTOR TO POST A COMMENT OR A SEEDED ARTICLE ABOUT BLACK KIDS IN CHICAGO OR PHILLY BEING KILLED BY OTHER BLACK KIDS " This is not only an unfair comment but it is also very misleading IMO. While its true YOUR DETRACTOR posts seed about blacks killing black and crime in Chicago and Penn. I have noticed it is only done AFTER the front page is bomb barded by another member about WHITEs killing (MURDERING) Blacks.
"Further, my detractor never mentions the guns used in these killings -- the illegally obtained guns that are being used by black kids to kill other black kids..." Of course he doesn't. Its the person doing the killing. To blame the death or the killing on the gun is just ignorant. To say "Guns kill people" is or has to be the most ignorant if not STUPIDIST thing I have ever read. In all the time I have been here on NT I have yet to see or read an article where a person was really killed by being pistol whipped by a gun or stabbedwith a gun. Here is a NEWS FLASH, ...IT IS THE BULLET THAT KILLS!!!!!!!
funny how you say "HE" doesn't mention the gun and you never mention the bullets when ranting anti gun crap.....just calling it like I see it.
And the bullet comes from what? Usually an illegally obtained gun!
Almost. Next to the idea that "guns don't kill people people kill people," it's genius.
Hey, I know, let's eliminate ALL people and just keep the guns around. PROBLEM SOLVED.
Here's one for you. In order to pistol whip or stab someone, the assailant needs to be in really close proximity to the intended victim -- unlike when shooting that victim from a distance, from a concealed position, a moving vehicle see the heightened advantage for the shooter?
And have you ever heard of anyone being killed by a BULLET that was not SHOT FROM A GUN INTO A VICTIM?
Stabbed to death with a bullet? A bullet that fell from a third story window landing on its victim?
You see it through NRA-colored myopic glasses LR.
And by the way, regardless of whether or not the shooter or the bullet kills the victim, that's not the point of my article.The point is the disingenuous and selective indignation of those who decry black-on-black killing BUT ONLY WHEN A WHITE COP, etc. KILLS A BLACK KID! Then it's, "So what, blacks in Chicago/Philly kill blacks (so what's the big deal if a white cop kills a black)?
Can't grasp that?
It's not the venom injected into a victim by a Rattlesnake that kills its victim, it's the Rattlesnake! Rattlesnake venom doesn't kill people, Rattlesnakes kill people.
It's not the toxic antigens that cause human cells to explodes when a victim contracts the Ebola virus, it's the Ebola virus! Toxic antigens from viruses don't kill people, viruses kill people.
Trying to somehow separate the "weapon" from "shooter of the weapon" -- is a fool's errand.
Together they become a lethal entity.
"And by the way, regardless of whether or not the shooter or the bullet kills the victim, that's not the point of my article. The point is the disingenuous and selective indignation of those who decry black-on-black killing BUT ONLY WHEN A WHITE COP, etc. KILLS A BLACK KID!" I got the point of your article. and incase you missed it, the first part of my comment addressed that issue. would you like me to repeat it?
" COUNT ON MY DETRACTOR TO POST A COMMENT OR A SEEDED ARTICLE ABOUT BLACK KIDS IN CHICAGO OR PHILLY BEING KILLED BY OTHER BLACK KIDS " This is not only an unfair comment but it is also very misleading IMO. While its true YOUR DETRACTOR posts seed about blacks killing black and crime in Chicago and Penn. I have noticed it is only done AFTER the front page is bomb barded by another member about WHITEs killing (MURDERING) Blacks.
"And have you ever heard of anyone being killed by a BULLET that was not SHOT FROM A GUN INTO A VICTIM?" YES I have. every year there is always some hunting accident where a drunk hunter or careless hunter ends up throwing live rounds into a camp fire.
Here is a SIMPLE test for even you. Take an unloaded gun (without bullets) and hold it 6 inches from a plate. (don't want you to claim you missed the plate) shoot the gun and tell me if the plate breaks. If the plate breaks then I AM WRONG GUNS CAN KILL. If the plate doesn't break then It must be something else that does the actual killing, Oh yeah, the BULLET.
Guns are nothing more than a tool that can be used to kill with, just like a knife a car, a baseball bat. the fact that it is easier to kill or can be done from a greater distance with a gun is irrelevant.
My detractor often makes the same argument again and again often with additional deflections.
Stuff like
I directly addressed that premise.
Incorrect guess. The violence in major cities is being addressed constantly. The time, efforts and resources devoted to mitigating both the causes and effects are rarely publicized in the media AND THE DETRACTORS WILL CONTEND THERE ARE NO SUCH EFFORTS, etc., -- that reinforces both their ignorance and their relentless efforts to make people think that all the blacks and white liberals don't actually do things to fix the problems!
Because the National Guard is not the answer to the causes for street violence in Chicago UNLESS OF COURSE THE GUARD WOULD BE SENT THERE TO PUT THE PURVEYORS OF ILLEGAL GUNS OUT OF BUSINESS.
Good idea Robert G!
Speaking for myself, I'm basing my babble on babble like yours.
Gun Deaths Exceed Motor Vehicle Deaths in 10 States
...
Separate the tool from the shooter and you have no shooting. Knives need to start relatively close to the stabee to be effective baseball bats and cars are not intended nor designed for the purpose of penetrating human flesh. A Toyota traveling at 70mph from a distance of 100 yards is not anywhere nearly as threatening to a potential victim as is a bullet fired from a gun at multiple times that distance -- one reason why most criminal carry concealed firearms as opposed to Honda Civics.
"Gun Deaths Exceed Motor Vehicle Deaths in 10 States" that's irrelevant. a red herring argument. it doesn't change the fact that what I said is TRUE.
YOU raised the CARS, I didn't. And you somehow can't comprehend the significance of guns involved in murders vs. cars involved in ACCIDENTAL deaths.
What you said is the NRA nonsense about "guns don't kill people." PEOPLE SHOOTING GUNS THAT RESULT IN BULLETS KILLING PEOPLE IS THE ENTIRE SCENARIO.
Argue that.
And your comment still misses the point of the article.
Those I characterize as "My Detractors," raise the black-on-black killing, NOT IN SYMPATHY OF THE VICTIMS, RATHER TO PERPETUATE AND TRY TO VALIDATE THE RIGHT-WING STEREOTYPE OF BLACKS BEING TAKERS-WITH-A-PROPENSITY-FOR-VIOLENCE never bothering to note that most blacks are like most whites caring about their loved ones, wanting to succeed in life, wanting to be safe and NOT WANTING TO BE DEMAGOGUED BY A BUNCH OF HATE MONGERS CHEERED ON AND EXPLOITED BY BIG STUPIDITY, BIG MONEY AND BIG-TIME POLITICIANS.
" Separate the tool from the shooter and you have no shooting ..." really?
OK lets run with that statement.... Separate the tool (knife) from the people NO ONE will die from stabbings,...Separate the tool (car) from the drunks NO ONE will ever be killed by a drunk driver driving a Toyota at 70 MPH. Separate the tool (baseball bat) from,....wellI think you get the point.
Again you have failed to show us just how an UNLOADED ( NO BULLETS) gun cankill a person, ...still waiting.
Egilman,
I'm looking for "fair and balanced" when it comes to characterizing the lives of black people.
No argument that killings in black, urban areas are abominable. But lamentation by whites who only lament (disingenuously) on days when the news is "Michael Brown gets shot to death by a white cop because Michael was jay walking," IS RACIST BULLSHIT DESIGNED TO DIVERT FROM ANOTHER TYPE OF BLACK-VICTIM CLASS!
I worked in North and South Philly with thousands of black kids and their families and in the worst-of-worst neighborhoods. Most of the residents in those neighborhoods were not gang members just regular families who happened to be black and who loathed the killings as would any family.
These fuckers who relentlessly portray Chicago and Philly (to break my balls and JR's) in such a way as to make it appear that the only thing that ever happens in those cities is comprised of "Niggers living on welfare and shooting people" -- these fuckers are ignorant, hateful and dangerous in that they perpetuate the message of the hater and the politician who panders to the haters and the big money that pays for such propaganda.
If you haven't live and worked where I have -- you don't know. And shilling for haters based on racist propaganda is what haters often do.
If you're not part of the solution, you're part of the problem.
I taught a whole lot of inner-city kids. Only one of my black students, as far as I am aware, was convicted of murder.
And one of my white students is currently in prison he was the head of the Philly mob!
Let me know how someone without a gun shoots someone else.
You can't stab someone from 100 yards away. Who the fuck gets in a car, drunk or otherwise with the intent to run someone down?
Oh yeah, I get the point but you clearly choose not to.
Are you kidding? Is that a real question? I never stated an unloaded gun in someone's hand could SHOOT anyone. Try and understand your own questions?
"one MUST recognize the problem for what it really is before coming up with a solution."
And also, to not mischaracterize the acts of a depraved, relatively few, to make it appear to be the acts of an an entire population, race or demographic.
You nailed it my friend.
" Who the fuck gets in a car, drunk or otherwise with the intent to run someone down ?"
"A Vermont woman lost control of her car along Route 5A, crashed into a tree and lost her husband in the ensuing accident. It all seemed like a terrible tragedy. In time, it was revealed to be a terrible crime.
Christine Billis was sentenced to 7 to 15 years in a plea bargain Friday in Vermont Superior Court, after she admitting to causing her husband's death in the 2009 accident. She had originally been charged with murder, but pled to manslaughter.
Billis, a Brownington resident, may have gotten away with the crime had she not created an account on the dating site OK Cupid shortly after the accident. In time, she told a romantic prospect that she had purposely caused the crash in hopes of killing her husband . She wore her seatbelt on the night the car veered across the road in Charleston, Vt. Her husband, Charles, 57, did not.
Instead of dating Billis, the online user contacted police and became an informant, according to the New England Cable News network. He recorded conversation and turned the tapes over to police.
She claimed her husband was controlling, abusive and had threatened to kill her.
And you'd end upon your ass but that aside, I named no names so your paranoia is showing -- and there are others herein who have also made whites killing unarmed blacks as somehow less egregious as blacks-killing-blacks. And, to boot, they toss in additional stereotypical demagoguery about blacks in the same post!
The timing of what individuals state and the way in which they state it, overtly or obliquely, speak for themselves. When an individual makes repetitive distinctions between needless deaths of members of a demographic, lamenting one while simultaneously minimizing or failing to lament the other, it's not difficult to speculate about underlying motives.
I never express a desire to assault you regardless of how hateful, inciting and insulting your comments often become. And the only time I make a disparaging remark about you personally is when you take the first shot like now for example.
For a guy who cries about violent people as you do when it suits your purpose, you're quick with the fighting words.
Rather than express your negative feelings about my comment, post links to your comments about blacks-killing-blacks in Chicago/Philly THAT DID NOT COME IN CLOSE PROXIMAL TIMES TO NEWS ITEMS RUNNING SIMULTANEOUSLY WITH STORIES OF TRAYVONS, MICHAELS AND OTHER UNARMED BLACKS KILLED BY OVER-REACTIVE WHITE GUYS WITH GUNS.
You are quite right to assail the murders by blacks in their own neighborhoods; but in your obvious avoidance of castigating the unwarranted white killers of other blacks, you are conspicuously one-sided.
That's correct. Do you think no one understands the innuendos that allude to such stereotypes?
"The takers," "The Food Stamp President," "Welfare Queens" and all the innuendos.
But not the victims killed by white police officers AND ONLY POSTED AT TIMES WHEN SUCH KILLINGS ARE IN THE FOREFRONT OF THE MEDIA!
Ladies and gentlemen I rest my case. Jackson's presence nor his son's criminality have thing-fucking-one to do with Michael Brown's dead body laying in the street for 4 hours FOR FUCKING JAY WALKING!
You can't see it Robert G. .
See you on another thread.
Yes ALL, Robert G. Lament them ALL. Speaking for myself, I not only don't defend "them" -- the perpetrators, I have taught and worked with "them" -- the victims and potential victims-"them."
Some of "them" are just like you and me albeit many of "them" are unjustly feared by whites who only know the stereotyped "them" and despise "them" as being something they are not!
Oh, but it is mentioned when trying to further "blaken" blacks and portray them all as sub-human, "not-like-the-rest-of-us," you know, "Kenyan," "sympathizer of Africans!"
The stats are the stats and you can accuse those who run with stats as skewing them either by putting them in context or taking them out -- either way to satisfy an agenda which you are doing by implying the stats are never given in context.
"One must tiptoe around idiots so they're feelings don't get hurt. But they are obstructionists. A big part of the problem."
Feelings getting hurt? Who wants to "punch who in the mouth," Robert G. You think you understand the violence in the inner-city ghetto and yet, you can't have a civil discussion, insult-free! What do you think that short fuse of yours would make you do in a Chicago/Philly "discussion?"
Your f'n right there's a curse in these neighborhoods and it's not all self-inflicted.
Would you or would you punch me in the mouth, or, if you could easily get yourself an illegal gun, shoot me? Jackson may be a victim-crat and hypocrite, but if he rails against a no-indictment, bullshit grand jury on behalf of a community regularly fucked over because it's mostly black, he's not wrong is he?
There's that "welfare "N"-word innuendo again, Robert G. You just can't help it.
And one more time. Are all blacks in that category? Who makes you think that might characterize inner-city blacks as a demographic?
Not if some redneck legislature passed a load of "voter-suppression legislation I couldn't! Couldn't vote for anyone. It's a lot more oppressive than seem to think it is and more complicated. But you're not entirely wrong Robert G. Many black and white politicians exploit minorities and continue to get re-elected and that's on the fools who keep electing them. But they are no more fools than the haters who elect those who pander to their bigotry!
It's complicated, Robert G.
And for the record, as big a pain in the ass as you are I don't hate you.
Not even a little.
'Course, lots of liberals can disagree with folks and still like them.
Peace, we just (vehemently) disagree.
_____________________________________
Note, the site has been quirky and I currently can't put up block quotes. Once that is fixed, I'll edit for clarity/readability.
"Don't pile stupid on stupid. You know who you have been talking about. And I know."
Yes. I made it clear as to what I'm talking about. Shall I post a retrospective of your comments?
"And I have ZERO worry that a white killer will EVER be ignored."
Good for you. Start with Michael Brown and work your way back.
Me too; it would make my NT life a lot easier.
More insults no content.
And you talk about "duh"?
Translation for Robert G.
A perspective might be diverse, represented by a spectrum of ideas albeit from a single demographic.
You imply endlessly that no one in Chicago addresses or does anything to mitigate the violence, to offer hope to residents through education, counseling, opportunity, attempts to make equitable, the resources playing field; to you, that's "redistribution of wealth." You don't need to spell it out, it's clear by virtue of your broad brush mischaracterizations.
You imply that the killing goes on in black neighborhoods and everyone looks the other way. Your perspective is myopic. YOU DON'T KNOW!
JR,
I fixed the block quotes above. It's functioning at least for the moment.
I give him the respect of a response; whether he likes the response or not is part of the debate process.
A riot? Really? If such a riot took place, the usual white critics and haters would raise hell about "those rioting, uncivilized, animal 'Ns' rioting."
And when blacks march and demonstrate peacefully (like on Bloody Sunday) they get maced, beaten, attacked by police dogs, shot and killed! And then the politicians supported by haters, fuck with voting rights!
THEY CAN'T WIN WITH THOSE WHO HATE AND THOSE WHO DON'T HAVE CLUE ONE ABOUT THE DYNAMICS OF RACISM.
These neighborhoods don't become hellish overnight although they do in a way. I've already explained the "blockbusting" tactic of illicit realtors and JR delineated the other logistics.
White flight is an engineered phenomenon predicated on greed and fear and racism.
To the willingly deaf and the uninterested, all they hear is silence. Those of us who didn't run and who stayed to be helpful and stabilizing forces know that riots are self-destructive both literally and from a P.R. standpoint.
Once again, I rest my case.
You sit on the sidelines and believe and repeat the shit that the haters in the media spew along with the bigot politicians who push the buzzwords in public and use the "N" word in the back rooms.
You can't have a discussion on-line without losing your cool and getting personal and insulting, but you think you understand the anger and despair that is a constant factor in a neighborhood that's been subterfuged by greed and bigotry and political underhandedness.
Ironic.
I'm not trying to help him up; he establishes his own level as we all do.
It ain't no "cottage," JR it's the Koch Brothers' haunted mansion.
I'm well aware of my detractor(s) -- a term I use generically in singular and plural in generic form; if the shoe fits, most objective individuals can see who wears it, and, if the term and the context in which I use it evokes a paranoia response, such a response is not synonymous with a counter-point rebuttal, and, it is revealing.