Yellow light change led to 77,000 tickets - Chicago Tribune
The Emanuel administration quietly issued a new, shorter yellow light standard this spring that generated 77,000 red light camera tickets that would not have been allowed before the rule change, the city inspector general announced Friday.
The administration defended the $100 tickets -- and the nearly $8 million in revenue it will collect from them -- as valid. But the city agreed to Inspector General Joseph Fergusons recommendation to end the new practice of issuing citations with yellow light times below 3 seconds.
The Tribune reported Thursday that its analysis of overturned tickets and interviews with experts suggested the Emanuel administration had made a subtle, but significant, change when it switched camera vendors this spring from the beleaguered Redflex Traffic Systems Inc. to Xerox State and Local Solutions. Hearing officers were suddenly throwing out hundreds of tickets that showed yellow light times at 2.9, below the 3-second minimum required by the city.
The city would not answer questions this week about whether it changed the yellow light standards, and Transportation Commissioner Rebekah Scheinfeld declined to explain the mystery in a recent interview with the Tribune, saying only that the tickets were valid because they fell within an acceptable standard for electrical deviations.
But in a broader review about problems with the red light program sparked by Tribune reports, the inspector general on Friday revealed that Scheinfeld's department had ordered changes early this year as the program was transitioning from Redflex to Xerox control.
At the Citys request Redflex categorically rejected any captured event with a recorded yellow light time below three seconds, Ferguson wrote. However, after Xerox took over the operations of the RLC program, the City directed Xerox to accept RLC violations with yellow light times above 2.9 seconds.
The city said it relied on a national electrical industry standard that allows for deviations in the hundredths or thousandths of a second. Ferguson recommended the city should change the standard back in order to improve public confidence in the camera program.
The Tribune reported Thursday that its review of 1,500 overturned tickets since April revealed evidence that the city had changed the rules on yellow light times when Xerox took over.
In more than 200 of those cases, city hearing officers blamed yellow light times under the 3-second minimum required by the city. An additional 299 rejected tickets had yellow lights under 3 seconds, although judges did not specify that as the reason.
Scheinfeld declined to answer Tribune questions earlier this week about whether the city had changed the rules. But she said the yellow light times being rejected by judges as too short are in fact valid because they fall within an allowable variance of hundredths or thousandths of a second caused by fluctuations in electrical power
Scheinfeld maintained in her response to Ferguson that the sub-3 second tickets were valid but acknowledged the city had quietly suspended the lower threshold in September, after questions were first raised by hearing officers and the media.
She said the city had now ordered Xerox to stop processing any violation with an amber measurement under 3.0 seconds.
Copyright 2014, Chicago Tribune

Yes they have been known to enrich the wrong people Cerenkov. Actually they were sold on the idea of preventing accidents, but I think there were far fewer accidents from people running the yellow to red light than rear end accidents for stopping.
I got a ticket here in Charlotte several years ago for being recorded as running a yellow/red light. The only thing is they didn't show the dump truck behind me who also ran it on my ticket. I'm sure he/she got one as well. I didn't like the ticket, but thought it to be a better punishment than having a dump truck running into the rear of my car. At least there was no accident.
Since then they've outlawed them here. Wonder why?
Just another new way to steal from people.
I got 2 of them in 2 weeks. I don't know how much they cost in other states, but in Illinois they cost you $100.00 per ticket! Now, I'm paranoid when I have to use that intersection, pray for a red light!! sigh...